Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do some parents do this?

186 replies

Biscuitbabe87 · 07/01/2023 10:34

I've noticed more often that whilst on public transport, parents with young children handing them tablets playing annoying repetitive music or tv shows(always without headphones)- this morning I've had to endure Dora the explorer for 3 hours! Why on earth do people think this is okay? Or am I being grumpy?

OP posts:
DappledThings · 07/01/2023 14:28

Headphones or sound off only. Sound coming out of phone or tablet in a public place is never acceptable. At any age.

Yesterdaywasntreal · 07/01/2023 14:25

'What would you have done 20 years ago?'

What would you do today?

ClaudiusTheGod · 07/01/2023 14:18

TotallyAverage · 07/01/2023 12:32

What a terrible waste of 3 hours when the parent and child could have been interacting and enjoying each other's company

I'm obviously a horrendous, lazy, selfish, entitled parent and my children are DOOMED because 3 hours of 'enjoying' my children's company on a bus sounds like utter hell.

I absolutely love spending time with my children, but would 100% use a screen on a 3 hour bus journey. With headphones.

What would you have done 20 years ago?

mincedtart · 07/01/2023 14:15

Sorry to derail but can people please stop saying things like “ADHD/ASD”. They’re not interchangeable. Not even slightly similar.

Suziesz · 07/01/2023 14:15

At the end of the day if you’re annoyed hearing a cartoon you would be annoyed hearing them whinging the whole time with no entertainment.

I have a very long journey to visit family via public transport. DD is too young to keep headphones on. I bring games, I read books, we sing songs, she has a nap etc but it’s a long journey and a long time to keep her occupied while cooped up so sometimes she will watch something on a low volume.
Frankly I don’t really care if it annoys someone. It’s quieter than many conversations around us and the people who would get annoyed would also roll their eyes if she was agitated no doubt 🤷‍♀️ you can’t win sometimes.

PrincessAnastasiaRomanov · 07/01/2023 14:06

I'm neuro diverse and so have a 'loud carrying voice I can't control'.
So I imagine I'm exactly the sort of person who gets accused of performance parenting.
My child is not nt either and I don't use screens very much. But if I did I'd be judged for that too.

It would be nice if people were not bitches.

QuertyGirl · 07/01/2023 13:54

TotallyAverage · 07/01/2023 12:42

Equating watching a tablet and spitting on the table though? Confused

MN is absolutely bonkers. I (and every other parent I know in real life) shall continue to use screens with headphones in restaurants and transport, those around me will silently thank me, and MNers will silently judge me. Meanwhile my perfectly normally developed children will have a nice quiet time playing and DH and I might have some peace for a short while in our otherwise noisy, chaotic and happy lives.

Do you sit at dining tables ignoring your companions and staring at a screen?

Do you yourself stare at a screen while your child stares at theirs? Why bother sitting at a table then?

If you do, that is bad manners and you simply have different standards. That is fair enough but I would find it very rude if you did that at the table.

I hosted an open day for potential new recruits. Those that stared at their phones during the lunch did not do well.

Manners cost nothing.

Sleepyblueocean · 07/01/2023 13:32

Ds doesn't use devices but does sometimes have noise/music making toddler toys in public places because they keep him calm. . He is 17 so anyone should be able to work out he is severely disabled.

PuttingDownRoots · 07/01/2023 13:21

My DD has sensory processing disorder... one of her triggers is other peoples devices (especially repetitive noises).

We used to travel first class so that she could get to the other end without being a shaking mess.

Thehonestbadger · 07/01/2023 13:20

@foxp3

I always click on them because it’s exactly what I’m paranoid about every time we leave the house!

Ive been tempted to have T-shirts printed for my son with IM AUTISTIC on them just so I don’t feel I need to explain myself or feel so hyper aware all the time, not that we should have to explain but still.

