Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS has already failed.

310 replies

Goingforplatinum · 07/01/2023 11:05

5 hour wait for a cat1 ambulance for a child. Unresponsive patients being taken to hospital by neighbours. 90 hour wait in A&E, unsafe staffing on wards, 7 month wait for coil or implant fitting. The NHS isn't failing. We need to admit its failed

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Alexandra2001 · 11/01/2023 19:19

www.theguardian.com/society/2023/jan/08/sick-man-of-europe-why-the-crisis-ridden-nhs-is-falling-apart

A very recent comparison & on funding.

BirmaBrite · 11/01/2023 19:09

Interesting listening to R4 tonight on PM who were covering that claim that other comparable European countries are seeing identical levels of chaos. They seemed to focus mainly on France who have similar issues with this Flu outbreak, but also have issues peculiar to France. Not sure if they covered Germany as was searching for an address in the dark and not having the radio on helps !

Alexandra2001 · 11/01/2023 15:41

@FlameGrilledSquirrel I didn't mean or intend to belittle you.

But even a cursory read through shows that the issues European health services are facing are tiny compared to what the UK faces.

If we are to get out of this mess, then trying to score political points to make out this is a european wide problem and not on the Tories (and to some extent Labour Governments too) will not help.

I despair when i listened to PMQs today.... Lab need to come out and pledge a min 10% pay rise for all NHS health workers and 5% for all other staff.... put the "How to afford" back to the tories as "Whats the alternative"

We have no choice.

FlameGrilledSquirrel · 11/01/2023 15:30

Alexandra2001 · 11/01/2023 15:12

you should read your own link....

Germany 35k vacancies.. the UK 285k.
France has less Dr's than in 2012 but still double what we have.
Spain 700k waiting for operations... UK 7.2m... we had 4m pre covid...

Its just not comparable.

I agree we are all facing a healthcare crisis but the UK's is off the scale.

Sweden is no longer the Gold Standard, right wing Govts have seen to that.... when i lived there 20 years ago, it certain did have a very good HS.

I did read it but thank you for the attempt to belittle. Haven't got the time to prepare a full presentation on the articles.

All I was doing was pointing out that the countries that we are being compared to frequently on this thread aren't exactly doing brilliantly themselves. Nothing more.

Alexandra2001 · 11/01/2023 15:12

FlameGrilledSquirrel · 11/01/2023 14:59

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-64216269

www.theguardian.com/society/2022/dec/14/a-ticking-time-bomb-healthcare-under-threat-across-western-europe

So it's not just here then?

As Sweden tend to be trotted out as the gold standard it is Interesting to see that we spend roughly the same as Sweden as a % of GDP.

www.visibacare.com/en-gb/articles/is-healthcare-in-the-uk-and-sweden-different

Main difference seems to be that Sweden have used the private sector for online consultations. Which doesn't quite fit the private bad narrative noting that when costs were massively increasing, the Swedes took the initiative and are starting to push for modernisation of their own services not just the British tactic of screaming about the nasty Tories or blindly throwing even more money at the problem without any plans to adapt.

If anyone can actually show something about the nasty Tory NHS privatisation agenda please publish it. fullfact.org/election-2019/nhs-private-spending/

you should read your own link....

Germany 35k vacancies.. the UK 285k.
France has less Dr's than in 2012 but still double what we have.
Spain 700k waiting for operations... UK 7.2m... we had 4m pre covid...

Its just not comparable.

I agree we are all facing a healthcare crisis but the UK's is off the scale.

Sweden is no longer the Gold Standard, right wing Govts have seen to that.... when i lived there 20 years ago, it certain did have a very good HS.

poetryandwine · 11/01/2023 15:06

I thought you were asking about GM’s views, @JenniferBooth I didn’t see anything of his concerning the vaccine mandate

JenniferBooth · 11/01/2023 15:04

You can be a vaccine supporter and still see that the vaccine mandate for care workers was insanity in a profession that was already short staffed.

FlameGrilledSquirrel · 11/01/2023 14:59

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-64216269

www.theguardian.com/society/2022/dec/14/a-ticking-time-bomb-healthcare-under-threat-across-western-europe

So it's not just here then?

