Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL cut my daughter’s hair without telling us

219 replies

Lkjhgfdds · 06/01/2023 23:17

My partner and I have been together for 14 years. We have a 2 year old daughter.

We recently stayed at the in laws for Christmas and MIL was looking after our daughter most of the days, so I can rest (I am also pregnant with our second).
On the last day before we were going to leave, MIL cuts our daughter’s hair without telling me or my partner. (The cut is not good and not bad)
I was furious and confronted MIL, she admitted it.
It has affected me so much that it has caused arguments with my partner everyday. It has now got to the point where I don’t want my MIL to see our daughter but my partner still wants her to carry on seeing our daughter. We haven’t reached a compromise so now we have decided to separate because he chose his parents over me.
Am I being unreasonable? Should I just get over it and let my MIL see our daughter.

OP posts:
Jazz12 · 07/01/2023 17:07

itsgettingweird · 07/01/2023 08:03

No no! You are totally gaslighting the situation! No one must undermine parental authority. And people must respect boundaries. That’s non negotiable in any relationship.

You really think grandparents can do what they want and the parents have to just suck it up because it’s not physically dangerous!? Is it okay to just let the child have screen time all evening, eat sweets for dinner and stay up till 1am because it’s not dangerous!??? You must be joking!! ITS OPs CHILD !! Why should OP put up with being walked over !?

Children are not dolls for anyone to just randomly do haircuts on them!

I don't think that was gaslighting.

My parents raised 3 children perfectly well. When they had DGC it was a chance to do the fun side of raising children. The same way as sleepovers at friends we have no control over screen time etc and occasionally sweets for dinner won't hurt.

My parents would never completely disrespect anything I asked them but then again I didn't need to put in boundaries because I rushed them to do what they felt best - even if different to what I would have done.

My mum died when me and my siblings were in our 30's and I'm glad she got to be a nanny and spend time with her grandchildren before she became ill.

OP. Honestly this cannot be serious? You trust MIl enough to look after your child so you can sleep loads because your pregnant. But because she did 1 thing that over stepped your boundaries you've now got a list of reasons for your DD not to see her. But yet have split from your partner so now both your children will see her without you and only their dad will be setting boundaries with her?

Unless you actually don't love your DP then you've not solved the problem by splitting with someone you care for.

My parents would never completely disrespect anything I asked them but

THIS ☝🏻

itsgettingweird · 07/01/2023 16:57

My dad cut ds hair once.

I usually borrowed the clippers and did it myself. I'd happened to mention in passing one day I needed to sort his hair out. What I hadn't explained was having had a Barbers consult I was changing style (his hair grows fats and is thick and they suggested a different style).

He genuinely thought he was doing me a favour cutting it whilst he was at theres for an afternoon whilst I had an appointment. Ds was 5yo so didn't really know what was happening re growing it to get barber to style it with scissors.

I didn't say a word. About 4 weeks later when it had grown again i mentioned the barbers appointment and we were growing it out as if we'd only just been.

He was trying to help through love. Not worth making him feel bad over. 🤷‍♀️

Liz1tummypain · 07/01/2023 14:26

I think you need to take a chill pill. Or a few more than that. Forgive and move on.

Adelant · 07/01/2023 14:19

Bit of a drip feed there.

Based on the OP alone, I’d say MIL
was wrong but it would BU to never allow MIL
to see dd again.

My mum took my niece to get her ears pierced when niece was 8 and asked for pierced ears. She just told my sister she was taking her and took her 🤷🏻‍♀️ My sister shrugged her shoulders and let her crack on.

I’m not saying others should be allowed to do the same, every family is different, I’m just putting a view out there that in some families grandmothers are allowed to get hair cut, ears pierced etc.

Zebedee55 · 07/01/2023 14:08

Hair will grow. Not worth a drama.

MaryMcCarthy · 07/01/2023 14:04

YABU. If you liked the woman you wouldn't be reacting like this.

Imagine the kid asking when they're 18 or something... Mum, why did I never know my grandmother? You think they'll appreciate the answer? It's just absurd.

Togoodtobeforgotten · 07/01/2023 13:34

I guess you don't have many positive relationships? Most mature adults know you have to work on relationships it's give and take things aren't always perfect if we all binned relationships as soon as something was wrong nobody in the world would have a relationship.

GoodMorninSunshine · 07/01/2023 13:26

It sounds like you’re letting your emotions cloud your judgement. If she’s already apologised, could you remain amicable with MIL for the sake of your daughter?

