Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be jealous of my friend’s social housing house?

281 replies

Crankitcrew · 06/01/2023 23:03

I have a house with a mortgage. I can barely afford to pay for repairs to the house. It’s falling apart.
My friend has recently moved into social housing and has a much more spacious house than mine, but the biggest reason I’m jealous is if anything goes wrong with the house it’s fixed by the housing association within days. No cost. She only pays a small contribution towards her rent. The rest is paid. She doesn’t work and claims PIP because she has PTSD and depression.

She and her partner are talking about getting some decking done in the garden and paying £600 for it. There’s no way on earth we could afford that, we can’t even afford to have the re plastering done that is falling off, not to mention the damp problem.

People say to me “well, at least you own your home” and “you can leave it to your children” but what if we never pay the mortgage off? What if we end up needing care and the money from the house goes to pay that instead? Which is what happened to my grandparents.

I saw getting on the property ladder a right of passage or something, but I now realise it’s not all it’s made out to be.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JenniferBooth · 16/01/2023 22:05

@Maverickess after all the bullying moaning bellyaching and whining that they need to do an electrical check, my neighbour has had another no show!

crnche · 16/01/2023 15:23

People are being unnecessarily harsh to you imo.

Being a homeowner is hard and very very expensive. I have friends in social housing (shock - it's not that hard to get, I think it's area dependent) with zero need for it. One of my friends got paid £5000 to move to a new build flat because his old one was being demolished (this was only 2 years ago).

It is frustrating when they have days out/holidays etc. and we have to pay £1200 to replace a back door that broke, and so go without these 'luxuries'.

Yes, we 'own our home' but honestly, will we ever actually own it? Does it even mean anything?

OP your feelings are valid. The grass isn't always greener but it's okay to wonder.

Best to focus on yourself because there are so many things in this life to be happy about, just not having depression and PTSD is one of them i suppose!

YourApplePie · 16/01/2023 12:15

Not all SH rent is 80% of market rates. Mine is exactly 50% and the only way we can afford to live where we do.

Ginmonkeyagain · 10/01/2023 17:25

I grew up in rented accommodation so have no snobbery about it. But for many the choice is either buy or live in insecure private rent where you can be evicted with 2 months notice. In some parts of the country secure, socially rented houses are as rare as hen's teeth.

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 10/01/2023 16:54

We don't have £500 or £600 surplus MOST months, by the way, sometimes it is £250 to £300. Depends on DH's income, as his hours vary from 26 to 30 a week. He is contracted for 26, but sometimes does do 30-31. Also, some months, we have bigger outgoings/things to pay out for, or if DH is off sick for a few weeks, he only gets £90 a week sick pay, and we get a big drop in income. But because the rent is so low and we have no repairs to pay for, we are OK, and manage to break even - even on the months he has low pay.

Just trying to make the point that now we rent (social housing) we are much better off financially. We were always on the bones of our arse when buying!

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 10/01/2023 16:45

WARNING. Very long post! 😬 @Crankitcrew YANBU at all.

Me and DH live in a social housing bungalow and have done for 7 years - a 2 bed one. We got a 2 bed because our DC was living with us when we got it. They left not long after, but were still living with us when we moved in/signed the tenancy agreement.

We have lived together 34-ish years, (since 1988.) We rented a one bed HA flat in summer 1988,. It looked like 2 semi detached houses, but was in fact, 2 upstairs flats and 1 big downstairs one. We stayed 4 years, and absolutely loved it.

There was a couple downstairs with one child who had a 2 bed flat. Next door to us was a couple 20 years older than us (middle aged) and they were hardly ever in. It was five minutes walk to the shops, 10 minutes walk to bus stop, GP, dentist etc. LOVED it. Just pay the rent and everything is covered...Repairs, insurances, everything. (Only had to pay home contents.)

We only moved (and bought a 2 bed semi detached starter home,) because everyone around us was buying, and renting was considered 'dead money,' and you were considered (by some) to be something of a failure if you rented (We now know that is bullshit!) We were both young and impressionable, and easily swayed then, and thought buying a house was the thing to do, and would make us better people, and look more successful etc... (I know dumb right?!)

We rented the 1 bed flat for £175 a month - (this was in the early 1990s.) The mortgage was around £350 a month for the 2 bed semi......£350 a month 30 years ago, is probably like £800 now. (The £175 rent was like £400 now, so it was a huge increase.) We had both grown up on council estates and had NEVER experienced being a homeowner mortgage owner!

We regretted it quite quickly when one thing after another started going wrong with the house, and we had to pay 1000s of pounds out. We didn't have any savings as we had spent them all on the deposit, and solicitors fees, and land and mining searches etc etc, and our income took a hit because the mortgage was double the rent.

In addition to paying double the rent (for the mortgage,) along with additional insurances, like unemployment insurance, and life insurance etc, we had to fork out for every little thing from the leaky garage roof, to new windows, a new kitchen, new front door, new 60 foot long fence, and the removal of 36 fifteen foot conifers.

We could not get 'full cover' bricks and mortar insurance until we removed them, as the insurance companies were still licking their wounds after the 1987 hurricane. So as we had no money spare, we took out a loan, and then used the credit cards a lot more, and were 1000s in debt before we realised it. We had never been in debt before and it was horrible...

We lived in the 2 bed semi for 5 years, then new neighbours moved in who were utterly vile (long story,) and it also became too small after having DC, so we bought a 3 bed, which was about 10% more in cost at the time. It had an extra bedroom but no garage or carport like our last house, and the garden was much smaller, hence the price not being much different.. Again, we spent 1000s and 1000s of pounds doing necessary repairs that we didn't realise would need doing when we bought the house!

