Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell all of you pushy parents how much you're damaging your CHILDREN?!

132 replies

AbsolutelydisgustedGCSE · 07/01/2023 01:14

Yes, they're children. They're 15 years old and they don't know what clothes they want to wear, never mind what they want to do with their lives.
When I did my GCSEs, in a very strict independent school, the pressure was so bad that 4 of my schoolmates had eating disorders, 3 were pregnant, at least 3 had drug addiction and 2 turned up to exams drunk.
This was only 20 years ago.
My child is doing GCSEs this year and I've told them to try their best but, under no circumstances, to feel pressured into anything!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
XenoBitch · 08/01/2023 00:36

I guess it depends what they are being pushed into.
As a kid, I was pushed into doing Judo, as a guise for it being a way to defend myself. I was absolute rubbish at it. Yet, I was hauled all over the country for competitions that I only got a trophy in because there were not enough people in my weight class to compete against. It had a huge effect on my self esteem. I was constantly being set up to fail.

blueshoes · 08/01/2023 00:30

@BuHao I would also add it is ingrained culturally in the Chinese mindset that success is the result of hard work, not necessarily natural ability. So if a student is not getting good grades, the answer is to work harder. There is no shame in needing to work harder than their more naturally bright classmate to get the same academic grades.

Weaker students are not pushed into less academic options automatically. They are expected to practice more.

I remember being fed 'motivational' stories of scholars taking drastic measures to pass the fiendishly difficult imperial exams in dynastic times because passing was the gateway to a successful civil service career. It develops work ethic.

BuHao · 07/01/2023 23:06

In the UK:
Independent and public schools = parents pay for schools. Public schools always cause confusion - these are independent (fee-paying) schools with status e.g. Eton, Harrow etc.

If you don’t pay - state school, and boy there are loads of those. Academies, free schools, upper schools, state grammar and on and on.

BuHao · 07/01/2023 22:59

I know what you are saying OP, and feeling that your worth is tied up in your grades must be hard. However, I work in a top school in China. High expectations and insane level of tutoring are just normal. Pupils end up well-educated, in part because everyone around them expects them to be. For them it is normal, and they react accordingly. Even the more challenging kids, still really care about their grades. There are no drop outs.

It isn’t just our school. China regularly churns out excellent grades. Chinese pupils in the UK still have families that prioritise education, and do better than any other pupils. Even Chinese pupils on free school meals outperform everyone except Chinese pupils not on FSM. So pushy parents from this culture get better results. It really isn’t rocket science. This also translates into highly paid careers.

It’s logically consistent - more work and effort when they are young results in better exam grades when they are older. You may choose not to subject your child to that, and I think it’s difficult to do so in the UK without causing a resultant victim mentality (because in the uk, being tutored for, say, 5+ hours per week would be unusual and pupils may view that as cruel), however, IME the fact remains that considerable effort leads to better results. Surely that is logical.

It doesn’t all need to end in teen pregnancy and rebellion. If the wider culture is consistent with hard work, then I feel that it’s more likely to be viewed as normal and adhered to. And as Chinese parents on FSM show, actually hard work at school pays off in the long run.

Needmorelego · 07/01/2023 19:18

@HyacinthBridgerton yes the CTCs were the early version of the Academy schools.
State funded but run separately from Local Authority schools and also funded by sponsorship and independent in the way that they could set their own admissions and curriculum.
Unfortunately the government wants all schools to be Academy schools now (and most are) so they are essentially the only schools available in most towns so the Local Authority sends the children there - because they is no longer LA alternatives.
'Academy' just means 'local bog-standard comp' these days.
Shame because the original CTC concept was actually quite a good alternative idea.

HyacinthBridgerton · 07/01/2023 18:46

The school I went to classed as Independent in all the stars etc. It was free. I think it was something like a City Technology College - founded in the mid 90s for kids aged 11 to 18.

HappyGrumpyDoc · 07/01/2023 18:37

For me there are a lot of mums on here who seem unable to accept their lovely child is perfectly average. ‘They’re so bright but it just doesn’t show in their school work’ ‘Their low grades is because the school isn’t supporting them properly’ ‘They’d do so much better if they just studied more than the hour a day they currently do’ etc.

No, your child is just average, and there’s nothing wrong with that.

There are also lots of teens who are quite bright, but unfocused, or maybe a bit lazy. They'd much prefer to play games online or chat with their friends rather than doing their homework. Or they have poor time management or study techniques and spend lots of time re-writing notes but not enought time absorbing them. And they understand very little about how the education system works.
It's all about balance. Of course downtime is extremely important, but there are many reasons even a bright student won't achieve well. If they don't bother studying the course, for example, or if they are not equipped with the techniques to enable them to get the best benefit from their work.

It's a parent's job to guide their child and to help them achieve their best.

IHateFlies · 07/01/2023 13:19

I've seen kids who were never 'academic' but do really well once pushed to study.
I think you're doing a child a disservice if you're not pushing them to get good results.that doesn't mean everyone will get 9's but most can get very respectable grades.

ChekhovsMum · 07/01/2023 13:11

There are shades of grey here aren’t there. It depends what ‘pushy’ means. But yes, parents who constantly compare their DC to others while making them effectively work a double shift with tutoring alongside extracurricular that they don’t even enjoy, deserve a special place in hell. YANBU.

blueshoes · 07/01/2023 12:45

lailamaria · 07/01/2023 06:03

@blueshoes hard work, to the degree of the posts op is talking about does kill people, the pressure results in burnout and burnout sometimes results in depression which then sometimes leads to suicidal thoughts, i can't believe you're that ignorant

Fair enough. For extreme cases. But for the average teenager, most would rather be out with their friends. Of course, unless they are the rare golden children who are ambitious and can project into the future, some pushing to revise is needed. Yes, it is hard work. But hard work is what begets success. Success gives self esteem and a sense of achievement. It is called the Matthew effect. A good work ethic is worth instilling.