As Sweden tend to be trotted out as the gold standard it is Interesting to see that we spend roughly the same as Sweden as a % of GDP.

www.visibacare.com/en-gb/articles/is-healthcare-in-the-uk-and-sweden-different

Main difference seems to be that Sweden have used the private sector for online consultations. Which doesn't quite fit the private bad narrative noting that when costs were massively increasing, the Swedes took the initiative and are starting to push for modernisation of their own services not just the British tactic of screaming about the nasty Tories or blindly throwing even more money at the problem without any plans to adapt.

If anyone can actually show something about the nasty Tory NHS privatisation agenda please publish it. fullfact.org/election-2019/nhs-private-spending/

poetryandwine · 11/01/2023 14:58

What about the vaccine mandate, @JenniferBooth ? George Monbiot is a big vaccine supporter

poetryandwine · 11/01/2023 14:49

@KnittedCardi According to the OECD, the average OECD member country has 5 hospital beds per 1000 of population. France with its highly lauded health system has 5.7. The UK with its health system now finally admitted by the PM to have major problems has 2.4. Our rather poor health outcomes speak for themselves. Are you suggesting we know something that other OECD countries choose to ignore?

We agree bed blockers by definition don’t belong in hospital, although they mostly started there because they were admitted for good reason.

Anon778833 · 11/01/2023 14:39

YANBU but people voted for this. I certainly didn’t!

KnittedCardi · 11/01/2023 14:39

MaryMcCarthy · 11/01/2023 11:48

Yeah because they're willing to pay for it.

Look at average healthcare spend per capita in Australia vs. UK.

In the UK we vote for governments ideologically opposed to paying for it.

In the UK we've convinced ourselves that we couldn't possibly pay any more.

But in Australia you don't bet everything paid for I believe. I think I have seen other posts where you pay something towards meds, you pay for ambulances, you pay for dental care. So, the difference is in what they (government and tax payer) have chosen to fully fund, which in this case is disability therapy. We could choose to do the same, but there is an entrenched inability in this country to even countenance paying for anything medical related.

KnittedCardi · 11/01/2023 14:33

poetryandwine · 11/01/2023 14:08

George Monbiot reports in The Guardian online today that the UK has lost 9000 hospital beds since 2010. There are about 13000 cases of bed blocking currently obstructing the system. In other words, the bed blocking problem, while very real, could be reduced by over 2/3 if the Tories had not cut hospital bed numbers.

GM has a further discussion of the £10B the Tories have quietly allocated to reserving beds in private hospitals for the next four years, instead of putting money into increasing NHS beds. He calls it the moral equivalence if the PPE scandal

Bed blockers, generally elderly, should not be in hospital beds at all. It is bad for recovery, it's stressful, they degenerate, and loose independence. You need to put the money into social care beds or home care.

The case for increasing hospital beds then diminishes. Acute hospital beds are generally not long stay, the majority, in modern medicine are for short stay post operative observation. Most people even after fairly major procedures can now go home after a couple of days.

Alexandra2001 · 11/01/2023 14:27

9000 beds? in a period when demographics should have meant an increase of 9000...

Anyway, the Cons want the NHS gone.. to be replaced with nothing at all.

After all we all managed before the NHS......

JenniferBooth · 11/01/2023 14:24

I bet he hasnt mentioned the vaccine mandate.

poetryandwine · 11/01/2023 14:08

George Monbiot reports in The Guardian online today that the UK has lost 9000 hospital beds since 2010. There are about 13000 cases of bed blocking currently obstructing the system. In other words, the bed blocking problem, while very real, could be reduced by over 2/3 if the Tories had not cut hospital bed numbers.

GM has a further discussion of the £10B the Tories have quietly allocated to reserving beds in private hospitals for the next four years, instead of putting money into increasing NHS beds. He calls it the moral equivalence if the PPE scandal

Alexandra2001 · 11/01/2023 13:53

nolongersurprised · 11/01/2023 12:02

In the UK we've convinced ourselves that we couldn't possibly pay any more

I agree this is part of it, but also that “our wonderful NHS” is so revered that no government will risk a major overhaul.

Been several major overhauls i.e. change to trusts, health and social care act.

