Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS has already failed.

310 replies

Goingforplatinum · 07/01/2023 11:05

5 hour wait for a cat1 ambulance for a child. Unresponsive patients being taken to hospital by neighbours. 90 hour wait in A&E, unsafe staffing on wards, 7 month wait for coil or implant fitting. The NHS isn't failing. We need to admit its failed

OP posts:
Theeyeballsinthesky · 09/01/2023 08:04

Virtual wards

this is a paper from the British geriatric society on the use of virtual wards with older people

BirmaBrite · 09/01/2023 08:01

Theres a box given to patients with these items in, they are then educated how to use them or a family member is. These items sync to a programme that the HCP can view remotely. They speak via video call and do home visits where ness or if they need bloods. They actually do work really well for certain demographics of patients. Hospitals can be the worst place, for sleeping for example which is vital for recovery. Being monitored, having regular contact, 24 hour access to people, but in the comfort of your own home with decent sleep and meals, can increase recovery time massively

That is really interesting @lacey79 Can you give any examples of where this is working well currently ? I can see it working well with some people with long term conditions. Just as some diabetics are given the new body worn monitoring devices which sync with their phones, although I am not sure how often the data is reviewed by their team ?
Does the team providing the service you mention offer 24/7, 365 access to a HCP and is that for advice or can they also prescribe ?

Throwawaytheusername · 09/01/2023 01:04

@QueenCremant Please try to separate yourself as an extremely hard working individual from the “system” that is letting everyone, including staff, down. In my case my criticism is not of the individuals who were doing the observations at all hours, holding my hair back as I was being violently ill, making sure I didn’t choke to death.

It was the person who wasn’t there that could have made the difference. (And I don’t mean this in the sense medical staff need to be robots that work 24/7. I mean adequate staffing to ensure cover)

I mean, I guess an individual somewhere must have dropped the ball at some point as apparently there simply wasn’t the right specialist available for the 24 hours I was there. I know everyone is human but there was NOTHING in place to catch the error. That is what is failing.

@lacey79 Look, I don’t know how to say this without being seen as disrespectful, but I did speak to more than one GP and got absolutely nowhere. I’m not medical and don’t have the vocabulary to use the magic combination of words that would have gotten me referred to a specialist against the opinion of two GPs.

I do think that someone at the hospital making a recommendation to my GP that I be seen by the specialist they couldn’t provide and do the imaging they suspected was necessary but couldn’t do at the time would have cut out a lot of the hassle in the long run. That makes no sense to me how that can happen and I do feel very let down, particularly now in hindsight.

So in my opinion, when a person is genuinely sick and they access a health provider at various points to try to get the help they need and that help is just not forthcoming, irrespective of the reason, it does in fact mean that the system is not working.

lacey79 · 08/01/2023 22:52

Throwawaytheusername · 08/01/2023 22:21

@lacey79 I find it very sad you are suggesting that it’s standard for the NHS to take several years to route a patient via mental health services for a very real physical condition. It’s also sad you assume that the NHS saw me right in the end. Once the one GP suggested I had mental health issues, there was literally no way for me to be taken seriously to get the referral I actually needed.

Im no longer using the NHS and Drs reading the NHS discharge notes are appalled that I wasn’t diagnosed that day/night, given my symptoms and what was observed by a DR in A&E.

This is a good example of how the NHS has been failing for a long time - not staffed adequately in the moment to make sure patients are seen by the right specialists; no follow through between the hospital and GPs to connect the dots to make up for these shortcomings; and no way for me, a patient, to make persistent (yet valid) enquiries about my health without being fobbed off as having “health anxiety”.

I didnt suggest your GP experience was right, i said your experience of leaving hospital without a follow up and that being down to a GP to arrange is protocol. Of the GP directed you incorrectly that is on them, and they shouldnt be allowed to dismiss you, or incorrectly refer, and you as a patient have the right to request a different GP or a referral you feel is appropriate. I just commented on the part about leaving the hospital without a follow up. That is standard.

QueenCremant · 08/01/2023 22:28

I haven’t read the whole thread as quite honestly, I find the nhs bashing so upsetting.

It isn’t entirely failing. There is still so much work going on. You have cancer, you get thousands of pounds worth of treatment for free. You may not get it as quick as you’d you’d like as demand outstrips capacity but you still get it. You are in danger of waiting longer for it because we do not have the nurses to give it. Hence the strike. But that’s another story.

It is so demoralising every day to read about the nhs failures when do many of us are working so hard and are close to burn out.

Throwawaytheusername · 08/01/2023 22:21

@lacey79 I find it very sad you are suggesting that it’s standard for the NHS to take several years to route a patient via mental health services for a very real physical condition. It’s also sad you assume that the NHS saw me right in the end. Once the one GP suggested I had mental health issues, there was literally no way for me to be taken seriously to get the referral I actually needed.

