Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell all of you pushy parents how much you're damaging your CHILDREN?!

132 replies

AbsolutelydisgustedGCSE · 07/01/2023 01:14

Yes, they're children. They're 15 years old and they don't know what clothes they want to wear, never mind what they want to do with their lives.
When I did my GCSEs, in a very strict independent school, the pressure was so bad that 4 of my schoolmates had eating disorders, 3 were pregnant, at least 3 had drug addiction and 2 turned up to exams drunk.
This was only 20 years ago.
My child is doing GCSEs this year and I've told them to try their best but, under no circumstances, to feel pressured into anything!!

OP posts:
Suprima · 07/01/2023 10:18

When I look around at my fuckwit cousins with zero critical thinking facility, zero concept of graft or zero life experience, I’m pleased I got the pushy parents.

TallTalesForShortAdults · 07/01/2023 10:18

Gem123J · 07/01/2023 01:56

I wouldn’t blame only pushy parents for rebellion. My DM never pressured me to do my homework, or to study, or basically anything. No emotional support at all and obviously I rebelled. I would of loved for her to push me to do my homework or to study (I actually did good in school but I could have done so much better). And then my DH grew up with plenty of emotional support but wasn’t pressured in doing anything and he made a lot of bad choices with education. Went to Uni to study astrophysics, went into a lot of student debt because he was basically partying all the time (as some do), and failed! After 2 years came back home with no degree. Also to this day he can’t make much decisions on his own, asks ne such silly questions such as how to cook something when it shows on the packaging, where this or that or everything is, if he should hoover after DD has gone to bed, literally things he could decide or look up for himself. He also never buys himself clothes, complains he has no clothes but doesn’t buy anything for himself. So I think pressure can be good sometimes and doesn’t always end up in rebellion.

Are you married to my husband?

Whatsshecalled · 07/01/2023 10:13

Odd post, I mean everyone agrees with your general concept, that's nothing new but you haven't included much context. Also 'Independent' DOES mean private in UK, academies are not Independent they're just an extension of the state system.

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/01/2023 10:11

Ffs if anyone thinks average = minimum wage then it’s them that needs to go back to school 😆

daybroke · 07/01/2023 10:11

@Cuppasoupmonster if she'd left school at 16 she wouldn't be a teacher. Not now at 23. She just wouldn't be.

So the options at 16 were stay in school or leave and get a min wage job.

She knows - now, she didn't at the time - that it would've restricted her options.

toocold54 · 07/01/2023 10:11

Because doing it as a mature student is many times harder than doing it at 18. I did it - and it was harder than going at 18.

Because I don't want her to have to experience the grinding poverty I did.

Yes that’s what I’ve said to my DD too.

She’s saw the struggle I had to go through and I tell her that having a well paid job means a nice big home, holidays, a cleaner etc all things that she’d love now but I can’t afford and so I’ve said that getting a higher paid job will mean getting these things.

But ultimately if she wants to muck out stables as her career I’m going to have to just be supportive and let her do it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/01/2023 10:10

@Cuppasoupmonster

Average careers to me are perfectly respectable and valuable roles like nursing and policing. It’s hilarious the snobs on here are confusing them with NMW dead end jobs, and shows how little you actually understand careers these days.

Totally agree about nursing and policing… they are extremely valuable jobs. But you do realise these careers require qualifications and application and hard work, right?

Dont put words in my mouth. I didn’t say anything about these being dead end jobs.

But if you think kids can sail into jobs like nursing and policing without GCSEs and without a bit of work and application at school you are deluded.

And telling a child that they are average and that there is no point having aspirations will not help them achieve these careers.

Hawkins001 · 07/01/2023 10:10

OhBitchPeas · 07/01/2023 08:55

Sorry but your example is unreasonable.

The pressure may have been hard for you.

But I went to a very rough school where several girls were pregnant by the time they were 14, drug taking was rife and two of my friends had bulimia.

And there were no pushy parents there...

That's what I thought is regardless of the pressure or lack of, there will always be some either way

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/01/2023 10:10

daybroke · 07/01/2023 10:06

To echo the previous poster. Dd is a teacher. That's not average to me and it's not min wage

It’s an average wage, and a perfectly respectable job. Average teacher salary £35k average salary in U.K. is £38k

Jazz12 · 07/01/2023 10:10

My parents were “pushy” and I am eternally grateful to them for my amazing career and great life.

daybroke · 07/01/2023 10:09

toocold54 · 07/01/2023 10:06

My job now - degree, masters, further professional qualifications - is much less stressful than my minimum wage jobs were. Working nights in a cafe home, serving in a shop, working in a call centre were all much more stressful.

This is what I tell my child/students.

There is nothing wrong with min wage jobs but they are much harder work than many other jobs that pay much more but also provide other benefits such as career progression, proper contracts and not zero hours, pensions, easier getting a mortgage etc.

Exactly.

I have a sufficient pension to keep me comfortably in retirement now that I wouldn't have had if I'd stayed in care work.

I get days off for conferences, to attend courses, I have private medical insurance, I wfh (which suits me because I'm ND) - and my job itself is something that just "fits" me and I don't find stressful.

I only actually "work" about 3 days a week. The rest of the time I'm keeping my knowledge up to date and doing career development and enrichment and outreach activities.

I'd far rather that than a 12 hour night shift in a care home.

QuinkWashable · 07/01/2023 10:09

Did you read the twins thread? The OP, and pretty much every respondent (at least when I read it) said that pitting them against each other was a terrible idea, and instead to off rewards to each based on result (my parents did that too).

