Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL cut my daughter’s hair without telling us

219 replies

Lkjhgfdds · 06/01/2023 23:17

My partner and I have been together for 14 years. We have a 2 year old daughter.

We recently stayed at the in laws for Christmas and MIL was looking after our daughter most of the days, so I can rest (I am also pregnant with our second).
On the last day before we were going to leave, MIL cuts our daughter’s hair without telling me or my partner. (The cut is not good and not bad)
I was furious and confronted MIL, she admitted it.
It has affected me so much that it has caused arguments with my partner everyday. It has now got to the point where I don’t want my MIL to see our daughter but my partner still wants her to carry on seeing our daughter. We haven’t reached a compromise so now we have decided to separate because he chose his parents over me.
Am I being unreasonable? Should I just get over it and let my MIL see our daughter.

OP posts:
Snippedasababy · 07/01/2023 09:09

Fraaahnces · 07/01/2023 08:58

Time to sit them both down and lose your shit with them both. Establish boundaries and stop caring about who cares about how you look or protecting their precious feelings. You have been a doormat for too long. Grow an iron spine and start saying no to MIL when she shows up. Tell her to call YOU first and ask if it is a good time. Tell her that your kids are YOURS. Cutting hair, piercing ears, etc, without your permission are assault. None of this will be tolerated. If DH wants you to remain his loving wife, then he is going to have to learn the circles of priorities theory (draw it for him) because until he does, you are rapidly losing respect for him. Every time he allows his mother to come between the two of you, the more emasculated you feel he is. He needs to back you up or move back to mummy’s house. If that happens, you will move with DD to wherever you are happiest.

Wow, you just posted advice that tells op to abuse her husband and her child!

Excellent advice!

saraclara · 07/01/2023 09:02

If that was me I'd probably have gone to her house and ended up smacking her in the face.

Yes, that's so much more reasonable than her trimming a tiny bit of hair.

pictoosh · 07/01/2023 09:01

Fraaahnces · 07/01/2023 08:58

Time to sit them both down and lose your shit with them both. Establish boundaries and stop caring about who cares about how you look or protecting their precious feelings. You have been a doormat for too long. Grow an iron spine and start saying no to MIL when she shows up. Tell her to call YOU first and ask if it is a good time. Tell her that your kids are YOURS. Cutting hair, piercing ears, etc, without your permission are assault. None of this will be tolerated. If DH wants you to remain his loving wife, then he is going to have to learn the circles of priorities theory (draw it for him) because until he does, you are rapidly losing respect for him. Every time he allows his mother to come between the two of you, the more emasculated you feel he is. He needs to back you up or move back to mummy’s house. If that happens, you will move with DD to wherever you are happiest.

Scary stuff.

rogueone · 07/01/2023 08:59

Well you have failed in your attempt at going NC as now your separating from your partner he will be ensuring the relationship with his DC and his mum continues. Cutting her hair is outrageous, you challenged her and she has apologised. What more are you after?

Fraaahnces · 07/01/2023 08:58

Time to sit them both down and lose your shit with them both. Establish boundaries and stop caring about who cares about how you look or protecting their precious feelings. You have been a doormat for too long. Grow an iron spine and start saying no to MIL when she shows up. Tell her to call YOU first and ask if it is a good time. Tell her that your kids are YOURS. Cutting hair, piercing ears, etc, without your permission are assault. None of this will be tolerated. If DH wants you to remain his loving wife, then he is going to have to learn the circles of priorities theory (draw it for him) because until he does, you are rapidly losing respect for him. Every time he allows his mother to come between the two of you, the more emasculated you feel he is. He needs to back you up or move back to mummy’s house. If that happens, you will move with DD to wherever you are happiest.