Im no longer using the NHS and Drs reading the NHS discharge notes are appalled that I wasn’t diagnosed that day/night, given my symptoms and what was observed by a DR in A&E.

This is a good example of how the NHS has been failing for a long time - not staffed adequately in the moment to make sure patients are seen by the right specialists; no follow through between the hospital and GPs to connect the dots to make up for these shortcomings; and no way for me, a patient, to make persistent (yet valid) enquiries about my health without being fobbed off as having “health anxiety”.

lacey79 · 08/01/2023 21:41

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 21:35

So i feel certain a VR bed at home (basically remote monitoring of a patient) WILL be part of these 7000 new beds.

Does that mean someone will be given a BP machine and sats probe and asked to check their own obs at home ? Or are we talking about other technology which is more complex and can be accessed 24 hrs by health professionals ? How widespread is this currently ? who is monitoring and reacting to the information provided by this technology ?

Theres a box given to patients with these items in, they are then educated how to use them or a family member is. These items sync to a programme that the HCP can view remotely. They speak via video call and do home visits where ness or if they need bloods. They actually do work really well for certain demographics of patients. Hospitals can be the worst place, for sleeping for example which is vital for recovery. Being monitored, having regular contact, 24 hour access to people, but in the comfort of your own home with decent sleep and meals, can increase recovery time massively

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 21:35

So i feel certain a VR bed at home (basically remote monitoring of a patient) WILL be part of these 7000 new beds.

Does that mean someone will be given a BP machine and sats probe and asked to check their own obs at home ? Or are we talking about other technology which is more complex and can be accessed 24 hrs by health professionals ? How widespread is this currently ? who is monitoring and reacting to the information provided by this technology ?

Alexandra2001 · 08/01/2023 21:29

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 20:52

The latest is 7000 new beds.. Where? ..and staffed by whom?

Thought the exact same thing @Alexandra2001 they wouldn't be as sly as to include the virtual wards or beds in A&E corridors into that number would they ?

The Tories include private medical insurance, private schools fees and student loans as money the UK spends on health and education. .....

So i feel certain a VR bed at home (basically remote monitoring of a patient) WILL be part of these 7000 new beds.

I listened to Marie Caulfield today.. when it suited her argument, the 13000 patients stuck in hospital were fluid and not the same people, when it didn't, she changed them to be the same 13000 folk..... very clever.

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 21:22

That NHS England website info was from August last year. Not sure how it is all panning out ? Are we supposed to believe it could be worse than this ?

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 21:19

From the NHS England website;

Health chiefs will outline plans to prepare local services for additional pressure, by creating the equivalent of 7,000 more beds through a mixture of new hospital beds, ‘virtual ward’ spaces and initiatives to improve patient flow over the coming months.

New hospital beds, would be nice to know exactly how many of those 7,000 beds are actually brand spankety new hospital beds wouldn't it ? Virtual ward beds mentioned, what's the guess that this makes up for 6,900 ? and initiatives to improve patient flow ? you mean getting people disharged ? as opposed to not having them admitted in the first place ?

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 21:06

Our Chief exec got a much better and bigger job due to that absolute guff, I doubt they would have had any personal interest in publicly calling it out.

colouringindoors · 08/01/2023 20:57

CurlyhairedAssassin · 07/01/2023 11:25

It amazes me when I think of the absolute guff we all swallowed from Boris during COVID. All this shit about the Nightingale hospitals, it was all for show so why didn’t anyone in the NHS call him out on it at the time, say it was a huge waste of money and absolutely pointless. We are left with the hangover of those huge huge mistakes.

Believe me, Many did but Boris does his thing...

colouringindoors · 08/01/2023 20:55

I don't like the word Failed as it implies lack of effort/skill of staff which in >90% of cases is not the case.

But it is definitely broken.

To think the NHS has already failed.
BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 20:52

The latest is 7000 new beds.. Where? ..and staffed by whom?

Thought the exact same thing @Alexandra2001 they wouldn't be as sly as to include the virtual wards or beds in A&E corridors into that number would they ?

Alexandra2001 · 08/01/2023 20:46

@Throwawaytheusername 2016 was the point at which the NHS failed every single target it previously used to meet.

By then we'd had 6 years of below average funding and huge cuts in social care/council funding.

but yes the NHS has been dire for a while.

lacey79 · 08/01/2023 20:46

@Throwawaytheusername

Thats standard tbf. If your acute symptoms stop, hospital is not the place for u. A follow up is arranged by primary care generally. Its very rare in my dept we arrange them. We discharge, send to gp, gp do referral to outpatients if needed. Ward staff dont have the access to make outpatient appointments. Consultants/drs on wards dont have time to sort referrals for everyone who needs it. Its a GPs role to do so. What you experienced sounds like a standard route to seeing the right people

Alexandra2001 · 08/01/2023 20:44

The Conservative manifesto said they would build 40 new hospitals. I think what they meant was that they would re-build hospitals, not provide the bed numbers of the equivalent of 40 average sized hospitals, if you have a Conservative MP maybe you could email them to clarify this

BJ had no intention of building 4 new hospitals let along 40, its just another long line broken promises.