My mother and her MILs/my grandmothers relationship wasn’t perfect, but I would have truly resented my mum if she had let this impact or destroy the relationship I had with my grandmother.

Tiani4 · 07/01/2023 13:21

You have to work out OP what MIL adds to your DDs life. If she is loving and otherwise a super help then some of those things I would have a word with MIL, accept her apology and let it slide

I'd mix the unannounced visits to my home by saying "no MIL you have to text and ask me if you're coming over as I don't want visitors sometimes much as we love you"
However if she doesn't add much and doesn't have a wonderful relationship with DD and is a hindrance not a help then I suggest you go for what I said before.

My children have always been my children first and foremost but I love that they have others in our family who care for and love them and add heaps to their lives so I try not to interfere in their relationships with others

Tiani4 · 07/01/2023 13:17

So you take control of your child

If MIL hogs her at family get togethers you take her back and say no. In photos you sit her on your lap. Unless your DD wants to sit on nanny's lap.

You tell people that gift her items MIL isn't passing on, that that you understand They sent a present to DD, but neither DD nor you as her parents saw it as MIL unfortunately didn't pass it on.

Also it's ok not to leave DD with MiL of you don't trust that she might not cut her hair again. I mean my parents are lovely and can be a bit overbearing (through love and best of intentions) but even my Mum would never ever cut her DGC hair without offering and asking us first!!!

LuckySantangelo35 · 07/01/2023 13:02

Yabu

don’t alienate your mil

Imturningintoadetective · 07/01/2023 13:00

Also, you make points that one of the reasons you are going no contact is because "she overstepped boundaries" and wants to me near your daughter in photos. However, she was looking after your daughter most days do you could rest. You obviously had no issue with her then.

Imturningintoadetective · 07/01/2023 12:58

I think your overreacting. She obviously lobes your daughter and you're going to deny your child a relationship with her grandmother. I think that's awful.

Trez1510 · 07/01/2023 12:53

Are you always this high-maintenance or it is hormones?

Assuming it was your mother who trimmed your child's hair, would you be going NC over this?

If that wasn't your automatic reaction i.e. to exclude your mother from your child's life, would you support NC based on your partner's demands?

Would you consider your partner to be 'reasonable' to demand separation if you didn't cancel his child's relationship with your mother?

It's already been done to death on this thread - it was a minor haircut, the child's GM has apologised, your partner agreed his mother over-stepped a boundary.

You're looking to use your child as a weapon, and that's extremely poor parenting way beyond any, apologised-for, hair trim really.

Togoodtobeforgotten · 07/01/2023 12:46

She apologised and yet you want to force your partner to choose between you and his mother? You are very wrong to do this you actually sound very controlling. You had every right to be cross. However she apologised you move on. In the end you will be the one that Loses out.

SleepingStandingUp · 07/01/2023 12:40

Your MIL was looking after your daughter most of the DAYS you were stopping with her because you're pregnant and your husband was...?? but you expected him to never see her again because she did one thing she immediately apologised for that isn't going to have affect on your daughters life at all and now your breaking up your marriage over it.

Where do you think he's going to take them on his custody time?

BigglyBee · 07/01/2023 12:34

SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 07/01/2023 12:31

Stop with this!

Do you REALLY want that to be the message for any woman with kids? Don't leave your abusive/cheating/lazy/now unloved man honey, cos then you have no say in what he does with the kids!

FFS! Do better.

In a situation where the problem seems to be that the OP wants to be better able to control her MIL's contact with the children, it's totally fair to point out that she may well be shooting herself in the foot.

Nobody is saying that women should stay no matter what, but leaving doesn't always solve all the problems.

PinkSyCo · 07/01/2023 12:34

Your reaction is totally over the top. I would so grateful that my MIL not only hosted me and my family over Christmas, but also looked after my child so that I could rest that I would not be bothered at all about her giving my kid a wee haircut. Maybe it’s your hormones but you sound very spoilt and pretty unhinged. I feel sorry for your DH, your MIL and your child.

Confusion101 · 07/01/2023 12:32

So to summarise.... MIL cut daughters hair without asking, apologised when confronted, and now you are going no contact and are separating from your husband? Has to be a wind up!

