Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be jealous of my friend’s social housing house?

281 replies

Crankitcrew · 06/01/2023 23:03

I have a house with a mortgage. I can barely afford to pay for repairs to the house. It’s falling apart.
My friend has recently moved into social housing and has a much more spacious house than mine, but the biggest reason I’m jealous is if anything goes wrong with the house it’s fixed by the housing association within days. No cost. She only pays a small contribution towards her rent. The rest is paid. She doesn’t work and claims PIP because she has PTSD and depression.

She and her partner are talking about getting some decking done in the garden and paying £600 for it. There’s no way on earth we could afford that, we can’t even afford to have the re plastering done that is falling off, not to mention the damp problem.

People say to me “well, at least you own your home” and “you can leave it to your children” but what if we never pay the mortgage off? What if we end up needing care and the money from the house goes to pay that instead? Which is what happened to my grandparents.

I saw getting on the property ladder a right of passage or something, but I now realise it’s not all it’s made out to be.

OP posts:
PrincessOfWaiIs · 07/01/2023 12:12

AlwaysGoingBackwards · 07/01/2023 09:39

Imagine have PTSD and depression but still having to go to work and pay for things….

Why on earth would anyone wait two years for the council to fix their kitchen cupboard. Attitudes like that just come across as lazy. Yes, people are entitled to benefits, but it is a lifestyle for some. No need to aim higher because the money is there anyway, and you have your diagnoses to justify not having to work and a weapon to use against anyone who questions you.

As I said upthread, she's probably not allowed to fix her kitchen units. If she does the council will charge her to re-do the work when they finally get around to it. It's not lazy, it's in her tenancy agreement. But judge away.

WombatChocolate · 07/01/2023 10:39

I think this thread shows lots of people have hard situations in all kinds of housing. As always, it’s never as clear-cut as one situation is best for all, but there is plenty of nuance and individuals find what might have worked well for them at certain points of life, isn’t always best for them, but they might not have much flexibility to move.

To those who have difficulties in privately-owned homes, I’d just mention that the security of those homes, along with the security in social housing, is something those in private rented most long for. People forget that with all the costs of home ownership, at least you can plan to be there in 3/5/10 years if that’s what you want. Those who live in properties they own, also have the most choices. They have an asset whichbiver time will increase in value and it is something which can be sold and moving elsewhere is possible….even if many don’t want to do it.

Most people in social housing would acknowledge their security of tenure as being a big upside, but there are all kinds of Daily Mail type myths out there about paying a pittance of rent. There is a small window when people have small children, when low paid workers can get much if their rent paid. Most other workers are paying substantial if not market rate rents. And to anyone envying those on benefits, remember it’s only going to get meaner and most people struggle and crucially have a lack of choice.

When people look at those on benefits and think they are living the life of Riley and envy them, I’d say it’s time for a big look at yourself. You might not be problem free. No-one is and all situations have some downsides and pressures….but it’s about getting a sense of perspective on those. That’s where people trip up and allow comparison to become the thief of joy and convinced others always have it better than themselves and become bitter.

People with property almost always have choices. They often discount lots of the choices and forget they are being quite picky, but actually property ownership gives you choices (including about the type of care home you might go to if you need one) which is simply not available for those who aren’t owners and asset rich.

Seymour5 · 07/01/2023 10:23

ShakespearesBlister · 07/01/2023 09:07

Not sure of this is just a council tenant baiting thread but often in cases where people are living in properties which are falling apart and they can't afford to maintain, you tend to find they have overstretched themselves and wanted bigger than they could realistically afford.

In practically every street around me there's at least one 3 bedroomed house falling to bits which has seen no maintenance in decades and has an elderly person rattling around inside it who can only afford to heat one room while the house falls apart around them.

I always think if they downsized even to 2 bedroom they could live like a king in luxury most of us will never know, have tens of thousands of pounds to play with and still leave a generous inheritance behind.

