Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS has already failed.

310 replies

Goingforplatinum · 07/01/2023 11:05

5 hour wait for a cat1 ambulance for a child. Unresponsive patients being taken to hospital by neighbours. 90 hour wait in A&E, unsafe staffing on wards, 7 month wait for coil or implant fitting. The NHS isn't failing. We need to admit its failed

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 07/01/2023 15:43

Badgirlriri · 07/01/2023 12:32

ANOTHER NHS bashing thread. Couldn’t you have added this statement to all the other ones? Is it time to have an NHS board?

I work for the NHS and our department isn’t failing. Yes staff are stressed and overworked but the care is there for our patients.

With great respect to you and your colleagues (from the bottom of my heart), we have to be allowed to discuss this.

No one blames NHS staff for this. We all know you are heroic.

But some of us are frightened and upset at the prospect that we won’t be able to obtain either primary or emergency care. We pay for this through our taxes and we have a right to talk about it without being accused of NHS bashing.

Eilan50 · 07/01/2023 15:41

The NHS is not free, we all pay for it. In this country we pay taxes to the Gov who then fund and control healthcare on our behalf. Other countries do things differently.

But the point is at the moment we're all paying for it but most of us can't access healthcare.
Are other countries such as France, Germany etc having the same issues with citizens still being asked to stay away from GO and A&E, or being told their wait for operation will be 2 years?

Oher · 07/01/2023 15:35

The elephant in the room is the level of alcohol abuse in Britain.

Alcohol and smoking cos the NHS £17 billion 2017-2022. www.sheffield.ac.uk/news/nr/alcohol-to-claim-63000-lives-over-five-years-1.718406

I don’t drink alcohol. I don’t smoke. Why should I endlessly fund the medical problems of those who do?

Oher · 07/01/2023 15:31

“Why should people who earn £250,000 a year be able to access NHS care free?”
^^
Because their taxes pay for it.

You could equally ask, why should someone who earns and contributes nothing towards it, be able to access the NHS for free?

All those services you use like hospitals and schools and police and streetlights and bin collection and so on aren’t actually ‘free’ they’re paid for by high earners. So
saying that high earners should have to pay to use the NHS is insane.

Let’s keep this simple. If a public service has collapsed, as the NHS has, then either taxes must go up, or the scope of what the service does must be reduced. Here, both are probably needed. (Why on earth are taxpayers funding unnecessary sex change operations and lifetime drugs for men with identity issues, when we can’t afford to run ambulances properly?)

Hey, remember pre-Brexit when some of us warned that the NHS was reliant on cheap labour from the EU? No? I do.

As of September 2022 there were 133,400 vacancies in the NHS. www.health.org.uk/news-and-comment/news/nhs-vacancy-rates-point-to-deepening-workforce-crisis

MojoMoon · 07/01/2023 15:17

Social care should be free at the point of use, regardless of housing wealth BUT there should then be much higher taxes on inheritance on everyone to fund this.

Those unlucky enough to need many years of dementia care are then treated the same as those lucky enough to die suddenly in their sleep while still living independently.

They both pass on the same amount of wealth to their families while also socialising the cost of the small number of people who need a long period of care across the entire population.

MarshaBradyo · 07/01/2023 15:15

Eilan50 · 07/01/2023 15:12

@MarshaBradyo but we are being required to change behaviours.
My local health board has twice recently had to put out a Do Not attend A&E notice.
My GP sometimes has their messaged changed to say they have staff shortages so call back tomorrow unless it's an emergency.
This is making us change by not accessing healthcare

Yes but it doesn’t require the level of emotive reaction there had to be to get people to stay home etc. that is a huge ask

KnittedCardi · 07/01/2023 15:14

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/01/2023 15:10

No. I don’t want to pay for social care for a pensioner sitting in a £1m mortgage free house.

But you already pay for their pension and healthcare, why not social care in particular?

Eilan50 · 07/01/2023 15:12

@MarshaBradyo but we are being required to change behaviours.
My local health board has twice recently had to put out a Do Not attend A&E notice.
My GP sometimes has their messaged changed to say they have staff shortages so call back tomorrow unless it's an emergency.
This is making us change by not accessing healthcare

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/01/2023 15:10

KnittedCardi · 07/01/2023 11:16

ifs.org.uk/news/nhs-2022-more-funding-more-staff-treating-fewer-patients-covid-impacts-linger

Some stats for interest. So many NHS related posts atm, of course, it's in crises, but the strain still seems to be coming from Covid in particular, and delayed discharges in general.

The initial big mistake, right at the very beginning, was to run the NHS and Social Care separately with two distinct budgets, two departments, two entirely different entities running the disparate systems. If anything were to change, this single change would make a huge difference.

No. I don’t want to pay for social care for a pensioner sitting in a £1m mortgage free house.

Coucous · 07/01/2023 15:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Luredbyapomegranate · 07/01/2023 15:08

It’s in crisis. There are some areas that seem to be in total failure.

But I suggest you take yourself to a country without public health provision before you declare it’s failed.

You’d be back in a hurry.

MarshaBradyo · 07/01/2023 15:07

Eilan50 · 07/01/2023 15:05

This^
Why were we given a daily total of covid deaths for 2 years, long after the peaks, but we're not being told how many excess deaths we have daily now.
My guess is because the covid deaths were "the public's fault".
Excess deaths through people unable to access healthcare is not the publics fault Hmm

It’s because you are not required to change behaviour or comply with any measures.

Daily deaths were for compliance.