But they don't work because they do not address long term funding, aims, staffing and integration of social care.

Whatever one Govt does.... gets redrawn by another 5 years later.

But now we have a situation where we wont tax more, tax take is falling, GDP is shrinking and the UK cannot borrow... so whatever happens after 2024.. the NHS wont improve and major reform, by their very nature will cost a fortune for gains many years hence... who is going to do that?

nolongersurprised · 11/01/2023 12:02

In the UK we've convinced ourselves that we couldn't possibly pay any more

I agree this is part of it, but also that “our wonderful NHS” is so revered that no government will risk a major overhaul.

MaryMcCarthy · 11/01/2023 11:48

nolongersurprised · 11/01/2023 11:06

My DH is an UK trained specialist, now also working in Australia. Consequently, we have family in the UK, including a young person with a complex disability. He can’t help but compare the early intervention and specialist involvement that his relative is getting (poor) to that which is accessible here. Australia has pretty good, government funded, community based therapy for children with disabilities.

Yeah because they're willing to pay for it.

Look at average healthcare spend per capita in Australia vs. UK.

In the UK we vote for governments ideologically opposed to paying for it.

In the UK we've convinced ourselves that we couldn't possibly pay any more.

nolongersurprised · 11/01/2023 11:06

BirmaBrite · 10/01/2023 08:20

Believe it or not, the NHS is not unique in offering “free” health care but it does seem unique in that its users seem pathetically grateful to be receiving any health care at all.

Bit harsh ! I am intrigued why you care so much about a health system in another country to insult its users ? You have one that you claim is far superior, so what's your beef ?

My DH is an UK trained specialist, now also working in Australia. Consequently, we have family in the UK, including a young person with a complex disability. He can’t help but compare the early intervention and specialist involvement that his relative is getting (poor) to that which is accessible here. Australia has pretty good, government funded, community based therapy for children with disabilities.

Alexandra2001 · 11/01/2023 10:37

@poetryandwine 100%

We aren't starting from scratch...

poetryandwine · 11/01/2023 09:41

Agreed, @Alexandra2001 . But either party, when in power, could choose to make a small start by exploring ideas such as co-pays, NI for pensioners who pay higher rate tax, etc. (Perhaps on a sliding scale) If anyone wants to issue with these particular ideas that is fine: that’s what debate is for. There are loads of others. The critics should try coming up with some

As you said earlier, evolution. The NHS is too big to tear up and rebuild.

Alexandra2001 · 11/01/2023 09:17

@poetryandwine Yes we lack everything.... ... we don't have cooperative funds that are genuinely not for profit, we don't have enough staff, buildings, equipment or the people to maintain it all.... then there is the money, we are talking 100s of billions... which we can't borrow for and people wont pay the taxes or in many cases, can't afford it.

In practical terms its beyond us, with planning for new buildings and training plus retaining of staff, we are looking at 15 plus years to get to a system like France/Germany.

BUT none of that can happen, because we have one party that wants an NHS and another that does not, so whatever Labour do in 2024 (if they get in) will be undone 5 or 10 years later when the Cons get back in.

Barclay can relieve pressure on the NHS by funding social care... he wont or even discuss pay for nurses to avoid strikes.

midgetastic · 11/01/2023 08:21

You are right - the 28 day cut off is clearly too low

But the excess deaths tracked the covid deaths well - a bit higher as a result of the short cut off - despite us knowing that there were hugely fewer accidental and asthma deaths

Even now they think part of the excess deaths today are covid deaths

sst1234 · 11/01/2023 00:36

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 18:58

Daily deaths were for compliance

Do you think they were made up numbers?

We had a new virus, hospitalising and in many cases killing 1000s per week and no vaccines.

I 'm really at a loss as to what anyone thought we could otherwise do, countries like US, Brazil and Russia tried a no or little lockdown plan and suffered enormously.

Plus unless you believe the moon landings were fake, it should be remembered that most of the developed world came to the same conclusions.
Our mistake was locking down to late and then forced to do so for far longer.

With huge implications for the NHS and social care.

Yes they were made up numbers. Dying within 28 days of getting Covid is not the same as dying of Covid.