My eldest just started secondary. He has exams twice a year. He goes to a private school - I think they do this so when the exams are actually important, they are used to the whole process, as whilst the exam results are communicated, and congratulated, they aren't pressured exactly - the teachers go to great lengths to explain that this is about monitoring so they know what to teach more on and effort, not about the final result.

At home, I have expectations, but I wouldn't really call myself pushy - maybe more pushy in some ways (they must do one instrument, and one club. They must hand in their homework on time - and I don't advise doing it last minute, but it's up to them if they do).

Seems to be working, but TBH, I think it very much depends on the character of the kids, and I wouldn't want to go congratulating myself until they're adults, just in case!

smileladiesplease · 07/01/2023 10:09

If your kids can't choose their own clothes at 15??? My dds had strong views at 3 on clothes and hair 😂😂

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/01/2023 10:08

CrazyGolfee · 07/01/2023 10:06

All the 'be happy, don't worry about anything' bullshit some people spout isn't helpful.

Being happy doesn't pay the bills. Working hard, getting the best grades you can and then getting a good job does pay the bills.

We should be honest with our children. Dossing around at school and making excuses not to work hard will not help you succeed as an adult.

Im on an average salary. I can pay my bills. Nobody is saying let your kids doss about and go on UC as a viable career option. Just that what a lot of parents push their kids towards is something that isn’t really achievable to them, and will just result in a lifetime of stress.

pinkyredrose · 07/01/2023 10:08

AbsolutelydisgustedGCSE · 07/01/2023 01:36

Independent

Academies aren't independent schools 😐

RewildingAmbridge · 07/01/2023 10:07

I went to a poor-average comp in a rough area. This kind of academic pressure/pushy parenting wasn't present, lots of parents didn't give a shit and thought it was a waste of time. If I look back at my year group the sheer number of teen pregnancies, arrests, prison sentences, suicides, self harm etc is astounding, even those who have done on are largely in minimum wage jobs and life is a struggle. Life is complex, expectation to do well at school isn't the root cause of these issues.

CrazyGolfee · 07/01/2023 10:06

All the 'be happy, don't worry about anything' bullshit some people spout isn't helpful.

Being happy doesn't pay the bills. Working hard, getting the best grades you can and then getting a good job does pay the bills.

We should be honest with our children. Dossing around at school and making excuses not to work hard will not help you succeed as an adult.

daybroke · 07/01/2023 10:06

To echo the previous poster. Dd is a teacher. That's not average to me and it's not min wage

toocold54 · 07/01/2023 10:06

My job now - degree, masters, further professional qualifications - is much less stressful than my minimum wage jobs were. Working nights in a cafe home, serving in a shop, working in a call centre were all much more stressful.

This is what I tell my child/students.

There is nothing wrong with min wage jobs but they are much harder work than many other jobs that pay much more but also provide other benefits such as career progression, proper contracts and not zero hours, pensions, easier getting a mortgage etc.

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/01/2023 10:05

You are assuming that a career which is competitive is going to be outside of most children’s capabilities. Why do you assume that?

Because it is? That’s why it’s competitive because ‘most’ children won’t achieve it?

Who said average = minimum wage? That makes no logical sense at all given the ‘average salary’ is well above NMW Confused

Average careers to me are perfectly respectable and valuable roles like nursing and policing. It’s hilarious the snobs on here are confusing them with NMW dead end jobs, and shows how little you actually understand careers these days.

daybroke · 07/01/2023 10:04

toocold54 · 07/01/2023 10:02

If I'd let DD do what she wanted - and not pushed her - she would've left school at 16 and gone to work a min wage job. She's now a teacher.

But why would you not let her do that?

I worked many minimum wage jobs before studying as a mature student and eventually becoming a teacher.

Part of me wishes I became a teacher sooner so I could have better options, money, future prospects etc.
But another part of me is glad I had those life experiences of being on min wage and understanding life a bit more.

I feel my DD will be the same and she’ll want a minimum wage job like mucking out stables or cleaning dog kennels, as that’s what she enjoys.
But I know that these are hard work, crap money and have no future career prospects.
So I’m struggling to know how much to push her.

Because doing it as a mature student is many times harder than doing it at 18. I did it - and it was harder than going at 18.

Because I don't want her to have to experience the grinding poverty I did.

TotteringByGenteely · 07/01/2023 10:03

What we've learnt from this post is that all children are different and parenting is all about doing what's best for your unique child.

toocold54 · 07/01/2023 10:02

If I'd let DD do what she wanted - and not pushed her - she would've left school at 16 and gone to work a min wage job. She's now a teacher.

But why would you not let her do that?

I worked many minimum wage jobs before studying as a mature student and eventually becoming a teacher.

Part of me wishes I became a teacher sooner so I could have better options, money, future prospects etc.
But another part of me is glad I had those life experiences of being on min wage and understanding life a bit more.

I feel my DD will be the same and she’ll want a minimum wage job like mucking out stables or cleaning dog kennels, as that’s what she enjoys.
But I know that these are hard work, crap money and have no future career prospects.
So I’m struggling to know how much to push her.

daybroke · 07/01/2023 10:02

@Cuppasoupmonster you're determined to belittle my descriptions of my dd.

If I hadn't pushed her she would've done no work at school and left at 16.

She was bright and capable enough but she had no work ethic or motivation. That's common amongst teens.

daybroke · 07/01/2023 10:01

My job now - degree, masters, further professional qualifications - is much less stressful than my minimum wage jobs were. Working nights in a cafe home, serving in a shop, working in a call centre were all much more stressful.