It is much easier for me to say 'do your best, whatever', than to help mark the questions they are practising. I am a parent , I know what ds is capable of and I know that he will achieve more if he focuses on getting his revision notes together rather than going out and being on his phone.

PS no need to slur to make a point. You are more effective if you don't.

RoseGoldEagle · 07/01/2023 12:25

The science GCSE thread didn’t sound like a pushy parent to me- they were just asking the question about whether choosing to do double science at this stage could limit their daughters career options- nothing wrong with making sure your kids have all the information.

The twins thread- yeah that was crazy.

Wisenotboring · 07/01/2023 12:09

AbsolutelydisgustedGCSE · 07/01/2023 01:35

Indep is run outside of the council. Academies.

It really doesn't.

CeriB82 · 07/01/2023 11:52

My DD would not be where she is today without that push. She had a talent, and we saw that. And others in that field saw it. She became something and loved it once she realised it.

please jog on with your sweeping statements.

darjeelingrose · 07/01/2023 11:45

You think that independent schools are the same as academies, which means you know very little about education and how it works, so why should anything else you have to say on the topic be valid?

restorativejustice · 07/01/2023 11:14

If your 15 year old doesn't know what clothes to wear, how do they know what doing their best even means?

KittiKati · 07/01/2023 11:13

I couldn’t agree more. I’m a tutor and work with children of all ages and it seems pushy parents just care about exam results. It makes my blood boil that they can’t see how much they are damaging their self esteem and quashing their confidence.

I just tell my children to do the best they can - life is about so much more than how well you may or may not do in education.

restorativejustice · 07/01/2023 11:11

What does 'pushy' even mean in this context?

For many people it's a luxury to think you don't need to work hard or encourage your children to work hard at their education if you want them to be solvent and secure in the future, or to have options in terms of career. What does 'do your best' even mean? How do you know what someone's 'best' is if they don't push themselves?

Some 15 year olds do know what they want to do with their lives, and certainly know what clothes they want to wear. Helping them understand the steps that might be necessary to achieve what they want is good parenting. Vague 'do your best' is not.

EnyoClytemnestra · 07/01/2023 11:09

Why are you SHOUTING??

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/01/2023 11:05

@Cuppasoupmonster

Your central argument is that pushy parents all think their kids are “special” when in fact they should accept they are all very average.

You are probably right, statistically, most of these kids are not gifted. But you suggest that pushing “average” kids to achieve is either pointless or will damage them psychologically.

I am saying that sometimes even “average” kids need a bit of encouragement. Statistics bear this out. If only the gifted kids were going into quality jobs then you wouldn’t get any people advancing economically or socially at all in society. The fact kids do get jobs that are better than those of their parents bears this out.

But to do this kids need to have aspirations. They need to feel there is a reason to try and to improve. If it’s conveyed to them that goals and hard work won’t improve their chances why would they bother seeking these goals and applying themselves?

rogueone · 07/01/2023 10:38

hmm well the pushy parents i know are high fliers themselves and have high expectations of their DC. I don't know of any who ended up with kids who were drug addicts, pregnant or failures. In fact quite the opposite. All successful, did well in exams and uni and have good careers.

My mum used to shout and scream at me for not doing as well in an exam as my neighbours DD. That was the amount of 'pushy' parenting she provided. I was offered no practical guidance about next steps just shouted at. My DH however had two parents with aspirations for their DC, they were expected to work hard, it was in built that to succeed you work hard at school. They were provided with a loving nurturing home but with high expectations. Both excelled in their chosen careers .

So it really depends what OP means by 'pushy' parents.

sanityisamyth · 07/01/2023 10:29

SantasBigToe · 07/01/2023 01:16

The pressure to do well at GCSE resulted in pregnancies?

Lots of revision of the practical biology syllabus.

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/01/2023 10:26

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/01/2023 10:24

I (and others) have explained that we don’t believe this to be the case.

I’m not talking about working at Goldman Sachs or being a heart surgeon. There are plenty of decent, interesting, valuable and well paid careers between this and minimum wage jobs. But they need hard works and decent GCSES. And relentlessly telling a child how average it is won’t inspire it to achieve that.

who said anything about relentlessly telling them how average they are Confused

Iwonder08 · 07/01/2023 10:25

I know someone like you. Her child mentioned he feels too stressed when she mentioned gsce prep so she told him exactly that-not to worry and just do your best. He has no qualifications and no desire to do anything

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/01/2023 10:24

Cuppasoupmonster · 07/01/2023 10:11

Ffs if anyone thinks average = minimum wage then it’s them that needs to go back to school 😆

I (and others) have explained that we don’t believe this to be the case.

I’m not talking about working at Goldman Sachs or being a heart surgeon. There are plenty of decent, interesting, valuable and well paid careers between this and minimum wage jobs. But they need hard works and decent GCSES. And relentlessly telling a child how average it is won’t inspire it to achieve that.

BungleandGeorge · 07/01/2023 10:24

Perhaps you’d like to provide your evidence that addiction, teen pregnancy and eating disorders are caused by pushy parenting? Or is it just that you’ve decided that your parenting style is correct for all children and like to feel smug about how you’re getting it right and other parents aren’t?