Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About flying business class

263 replies

KittiKati · 07/01/2023 11:18

DH has fibromyalgia & MS. It’s extremely difficult for him to sit in a plane seat for any length of time whether short or long haul.

We were talking about holidays and he suggested he flies business class and me and DS fly economy. I said I didn’t feel that this was appropriate and would rather save up the extra money and we all fly business class.

He seemed genuinely put out by this and is acting like I am being unreasonable? Interested in other peoples opinions please

OP posts:
scaredoff · 09/01/2023 21:34

I don't understand what you mean that you "didn't feel this was appropriate". What exactly is your problem with his suggestion? It makes perfect sense to me.

It also depends of course on how much money you have. I could never imagine taking the whole family business class and it seems an incredible extravagance. But if you have sufficient funds that it isn't, I suppose that's different.

ArchibaldsDaddy · 09/01/2023 21:27

Utter chutney! I fly Business with work quite a bit and, other than a slightly better meal and maybe a little more legroom, I’m very little better off. An aisle seat would allow the same amount of stretch.

The key issue here is the reaction to you all joining him - that’s total arsey behaviour. Even if I could fly Business, if it meant being separated from my family, I’d fly back with my gang.

So, YANBU - but he definitely is being a bit of a belter.

ArchibaldsDaddy · 09/01/2023 21:26

Utter chutney! I fly Business with work quite a bit and, other than a slightly better meal and maybe a little more legroom, I’m very little better off. An aisle seat would allow the same amount of stretch.

The key issue here is the reaction to you all joining him - that’s total arsey behaviour. Even if I could fly Business, if it meant being separated from my family, I’d fly back with my gang.

So, YANBU - but he definitely is being a bit of a belter.

Dibbydoos · 09/01/2023 21:17

You ANBU.

We're going to Thailand for a family wedding later this year and we're all going BC cos my mum needs to be in BC. My son suggested PE which we used when we came home from the USA cos we took a red eye as it's easier to sleep there vs SC, but Thailand is a 14+ hour flight, so BC feels best.

BA have a sale on at the mo, might be worthwhile taking a peak now.... But be careful cos BC for short haul is not BC.

Good luck x

Siepie · 09/01/2023 21:09

MrsDouglas · 09/01/2023 20:45

I hope I don't get shot down here lol but the regularly inappropriate voice in my head responds with this compromise; I would suggest a similar compromise... he stays at home and you go on holiday with your son 😆 then it means you dont have to save up for any business class seats at all 😆😏

You suggest he should be left out of his family's holiday because he's disabled?

cruisebaba1 · 09/01/2023 20:45

Soapnutty · 09/01/2023 18:15

Fibromyalgia... definitely would not get a business class seat IMO.

Hark you, fibromyalgia can be incredibly painful and having more space could prevent a lot of discomfort not only on the plane but with less increased pain for the first few days of the holiday.

Well said!!!! Someone on here who understands FM

MrsDouglas · 09/01/2023 20:45

I hope I don't get shot down here lol but the regularly inappropriate voice in my head responds with this compromise; I would suggest a similar compromise... he stays at home and you go on holiday with your son 😆 then it means you dont have to save up for any business class seats at all 😆😏

MrsDouglas · 09/01/2023 20:42

I hope I don't get shot down here lol but I would suggest a similar compromise... he stays at jome and you go on holiday with your son 😆 then it means you dont have to save up for any business class seats at all 😆😏

CurlyhairedAssassin · 09/01/2023 20:31

OP, have you ever flown business class? We did this year for the first time, from LA to Manchester (via Heathrow). The business class lounge at LA was amazing, so quiet and loads of seats to choose from. Did really feel exlusive, like we were in celeb-land! But it went downhill after that really, in terms of value for money. At Heathrow the lounge was shit, a glorified all inclusive type of atmosphere - overcrowded and noisy and with uncleared tables at Heathrow.

Yes, so we had lie flat seats on the plane from LA to Heathrow but it was over the engines so even with ear plugs in and it being a night flight it was just so noisy. And they turn the lights out and just expect you to go to sleep so don't expect much service at all. I was uncomfortably hot and so thirsty. With the noise too I didn't sleep a wink even though it was a night flight so I SHOULD have felt tired, so all in all, it was a total waste of money.

