Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL cut my daughter’s hair without telling us

219 replies

Lkjhgfdds · 06/01/2023 23:17

My partner and I have been together for 14 years. We have a 2 year old daughter.

We recently stayed at the in laws for Christmas and MIL was looking after our daughter most of the days, so I can rest (I am also pregnant with our second).
On the last day before we were going to leave, MIL cuts our daughter’s hair without telling me or my partner. (The cut is not good and not bad)
I was furious and confronted MIL, she admitted it.
It has affected me so much that it has caused arguments with my partner everyday. It has now got to the point where I don’t want my MIL to see our daughter but my partner still wants her to carry on seeing our daughter. We haven’t reached a compromise so now we have decided to separate because he chose his parents over me.
Am I being unreasonable? Should I just get over it and let my MIL see our daughter.

OP posts:
Lilgamesh2 · 07/01/2023 10:04

saraclara · 07/01/2023 09:51

Those who think OP is doing the right thing, can I ask a question?

If your own mother did something that infuriated your husband (but which in the scheme of things was far from the end of the world, even if it annoyed you too) and he said that your children could never see her again, would you just accept that?

Would refusing to accept that be "choosing your mother over your own little family"? Would you be "trivialising his feelings, by telling him that it's a massive and unreasonable overreaction? Would you let him have his way and your children never see their Grandma, and your relationship with your own mother be destroyed? Over a hair trim or something similar?

I think that a strong message needs to be sent to MIL but not NC forever.

Ideally, the DH would tell MIL its unacceptable, a stern conversation about boundaries would be had, and maybe it would be agreed that for the next several visits they would only have supervised contact as the trust has been breached.

The point isn't really to stop grandma seeing the child but to establish boundaries and reinforce the notion that the Mother has more of a say over the child that the MIL does. I think in light of her follow up post where the MIL refused gifts meant for the child she is clearly overstepping. I would expect my DH to back me up in this instance.

TonTonMacoute · 07/01/2023 10:03

It's not worth going completely berserk about, it really isn't. So long as MIL understands she must never do it again!

However, I would be concerned that your DP is obviously on his DMs side. He does need to back you up in these disputes in future, even if he doesn't really see what the problem is.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/01/2023 10:01

*sleepovers, not sellpovers

😬

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/01/2023 10:00

AnxiousPancreas · 06/01/2023 23:24

YABU

Obviously she shouldn’t have done it but you don’t prevent a 2yo seeing an otherwise loving grandparent because of one incident where the child wasn’t harmed, wasn’t in danger and the only thing that was bruised was your authority as a parent.

If my DH tried to prevent my mother seeing my child over an incident like this, I’d consider separating too.

This.

It would have boiled my p*ss if my MIL (or DM) had done this - but I'd just have let her know (forcefully) that it wasn't on.

I wouldn't stop her seeing them, but there's no way I'd have sellpovers for a long time.

Runnerduck34 · 07/01/2023 10:00

I would be upset and angry too.
You say the cut isn't good or bad - so I assume neutral- how much did she cut off, was it just a trim or fringe cut or more drastic?
You need to tell her not to do it again but if she apologises then move on. I wouldn't break up a relationship between DGC and GP over one incident like this, that is an overreaction imo.
If its a the tip of the iceberg and there's a back story it may be different but you haven't mentioned anything else so I think you need to make your boundaries clear and forgive and forget.
DDs hair will quickly regrow and it doesn't sound like the haircut looks terrible.

Katherine1985 · 07/01/2023 09:58

Could you reduce contact and supervise itself until there’s respect?

It’s important to have this before DC2 is born - it’s a natural step for DC1 to spend more time with close relatives then, but to feel relaxed about that you need to trust them and feel respected

Verbena17 · 07/01/2023 09:56

You’re not BU for being annoyed/angry at your MIL but you are BU in not moving on from it.

All that’s needed is very firm words from your DH and yourself, stating your feelings about it and that it’s not to happen again.

Your MIL should have realised you don’t just cut someone else’s child’s hair without asking. It’s strange and controlling. She will probably say she being helpful whilst your pregnant but it’s really overstepping I think.

Ronnytigs · 07/01/2023 09:56

As a grandmother of my son's two year old I can say categorically I would never cut her hair without getting the consent of her mother. This is not about 'hair' nor is it a 'trivial matter'. It is about respect, boundaries and love. Especially if it was the 'first time'. It seems that Lkjhgfdds is in full flight or fight mode heightened by her pregnancy. 14years of being together means you have known his mother a long time, I wonder what your relationship with her has been like during all that time, and also her relationship with her son?

Lilgamesh2 · 07/01/2023 09:56

Taking gifts that were given by other people to our daughter and returning it to them without telling us

Seriously?? Your MIL stole from your DD.

How has your DH handled this situation? I think he needs to have your back tbh.

The haircut was unacceptable too, I wouldn't go NC but I would only allow supervised contact until I felt comfortable again.

I am surprised that you are being advised to relegate your own feelings to third place after the MIL and DH. I think it's because going through a breakup when pregnant must be hard and people are worried about you.

Is there a way to resolve this whereby DH is more supportive of you but you don't break up? How did you handle the haircut? Did he acknowledge your view at all or just tell you to suck it up?

PurplePixies · 07/01/2023 09:52

OP, you sound ridiculous.

If you want to split from your husband, go ahead, but making up daft excuses blaming your MIL for the split is pretty childish.

If you’re this petty about things you should be talking through in an adult way, I pity your children, to be honest.

