Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS has already failed.

310 replies

Goingforplatinum · 07/01/2023 11:05

5 hour wait for a cat1 ambulance for a child. Unresponsive patients being taken to hospital by neighbours. 90 hour wait in A&E, unsafe staffing on wards, 7 month wait for coil or implant fitting. The NHS isn't failing. We need to admit its failed

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 19:36

To anyone saying the NHS hasn’t failed, or we have to wait for it to “totally collapse” - what exactly does that look like?

28 Days Later, I should imagine

Minfilia · 08/01/2023 19:32

To anyone saying the NHS hasn’t failed, or we have to wait for it to “totally collapse” - what exactly does that look like?

I don’t see that it can get much worse than closed hospitals, 2 day waits in A&E, continually postponed routine appointments, an inability to get a GP appointment, trying 111 and never getting a call back and no ambulances available….

What exactly else has to happen for it to be deemed a failure?!

Kazzyhoward · 08/01/2023 19:26

@Flowersinthebasement

I would have thought that where a patient is ready to go home, they could be moved to an area away from the ward to wait for the discharge papers and any prescriptions etc.?

But it's not just a few hours that they're waiting. Sometimes it can be several days, especially at weekends. Where would they sleep whilst waiting for the prescription or for the ward doctor to sign the discharge papers?

When both my Mother and FIL were in/out of hospital several times, and even myself after C-section, we were all "ready" for discharge on the Friday morning, but still there over the weekend, treading water, until finally all the ducks were in place on the Monday afternoon. Hospital pharmacies are notorious for being slow (although they blame the doctors for not issuing the prescription soon enough), and we experienced lots of doctors not working on Fridays, hence no one to sign the paperwork! There's just no urgency!

RedHouseWins · 08/01/2023 19:24

The NHS has not failed. It is being failed by a cynical money grabbing government hell bent on destroying it for personal gain. They've been quite open about the intention.

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 19:24

either way this bloke didn’t have it, or I would be stunned if he did, he looked mid fifties.

Anybody who is over 50 and does a sedentary job ( desk job ) and leads a sedentary lifestyle, should probably think about wearing low level compression hoisery. If they are overweight, definitely.

JenniferBooth · 08/01/2023 19:22

We also need to stop blaming everything on ‘mental health’. I have met very few overweight people who admit it’s because they like food, eat too much and struggle with the willpower to restrict it. However I’ve meant many who say it’s due to ‘mental health issues’, and further blaming the NHS for not setting up a serious of costly psychiatrist appointments to ‘work out why they’re eating too much’. We didn’t have this with smokers - it was a case of chuck the fags away and buy yourself some nicotine patches (smoking has massively reduced incidentally, since it became socially unacceptable

Am now wondering if you would have dismissed the mental health issues if they had done the opposite and restricted their food intake (anorexia)

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 19:17

a&e is a disgrace at the moment . I can’t even look the patients in the eyes I’m so ashamed of everything. I can’t even face going to work anymore . We had them on the corridor again this week .

@irene90 why are people needing to be nursed in a corridor in A&E ? why can't you move them to the appropriate ward ? Not sure how long you have worked here but we used to have a 4 hour limit thing in A&E ? What happens to people in the country you come from if they fall and injure themselves, so #NOF ? Do they have to wait for an ambulance on the floor for hours and hours ? Are they nursed in a corridor ? How do they get back home if they have mild dementia or develop delirium and need carers 3x daily ? It would be interesting to hear how social care works in other countries, are there intermeidiate/rehab beds in the community? or are family expected to take on the lions share of the care ? is social care and health care joined up ?

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 19:12

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 19:00

As for the circulation issue most times it diabetic neuropathy.

No it isn't, most of the time it is due to wear and tear on the vascular and arterial systems, some of which can be improved with a referal to a specialist vascular surgeon and other times with compression hoisery or bandaging. Diabetic neuropathy makes up a tiny percentage of the 'poorly legs' I see and is often down to poor glyceamic control over the years.

Confusedeither way this bloke didn’t have it, or I would be stunned if he did, he looked mid fifties.

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 19:00

As for the circulation issue most times it diabetic neuropathy.

No it isn't, most of the time it is due to wear and tear on the vascular and arterial systems, some of which can be improved with a referal to a specialist vascular surgeon and other times with compression hoisery or bandaging. Diabetic neuropathy makes up a tiny percentage of the 'poorly legs' I see and is often down to poor glyceamic control over the years.

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 18:55

Maybe we should get a certain number of GP appointments a year free - say, 3 - then charged after that. That way nobody has zero recourse to a certain level of GP access, but it stops the time wasters. A few years ago (before covid) I was speaking to a GP at a party who said there are a lot of patients who make appointments almost constantly, they’re either hypochondriacs or enjoy it as an ‘outing’. He said his response is usually to book them a regular slot (say every 3 weeks) so they’ve always got an appointment booked, but stretches out the time between them a bit. To be honest I thought that was totally wrong, it made me quite cross some people get this level of ‘special treatment’ while less demanding people fall down the list of priorities.

irene90 · 08/01/2023 18:53

I’m not originally from the U.K.
I thought the NHS was bad many years ago when I came . I work for it . I work in ED at the moment.

im of the opinion the main problem is how the population worships it . It’s really hard to admit faults on something you love so much, its like an abusive relationship. You know its not good for you but it’s hard to leave .