BigglyBee · 07/01/2023 12:32

This situation has reached the point where it really doesn't matter what started it. It needs to stop, before it escalates any further. If you can, I think you should try to reconcile with your partner and work out a way forward together. Yes, his mum was out of order and I would be furious for a while, but there are a couple of things you need to think about.

Firstly, you seem convinced that she is somehow trying to "take over" your daughter. Well done, you've handed that to her on a plate, with a baby thrown in for good measure. With you living apart, your partner will need childcare while he works (assuming he wants 50/50 care). Guess who he will go to for that? She may even be living in Granny's house during her time with her father.

Secondly, have you read the threads on here started by women who have to deal with ex-partners and child arrangements from birth? They rarely involve the words "calm", "peaceful" or "amicable". If you can find a way to stay together, then you will all benefit. Of course a conversation needs to be had about contact, and since you find her such a problem, you could say that she can only come round when your partner is there (and enforce it, even if she turns up at the door). He can also take both children to visit her without you, once the baby is weaned. I have actually cut my own parents off from my children, so I know it can sometimes be unavoidable, but they were seriously abusive to me and showing signs of starting on my children. This isn't what happened here.

I think you probably need some counselling, both together and you on your own. The strains of pregnancy, birth and raising young children can sometime throw perspective out of whack a little, and getting some support will help you. Depression in pregnancy is also not unusual, and it might be worth speaking to your midwife or GP about that. I say this, because you don't seem to be just a standard-issue twat, you seem like someone who is struggling and has got themselves into a bit of a state. Your partner may need to work on his issues around his mother, that isn't uncommon. But my main concern is that you seem to be in need of help, and I hope you find it.

SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 07/01/2023 12:31

IDontCareMatthew · 06/01/2023 23:22

So you seperate.... and he takes his daughter there on his access days so now you have ZERO control or influence over his mother

Stop with this!

Do you REALLY want that to be the message for any woman with kids? Don't leave your abusive/cheating/lazy/now unloved man honey, cos then you have no say in what he does with the kids!

FFS! Do better.

jackstini · 07/01/2023 12:29

You could use this as a catalyst for change, unless there are other massive issues in your relationship with dp

Coming to see her - meh
Holding her in photos - a bit much but she's just proud. You will have plenty more pics with you front and center

Hair cut - definitely overstepping but depends how bad it is and whether she apologised

Returning gifts - this really depends on how she does it. If she is saying you hated it or are ungrateful and don't want it, that is not on. Same if she is not even showing you the gift. Overstepping again, should be nothing to do with her

But seems a massive overreaction to separate (appreciate pregnancy hormones are a magnifier of emotions!)

You need a clear, honest conversation about boundaries with dp and his Mum
Try to get this fixed and you can all move forward

FamilyLife2point4 · 07/01/2023 12:25

She apologised because she was caught and it upset the mother. Going to guess she wouldn’t have apologised otherwise …….. as she didn’t see anything wrong with what could be construed as ‘assaulting a child’.

A PP suggested supervised contact, that would be my approach as she can’t be trusted to make sensible decisions with the child on her own and supervision via DH won’t work either from what’s been posted.
It’s almost as if she had to be the ‘first’ to cut her hair (those first cuts / curls are normally kept by parents as keepsakes - has she done so to keep them herself and deliberately deny parents those - that would push me nuclear) - going to guess she needed to be first to push her pram too, must be centre stage in the pictures etc.
The OP is over-reacting imo, however it might be the straw that broke the camels back and this GM clearly needs put in her place, as 2 years later her behaviour is increasing - maybe OPs over-reaction, along with supervised contact, will make this stop?!
The DH is a total different kettle of fish. He is not responsible for his mother and you can’t force him to chose - if you have, then hell mend you - as I’d have made the same decision as him as that is totally controlling behaviour (pregnancy hormones aside). DHs generally want an easy life so won’t want to speak up against his mum either, esp as men tend not to be overly bothered with hair either (it’ll grow again type attitudes), whereas his bond with his parents will be more important than hair, and you should take that on board too!

Tamarindtree · 07/01/2023 12:24

It’s completely unacceptable for her to have cut your daughters hair.

I would never leave the child alone in her company again which is what is going to happen if your split up as her father will be able to take her round to see his mum and she will have every opportunity to cut her hair again.

By staying together you can at least exert some control over your child seeing her grandmother.

Chikapu · 07/01/2023 12:24

Should I just get over it
Yes. Your daughter will have her hair cut and it'll grow back many, many times throughtout her life. Your reaction is ridiculous.