Is it possible you've just overstretched yourself and bought something you couldn't really afford?

We, pensioner couple, live in a standard 3 bedroomed semi. Third bedroom is a tiny boxroom. Its not in bad nick, we upgraded doors, some windows, new boiler etc in the last few years. The roof is ok, and the outside was painted quite recently, so our savings are rapidly diminishing. We have no space for a downstairs loo, and will probably need level access in the near future.

We would like to move near one of our children, but properties are more expensive there. Even if we sold our existing home, we can’t afford to take on a mortgage as we are on a fairly low income. We’d like a small bungalow or ground floor flat in a retirement complex. If we were already tenants, it would be a straightforward move, but as homeowners, it will be very difficult to get a tenancy. Our current home could fall into disrepair because we are not able, and won’t have the means, to maintain it. We are in fuel poverty, our fuel costs are higher than they would be in a smaller property. One or both of us may bed block because our home (stairs) is no longer suitable. If we could rent appropriate housing for our last years we’d be financially self sufficient, and would manage independently for longer, rather than struggle on where we are, and then ultimately go into a care home.

Silentsalamander · 07/01/2023 10:21

FoxCorner · 06/01/2023 23:08

I wouldn't be jealous of someone with PTSD and depression. Must be horrible, even with decking.

Sorry this was funny 🤣

Pasithean · 07/01/2023 10:19

70sDuvet · 06/01/2023 23:23

Yet another MN thread (not so) subtly benefit bashing.

From your post you haven't mentioned your health but I assume from the dig at your friend getting PIP you are healthy.

I get PIP, I'm a homeowner, I am also - take a deep breath ladies - financially dependent on my husband as all benefits bar PIP take the earning of the other adults in the household.

2 of my 3 wishes from my genie

  1. Make disability benefits known as a different name than "benefits", I guarantee your aunt Dora's best friends nephews SILs son is not a benefit cheater on disability benefits - they need too much medical backing to prove the reason and medical intervention in your illness.
  1. That disability benefits were not means tested by household money. I'm not at all in this position but know of people who are in a bad state due to not so Dear spouces withholding family money and the disabled person having to live off PIp alone and pay their own way in the household- it leaves disabled people ripe for financial abuse.

Oh OK then for my 3rd wish I'd like to be well again and go back to my high paying job and be able to buy lovely expensive high heels again.

But as you were OP, dont be appreciative of your asset or your health. God isn't it unfair when something you own breaks down. It's really shit when it's your own body.

This is so true in many many ways. People who are disabled being financially and emotionally dependent on their partners or husbands, when claiming pip esa.

FixundFoxi · 07/01/2023 10:16

@shsiwb well yes when no bugger wants to contribute to their social care costs and sponge off the state instead. House worth £750k - pay your own care home fees ? No way, got to leave it to the kiddies...

Whynowwhynow · 07/01/2023 10:14

Your post is FULL of total ignorance! And extremely goady.

Firstly, once in social housing it is VERY hard to move from that property to another. You have to either apply and be considered the top priority normally out of hundreds or even thousands of applicants, or you have to exchange which is not easy.

Secondly, you are far more likely to have neighbours from hell!! I speak from experience I lived in social housing for a while and in my road the police were frequent visitors, we had two feuding families and several fights in the street! Children still out playing, screaming, shouting and swearing at 11pm in the summer and no will confront the families for fear of reprisals.

Thirdly, the idea that you have no responsibility for the property and everything is repaired within days shows complete ignorance. Most tenants wait months or years for repairs to be done. I waited 4 years for a broken window to be replaced before repairing it myself.

Fourthly the stigma surrounding living in ‘social housing’ and the assumption that all tenants are lazy, coasting through life on a free ride sponging off the government is still alive and kicking as shown by your goady post.

And finally although the property will be cheaper than the equivalent private rental, it will not be free. Not all tenants live on benefits. And, ultimately, after years of renting you own nothing. At least when you own a property you pay off that property until it is eventually yours to do as you wish with eg move.