Rabbitsandhabits · 07/01/2023 08:52

She sounds a bit full on and hard work and I would want to draw a few boundaries for her too BUT you didn’t mind her minding her child for DAYS so you could rest? You can’t have been too bothered by the past behaviour to let her do that when it suited you. If you need so much help when pregnant then I suspect you will be grateful for her when you have a newborn.

pictoosh · 07/01/2023 08:51

Try to understand that when your mil lavishes her attention on her baby granddaughter at meals and family events, you view it as an invasion while your husband only sees his own loving mum enjoying his child. So what if she's in the middle of the photos? She's proud of the family she helped to raise.

Do you have to be the main feature every time? Jesus, you've plenty of photo opportunities without her.

TheOinkySplit · 07/01/2023 08:51

She should have asked really. Was it a drastic haircut, or just getting it out of her eyes? (As my mum and MIL always say about my boys)

why is she taking presents away? That's strange.

WomanhoodIsABirthright · 07/01/2023 08:50

I don't agree with all the posts saying this is nothing. I'd hit the fucking roof.

My mum kept our first locks of hair that were cut and I've still got mine.

My nephew had a beautiful curl at the back if his neck but wasn't ready for a full cut yet. My sister was letting it grow so she had a decent bit to tape and keep.

One day he came back from his paternal aunts and she'd cut it of and thrown it.

For what reason, we'll never know. It wasn't her place and he didn't need a cut anywhere else, the front wasn't in his eyes or anything, and even if it was, it's for his parents to sort out.

If that was me I'd probably have gone to her house and ended up smacking her in the face.

Cutting another person's child's hair is not acceptable, there's no reason for it at all, except as some stupid power play or vindictiveness.

saraclara · 07/01/2023 08:48

Also you're cutting of your nose to spite your face. Whose going to look after your child/ren 'most of the days so you can rest' now? When that baby arrives and you're a single parent of two, you're going to be more than a bit tired

Mariposista · 07/01/2023 08:43

Separating over a haircut? Are you always so hysterical?

Xrays · 07/01/2023 08:41

So the hair cut was so minor and barely noticeable that you had to actually ask your mil if she cut it? 😳 And you’re this upset? Wow.

Grumpybutfunny · 07/01/2023 08:33

You have been going on about it everyday that why he's separating not the hair which will grow back. Yes you have been unreasonable! If my MIL had cut DS hair badly the limit of my anger would be enjoy taking him to the barber to get it sorted DH she your mother

MassiveSalad22 · 07/01/2023 08:33

Jesus. To be honest I already thought you sounded precious when you said MIL was looking after your kid for DAYS so you could rest just because you’re pregnant. Fair enough if you’re having issues in your pregnancy, but days? and where was your DH??

I’d be pissed off about not asking about the hair but it will grow back and it’s not something to separate over.

WandaWonder · 07/01/2023 08:32

Nowthenhere · 07/01/2023 08:24

You are doing the right thing. Stay strong, you have two children that will be looking to you for security and direction.
Sorry your husband has chosen his parents instead of his growing family. He's made his bed.

Are you genuinely suggesting this over a hair cut?

pictoosh · 07/01/2023 08:30

You haven't given any details about the cut but there's a world of difference between trimming a fringe that's annoying a child and lopping a ponytail off on a whim. I'm going to assume the cut wasn't very dramatic. She should have asked first of course. You're not unreasonable to express that she overstepped and it annoyed you.

However, you're basically trying to tell your baby's father that his mother may not see his child. Over a haircut. Based on the details you've given, this appears to be an exercise in control for you. You are not your daughter's only parent and it's not all about you. There is a frothing contingent on here who wring their hands over the sanctity of motherhood and will tell you that you are right, but in the real world of actual people and families, cutting off contact with a grandmother over this is outlandish and disproportionate and ordinary people will think you quite mad.

HiccupHorrendousHaddock · 07/01/2023 08:29

That’s a crazy overreaction, OP.

Yes, I’d have been angry about the haircut, but to break up your family when you’re just about to have a baby? Bonkers.