I see the nhs it as provider for health and at the moments it’s not providing anything good .

just the fact that you got to wait months for a scan or any sort of diagnostic investigation is dreadful .I have a 30 year old friend with heart failure who has been waiting months and months for an operation ..she is only 30 !

if I needed a scan , I’d happily pay for it to have it done in days rather than months . I’m sure I’m not the only one willing to do so .

where I am from is mixed . If you have the money , you pay , have all the investigations done quickly . If not , you join the national health system queue, which is shorter than here because not everyone is on it! There is lots of demand for private so costs are lower, like a mammogram would be 50£ ..nothing outrageous. Used to see a gynaecologist consultant for 100£ in 2/3 days if needed ..
yes it’s not fair having to pay , but neither is dying waiting for months untreated .

also , if you have to pay for your health , maybe it makes you value it a bit more ..maybe people will be drinking a bit less if they need to pay bills for sorting their liver/ falls that comes from it . Maybe they’ll lose weight too..

I don’t like the USA system but there are lots of alternatives in Europe ..just next door .

a&e is a disgrace at the moment . I can’t even look the patients in the eyes I’m so ashamed of everything. I can’t even face going to work anymore . We had them on the corridor again this week .

And yes , I am thinking of going back just to have access to medical care . So it’s pretty bad.

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 18:52

I must be mistaken as my ex had this done at GP 7 years ago, has it changed?

I know it is no longer offered by GP's in our area, it was 7 years ago, even to housebound patients, it now costs £84 privately.

Alexandra2001 · 08/01/2023 18:38

In my FiL case its some sort of vascular disease, misdiagnosed ..... he stopped complaining about it because he felt he was a "time waster" only when DD saw the sores that she got him in for a scan (via a different GP) his leg was turning black but to to see him walking, you'd never know....

He could have very extreme leg pain....

3 op's later, long stays in hospital and doubtless a small fortune, he is on the mend ... with both legs :)

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 18:38

You can't keep old, end of life, buildings forever. At some point they need total refurb, and that's very expensive, often more expensive than building new.

@Kazzyhoward I will defer to your knowledge on that. The problem is they closed them and there is no intention or funds to build new. So old building demolished, land sold off for housing and where does that money go ? it doesn't go towards a new facility to continue the provision of intermeidiate beds, so the end result is less beds for that purpose. I do appreciate that LA's have had a terrible time of it in recent years and have had to make really tough decisions when it comes to cutting services due to their own budgets being cut massively.

Goosefatroasts · 08/01/2023 18:31

There’s definitely a group of people who like to attend the GP for incredibly small and minor issues. My father is one of them and also my sister in law. It is genuinely like a hobby for them both. The GPs must think oh fuckinghell here they are again.

Alexandra2001 · 08/01/2023 18:31

You can't really base a medical diagnosis on an overheard conversation in shop... you may be right... i don't know but maybe what he didn't mention was he'd had recurring pain for many months, had a cold foot, was getting sores... you have no idea.

I just think to say we are nation of hypochondriacs because of one guy in shop is bit extreme.

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 18:29

As for the circulation issue most times it diabetic neuropathy. I’m type 1, neuropathy means you lose sensation in your leg so it wouldn’t cause pain anyhow.

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 18:27

It wasn’t that though, I had to listen for a few minutes to him saying he’d developed a ‘severe leg pain’ and that he wanted ‘an emergency appointment’ but was ‘being forced to wait 4 days’. He was walking around without any pain or difficulty. So either the pain was nowhere near as bad as he said, or it was coming and going enough for him to walk around the shops in which case I think 4 days is completely appropriate. For most people with leg pain, they wouldnt ask for an emergency appointment (or an appointment at all) until they’d rested it for a few days to make sure it wasn’t a sprain. Not him!

Alexandra2001 · 08/01/2023 18:22

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 16:51

We are a nation of hypochondriacs to be honest. I was in a shop this afternoon and overheard a man in front of me complaining about waiting 4 days for an ‘emergency appointment’ for his ‘bad leg’. Yet he was strolling around the shop without a limp or any outward sign of pain at all.

People can have very severe circulation issues in their leg that will end up with an amputation yet still walk perfectly normally.... my FiL would be a classic example of this.

My DD could show you many patients who come in walking and come out minus a leg when the op to fix doesn't work.

Its a huge problem but its often caused by life style, not least smoking and diet.

I think we are actually a nation of know it all's, people comment about matters they haven't a clue about.