The food was fine but, it was just food, we'd had loads of it in the LA lounge anyway so didn't need much. And of course had availed ourselves of champagne in the lounge too so by the time they hurriedly brought us a glass of champagne as the rest of the flight was boarding it didn't feel much of a treat to be honest. I mean, it's just a glass of fizz when all is said and done!! The meal in the morning as we were approaching the UK was a cooked breakfast if you wanted it. But it was, like, 3am to our body clocks so we weren't really hungry and ended up leaving a lot of it.

Business class from Heathrow to Manchester was pointless. So we could sit at the front of the plane, get off first, and we had an empty seat between us. So what? They threw some afternoon tea at us and were virtually hovering over us waiting for us to eat our scones because the flight was so short they needed to collect the tray back in ready for landing. Hardly a premium experience. We didn't enjoy it, we'd had the lounge food at Heathrow and our appetites were all over the place.

If we were doing it again, I would book economy but look VERY carefully at the type of aircraft and choose my flight and seat accordingly. We had a very pleasant journey indeed in economy from the UK to the US and would book the exactly the same again in a heartbeat. I would be happy to pay for my DH only to go business class if he had the issues your DH has, as I really don't think business class is worth the thousands of pounds extra per family. I was glad we tried it, but unless someone else is paying I wouldn't bother with it again. Maybe if we were going to Oz or somewhere longer than 11 hours I would consider it.

What you'd need to consider is that he would be "queue jumping" if he was business class, so he'd be on his own checking in, separate from you. He'd then have access to a different lounge to you. Would he be able to manage on his own? SAme with getting off, he'd be off the plane first having to wait for you to get off.

KittiKati · 09/01/2023 20:24

Yeah I’ve said no problem at all, he can go Business class, me and DS will slum it in economy ☺️. We both work hard and don’t have any particular money worries, but it seems silly to waste the extra costs of business seats when we could easily spend the money elsewhere either on the house or towards another holiday.

I’m not sure it’s worth it for a short flight but long haul I think it’s definitely worth him having some comfort. Not sure where we want to venture to yet, out son wants to go to New York (DH and I have already been there and are not bothered about returning) or DH and I quite fancy Abu Dhabi but I’m not sure DS will like it. There’s so many places in the world who knows!?

They also want to go inter railing around Europe on sleeper trains! 😁

OP posts:
HolidayHappy123 · 09/01/2023 20:06

If it’s short haul the business class seats are exactly the same size as economy with the middle seat blocked.

silverbubbles · 09/01/2023 20:04

I think you sound unreasonable. he is not travelling business class for any other reason apart from health.

Merlin3189 · 09/01/2023 19:49

I've said YABU since there are only two options, I do see your point of view and think it not unreasonable, but it's not what I'd do.

If paying a large premium for first class is worthwhile for everyone, then go ahead - and perhaps you should have been doing it already? But it looks to me that it is only worth it for your DH, so there's no need to waste money for everyone else.
Often my partner and I travel in separated seats (in economy) in order for me to have sufficient legroom (I'm 1.97m, she's 1.57m.) The difference in cost (if any) is more acceptable to her than it is to me!

Wilmawheelmouth · 09/01/2023 19:43

Please don’t go there. You’ll be setting the precedent forever more. Ask yourself WHY is he put out? Is it the price for two ? If so, save up as you suggested so you can both go. Or, is it because you’ll actually be joining him and he wanted the experience of business class all to himself? Either way for a married couple he is acting weird ! The journey to the holiday destination is included as part of the holiday so you should be together. Why doesn’t he suggest he stays in a five star hotel whilst you stay in a third when you get there. Ffs. Or, even better, you could save up and book yourself into FIRST class travel and wave to him from there to the class below . See how DH likes it.

Zazazoolly · 09/01/2023 19:39

My goodness, if my DH has MS, even without any other condition, I would’ve been the one to suggest he flew in appropriate comfort. Apart from being more considerate towards his condition, he’ll probably arrive more relaxed and in better shape making fir a better holiday.

WotsitsMadeIn1927 · 09/01/2023 19:35

I agree with you, why shouldn’t you and your son get a treat too? It’s only fair!

