Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS has already failed.

310 replies

Goingforplatinum · 07/01/2023 11:05

5 hour wait for a cat1 ambulance for a child. Unresponsive patients being taken to hospital by neighbours. 90 hour wait in A&E, unsafe staffing on wards, 7 month wait for coil or implant fitting. The NHS isn't failing. We need to admit its failed

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 10/01/2023 22:03

@Alexandra2001 Any meaningful changes, even small ones, will involve legislation. We could easily begin to bring in small elements of the French or German systems tomorrow, without ‘ripping up the NHS’ if we had the will and the skill I do not wish for that. I do wish to begin exploring the possibility.

You seem to be saying that we lack the skill. I don’t disagree but I don’t see why that should be a permanent state of affairs

BirmaBrite · 10/01/2023 21:36

Thank you for that @yubgummy , like I have said I have no issue with exploring a co-payment system in principal and we already have a two tier system for many things if you can afford to pay.
I suppose my biggest concern is we are not very good at privatisation in the UK from a consumer point of view, our track record is pretty shocking really, so I can't see this particular privatisation panning out any better. The parts of the NHS already outsourced aren't always great as it is, I am in touch with such a provider on an almost daily basis and they are quite frankly rubbish, fail to deliver their service, very little interest if you contact them and we are stuck with a substandard service until their contract finishes or they figure out they can't make enough money out of it !

yubgummy · 10/01/2023 15:54

BirmaBrite · 10/01/2023 10:30

Also @yubgummy , how does elderly social care work over in Australia ? Because you can't discuss one system without including the other as they are so interlinked, or at least they are in the UK because of our acute and general bed numbers.

Social care is also run on a public-private basis. Aged care (either in-home or dedicated facilities) is government-subsidised but there is a means-tested co-payment component. (Of course there are also fully-private providers too.)

www.myagedcare.gov.au/

There is a separate scheme called the national disability insurance scheme (NDIS) which funds disability-related support for people of all ages - this is more tailored and depends on situation obviously.

Australia isn't the perfect comparison, they have some challenges we don't and vice versa. But it's worth looking at to challenge some of our assumptions about the constraints we have.

And I think fear of introducing any level of privatisation has led us to the point where we are now: discreet, total privatisation only for the very rich, and no mechanism to allow middle-income people to add private funds into a public/private mix and increase overall funding.

Alexandra2001 · 10/01/2023 13:55

poetryandwine · 10/01/2023 12:26

I am not suggesting ‘ripping up the NHS’, @Alexandra2001 and I do not recall other thoughtful PPs pointing out that systems generating better outcomes may have something to teach us have suggested this either. Misrepresenting us helps nothing.

The steps we want to explore do represent evolution of the system.

Many posters have said "rip it up..." etc...

To go from what we've got now to a French, let alone a German style system would involve dismantling the NHS and starting again.
Plus creating whole new private insurance and health industries.... which in its self would involve changes to legislation & regulation.

Before we even think about reform, we need to get what we've got working to (at the very least) 2019 levels... that will probably take 3 or 4 years.

Its only by talking to my DD that i realise what an utter shambles the NHS is in and this Govt, as Tory MP Edward Lee said yesterday has no plan to change anything.... so to the 3 or 4 years i mentioned earlier, we need to add 2 more years until the next GE (assuming Labour win)

Paying people in social care more and giving them company vehicles, is hardly reform... it could be done tomo.

BirmaBrite · 10/01/2023 13:27

All the systems generating better outcomes tend to spend more and have more beds per 1000 people. It isn't unreasonable to suggest that if we had similar resources the NHS might work better than it currently does. I do think it is good to look at how these other systems function, for instance whilst Australia has a much smaller population than the UK, it has a very similar demographic, which is why I asked a PP about how social care for the elderly works over there.

One big issue I can see with fragmenting the NHS is that it would lose its negotiating power with pharmaceutical companies ? This doesn't seem to get mentioned a lot on the NHS threads.

poetryandwine · 10/01/2023 12:26

I am not suggesting ‘ripping up the NHS’, @Alexandra2001 and I do not recall other thoughtful PPs pointing out that systems generating better outcomes may have something to teach us have suggested this either. Misrepresenting us helps nothing.