Heard it today "well, its only one person, why do they need 4 ambulances?" (this was during an incident to recover someone from water, involving multiple agencies) never occurred to this man that there may be more than one victim, that the rescuers may need help too, that an ambulance could breakdown......

lacey79 · 08/01/2023 16:56

Goosefatroasts · 08/01/2023 16:50

@lacey79

Lots of good points but certainly in the winter a lot of appointments are for flu symptoms/infections etc that possibly require antibiotics etc. I couldn’t get a GP appointment at all pre Christmas and then I ended up with pneumonia. I didn’t attend A and E or out of hours as OOH were prioritising under 5s only. On the 6th day I got lucky and got an appointment. Was very ill by this point though and definitely considering A and E.

Absolutely. I also had pneumonia back in November, one particularly bad night i was in bed at 4 am struggling to breathe, i pulled all my chest muscles so couldn't cough without agonising pain to try and clear it, but i wouldn't have been since in the walk in and a&e was the wrong place, it also took me days to get a gp apt that i would have absolutely paid for ha that been an option. Something needs to give, maybe payments from primary care is the first option, but its just one very small pat in a massive list of failures that need fixing.

I love our NHS, i will never leave my NHS role as i enjoy seeing all different patients from all walks of life and backgrounds and being to help all of them equally to the best of my ability. However, it is at the point of breaking and failing the public who need it most.

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/01/2023 16:51

SnackSizeRaisin · 08/01/2023 16:36

It could pay for itself by reducing demand. Every gp apt costs about £70 so a tenner contribution isn't that much. But if 10% of people decided not to attend, that would make a huge saving

We are a nation of hypochondriacs to be honest. I was in a shop this afternoon and overheard a man in front of me complaining about waiting 4 days for an ‘emergency appointment’ for his ‘bad leg’. Yet he was strolling around the shop without a limp or any outward sign of pain at all.

Goosefatroasts · 08/01/2023 16:50

@lacey79

Lots of good points but certainly in the winter a lot of appointments are for flu symptoms/infections etc that possibly require antibiotics etc. I couldn’t get a GP appointment at all pre Christmas and then I ended up with pneumonia. I didn’t attend A and E or out of hours as OOH were prioritising under 5s only. On the 6th day I got lucky and got an appointment. Was very ill by this point though and definitely considering A and E.

SnackSizeRaisin · 08/01/2023 16:36

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/01/2023 15:55

And where's the money coming from for this extra bureaucracy? have charges for visiting the doctor and it'll be sliding scales how old you are, what conditions you have, how many times you've missed an appointment before, what benefits you're on, how many children do you have, do you have your own transport to appointments or do you rely on public transport, how many appointments missed before you get charged and what's your income? that's before we get into who chases this up and does it affect your credit score and what's the penalty for not paying?

Before you know it the scheme costs three times what it brings in.

It could pay for itself by reducing demand. Every gp apt costs about £70 so a tenner contribution isn't that much. But if 10% of people decided not to attend, that would make a huge saving

lacey79 · 08/01/2023 16:20

@Goosefatroasts

If the income generated just goes towards paying for locums, how is that going to help? Being seen at the GP often requires a referral to a specialist or further investigations. All these services are also under pressure.

I think payments - if they work - would free up those attending emergency services for antibiotics and the like, and has the potential to stop some conditions from becoming more serious and requiring inpatient interventions. But in the grand scheme of what is failing, I'm not sure it'll make a dent.

What is needed, IMO, is to reopen the closed-down emergency departments. We currently cover 3 areas that since had their own a&es. Reopen community and cottage hospitals that allowed patients requiring less treatment to be transferred there. streamline services more, at the minute community nurses for example cant access hospital systems and vice versa, it makes the transfer of care between departments a nightmare, as they just can't communicate. I was with community nurses recently, and each visit costs the NHS £65 at least, in one day we turned up at 3 patients' houses and they were in the hospital, but the community teams online system doesn't notify them, all that time and money wasted that could have been saved if their system synced with the hospital one, streamline social care into the NHS so it's easier for patients to get support. More hospitals at home/virtual wards, where we check in on patients daily and give them treatments, but without them needing a bed.

Al this requires staffing though, we need to make coming to the UK for nurses from abroad and training our own more attractive. I agree what the unions are asking is a bit OTT, but make training free again, pay students for their training, make the starting wage more attractive (£30k as opposed to £27k, its not a massive hike but and realistic). We need to make the role of the carer more attractive, properly monitored, decent pay and training. Avoid burnout, when i worked in care homes 60 weeks were the norm, not the exception.

Its a mammoth seemingly impossible task, but if all these things dont happen, the NHS will only get worse till it does collapse entirely.

FandP · 08/01/2023 16:11

DomesticShortHair · 07/01/2023 11:12

The NHS failed when people had to do some pretty drastic things in order to protect it, rather than the other way round.

This

Swipe left for the next trending thread