Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS has already failed.

310 replies

Goingforplatinum · 07/01/2023 11:05

5 hour wait for a cat1 ambulance for a child. Unresponsive patients being taken to hospital by neighbours. 90 hour wait in A&E, unsafe staffing on wards, 7 month wait for coil or implant fitting. The NHS isn't failing. We need to admit its failed

OP posts:
Flowersinthebasement · 08/01/2023 13:50

Thanks for the discharge lounge information. Seems daft not to have any space for them, given that they would help free up much needed beds.

lacey79 · 08/01/2023 13:48

Flowersinthebasement · 08/01/2023 13:41

Regarding delayed discharges and holding up a bed, are there not "Discharge Lounges" in hospitals? I haven't been a hospital user (yet!), nor do I know the system very well either, but I would have thought that where a patient is ready to go home, they could be moved to an area away from the ward to wait for the discharge papers and any prescriptions etc.?

Surely this would free up beds immediately, but I am not sure if it happens or not. It does in Ireland, a friend's mum was in a hospital in Dublin recently and on discharge was sent to the hospital's discharge lounge for med script etc. Then went home.

A lot of discharge lounges have now been turned into ward areas because of the need for more beds. We had a couple of f wards where a bay was used as a lounge-type area for that department, but they don't last long and ended up being turned back into bays quickly.

carequalworker · 08/01/2023 13:47

@Flowersinthebasement There are in some hospitals but not right across the board, and these are at capacity too.

Flowersinthebasement · 08/01/2023 13:41

Regarding delayed discharges and holding up a bed, are there not "Discharge Lounges" in hospitals? I haven't been a hospital user (yet!), nor do I know the system very well either, but I would have thought that where a patient is ready to go home, they could be moved to an area away from the ward to wait for the discharge papers and any prescriptions etc.?

Surely this would free up beds immediately, but I am not sure if it happens or not. It does in Ireland, a friend's mum was in a hospital in Dublin recently and on discharge was sent to the hospital's discharge lounge for med script etc. Then went home.

lacey79 · 08/01/2023 13:10

That also stands for adults. Pain is an emergency, if you are in unmanageable levels of pain a&e is absolutely the right place to go, but if you can manage that pain at home, you should. People come in without having tried pain relief. We ask when was your last dose and they'll say they haven't taken anything as they don't like taking tablets. But surely that's the sensible thing to try first? Departments are used incorrectly by such high amounts of patients, and we as staff cant just turn people away, we have to see them, and waste all the staff time running pointless tests and dispensing meds they could buy from their local corner shop.

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 13:07

midgetastic · 08/01/2023 13:00

If they have retired early it's because they have earned a lot which means higher taxes

Sorry not sorry

No it’s because pension schemes were radically different back then and many workplaces provided final salary pensions, or required shorter terms of service before retirement could be taken. Sorry not sorry 🤷🏼‍♀️

lacey79 · 08/01/2023 13:05

Grumpybutfunny · 08/01/2023 12:59

Are kids being seen more quickly tho? My (& imagine most parents) concern isn't the elderly on trollies in the corridor it's the danger of missing something in the young.

There are far fewer children than there are adults so yes they are seen much quicker, but there are still waits. I was there with my daughter recently, i called 111 first to get advice and then i was told she needed to go to be checked over. We waited 4 hours to be seen. 90% of the children there literally needed calpol and fluids, and could have stayed at home. They were triaged, given calpol, then spent 2+ hours running around the waiting room bored, tired, and hungry. Its scary as parents when your children are unwell, i fully understand that. However, i wish parents would try calpol at home, if it brings down a temp and perks up a child, they don't generally need to be seen in a&e, its not the right place.

Kazzyhoward · 08/01/2023 13:03

Proudboomer · 08/01/2023 12:50

The nhs needs a complete overhaul. Why do we still need a prescription from a doctor for basic antibiotics when you can walk into just about any pharmacy in Europe and buy them over the counter? Why do doctors give prescriptions for anything that can be bought cheaper over the counter things like aspirin or nit lotion?

The GP gatekeeping role also needs review. Why do you need a GP appointment to get a referral for hearing aids? It's not as if the GP has any "tools" to do hearing checks. You don't need a GP referral for dental treatment nor glasses!

