Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS has already failed.

310 replies

Goingforplatinum · 07/01/2023 11:05

5 hour wait for a cat1 ambulance for a child. Unresponsive patients being taken to hospital by neighbours. 90 hour wait in A&E, unsafe staffing on wards, 7 month wait for coil or implant fitting. The NHS isn't failing. We need to admit its failed

OP posts:
crazeekat · 07/01/2023 14:09

This annoys me, the NHS has not failed, and is not a failure. The government and the private sectors they are allowing to charge extortionate prices for equipment has failed the public not the NHS.
Nurses and junior doctors are becoming ill themselves with stress and lack of support. They deserve their pay rise all of them. They have worked and a negative wage for decades also. There is no support whatsoever for nurses, they are angels when all is well and greedmongers when they put their foot down at their conditions. The nhs is a bottomless money pit because it has been abused system for decades, funding the pockets of so called managers and politicians who are supposedly trying to make it better. Bullshit.

I'm not saying it is perfect. There is lots of room for improvement, every trust has its up and downs.
But calling it a failure does not help, does nothing for staff moral reading this who are doing their absolute best every single shift they do to make a difference for their patients. Failure is what the government and their blind supporters want u all to believe.

KnittedCardi · 07/01/2023 14:08

PerfectYear321 · 07/01/2023 12:27

I wish people like you torieswould change the record. It's not just about money. We've had like what, 8 so-called Health Secretaries in the last 12 years of Tory rule? How can you begin to tackle any issues when you're only there for 18 months? In that period of time you've only just started to get your head around how the system works. Bear in mind none of these people have any experience in healthcare or the NHS. Maybe start by giving us a serious person in that 'role'?

Health secretaries/Government do no "run" the NHS, the NHS runs the NHS. "The NHS" gets funding from government, it flows down through CCG's, to hospital trusts and GP practices. The CCG's and trusts and GP's decide what to do with that money, so the people making the decisions are indeed those who should know what to do. That was the whole point of localism. The only thing you really blame the government for is not supplying enough money.

NHS Plans drawn up by governments are also always cross party, with lots of input from across the providers/patient groups. Great plans, often not implemented.

BirmaBrite · 07/01/2023 13:50

This does happen in some cases. But private beds are not free...

@WiseUpJanetWeiss to be fair nothing is free is it ? I was wondering about the available number of beds in private hospitals that could be utilised as a short term measure and I wasn't suggesting they be provided for free. What do we need ? staffed beds, what does the private sector have ? staffed beds ! The resource is there, we already pay the private sector for residential and domicillary care so why not in this instance, to get the NHS back on an even keel ?

Eilan50 · 07/01/2023 13:48

Lack of social care is a big problem.
But so is lack of GP access. People with long term conditions are managed by their GP - diabetes, heart and lung conditions etc.
But in some areas it's extremely difficult to access a GP appointment. People try for several days and then give up. So these conditions are not being properly monitored and controlled and they worsen to the point the person ends up in A&E.

The Gov has been being warned for years we were heading towards a national shortage of GPs and have failed to act. It's not something that can be fixed overnight as it takes years to train a fully qualified GP

rainydaysandcake · 07/01/2023 13:40

There are so many patients not been seen or waiting a lot. BUT there are also thousands of patients been treated (including my own child) and patients who receive expensive drugs or life saving surgery.

It's local authorities who are failing to provide social care for patients to move them out of hospitals so more patients can be seen / treated

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 07/01/2023 13:36

BirmaBrite · 07/01/2023 12:33

Those beds in private hospitals are already staffed though @PerfectYear321 ?

The NHS is struggling with the number of available beds, that is why there is carnage in A&E, they cannot move patients who need admitting onto the wards, because the wards are full.

This does happen in some cases. But private beds are not free...

DreamingofGinoclock · 07/01/2023 13:32

CurlyhairedAssassin · 07/01/2023 11:34

The delayed discharges isn’t always because of lack of social care though. Often it’s because of inefficient processes in the system and poor communication. When you have people fit enough to go home to their own houses and families and they are kept hanging around for 6-7 hours waiting for someone to sort their discharge out or their medication or get them booked in for an out patient visit in a few days, it all falls apart. There’s a bed there that’s being taken up that should be available for someone who actually needs it.

I’ve seen it happen so often. Even when I had my children it happened. DS2 was supposed to be one of those 2 or 3 hour discharges (what’re the minimum is). 6 hours I was waiting, perfectly fit and healthy. Baby seemed fine too but hasn’t had his final “sign off”. Therr simply was no-one to discharge us and I was terrified to just walk out in case it flagged us as neglectful parents for “not complying with standard medical checks” etc. So there was another statistic probably “our labour ward is full, we will need to send people to another hospital or keep them at home labouring as long as possible”. But a bed was there!