The steps we want to explore do represent evolution of the system.

BirmaBrite · 10/01/2023 10:30

Also @yubgummy , how does elderly social care work over in Australia ? Because you can't discuss one system without including the other as they are so interlinked, or at least they are in the UK because of our acute and general bed numbers.

BirmaBrite · 10/01/2023 10:27

The NHS conversation should include comparisons to other countries which are culturally close to us and which have come up with different solutions to the same problem.

I honetly have no issue with that @yubgummy , especially as from a selfish point of view, as nurses are generally much better paid in other countries Wink

midgetastic · 10/01/2023 10:20

We are at the bottom of equivalent countries and we pay less and we have a more unequal society with a larger gap between rich and poor

These are all interlinked but until we all accept higher taxation ( Germany has 3% income tax just for social care) it can't get fixed

Alexandra2001 · 10/01/2023 10:06

poetryandwine · 10/01/2023 09:16

I agree with @yubgummy. Britain is bottom of the league tables on so many aspects of health care. Why should we not learn from peer countries who do things better?

Does anyone suppose we have less than half the hospital beds (per 1000 population) of other First World countries, according to the OECD, because we are so healthy?

.... its meaningless, we cannot rip up the NHS and start again, the disruption would be massive and very long lasting.

People keep saying "oh no one has copied the NHS" as well as not being strictly true, who has exactly copied Germany's or France's health systems or anyone else's for that matter?

The NHS has worked relatively well in the past but if you have decades of lower funding than e.g. France.... then expect much lower levels of service.

What we need is evolution in health care.

The problems in the NHS are fixable... Social Care, retention i.e pay, fund to france germany levels over 15 to 25 years and open up the NHS to anyone from EU, without visa health insurance requirements.

However, none of that will happen.... even yesterdays announcements weren't new money, the £250m for additional beds etc has to come from current budgets... so something else will be cut.

Doubtless in 2024 we'll also vote Conservative again too... followed by years of moaning about the NHS or whats left of it.

EatYourVegetables · 10/01/2023 09:20

It’s not failed.

The care system has failed, and the ageing population increased the pressure on both. This was entirely foreseeable and deliberately ruined by the fuckers in charge.

If we keep saying things like “the NHS is awful”, it will promptly be replaced by something much worse AND much more expensive.

Let’s hold the bastards to account in the next elections, shall we?

poetryandwine · 10/01/2023 09:16

I agree with @yubgummy. Britain is bottom of the league tables on so many aspects of health care. Why should we not learn from peer countries who do things better?

Does anyone suppose we have less than half the hospital beds (per 1000 population) of other First World countries, according to the OECD, because we are so healthy?

yubgummy · 10/01/2023 09:11

@BirmaBrite The NHS conversation should include comparisons to other countries which are culturally close to us and which have come up with different solutions to the same problem.

I'm in the UK and frustrated with the NHS. I also lived in Australia for some years and I love it here but I had a much better experience with Australian healthcare, why can't we make the comparison?

SleeplessInEngland · 10/01/2023 08:27

*so many peripheral things

SleeplessInEngland · 10/01/2023 08:26

At some point the British public will have to decide whether it prefers an nhs that offers all the things free it does currently, or more long-term Tory governments. Covid was bad but didn’t do this on its own. There are so Jenny peripheral things to sort out that would ease the burden, but they haven’t been.

BirmaBrite · 10/01/2023 08:20

Believe it or not, the NHS is not unique in offering “free” health care but it does seem unique in that its users seem pathetically grateful to be receiving any health care at all.

Bit harsh ! I am intrigued why you care so much about a health system in another country to insult its users ? You have one that you claim is far superior, so what's your beef ?

nolongersurprised · 09/01/2023 21:09

It isn’t entirely failing. There is still so much work going on. You have cancer, you get thousands of pounds worth of treatment for free. You may not get it as quick as you’d you’d like as demand outstrips capacity but you still get it

I live in Australia where there is a hybrid public/private system including a public hospital that is free at the point of use, with all the services the NHS offers. I grew up with, and worked in another hospital system that also has a free public health system.

