Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS has already failed.

310 replies

Goingforplatinum · 07/01/2023 11:05

5 hour wait for a cat1 ambulance for a child. Unresponsive patients being taken to hospital by neighbours. 90 hour wait in A&E, unsafe staffing on wards, 7 month wait for coil or implant fitting. The NHS isn't failing. We need to admit its failed

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 09:42

Auntieobem · 07/01/2023 21:23

We should be focusing on social care, and not just because of the impact on delayed discharges. The lack of social care is appalling. Over the past couple of months I've heard of terrible terrible situations. Bed bound people who can't get care packages, an 80 year old alcoholic man who was chair bound and we couldn't get a package, until his carer passed away and he was on his own for days with no support. It's terrifying.

No. I’ll say it until I’m blue in the face but pensioners are the wealthiest demographic in the country and on top of this they get free prescriptions, bus passes and fuel allowance. They are best placed to afford private care if they need it. I don’t want £££ being channeled to social care, I want it firstly going towards recruitment and retention of doctors and nurses and secondly to reform our A&E and out of hours services.

Squisageandmosh · 08/01/2023 09:35

Those posters saying that “we already pay for the NHS through our taxes” do realise that in countries such as France and Germany, the taxes are higher and they pay for healthcare and gov subsidised health insurance on top of that?

It’s less apparent now with the cost of living crisis but people in the uk until recently had more disposable income in their pockets compared with people in many EU countries.

Covid and Brexit have undoubtedly had a profound effect on the NHS but In 2019, prior to the pandemic, the UK spent £3,055 per person on health care, 18% below the EU14 average, so this has been a very long-standing problem rooted in political priorities.

In very simplistic terms it boils down to a philosophical and political clash about what is good for society as a whole versus what is good for the individual, and UK governments, generally speaking, have prioritised the latter.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 08/01/2023 06:14

We had a very good vaccine candidate that we didn't use emergency power to push through

What do you mean by this?

User3456 · 08/01/2023 01:17

We need a change of government urgently.
Austerity, Brexit, Covid and general incompetence have led us here. Things will improve after the next election. In the meantime, look after your health the best you can. Try not to get ill or pass anything on to others (especially the very young or very old) as you are not guaranteed to be able to get medical care in a timely manner. The most practical thing we can all do right now is invest in some FFP2 masks and start wearing them again. And getting a flu jab at a pharmacy. They're about £10. Take care everyone.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 01:05

Kazzyhoward · 07/01/2023 12:48

No it hasn't because it's not like that everywhere. I don't deny that there are problems but some areas are worse than others. I went to our local hospital yesterday and walked past A&E on the way, not a single ambulance outside and the sign outside was showing approx 30 minute waiting time!

The real problem is the fragmentation into dozens if not hundreds of different trusts doing different things, which means it's harder than it should be for resources to be shared and transferred between hospitals.

Yes and it doesn’t help when in a city like mine with an increasing population the main hospital is rebuilt with FEWER beds than before. I mean it’s not rocket science to realise that that is going to have a major impact on things. It’s beyond idiotic. Why are decisions like that being made and approved? Why is someone not sitting in those planning meetings sticking their head above the parapet and saying “no, no, no, this is absolute lunacy and we must NOT go down this road. The maths doesn’t work. We are a growing population - We need MORE beds, and staffing to go with it, not LESS, no matter how far you try to justify it with your crappy graphs and forecasting.”

JessicaBrassica · 07/01/2023 22:28

mumda · 07/01/2023 12:58

10 non clinical staff per bed?

That's astonishing. Can you quote the source? Is that non clinical or non-registered?

In my team we have 3 staff (all clinical, 2 registered) and 170 patients. All patients require active treatment otherwise we discharge. I'd love some admin support!

Overall our health board has about 10 staff per bed (including clinical). 35% staff are non clinical.That includes estates & domestics (essential but non clinical.

BirmaBrite · 07/01/2023 21:50

The other issue is that people are put into private residential settings for stepdown/rehab but get very little or no expert care from physio's/OT's or allied HCA's. The HCA staff in these settings often don't have the time or training to provide what is needed, they are often running on minimal staffing as it is, so the person who has rehab potential loses out and ends up no longer fit to go back home.

BirmaBrite · 07/01/2023 21:44

@Auntieobem it is scary how little provision there is out there, especially for stepdown/rehab/respite. The problem is most domicillary and residential care is in the private sector now, how is the Government supposed to intervene ?
It could increase the money to LA's , but there are so many other essentials that need addressing by LA's other than elderly care, the only way to deal with it is by ringfencing funds and even then I doubt it would be enough for them to reinstate the provision that has been closed down. It is far more expensive to start something new than save something old.