There is so many little administrative stuff like this that with a bit of thought simple changes could help.

Why not employ a non clinical staff member to carry out discharge management. Getting the papers ready making sure the relevant clinical staff have signed off on forward plans etc!

Also social care as others have mentioned need a major overhaul.

Staff need to be paid more, nurses bursaries for training/ uni need to come back. Then perhaps recruitment to levels needed may actually happen, in turn reliving stressed on staff because of staff shortages. (Granted this will take time to train and recruit).

Short term offer European medical staff visas with full residence and make the administration of this easy (you could require sponsorship of the recruiting hospital / trust)

Simarly overhaul is needed in how GPs are run. Make becoming a GP more attractive, but at the same time make it a 7 day a week service.

MichaelFabricantWig · 07/01/2023 13:15

Yes, it was really worth the shitshow of Covid restrictions to “protect” if. Thanks Tory voters, I hope none of you are daring to complain.

MakeMineALarge1 · 07/01/2023 13:13

People using ambulance as it's more convenient and cheaper than a taxi.
Yes this does happen.

DisneyChops · 07/01/2023 13:09

To be honest I would happily train to work in the NHS, if it didn't look like such a stressful place to work.
I already work in teaching, and that's a shit show too.

MakeMineALarge1 · 07/01/2023 13:07

We need to change our ways
We need to cut down on alcohol and drugs
We need a healthy lifestyles
We need to change our diet
We need to stop demanding GP appointments for coughs and colds
We need to accept illness and cope rather than demanding GP to sort things
We need to look after our relatives
We need to have frank conversations with regards to resus and end of life planning

Goingforplatinum · 07/01/2023 13:04

In no way do I blame staff in any way shape or form. I think all staff, GPs, consultants, doctors, paramedics, nurses, hca's, domestics and everyone that works for the NHS is doing an amazing job, and I really do feel for you with what your dealing with ATM. But can you honestly say hand on heart that it's safe??

OP posts:
SmokeyPaprika · 07/01/2023 13:00

The problem with social care is how generous should it be - what is the criteria, how easy to be awarded some free help at home.
At the moment we know people are in dire straits before carers are made available - but say a lonely 78 year old has had a few falls whilst working in the garden. Bit forgetful. So at risk of fractures and hunger as forgets to eat. Carrrs in? 1or 2times a day? If it’s refused is the SS to blame when his health problems increase?
People admitted to CHomes pay if they can, huge amounts- should everyone get free care at home. If that’s brought in I can see the costs spiralling out of control.

mumda · 07/01/2023 12:58

10 non clinical staff per bed?

MarshaBradyo · 07/01/2023 12:53

PerfectYear321 · 07/01/2023 12:50

Where's the insult? Confused

You seem upset re a question re funding and want posters not to even ask.

You wouldn’t get far in any discussion re NHS if you can’t talk about funding 🤷‍♂️

Kazzyhoward · 07/01/2023 12:51

yubgummy · 07/01/2023 12:34

People don't like the idea of introducing a two-tier system but we already have a two-tier system. I have a fancy City job. Our company offers an in-house GP we can see whenever we want. Or you can pay £50+ for various private GPs around town.

Tories didn't do this, rich people did it themselves because they could.

I'd much prefer a system like Australia where money follows you to the provider of your choice. You could get it for free and slowly or pay for a timed or longer appt slot with a private provider, govt pays £30 and you pay £20 instead of you paying £50. There are a lot of people who could afford £20 but not £50 so we lose out on that extra money people would potentially be prepared to contribute because there's no mechanism to accept it.

Nail on the head. We're stuck with the ideology of equality for all, which means everyone has to put up with substandard service and there's no incentive to improve. The ridiculous "internal business market" and fragmentation into separate trusts was supposed to create "competition" to improve standards but in reality, it's just a matter of being less crap than the alternative, not that many people have choice in who provides their treatment anyway!

PerfectYear321 · 07/01/2023 12:50

MarshaBradyo · 07/01/2023 12:36

And I wish people like you would be able to answer a question without insults.

But there we are. You can’t because a question triggers your type of response.

Where's the insult? Confused

Kazzyhoward · 07/01/2023 12:48

No it hasn't because it's not like that everywhere. I don't deny that there are problems but some areas are worse than others. I went to our local hospital yesterday and walked past A&E on the way, not a single ambulance outside and the sign outside was showing approx 30 minute waiting time!

The real problem is the fragmentation into dozens if not hundreds of different trusts doing different things, which means it's harder than it should be for resources to be shared and transferred between hospitals.