Soapnutty · 09/01/2023 19:33

OverTheRubicon · 09/01/2023 19:22

I'd be sceptical of someone who can't handle economy class short haul but can mysteriously manage business class long haul - yes it's more spacious, but it's still not perfectly comfortable, and it's a far longer trip.

Also mysterious is why the vast majority of fibro/ME sufferers are women, yet it generally seem to be the male sufferers who require or get the luxury treatment for it 🙄

My mum has ME (l do too but more severely and can’t travel). She can manage short haul flights in economy but for long haul flights (goes to see my brother in Oz) she needs business class as it allows her to get some sleep during the 24 hr trip which means she feels less ill and gets less increase in symptoms for the first few days of the stay. When my dad was alive and they would fly together to Oz, she would have a business class and dad economy due to cost. Their last two trips dad managed to get a 2nd business class seat for only another £200 and their final trip they did decide to pay out for him going business class too. If mum wasn’t fortunate enough to be able to afford business class to Oz she wouldn’t be able to go.

SofiaSoFar · 09/01/2023 19:30

@OverTheRubicon

Also mysterious is why the vast majority of fibro/ME sufferers are women, yet it generally seem to be the male sufferers who require or get the luxury treatment for it 🙄

That's an interesting fact.

Spain1980 · 09/01/2023 19:30

*lounge

Spain1980 · 09/01/2023 19:30

When you fly business class you also have different check-in and access to a longe. All of which makes the flight more comfortable. If your husband flies Business and you go economy. You will effectively be flying as a lone parent. As it is a family holiday I would try to all fly business. Alternatively find out what the airline can offer you in terms of disability assistance. Such as early boarding, wheelchair/ride to the gate etc - and purchase extra legroom seats

Soapnutty · 09/01/2023 19:25

Business class is a choice not a disability adjustment.

I don’t agree. If symptoms mean you can’t sit up for long periods, cramped spaces increase pain severely and/or lack of sleep on a long haul flight increases symptoms then a business class seat which has more space and the opportunity to lie flat and have a greater chance of sleep acts as a disability adjustment.

I do agree with those who say the the attitude of person with the disability to it all will play a part. If they automatically think they are entitled and don’t acknowledge the other parent has the disadvantage of having to look after the children in economy in cramped seats then I can see the other partner might feel less happy that they have to go economy if finances don’t allow for two business class seats. I say this as someone disabled.

TerraNostra · 09/01/2023 19:24

dnaconundrum · 07/01/2023 13:13

I don’t see the benefit of business here, sorry. I fly long haul every month and know aircraft like the back of my hand.

We just had an 11 hour flight and my husband had injuries, we asked to be moved to a comfortable position. BA gave us the baby bit where you can put a basket. More leg room than business!

What are you talking about? Long haul business class is completely lie-flat, you can’t do that in the bulkhead economy seat!

Gemstar2 · 09/01/2023 19:22

How old is DS? If it’s a case of DH getting 10 hours of sleep while you single-handedly try to entertain an 18 month old on a packed flight then that’s quite different to you and your 7 yo sitting watching films together….but even so, I think I’d just be inclined to believe DH that if he thinks it’s worth paying tons extra for BC then he probably needs it and his daily pain must be pretty miserable…and if you don’t have to save up for 2 more BC seats then you can go on holiday sooner, which is a win!

OverTheRubicon · 09/01/2023 19:22

I'd be sceptical of someone who can't handle economy class short haul but can mysteriously manage business class long haul - yes it's more spacious, but it's still not perfectly comfortable, and it's a far longer trip.

Also mysterious is why the vast majority of fibro/ME sufferers are women, yet it generally seem to be the male sufferers who require or get the luxury treatment for it 🙄

notimagain · 09/01/2023 19:20

Also not sure how you can guarantee an empty seat if there is no one to sit in it, if the airline has oversold tickets.

FWIW some airlines allow you buy an extra seat - this for example is from BA.com:

"You can buy an extra ticket to keep the seat next to you free, e.g. for additional personal space or to secure a fragile or precious item, such as a musical instrument or painting."

I'm not quite sure what their policy would be with regard to overbooking, but it might get awkward if they try to use it after you have strapped your cello into it.......🙄