Auntieobem · 07/01/2023 21:23

We should be focusing on social care, and not just because of the impact on delayed discharges. The lack of social care is appalling. Over the past couple of months I've heard of terrible terrible situations. Bed bound people who can't get care packages, an 80 year old alcoholic man who was chair bound and we couldn't get a package, until his carer passed away and he was on his own for days with no support. It's terrifying.

yubgummy · 07/01/2023 20:47

Spot on @Grumpybutfunny

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 20:42

Nightingales were PR, could never have been staffed, they were to prove the UK could build a hospital quickly, waste of time and money.

We are democracy, we don't force untried drugs on people, we are not Russia.
Plus these things have to be tested.

We did not treat all covid cases, nothing like it, my Nan died at home, so did my aunt, we don't catch all cancer cases either, our rates on cancer treatments and outcomes have been bottom of the European league for many years.

Every country pretty much reacted as we did.

But like marsha i'm pretty washed up about CV, before xmas, the daily deaths with (not caused by) cv was less than 50 per day.

I'd rather focus on the cutting the 500 or so deaths caused by people not getting treatment right now and looking at measures to limit the 8 to 10k nhs staff off each day, NHS forces all med staff positive to stay off for 5 days min BUT then adds it to their sick record, which may mean loss of pay or a disciplinary :(

Grumpybutfunny · 07/01/2023 20:30

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 18:58

Daily deaths were for compliance

Do you think they were made up numbers?

We had a new virus, hospitalising and in many cases killing 1000s per week and no vaccines.

I 'm really at a loss as to what anyone thought we could otherwise do, countries like US, Brazil and Russia tried a no or little lockdown plan and suffered enormously.

Plus unless you believe the moon landings were fake, it should be remembered that most of the developed world came to the same conclusions.
Our mistake was locking down to late and then forced to do so for far longer.

With huge implications for the NHS and social care.

It depends on your view of the damages of COVID. Would ten of thousand more vulnerable dead, be better than kids missing out on years of education and a country billions of pounds in debt. The interesting question is how much longer these people will live I.e how much value have we added, it will be interesting to see what happens next year after a year of letting flu plus covid run unchecked. Remember nearly 25% of deaths were care home residents.

In my eyes our failures are:

We didn't completely isolate the vulnerable away from the rest of society by law. Instead we punished the mildly unwell.

We attempted to treat all COVID cases so the NHS missed cancer cases that could have been saved. The nightingales should have been used for the over X years and those at to much risk to survive to have high flow O2 and see what happens with minimal medical supervision to free up staff to deal with non-covid. On top of the we isolated positive but well staff instead of having them on the COVID wards further reducing staff numbers.

We had a very good vaccine candidate that we didn't use emergency power to push through and when we did release it months too late we didn't make it mandatory.

We closed schools leading to missed education and MH issues in kids. Teachers faced a much reduced threat than the NHS yet got to stay home. In future teachers need to be treat the same as NHS staff ie get on with it.

We kept restrictions such as social distancing far to long leading to increased economic damage. The pingdemic should have been a simple alert to say hey stay away from granny for two weeks please.

Goves statement that the virus did not discriminate was the worst miss truth ever it really did. What we needed at the time was government who could balance the economic and social damage against the scientific threat, what we got was a response more suited to a VHF or Polio than a SARS virus.

MarshaBradyo · 07/01/2023 20:12

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 20:03

Sorry i read it at first as you didn't believe the numbers.

I believe in freedom of information and Govts not hiding stuff.

Places were shut and laws put in place, we had little or no choice.

But what would you have done instead?

Tbh it wasn’t so much an argument for or against using it for compliance, just that it was very effective and we don’t need to do the same now re excess deaths (in response to pp asking about why we’re not hearing much on that atm).

I could probably post about whether it should have been used in that way but too covided out. Feel a bit blank on it so maybe another time 😀

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 20:03

Sorry i read it at first as you didn't believe the numbers.

I believe in freedom of information and Govts not hiding stuff.

Places were shut and laws put in place, we had little or no choice.

But what would you have done instead?

MarshaBradyo · 07/01/2023 19:35

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 18:58

Daily deaths were for compliance

Do you think they were made up numbers?

We had a new virus, hospitalising and in many cases killing 1000s per week and no vaccines.

I 'm really at a loss as to what anyone thought we could otherwise do, countries like US, Brazil and Russia tried a no or little lockdown plan and suffered enormously.

Plus unless you believe the moon landings were fake, it should be remembered that most of the developed world came to the same conclusions.
Our mistake was locking down to late and then forced to do so for far longer.

With huge implications for the NHS and social care.

None of what you have posted changes the basic fact that reporting daily deaths was an effective method to get compliance.

Especially as you’ve written Do you think they were made up numbers? so assuming something not even written.

Reporting was effective and meant the public complied, pretty much over what was expected

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 18:58

Daily deaths were for compliance

Do you think they were made up numbers?

We had a new virus, hospitalising and in many cases killing 1000s per week and no vaccines.

I 'm really at a loss as to what anyone thought we could otherwise do, countries like US, Brazil and Russia tried a no or little lockdown plan and suffered enormously.