You resent your friend having what you perceive to be an easier life than you. You resent her enough to post on a public social media site. You’re not friends.

TrifledOut · 07/01/2023 10:13

What’s the point of being jealous? Really?

Very few social housing tenants have that idyll - space, secure tenancy, responsive council who fix things quickly. Those days are long gone for the majority of people in social housing.

A much more common experience would be living in flats that are cramped, need updating and have chronic issues that aren’t addressed - unsafe cladding, damp, old draughty windows - and unresponsive, overstretched council maintenance departments. And then having to be rehoused somewhere smaller, at the mercy of the council, if you have multiple bedrooms once your kids are grown - so no real security or agency long term.

So, yeah, your friend is lucky. Sounds like for now she has a good set up.
But long term she is at the mercy of the local authority, and if the last 20 years are anything to go by, her future may not be any rosier than yours, and you may be in a much more fortunate position.

Also, that old adage ‘comparison is the thief of joy’ goes a long way. Jealousy if your friend won’t improve your life. Sorry to say!

FixundFoxi · 07/01/2023 10:12

@Ilovemycatalot sell said house and move somewhere cheaper ?
Get a better job ? sarcasam
What is it with the mean spirited benefits bashing posts today ? Daily Mail site down ?

LunaRegis · 07/01/2023 10:11

@Rosebel when I lived in HA they were more than happy for you to do whatever you wanted. They barely did many repairs as they knew that if they left it long enough people would do their own. I’m talking new kitchens & bathroom here, not just the simple jobs. It was a win win situation for them.

LunaRegis · 07/01/2023 10:07

There’s never a free lunch in this world OP, & you’ll never have it all. I consider myself to be very fortunate to have done all 4, that’s private rental, council new build, HA, & mortgage. If I remember correctly there was a few people that had sold their homes to move into HA, they weren’t needy people either. Although this wasn’t allowed with council homes years ago.

Rosebel · 07/01/2023 10:04

We live in social housing and unless your friend is very lucky nothing is fixed within days. Months perhaps if your lucky.
Also we've had to redo the plastering and replace floorboards and remove mould because that is our responsibility so it's not that brilliant.
Also decking in the garden.... be surprised if they get permission for that.

shsiwb · 07/01/2023 10:04

JLoti · 07/01/2023 01:09

People in this county are obsessed with owning property and leaving money to their kids.

You say that like that’s a bad thing?

Mirroredlove · 07/01/2023 09:57

I’m surprised some people think if you’re on pip then THEY MUST be actually sick. Of course most are, but I know two people who have nothing wrong with them but both get pip, due to great manipulation skills and knowing how to navigate the pip system. Not every single person on pip is truly ill, however it’s obviously a very tiny minority. They brought their 3 bed council house for pennies as they got such a huge discount and then built a huge extension on it, the house is massive. They are still on pip, still don’t work and now own a house too. I’m not jealous in anyway as one day in the far future it will benefit me too.

mynamesnotMa · 07/01/2023 09:56

My friend gran and her sister both ended up in the same care home one paid nothing as she'd lived in social care the other had to sell her home to pay for the care.
Sister 2 had travelled extended and moved siater 1 stayed same area all her life.
Which one had more choices and control over her life?

drspouse · 07/01/2023 09:56

My late PIL lived in HA housing and were obliged to move into a one bed flat when DH got his own place. It's not all roses.

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 07/01/2023 09:52

Crankitcrew · 06/01/2023 23:03

I have a house with a mortgage. I can barely afford to pay for repairs to the house. It’s falling apart.
My friend has recently moved into social housing and has a much more spacious house than mine, but the biggest reason I’m jealous is if anything goes wrong with the house it’s fixed by the housing association within days. No cost. She only pays a small contribution towards her rent. The rest is paid. She doesn’t work and claims PIP because she has PTSD and depression.