I get the argument of ‘yes but most kids don’t have additional needs so you’re the exception’ but actually since having DS I’ve been massively taken a back by just how common ASD and ADHD seems to be in children post covid. I mean, we had no family history on both sides, we never expected it and it certainly isn’t poor parenting (I cringe at how often ASD seems to be thought of as ‘just an excuse for lazy parenting’ honestly it’s the worst and threads like this are always a hot bed for ‘everyone’s autistic nowadays’ kinda comments) my son won’t acknowledge people and is totally non verbal… while my 19mo daughter will hold and conversation with you and say please/thank you no problem 😂

foxp3 · 07/01/2023 13:08

@Thehonestbadger

Just coming to say similar, and not to derail too much from OP, but as mindful as I am of keeping volume to a minimum I'm often on edge in case someone has a problem with my noisy almost-3 year old. Obviously they can't be expected to know he has autism. But I sympathise that they might not want to listen to his 70s disco music choices (even low volume, with him singing along) and be unaware of the screaming alternative.

Short of announcing ourselves and apologising every time we're stuck in a public place with strangers (eg GP waiting room) - I never know what's going to go down best. I don't mind too much what people think or assume but I really don't want to be confronted!

I don't know what I would have done pre-tablets. Probably just sung to him? Not sure there would have been a silent outcome whatever I tried.

Disclaimer: I know this thread isn't about autism. But I always click on these threads with interest to see how we might be coming across to others.

Fivebyfive2 · 07/01/2023 13:04

Obviously the ideal on a long journey is to rotate things around, so chat, snack, book, tablet with headphones or at least a very low volume, toy, repeat. Devices at loud volume with no headphones for an extended time would be annoying for other passengers. Although I do find it funny the amount of people horrified the parents didn't spend the entire 3 hours "engaging with the child" when you literally can't go a week on mn without someone moaning/judging about so called "performance parenting" which is usually just literally a parent talking to their kid in public. So yeah, basically parents will get judged by someone whatever they do so why not do whichever is easier for you and your family!

jannier · 07/01/2023 12:58

meetmynewusername · 07/01/2023 10:43

Because children can only draw or read a book once they are emotionally regulated. Giving a child a book isn't going to calm them from a tantrum because they need to use their prefrontal cortex to focus on the book and they can’t do that when upset.

Screens don’t call for as much concentration and processing though and the bright colours and sounds give the child a dopamine hit. So the child basically learns that the way to cope with difficult emotions is to look at a screen. Plus the games are addictive.

It’s a massive problem and no wonder mental health problems are through the roof. It is only going to get worse.

This exactly, were removing all creativity and the ability to sit think or daydream they even do it walking around the woods it's like the Pixar film where humans are in water beds attached to screens a wallowing mass of useless blubber

Thehonestbadger · 07/01/2023 12:51

@Biscuitbabe87

I think there’s a middle ground to be hit.
I have a nearly 3yo who is autistic and a 19mo who isn’t. I hate being in any sort of waiting around public situation with them tbh whether that’s transport, waiting for food at a table or in queues. It SUCKS. I honestly didn’t have a clue how much it would suck when I had them else I probably wouldn’t have tbh.

I tend to apply the following

  • Whack out a toy
  • shush and distract
  • present a snack/water
  • grab the phone and play YouTube

My 19mo is easier to distract as she’s interested in surroundings, people and everyday stuff but my eldest is totally in his own world and will not respond to anything other than snacks and YouTube really. I suppose the question is would you rather listen to YouTube (always keep it on low but he won’t tolerate headphones/earbuds) or my autistic child screeching, screaming and repeatedly smashing his head against things? It’s not his fault, or mine, that he’s disabled and he’s as entitled to use public facilities as everyone else.

As with everything else in life I think it’s just a case of ‘if you don’t want to tolerate other peoples noise/smells/presence, don’t use public transport’

TotallyAverage · 07/01/2023 12:47

Travel cluedo sounds awesome! I'm happy my eldest is nearly at the bananagrams stage. Even despite his development having been dreadfully hindered by screen use last time we were at pizza express... 🤔

MajorCarolDanvers · 07/01/2023 12:46

Nimbostratus100 · 07/01/2023 12:23

What a terrible waste of 3 hours when the parent and child could have been interacting and enjoying each other's company

How old are are your children?