Ive seen multiple posters on here grateful that the NHS provides basic health care to them, whereas that should be what a health service does, surely? Posters on here will say, “I can’t fault the NHS, when I presented with <various symptoms> I had investigations and then a diagnosis”. Or, when I was in labour and there was fetal distress I had an obstetric intervention and my baby was fine!”

Believe it or not, the NHS is not unique in offering “free” health care but it does seem unique in that its users seem pathetically grateful to be receiving any health care at all.

BirmaBrite · 09/01/2023 19:15

@Cuppasoupmonster everyone I know with a Libre says it is a gamechanger for their diabetes management Smile

BirmaBrite · 09/01/2023 19:13

I think the issue is that there isn't one magic fix for all.
We need people to prevent unnecessary admissions, be that intensive acute medical input or a mix of less intensive medical input and social care.
We need people to help people who have been admitted get home and get back on their feet if they have rehab potential.
We need alternatives if the above isn't possible.
We need falls teams, to help those without fractures get up off the floor and assess the reasons for the fall/provide equipment/advice.
We need to use technology where it is appropriate, but we still need lots of people working outside of the acute setting to allow the acute setting to function as it should.
What might be useful is a triage service that takes all the calls for the above services to cut down on referrals going to the wrong service ?

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/01/2023 17:54

BirmaBrite · 09/01/2023 08:01

Theres a box given to patients with these items in, they are then educated how to use them or a family member is. These items sync to a programme that the HCP can view remotely. They speak via video call and do home visits where ness or if they need bloods. They actually do work really well for certain demographics of patients. Hospitals can be the worst place, for sleeping for example which is vital for recovery. Being monitored, having regular contact, 24 hour access to people, but in the comfort of your own home with decent sleep and meals, can increase recovery time massively

That is really interesting @lacey79 Can you give any examples of where this is working well currently ? I can see it working well with some people with long term conditions. Just as some diabetics are given the new body worn monitoring devices which sync with their phones, although I am not sure how often the data is reviewed by their team ?
Does the team providing the service you mention offer 24/7, 365 access to a HCP and is that for advice or can they also prescribe ?

I have a libre worn on the back of the arm. The info gets reviewed once a year or so when I go for appointments but if I have any concerns before then I can book in with diabetes nurse. That’s plenty as far as I’m concerned, and the libre is completely life changing so I’m very grateful. It’s definitely keeping appointment numbers down from what I’ve read in my online diabetes groups.

paintitallover · 09/01/2023 17:20

I would like to see MPs have their pay rises since the pandemic recategorised as a lump sum, with a return to 2020 salary levels thereafter. Seems fair to me. Especially since their salaries rose £20, 000 since 2010.

BirmaBrite · 09/01/2023 15:42

The longer they remain in hospital the more deconditioned they become too.

Alexandra2001 · 09/01/2023 10:12

I see the Govt, in order to tackle failures to discharge patients are going to give hospitals £250m to help clear this, care home beds, hotels BUT the £250m will come from EXISTING budgets.

So robbing Peter to pay Paul... this really does show that the Tories are not interested in helping or solving NHS issues but to eventually remove it.

From what my DD tells me is that the patients who are medically fit but stuck in hospital are folk who can't get up stairs, prepare food or txfer from their bed.... they need physical help.

BirmaBrite · 09/01/2023 09:18

The demographic who are currently struggling to leave hospital would probably fail to meet the Virtual wards admission criteria ?
I agree that they sound good for your independent cohorts with chronic illness though.

BirmaBrite · 09/01/2023 08:54

That is a really interesting read @Theeyeballsinthesky thank you.

The sticking point that the frailty wards might face is Virtual Wards do not provide social care for patients who require support to return to their normal place of residence so there is going to need to be either social care provision or another team who can bridge that gap.

Swipe left for the next trending thread