SuperSange · 07/01/2023 08:29

I'm not quite sure how your MIL cut the hair in the morning but you didn't notice until later on? So she's not been scalped then? I think you're looking for problems to be honest; if you do have a problem, it's with your partner not backing you up. Not your MIL.

donttellmehesalive · 07/01/2023 08:28

I can understand being a bit irritated at the time, but doubling-down to the point of separation and becoming a single mum to two little ones? It can't be true surely. But if it is, I don't think the haircut issue is the reason your dp is ok with separating.

saraclara · 07/01/2023 08:27

Nowthenhere · 07/01/2023 08:24

You are doing the right thing. Stay strong, you have two children that will be looking to you for security and direction.
Sorry your husband has chosen his parents instead of his growing family. He's made his bed.

He's not chosen his parents over his family. He's told OP that she's overreacting by saying that his mother can never see her grandchild again. Which she is.

Nowthenhere · 07/01/2023 08:24

You are doing the right thing. Stay strong, you have two children that will be looking to you for security and direction.
Sorry your husband has chosen his parents instead of his growing family. He's made his bed.

saraclara · 07/01/2023 08:23

Why are partners supposed to have your back when you're being totally unreasonable?
Sometimes a partner's role is to tell you that you're over reacting. And deciding that your MIL can never see her grandchild again (over a hair trim so minor that you didn't even notice for hours) IS unreasonable.

Does everyone here have their spouse's back, even when they're being completely irrational?

NancyJoan · 07/01/2023 08:23

Lkjhgfdds · 06/01/2023 23:38

Hi all,

Thank you for your responses.
Just to answer a few questions.
We were with MIL all afternoon and she didn’t say a word. (She cut it in the morning) She only admitted it when we confronted her.
She apologised when I confronted her. No contact has been made since.

Some back story
Since the 2 years she has been
Showing up to the house unannounced to see daughter but using another excuse
Setting boundaries that are not followed e.g bedtime and food choices
Cutting hair without permission
Taking gifts that were given by other people to our daughter and returning it to them without telling us
Possessive in photos and at dinners/events (when taking family photos she would be in the middle with the baby when me and my partner would be on the side, at dinner/events not letting anyone else hold or be near the baby including parents)

All of these sound a bit annoying, and I would be upset about a haircut, but your reaction is completely out of proportion. She’s done nothing that requires a ceasing of all contact, and tearing up your family because your partner refuses to do that is very extreme.

And as PP have said, if you split, your DD could have 50% of her week with her dad and grandma.

WandaWonder · 07/01/2023 08:20

No she shouldn't have cut the hair, but far out making take a deep breath and go for a walk and calm down

Yes it would advisable to have her son tell her not to do it again bur no need for the dramatics, if this is genuine

AnxiousPancreas · 07/01/2023 08:16

Jazz12 · 07/01/2023 06:59

No no! You are totally gaslighting the situation! No one must undermine parental authority. And people must respect boundaries. That’s non negotiable in any relationship.

You really think grandparents can do what they want and the parents have to just suck it up because it’s not physically dangerous!? Is it okay to just let the child have screen time all evening, eat sweets for dinner and stay up till 1am because it’s not dangerous!??? You must be joking!! ITS OPs CHILD !! Why should OP put up with being walked over !?

Children are not dolls for anyone to just randomly do haircuts on them!

Firstly, that’s not what “gaslighting” means. You can’t just use a word that you think is triggering and act like it makes you right. Accusing my comment of gaslighting makes as much sense as me calling yours racist.

Secondly, no one said to “suck it up” or “put up with it”. I just said it’s child abuse to change who your child is allowed to see and have a relationship throughout their childhood based on your personal issue with that person. For one, you’re punishing your child by taking away someone that they love and, for another, it treats a child like an agent of their parent’s wishes. It’s called alienation and it’s desperately awful behaviour. It is a recognised form of child abuse.

Your suggestion is morally corrupt, harms the child and (to be frank) is one of the rare instances where a court is likely to award visitation to a grandparent.