Eilan50 · 07/01/2023 15:05

sst1234 · 07/01/2023 14:38

1000 excess deaths a week says so. But somehow it doesn’t make the news like the running tally during the Covid days. Makes you wonder.

This^
Why were we given a daily total of covid deaths for 2 years, long after the peaks, but we're not being told how many excess deaths we have daily now.
My guess is because the covid deaths were "the public's fault".
Excess deaths through people unable to access healthcare is not the publics fault Hmm

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 07/01/2023 14:54

MakeMineALarge1 · 07/01/2023 13:07

We need to change our ways
We need to cut down on alcohol and drugs
We need a healthy lifestyles
We need to change our diet
We need to stop demanding GP appointments for coughs and colds
We need to accept illness and cope rather than demanding GP to sort things
We need to look after our relatives
We need to have frank conversations with regards to resus and end of life planning

You are right.

MarshaBradyo · 07/01/2023 14:42

sst1234 · 07/01/2023 14:38

1000 excess deaths a week says so. But somehow it doesn’t make the news like the running tally during the Covid days. Makes you wonder.

Would you want it to be though? It’s just a way to comply to any restrictions

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 14:41

KnittedCardi · 07/01/2023 14:08

Health secretaries/Government do no "run" the NHS, the NHS runs the NHS. "The NHS" gets funding from government, it flows down through CCG's, to hospital trusts and GP practices. The CCG's and trusts and GP's decide what to do with that money, so the people making the decisions are indeed those who should know what to do. That was the whole point of localism. The only thing you really blame the government for is not supplying enough money.

NHS Plans drawn up by governments are also always cross party, with lots of input from across the providers/patient groups. Great plans, often not implemented.

The Govt of the day set the parameters, they set the targets and the estate building program, they set how the NHS is run, staff numbers, training places, tuition fees and which if any reforms take place - yes and also funding.

Govt does not have cross party support on the NHS, any more than they have cross party support on defence, education, council funding et el

You are either misinformed or seeking to pass the buck on who is really to blame for the failure in the NHS.

sst1234 · 07/01/2023 14:38

1000 excess deaths a week says so. But somehow it doesn’t make the news like the running tally during the Covid days. Makes you wonder.

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 14:34

Do you mean you just want more funding when you say this
Who pays more in your opinion

Its not about who pays more, its about political choices, hs2 and 10% pension increases for all (who tend to vote Tory) VS better pay for social care and nhs staff (who tend to vote Lab)

This country has had a decade of warnings about the demographic and staff time bomb & did nothing at all. we then had Brexit and now Covid.

I see first hand the devastation CV has on a largely vaxxed workforce, those who say "should have less or no restrictions" should consider what CV would have done to a un vaxxed population and NHS workforce &Delta was more deadly too.

MaryMcCarthy · 07/01/2023 14:24

There are at least 17 countries who spend more than the UK, per patient, on their healthcare service. And they don't all necessarily see significantly better health outcomes than we do here. We achieve great things relative to the resources we put in but unfortunately the resources have not kept up with demand because of ideological choices made by our governments.

That doesn't mean the system is broken or the NHS has failed. You wouldn't want to live in a country with a failed health service I can assure you.

Germany spend $7,300 per patient, France spend $6,100, Canada spend $5,900, even Ireland spend around $5,800 pp and of course the crazy USA spend $10,900 pp when everything's taken into account.

The NHS spends $4,300 so the idea we spend too much is absurd.

itsgettingweird · 07/01/2023 14:23

Yes I think he's pretty much failed in parts.

My ds has a neurological condition (degenerative).

Referred to OT by general consultant and adult neurology by specialist consultant.

OT went to peads but he turned 18 and neurologist sent to rehabilitation meds who can do nothing regards his meds etc.

Ds gotten worse. Now needing to use a wheelchair at times.

Told I need to see GP to get referrals done - for past 5 weeks GP have turned off e consults and won't give an appointment for anything that isn't urgent on the day.

This is just primary care level.

greybuolding · 07/01/2023 14:23

Goingforplatinum · 07/01/2023 13:04

In no way do I blame staff in any way shape or form. I think all staff, GPs, consultants, doctors, paramedics, nurses, hca's, domestics and everyone that works for the NHS is doing an amazing job, and I really do feel for you with what your dealing with ATM. But can you honestly say hand on heart that it's safe??

The NHS is not that black and white.

The bit I do? Hand on heart, yes, I provide a completely safe service. Patients are seen quickly, I treat them well, I've saved many lives and helped people go on and lead better lives and also die with dignity.

But I'm an AHP running a specialist service trust wide. I'm not the whole NHS.

Please don't tar every service with the same brush.

harrassedmumto3 · 07/01/2023 14:13

It depends on your luck and where you live. We had a 10 minute wait for an ambulance a few nights ago. The care that this loved one has been given has been excellent (still in hospital).

MarshaBradyo · 07/01/2023 14:11

MichaelFabricantWig · 07/01/2023 13:15

Yes, it was really worth the shitshow of Covid restrictions to “protect” if. Thanks Tory voters, I hope none of you are daring to complain.

Yes, it was really worth the shitshow of Covid restrictions to “protect” if.

Not sure if you were for or against restrictions with this? and if you think Labour wouldn’t have used them even more

Zebedee55 · 07/01/2023 14:11

Zebedee55 · 07/01/2023 14:10

From the GP onwards, it's failing us. But, it's been an inefficient monolith for decades, and it has just gone not a head.

It needs root and branch reform.

'Come to a head'

Zebedee55 · 07/01/2023 14:10

From the GP onwards, it's failing us. But, it's been an inefficient monolith for decades, and it has just gone not a head.

It needs root and branch reform.