She and her partner are talking about getting some decking done in the garden and paying £600 for it. There’s no way on earth we could afford that, we can’t even afford to have the re plastering done that is falling off, not to mention the damp problem.

People say to me “well, at least you own your home” and “you can leave it to your children” but what if we never pay the mortgage off? What if we end up needing care and the money from the house goes to pay that instead? Which is what happened to my grandparents.

I saw getting on the property ladder a right of passage or something, but I now realise it’s not all it’s made out to be.

PTSD and Depression are crippling, think yourself lucky, life is not always what you think it is.

zingally · 07/01/2023 09:52

Could you sell the house and move into a private rental?

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 07/01/2023 09:51

When I was a student nurse I live in a brand new Social housing house, the toilets were put in the wrong way resulting blockages in the street every week. The kitchen shelves fall down, the boiler stopped working, the Exterior lights never worked. Lust was endless. I was paying full rent on a student loan.

shsiwb · 07/01/2023 09:50

I think your feelings are valid, though there is nothing wrong with your friend being appropriately housed. I am envious seeing as I’ve lived in a one bed mouldy council flat with my kids/partner in an awful area for almost a decade with very little prospects for leaving which is incredibly depressing. But it speaks to wider issues in the country that social housing in general is in a terrible state, and then there are people who work really hard and still can’t get ahead.

Puffin87 · 07/01/2023 09:49

Snowmoab · 07/01/2023 09:28

Personally the day I give up working and try to claim PIP will be the day I give up on a better life

You realise you can claim PIP whilst working? It's not based on income. The ignorance continues apace.

Only in theory. If you read my recent post on the benefits thread, you'll see I was explicitly denied PIP because I work full time.

That's with bipolar, medication, seeing a psychiatrist at a CMHT regularly, weekly therapy and medical driving licence.

NotAnotherBathBomb · 07/01/2023 09:47

Sell your house and rent, then your landlord can fix everything for you 🙄

Notienesentido · 07/01/2023 09:45

OP whilst I feel for you, and I give thanks everyday that I got a SH place after 7 years wait, it does have its downsides:

  • heating is a nightmare because they are often badly constructed and insulated. Mould is a constant problem.
  • if something goes wrong, it doesn’t take days but months. I’ve been on the phone crying to my SH because of repairs they’ve promised and not delivered on.
  • you can’t change much to your taste. The PP probably isn’t allowed to fix her kitchen cupboards.
  • the rent is definitely lower than market rate but you still have to pay it! I pay mine in full, no benefits, so it’s not connected to that and definitely not like getting a free place.
  • I will never own my place and that worries me because I will have nothing to pass onto DS.

I am a lot worse off than my friends financially but I thank my lucky stars that a single mum like myself has a chance to have some stability in life.
So, next time you resent your friend, think of those of us to whom SH is a lifesaver.

Donotgogentle · 07/01/2023 09:45

Crankitcrew · 07/01/2023 09:36

The replies on here are fair enough. Maybe I’m a bad friend after-all. But I also have to say that I’ve struggled with my mental health for many years and I’m still struggling with it now. I would never qualify for PIP as I don’t think I’m considered bad enough to meet the requirements.
Of course I feel awful for her in terms of the PTSD, but I’m more frustrated at the system itself and actually in myself, as I shouldn’t have bought the house, we didn’t take into account interest rates skyrocketing as they have done…and I didn’t think ahead in terms of owning a property and what that would entail.
To me, I thought it was the thing you did and was almost a rite of passage…as I said in my OP.

It’s the terrible and unfair state of the housing market and housing provision in the UK op, people really struggle and it brings out a lot of negative feelings.

But it’s not your friend’s fault.

Tumbleweed101 · 07/01/2023 09:43

Ive got a council property and in my circumstances as a low income single parent I'm so grateful that I don't have repair costs to consider. Decorating and the basics are difficult enough to cover. I know that for my personal circumstances I have struck lucky for housing. It would have been lovely to have been able to buy and one day have an asset but my life path hasnt allowed that.