FloraPostIt · 07/01/2023 12:45

Not public transport but at a nice-ish tearoom, child at next table with very loud tablet no headphones. For me, t really tainted what should have been a special treat. I got a souvenir fridge magnet which also feels tainted. Which is possibly a slight overreaction to be fair!

On the flip side, went for a family meal last year. My cousin brought his new girlfriend who seems to be some kind on magic child whisperer. She whipped the travel cluedo out of her tiny handbag and the kids (who hadn't played it before) loved it - no screens required. (Although I have no judgement when headphones used)

SomethingOriginal2 · 07/01/2023 12:45

I love that it only took 5 posts before the tories got blamed for a kid watching Dora the exploration on a train 🤣

Goldbar · 07/01/2023 12:45

TotallyAverage · 07/01/2023 12:42

Equating watching a tablet and spitting on the table though? Confused

MN is absolutely bonkers. I (and every other parent I know in real life) shall continue to use screens with headphones in restaurants and transport, those around me will silently thank me, and MNers will silently judge me. Meanwhile my perfectly normally developed children will have a nice quiet time playing and DH and I might have some peace for a short while in our otherwise noisy, chaotic and happy lives.

And I'd prefer to sit next to your children on a plane or in a restaurant rather than children noisily playing board games, throwing toy cars or chewing crayons or having their parents painstakingly 'interact' with them for hours😁.

glamourousindierockandroll · 07/01/2023 12:44

TotallyAverage · 07/01/2023 12:32

What a terrible waste of 3 hours when the parent and child could have been interacting and enjoying each other's company

I'm obviously a horrendous, lazy, selfish, entitled parent and my children are DOOMED because 3 hours of 'enjoying' my children's company on a bus sounds like utter hell.

I absolutely love spending time with my children, but would 100% use a screen on a 3 hour bus journey. With headphones.

If I had to be on a three hour train journey with anyone, the very last thing I would want to do is have to talk the whole way. I'd want to read or listen to something, maybe even doze a bit. Is that so bad?

Last time I took my 4yo son on a long journey, I had a whole bag full of sticker books, colouring books, dominoes and yes, a tablet and headphones that we used on a rotation. Expecting him to just sit still and converse with me the whole way would have been boring and frustrating for us both.

TotallyAverage · 07/01/2023 12:42

Equating watching a tablet and spitting on the table though? Confused

MN is absolutely bonkers. I (and every other parent I know in real life) shall continue to use screens with headphones in restaurants and transport, those around me will silently thank me, and MNers will silently judge me. Meanwhile my perfectly normally developed children will have a nice quiet time playing and DH and I might have some peace for a short while in our otherwise noisy, chaotic and happy lives.

MajorCarolDanvers · 07/01/2023 12:41

With headphones totally reasonable

Without headphones completely unreasonable

I don't think I could take 3 hours of Dora. I think I'd have said something.

inquisitorgeneral · 07/01/2023 12:35

I was on a plane recently and there were about three separate kids playing on tablets with the sound blasting. The cabin crew didn't do anything to stop them, though I have no doubt if I started blasting music from my phone to block out the sounds of Peppa and Dora, they would very quickly tell me to turn it off.

It's rude of the parents and shows no consideration of other passengers. If you can afford to buy a tablet then you can afford headphones too.

QuertyGirl · 07/01/2023 12:34

TotallyAverage · 07/01/2023 12:24

*Also, I don't understand why anyone would hand a screen to a NT child in a restaurant, ever.

What's next? Encouraging them to spit on the table?*

😂 This is sarcasm I hope

Nope.

It's basic table manners to engage with your fellow diners.

No screens at the table.

Notellinganyone · 07/01/2023 12:33

I commute every day both by bus and train and this drives me nuts. It’s also adults increasingly doing this. I usually say something.