Kazzyhoward · 08/01/2023 13:01

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/01/2023 12:34

For a start you are assuming that all that demographic is wealthy. For a second, despite being asked, you never seem to manage to define exactly what you mean by 'wealthy.' For a third, that demographic is shouldering some of the burden - pensioners pay tax in the same way the employed do. For a fourth, what you mean is you want them to shoulder a disproportionate share of the burden because they are older and by definition as you get older you need more medical care.

HTH

Pensioners don't "pay tax in the same way the employed do". They don't pay NIC for a start which is a tax. They don't pay student loan repayments (they were lucky enough to get free Uni tuition or a job that didn't need a degree in those days). They don't pay workplace pension contributions because they rightly assumed that there'd be decent state pension provision (unlikely for the future) or employed by an organisation providing a healthy pension scheme. Irrelevant now, but in the past, they didn't have their child benefit taken off them (another tax) when they earned more than the higher rate threshold!

It's a absurd travesty that the "deductions" from a pensioner with an income of £50k per year are a hell of a lot less than the "deductions" suffered by a worker on £50k per year.

NIC needs to be extended to all forms of income, or if they can't do that, it needs scrapping and income tax increased instead.

midgetastic · 08/01/2023 13:00

If they have retired early it's because they have earned a lot which means higher taxes

Sorry not sorry

Grumpybutfunny · 08/01/2023 12:59

lacey79 · 08/01/2023 12:49

From working in the hospital at the moment, the biggest area in crisis is the emergency department. To attempt to solve this we have divided up the department.

We have portacabins outside the main doors being used as GP spaces for patients that can be seen and discharged with a prescription quickly.

Adults have taken over children, the children's assessment unit has closed and children's a&e is now there in a bigger department with more staff to try and see them quickly.

We have various assessment units GPs can direct patients to cutting out a&e. We have a specialist decision unit, a frail decision unit, plus the medical and surgical that have been around for a while. All the direct patients to be seen by the correct department faster.

However, we still have the patients coming in with ear wax (actually happened over the busiest period), with their kids that literally need a dose of calpol, with people who could go to a pharmacy, or repeat visitors that need a MH assessment that A&E cant offer. We have over 300 patients currently with covid or the flu, but the amount coming into to a&e is far far higher and most don't require treatment. Plus the ever-growing number of vacancies and staff shortages. A&E departments just cant run effectively understaffed and overused by the growing population.

Are kids being seen more quickly tho? My (& imagine most parents) concern isn't the elderly on trollies in the corridor it's the danger of missing something in the young.

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 12:53

midgetastic · 08/01/2023 12:46

And on average because they are older they have already paid more than young people have paid

Not true either. They’re much more likely to have retired in their 50s or early 60s, so their ‘working life’ has been something like 30-35 years in many cases, not the 45-50 years we are facing. Plus only half of women in the 1970s worked. Some never went back at all after having children, or only part time.

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 12:51

midgetastic · 08/01/2023 12:44

But the wealthy pensioners are probably not the ones needing the most nhs treatment ( not least because pensioner wealth decreases with age )

Surely it's unfair to bung the healthy and unhealthy ones together ?

As soon as you try to segregate based on characteristics you get into a situation where ever more refinement of the characteristics seems reasonable till its everyone for themselves law of the jungle which as evidenced by the US isn't a good system

My mum is a care worker and my gran over the years has been an ‘unofficial’ carer for lots of elderly people (befriended through church, her own mum died young so we think some kind of replacement mother figure type thing, but anyhow). Both have seen elderly people in huge, unsuitable properties who refuse to pay for the level of care they clearly need and would rather fall every few weeks and end up in A&E. If anything the wealthier they are the more reluctant they seem to part with any of their cash. One of my mum’s clients lived in a large flat (converted stately home) and every time the paramedics arrived he couldn’t remember the code for the main door so they would have to smash the glass to get in. It drove the other residents mad.

Grandma is a very Christian, socialist woman but she could rant about this all day! As could my mum.

Proudboomer · 08/01/2023 12:50

The nhs needs a complete overhaul. Why do we still need a prescription from a doctor for basic antibiotics when you can walk into just about any pharmacy in Europe and buy them over the counter? Why do doctors give prescriptions for anything that can be bought cheaper over the counter things like aspirin or nit lotion?

lacey79 · 08/01/2023 12:49

From working in the hospital at the moment, the biggest area in crisis is the emergency department. To attempt to solve this we have divided up the department.

We have portacabins outside the main doors being used as GP spaces for patients that can be seen and discharged with a prescription quickly.

Adults have taken over children, the children's assessment unit has closed and children's a&e is now there in a bigger department with more staff to try and see them quickly.