Notonthestairs · 07/01/2023 12:42

Perhaps we could have paid more to the NHS and social care by not spending millions of pounds on - the Britannia yacht, painting a trade plane, a Festival of Brexit, fixing the giant cock up of Trussonomics and not handing Tory peers (and their friends and family) vast amount of cash.

Or perhaps if we'd spent the last 13 years sticking with the IFS recommendations of 4% increase everything would be quite so run down now.

Pretending the last decade hasnt mattered or impacted service levels now is quite frustrating. Consistent maintenance and a long term workforce plan would have made a massive difference.

MarshaBradyo · 07/01/2023 12:40

Squisageandmosh · 07/01/2023 11:54

Sorry to say this but I think the time has come for everyone who CAN to pay a little towards their doctor appt and their hospital visit.

Just look at all the threads on Mumsnet about buying handbags and holidays! Don’t tell me there are people out there who can’t pay £10 towards seeing a GP or £20 towards a hospital visit. Why should people who earn £250,000 a year be able to access NHS care free?

We have to get our priorities straight! And it would certainly encourage people to turn up for their appointments and not to smash up A & E!

It doesn’t have to be like USA. Many European countries have a state subsidised and controlled obligatory insurance system which are NON PROFIT.
But the government has to be trusted not to be tempted to indulge in profiteering and I worry there are enough people at the top atm to set this up who have the correct integrity and authority.

I heard someone on the radio today suggesting a brilliant idea to retain staff too. (Obviously, pay staff more. Sort out social care.) But on top of that, why not when doctors and nurses are training, save their student fees, and give it back to them in a lump sum at the end of 10 years if they have stayed working in the NHS for that time?

We were with a relative in a European country during the summer who pays €28 to see the gp and gets 60% of that back through insurance. They can usually see a gp the same or next day after they call. The care they received was excellent.

Nominal pay is something to look at in terms of behaviour - ie will people get sicker or will they value the NHS more? Other countries use it.

However any system like ours relies on low users to pay more, and some pay twice. If you got close to users paying for what they use according to frequency it wouldn’t work.

That doesn’t mean charges definitely wouldn’t work (other countries use them) but that the idea the higher incomes are getting too much out of it isn’t the case.

Lbnc2021 · 07/01/2023 12:39

Ive been trying to cancel a procedure for next week and try and reschedule it, I can’t go because I’ve absolutely no child care on that one particular day. Since Wednesday I’ve tried to phone 157 times and phoned all different areas of the hospital and not one person will answer the phone on the number they gave in the letter that you’ve got to phone if you need to cancel. On the letter there’s a lecture about not turning up and how much that’s a waste for the NHS etc etc. Yes well I totally agree hence why I’m trying to cancel in good time.

MajorCarolDanvers · 07/01/2023 12:39

It's broken and change is needed.

MojoMoon · 07/01/2023 12:36

The NHS has been failed by the Tory government who have had 12 years to get to grips with the rising need for social care and health care from an ageing population.

They did not.

Social care is in crisis, thousands of beds are being used in hospital for patients who could be discharged to a care home.

Social care providers are almost entirely privately owned and reaping profits for their owners, some of which are offshore and pay little tax.

www.carehomeprofessional.com/care-home-sector-leaking-hundreds-of-millions-of-pounds-to-offshore-investors/

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/14/multinational-care-companies-new-tax-privatised

MarshaBradyo · 07/01/2023 12:36

PerfectYear321 · 07/01/2023 12:27

I wish people like you torieswould change the record. It's not just about money. We've had like what, 8 so-called Health Secretaries in the last 12 years of Tory rule? How can you begin to tackle any issues when you're only there for 18 months? In that period of time you've only just started to get your head around how the system works. Bear in mind none of these people have any experience in healthcare or the NHS. Maybe start by giving us a serious person in that 'role'?

And I wish people like you would be able to answer a question without insults.

But there we are. You can’t because a question triggers your type of response.

yubgummy · 07/01/2023 12:34

People don't like the idea of introducing a two-tier system but we already have a two-tier system. I have a fancy City job. Our company offers an in-house GP we can see whenever we want. Or you can pay £50+ for various private GPs around town.

Tories didn't do this, rich people did it themselves because they could.

I'd much prefer a system like Australia where money follows you to the provider of your choice. You could get it for free and slowly or pay for a timed or longer appt slot with a private provider, govt pays £30 and you pay £20 instead of you paying £50. There are a lot of people who could afford £20 but not £50 so we lose out on that extra money people would potentially be prepared to contribute because there's no mechanism to accept it.