The latest is 7000 new beds.. Where? ..and staffed by whom?

I'd bet they include beds in Hotels for discharged patients & the so called virtual beds in peoples homes as well.

Throwawaytheusername · 08/01/2023 20:42

I don’t know, in my experience it was pretty dire in 2016, although, to be fair, I did get a bed after a few hours in A&E. No specialist available to do any investigation or diagnosis. Acute symptoms resolved overnight so I was discharged the following day with no follow up. Upon making enquiries with my GP about some kind of follow up, CBT was suggested for being overly anxious about my health. Years later I’ve finally seen a specialist and have been diagnosed with a chronic condition that has now needed several surgeries instead of one.
My point being, there have been issues for a while.

Alexandra2001 · 08/01/2023 20:40

Epiphany2023 · 08/01/2023 19:59

I think the number of beds is a problem:

www.statista.com/statistics/473264/number-of-hospital-beds-in-the-united-kingdom-uk/

Unfortunately it is not easy to increase numbers. I think the reduction in bed numbers is due to lack of staff rather than costs or physical space.

Down here, they built new hospitals decades ago, with fewer staff & beds than previous, they had the staff.

Easiest way to save large amounts of money is to cut back staff... less staff less beds.

The removal of the bursary was done to get less student nurses/ahp's ... even now, neither party will say they will re instate... why?

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 20:30

Unfortunately it is not easy to increase numbers. I think the reduction in bed numbers is due to lack of staff rather than costs or physical space.

The reduction in bed numbers is due to many factors, lots of people now have surgery as a day patient, which is brilliant, key hole surgery is generally quicker and less invasive and means less recovery time in hospital. It has revolutionised surgery. So the number of day patient beds has massively increased. This is a good thing.
What isn't such a good thing is the reduction in the number of all the other beds the NHS used to provide and which unfortunately are still needed, especially with an aging population.
When I started my training many moons ago the general hospital I trained in had three (30 bed ) mental health wards, two acute and one geriatric. Now there are no acute mental health beds. Everything is done in the community or miles and miles away or privately ( see recent news about how that has panned out) , so those people end up on general wards or surgical wards, being looked after by staff who have limited training in mental health.
We used to have a 30 bedded facility ( run by the local LA ) for step down and respite care, that has also gone, never to be replaced. We are clinging on to the limited rehab facilities by the skin of our teeth.
They got rid of the admission prevention team and chose to go down the discharge service route. Both are required in reality as anyone who has worked in the NHS for more than 5 minutes is aware. But you could argue that it is cheaper if someone never needs a bed in the first place ?

The NHS in England has just 100,000 acute and general medical beds for a population of over 56 million.

The Conservative manifesto said they would build 40 new hospitals. I think what they meant was that they would re-build hospitals, not provide the bed numbers of the equivalent of 40 average sized hospitals, if you have a Conservative MP maybe you could email them to clarify this ?

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 08/01/2023 20:20

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 18:52

I must be mistaken as my ex had this done at GP 7 years ago, has it changed?

I know it is no longer offered by GP's in our area, it was 7 years ago, even to housebound patients, it now costs £84 privately.

Exactly. Silent, creeping privatisation.

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 20:01

I do get your point though @Kazzyhoward , nobody should be taking up a bed that isn't required simply because they are waiting for paperwork and medication, perhaps we need more Doctors and pharmacists ?

Epiphany2023 · 08/01/2023 19:59

I think the number of beds is a problem:

www.statista.com/statistics/473264/number-of-hospital-beds-in-the-united-kingdom-uk/

Unfortunately it is not easy to increase numbers. I think the reduction in bed numbers is due to lack of staff rather than costs or physical space.

BirmaBrite · 08/01/2023 19:50

@Kazzyhoward I used to work on a busy surgical ward and this is how it went. Ward round - consultant see's patient first thing in a morning and says you can go home today.Yippe thinks the patient and starts packing.
What isn't mentioned to them is that the Doctor who is in charge of completing the discharge paperwork needs to do another ward round on another ward before they can even think about doing it. Also they are a Obs/Gynae doctor so also on call for emergencies and theatre.
Now if the person is there for a completely planned surgery with a sort of defined discharge date and care pathway, then the Doctor can do a lot of the paperwork in advance, depending on any emergencies. Pharmacy will also have an idea of the medication they will need on discharge. So more straight forward.
We used to let people go without their meds and paperwork if they had someone who could pop back later ( always told them to ring first to check it was all on the ward ) and pick it up.
This worked really well for your ambulant, capacitous patient with a good support network of family or friends, who we were discharging with over the counter type medication.
We also had an alternative, an area where people could go and sit and get refreshments, whilst waiting for paperwork and medication, this was nurse led, I think it is pretty standard across NHS trusts as a way of freeing up beds.