Plus unless you believe the moon landings were fake, it should be remembered that most of the developed world came to the same conclusions.
Our mistake was locking down to late and then forced to do so for far longer.

With huge implications for the NHS and social care.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 07/01/2023 18:20

BirmaBrite · 07/01/2023 13:50

This does happen in some cases. But private beds are not free...

@WiseUpJanetWeiss to be fair nothing is free is it ? I was wondering about the available number of beds in private hospitals that could be utilised as a short term measure and I wasn't suggesting they be provided for free. What do we need ? staffed beds, what does the private sector have ? staffed beds ! The resource is there, we already pay the private sector for residential and domicillary care so why not in this instance, to get the NHS back on an even keel ?

Well yes, it could be done in part but the government would have to pay for it. Which it doesn't want to do. The private sector is a bit stretched at the moment too - my friend had to wait 2 months for orthopaedic surgery recently.

Isitsixoclockalready · 07/01/2023 17:21

Goingforplatinum · 07/01/2023 13:04

In no way do I blame staff in any way shape or form. I think all staff, GPs, consultants, doctors, paramedics, nurses, hca's, domestics and everyone that works for the NHS is doing an amazing job, and I really do feel for you with what your dealing with ATM. But can you honestly say hand on heart that it's safe??

What would you like to do? Assuming that we can all agree that it's not fair to disenfranchise people from accessible healthcare - not everyone could afford or would be provided with private health insurance through their employer, what is the alternative? There is no one stop shop for resolving the issues that the NHS faces. It does need an update but we all need to take responsibility too. We can reduce the impact on it by keeping healthy (as much as we can - some things are out of our control) and knowing what A&E is there for and not abusing it. Equally though, it needs investment and people need to feel encouraged to work for it.

I think that there are genuine debates to be had but I'm also a bit cynical about posts that suggest that the NHS is finished.

DrManhattan · 07/01/2023 17:18

@Oher I agree with you but those smokers and drinkers pay a shit load of tax. Dont know the maths but they could pay more in than they take out.

KnittedCardi · 07/01/2023 17:15

carequalworker · 07/01/2023 16:57

The initial big mistake, right at the very beginning, was to run the NHS and Social Care separately with two distinct budgets, two departments, two entirely different entities running the disparate systems. If anything were to change, this single change would make a huge difference.

@KnittedCardi Yes agree, this would be hugely transformative.

Integrated Care Systems should help, but because of budgets and crises, keep on being put back.

Eilan50 · 07/01/2023 17:13

carequalworker · 07/01/2023 16:57

The initial big mistake, right at the very beginning, was to run the NHS and Social Care separately with two distinct budgets, two departments, two entirely different entities running the disparate systems. If anything were to change, this single change would make a huge difference.

@KnittedCardi Yes agree, this would be hugely transformative.

I remember hearing this very thing being discussed on tv a few months ago. They were saying that back when the nhs was first proposed Aneurin Bevan & co made a decision that Free at the point of delivery applied to medical treatment only. Social care would be means tested and that's the reason it was not part of the nhs.

carequalworker · 07/01/2023 16:57

The initial big mistake, right at the very beginning, was to run the NHS and Social Care separately with two distinct budgets, two departments, two entirely different entities running the disparate systems. If anything were to change, this single change would make a huge difference.

@KnittedCardi Yes agree, this would be hugely transformative.

itsgettingweird · 07/01/2023 16:48

Eilan50 · 07/01/2023 15:12

@MarshaBradyo but we are being required to change behaviours.
My local health board has twice recently had to put out a Do Not attend A&E notice.
My GP sometimes has their messaged changed to say they have staff shortages so call back tomorrow unless it's an emergency.
This is making us change by not accessing healthcare

My Gp surgery hasn't accepted any e consults or anything not urgent for 5 weeks.

itsgettingweird · 07/01/2023 16:46

Why were we given a daily total of covid deaths for 2 years, long after the peaks, but we're not being told how many excess deaths we have daily now.
My guess is because the covid deaths were "the public's fault".
Excess deaths through people unable to access healthcare is not the publics fault

Spot on

LynneBenfield · 07/01/2023 15:52

Oher · 07/01/2023 15:35

The elephant in the room is the level of alcohol abuse in Britain.

Alcohol and smoking cos the NHS £17 billion 2017-2022. www.sheffield.ac.uk/news/nr/alcohol-to-claim-63000-lives-over-five-years-1.718406

I don’t drink alcohol. I don’t smoke. Why should I endlessly fund the medical problems of those who do?

Hmm

Unhealthy lifestyle behaviours (smoking, drinking, poor diet), personal responsibility and public health are complicated. As for the financial side, very few people are actually net contributors to the NHS and the enormous tax levied on those products goes into the general pot which helps to pay for the NHS and other public services. I do think that money should be ring-fenced for the NHS but that will never happen.