We have various assessment units GPs can direct patients to cutting out a&e. We have a specialist decision unit, a frail decision unit, plus the medical and surgical that have been around for a while. All the direct patients to be seen by the correct department faster.

However, we still have the patients coming in with ear wax (actually happened over the busiest period), with their kids that literally need a dose of calpol, with people who could go to a pharmacy, or repeat visitors that need a MH assessment that A&E cant offer. We have over 300 patients currently with covid or the flu, but the amount coming into to a&e is far far higher and most don't require treatment. Plus the ever-growing number of vacancies and staff shortages. A&E departments just cant run effectively understaffed and overused by the growing population.

midgetastic · 08/01/2023 12:47

I begin to think a small GP charge is necessary - for those on benefits refundable in most cases

midgetastic · 08/01/2023 12:46

And on average because they are older they have already paid more than young people have paid

KnickerlessParsons · 08/01/2023 12:45

Perhaps GPs need to grow some balls and tell such patients that they're wasting time and direct them to alternative services instead?

I completely agree. And I'm not averse to bringing in a charge to see a GP either. It would make people think twice about booking an appt.
It would have to be carefully thought through so that people who really need a GP but who are low income would still have access, and maybe a low priority service staffed by nurses/nurse practitioners/pharmacists as a triaging point (stand alone rather than part of a surgery as now).
You only have to watch GPS Behind Closed Doors to see how many people use the GP at the first sign of a runny nose.

midgetastic · 08/01/2023 12:44

But the wealthy pensioners are probably not the ones needing the most nhs treatment ( not least because pensioner wealth decreases with age )

Surely it's unfair to bung the healthy and unhealthy ones together ?

As soon as you try to segregate based on characteristics you get into a situation where ever more refinement of the characteristics seems reasonable till its everyone for themselves law of the jungle which as evidenced by the US isn't a good system

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 12:37

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/01/2023 12:34

For a start you are assuming that all that demographic is wealthy. For a second, despite being asked, you never seem to manage to define exactly what you mean by 'wealthy.' For a third, that demographic is shouldering some of the burden - pensioners pay tax in the same way the employed do. For a fourth, what you mean is you want them to shoulder a disproportionate share of the burden because they are older and by definition as you get older you need more medical care.

HTH

Where did I say ‘they are all wealthy’? I have never once said that. It is true that pensioners are the wealthiest demographic in this country, whether you agree or not. They’re also the biggest users of the NHS, and therefore I fail to see why expecting them to contribute to their own social (not emergency or medical) care is such an outrageous thing to say. Not only would it save the taxpayer some much needed cash, it would prevent them falling over and ending up in A&E as much as they do, freeing up beds and relieving the pressure on everyone.

’HTH’

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/01/2023 12:34

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 12:29

What is derogatory, untrue or unpleasant about sharing the view that the wealthiest demographic in the country should shoulder some of the burden? Do tell.

For a start you are assuming that all that demographic is wealthy. For a second, despite being asked, you never seem to manage to define exactly what you mean by 'wealthy.' For a third, that demographic is shouldering some of the burden - pensioners pay tax in the same way the employed do. For a fourth, what you mean is you want them to shoulder a disproportionate share of the burden because they are older and by definition as you get older you need more medical care.

HTH

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 12:31

We do need more beds but we also need to be using them properly. A third of beds in some trusts are taken up by people who don’t need to be there. To me it isn’t just about care packages after, it’s how they got there in the first place - an awful lot of them due to falls, broken bones etc (this is what happened with my grandparents. Granddad broke his leg, grandma ended up in hospital with him as a ‘social patient’ bed blocking for over 3 weeks because she wasn’t safe to be left home without him. Despite me trying to persuade them for years beforehand to live in a proper 24/7 care facility, but that’s a different story!).

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 12:29

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/01/2023 12:16

She really can't help herself, it seems. Every chance to post something derogatory and unpleasant about the elderly, and she's there.

What is derogatory, untrue or unpleasant about sharing the view that the wealthiest demographic in the country should shoulder some of the burden? Do tell.

midgetastic · 08/01/2023 12:24

The guardian article observes that all are struggling but Britain is struggling by far the most

KnittedCardi · 08/01/2023 12:19

Slightly off topic, but interesting article in the Telegraph today highlighting similar issues in Italy, Sweden, Portugal..... www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2023/01/08/not-just-nhs-health-services-imploding-europe/