Nosecamera · 07/01/2023 09:52

She has over stepped a boundary.
Also, concider thay your daughter, and any girl or woman has more value than the way she looks, you daughter is the same person whether or not people might have praised her for her previously lovely hair.

saraclara · 07/01/2023 09:51

Those who think OP is doing the right thing, can I ask a question?

If your own mother did something that infuriated your husband (but which in the scheme of things was far from the end of the world, even if it annoyed you too) and he said that your children could never see her again, would you just accept that?

Would refusing to accept that be "choosing your mother over your own little family"? Would you be "trivialising his feelings, by telling him that it's a massive and unreasonable overreaction? Would you let him have his way and your children never see their Grandma, and your relationship with your own mother be destroyed? Over a hair trim or something similar?

zingally · 07/01/2023 09:49

You're breaking up a 14 year relationship, with (about to be) 2 kids, because... your DD got a haircut without you being informed...? Jesus...

Can you imagine the conversation with the two kids when they're teenagers?
"So why did you and dad split up?"
"Because granny gave you a haircut when you were 2 and didn't ask MY permission."

It sounds bonkers because it is.

SchnauzerEyebrows · 07/01/2023 09:47

@Lkjhgfdds Come on OP, you're being hysterical. Yes your MIL does sound overbearing and I don't think anyone here would disagree with that. I'm sure most PPs on this thread will happily advise you on how to deal with her moving forward. But this reaction is disproportionate.
Just have a chat with your DH and blame it on pregnancy hormones. I think you'll probably find he is actually on your side re: the haircut and likely is only against the no contact suggestion. In which case, separating is not only disproportionate but also counterproductive as he will have contact with your DD without you.
At which point it he can take her to see his Mum himself so you wouldn't actually achieve your objective anyway. So get him back on side! Find a compromise! Flowers

Katherine1985 · 07/01/2023 09:47

OP isn’t ruining or blocking relationships, though, if MIL has chipped away. It’s not just one incident that damages a relationship, but constant overstepping and undermining will do it, especially if partner doesn’t have your back

Tessabelle74 · 07/01/2023 09:45

The hair cut is terrible and you were right to call her out. The rest you are being incredibly unreasonable. Were you already looking for an excuse to blow up your relationship?

CaptainMyCaptain · 07/01/2023 09:43

My mother had my daughter's hair cut while she was looking after her. My daughter has afro hair and she took her to a local hairdresser who didn't know what she was doing. It looked terrible but hair grows, it wasn't the end of the world.

saraclara · 07/01/2023 09:42

SnitterBug · 07/01/2023 09:27

I think the issue here is because he is trivialising your feelings over this and brushing it under the carpet .

I don't think he's trivialising her feelings. Or at least there's nothing to suggest that. Saying that he won't accept OP refusing to let his mother ever see her grandchild again, isn't trivialising her feelings. It's saying that it's a massive and unfair reaction. There's a difference.

ShandaLear · 07/01/2023 09:29

I’d be furious if anyone cut my DDs hair without my permission. That’s completely overstepping boundaries. While going no contact is extreme it would be worth sitting down and having a frank conversation with her about your annoyance at her behaviour (using the examples above), boundaries, and that you and your DH make decisions relating to your daughter, and if she doesn’t like them then you will have to be present at every meeting from now on because you don’t trust her to act in yours/your daughters best interests.

SnitterBug · 07/01/2023 09:27

I think the issue here is because he is trivialising your feelings over this and brushing it under the carpet .

Maytodecember · 07/01/2023 09:24

I think ending yoyr marriage is OTT.
Think forward: Your DH will have the children 50/50 so your MIL will obviously be looking after them a lot if that time. You’ll have no control over that.
If your DH chooses to let his mother cut their hair, change their clothes, fit them out with new shoes, even take them to dental appointments during his time with them there’ll be nothing you can do about that.
Yes your MIL oversteps the mark, I don’t get the “ grandparents want to own the child” thing ( and I’m a grandparent though probably a lazy one)
Strengthen your boundaries. Speak to your MIL on her own, tell her you are DDs mother, not her, you make the decisions on haircuts etc. Should she ever do this again you will stop her seeing your dd. Tell her to call to arrange visits as polite people do. Take control of the situation.

Alexandernevermind · 07/01/2023 09:20

Sorry op but I agree with everyone else here, I think you are being a bit ott. You are absolutely justified in being annoyed, but stopping contact because you don't like her is looking a bit too controlling. My SIL trimmed by dd's fringe once, actually after a haircut. I was livid, obviously, but told her not to do it again and we moved on. If you don't trust her then it'll be no unsupervised contact, but you can't cut her off from her father's family, against his wishes, over annoyances. Remember as pp said, if you split with him she will have as much unsupervised contact as she wants during his 50%.

LIZS · 07/01/2023 09:15

Your reaction is disproportionate. Why are you angry at your dh when it is your mil who has crossed the line and apologised? You can take dd to a hairdresser if you feel it needs doing properly. Presumably you were present in the house at the time , yet you both allowed her sole supervision for long enough that this happened. Are you deflecting your own issues perhaps?

EmergencyPoncho · 07/01/2023 09:13

If she'd taken her for her first tatt, then maybe. It's a haircut. She clearly adores your DD, this is no bad thing. Remind her you're her mother and anything like that, should be run past you first.

theleafandnotthetree · 07/01/2023 09:12

The suggested reactions of some on here to what sound like perfectly normal if mildly annoying family dynamics are actually frightening. I truly hope that if my children end up in significant romantic relationships, that it is with normal, kind, well balanced people who have an expansive notion of love. What is perhaps particularly galling about the OP's stance is that she is seemingly happy to lean on and trust this supposed 'monster-in-law' when it suits her.