The house value increased from the £45,000 we paid, to about £85,000 over about 5-8 years, and we were offered the chance to take equity out, and extend the mortgage term - which we did. We took £30,000, and paid off all our debts. Car loan, bank loans, credit card debts, overdrafts etc. We had not gone crazy buying luxury goods, we used credit because we didn't have enough income to keep paying out for the bloody house repairs!

So over some 13-14 years, we somehow accrued £30,000 of debt. (£7,000 of that was a car loan.) After another 4 or 5 years, we found ourselves still struggling to make ends meet, as the house had an ever open mouth, and every time we had a low income month, we had more outgoings than income again. We had another bunch of debt within 5 to 6 years, though not as high. (A few thousand.)

About a mile from the little cul de sac we lived, was an estate owned mostly by council and HA, (a few were 'right to buy,' but only about 10%,) and I was sooooooo envious of the people there - getting cheap rent, repairs done for free, new windows, doors, kitchen, driveway, garage door, etc etc, decorating and carpet allowance, rent paid if they couldn't work/weren't working, or if they lost their job. (That is SUCH an amazing safety net.)

Whenever DH was off work for 2-3 months at a time (which happened quite a few times due to illness/sickness/operations/surgeries,) we had no-one to pay our mortgage, we just fell really behind and further and further into debt. The people in social housing seemed to be happier too, with less debts/often no debts, less money issues, better cars, bigger holidays etc (NOT a stab at people in social housing by the way, I was just really envious and thought they were so lucky and wished I were them, but bore no malice or hatred at all.)

tl;dr ... For various reasons, after 21-22 years of being homeowners mortgage owners we sold our house, paid off anything that was owing, with the bit of equity we had left, (about £10,000 was left I think,) and then went into private let. (A small 3 bed cottage for £500 a month.)

No repairs, no maintenance, and we knew we would get money towards the rent if our income dropped or one of us lost our job. Went onto the housing list, and after 5 years of waiting and bidding we dropped lucky and got a little 2 bed bungalow. It came just in time, as the woman was selling the cottage! We got a lifetime tenancy!!!

Our bungalow was built in the late 1990s, it has a garage and a car port, and is a big end plot with no-one at the side, just the woodlands at the end of a 100 foot long garden. (It's housing association and is £350 a month. Was £335 when we started renting, but has risen a bit over 7 years.) All repairs done within DAYS sometimes, not usually more than 2-3 weeks, and we don't have to pay for repairs and maintenance. (And we have the safety net of rent being paid if we cannot pay it.)

We have paid full rent since we came here, but knowing we have a safety net is amazing.

Also, we have never been so comfortable financially. DH dropped his hours to 26 a week in 2021, and I work 18 a week. We are on about 10% above minimum wage, and we still manage (some months) to have around £500 to £600 a month surplus income........ That never happened when we were homeowners. DH worked full time then, and I worked 26 hours a week, and we seemed to have a shortfall of a few hundred some months.

You could not PAY us to buy again.

We have had the odd snide remark from people - like 'why do you rent, it's so silly!' And we just say 'it suits us, we don't have to explain.' At nearly 60, we have no hesitation in telling people to mind their own business. In our 20s we were not as assertive and vocal.

I know people have different experiences and different views, but being a homeowner mortgage owner did us no favours - ever. We should NEVER have bought, we should have ignored people, and stuck with renting a housing association property.

As some people have said, you cannot guarantee never losing your home, even if you buy, as you don't know if you will lose your job and income some time in the future.

And there is NO guarantee that you will be able to leave the house to your children, as you are fairly likely to have to sell it to fund your care!

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 10/01/2023 16:43

Maddison12 · 10/01/2023 01:22

I don't believe for a second there are council tenants that haven't had a rent increase since the 90s. My rent goes up every April, sometimes it goes up by a couple of quid, sometimes it's more but it goes up every year without fail.

True. No-one would have NO rent increases, ever. Not in this country (the UK,) anyway.

Maddison12 · 10/01/2023 01:22

I don't believe for a second there are council tenants that haven't had a rent increase since the 90s. My rent goes up every April, sometimes it goes up by a couple of quid, sometimes it's more but it goes up every year without fail.

Maverickess · 09/01/2023 19:09

JenniferBooth · 09/01/2023 14:27

Its about time that social housing and their contractors move into the 2020s Friend of mine has had a letter saying he has to have a new intercom fitted. Apparently this will happen over the course of two days this week. No time or date given. Just 11th to 12th Jan. And Mears have written to him saying he HAS to be in for an inspection next week on a certain day. So what happens if a tenant has a medical appointment or like his neighbour works for the NHS. Back in 2019 when we had new fire doors fitted we got a letter saying we had to be in Mon to Fri. An ALL WEEK call. I shit you not. Its obvious they dont want to make proper appointments and just want to go house to house flat to flat on the day FFS

This pisses me off, like even they think that social housing tenants must just sit at home all day. I have this every time for gas/electric inspections or anything else they need entry for, they send me an appointment (sometimes, sometimes they just arrive and then send me a nice letter saying I'm putting my tenancy at risk by refusing entry for an appointment I didn't even know I had) and it's invariably for less than a week's time, when I need to give a months notice for requesting a certain day off, and then get shitty when if I manage to get through on the phone to change it and say I need a months notice to arrange a specific day off.
Want your rent? Then I need to go to work and abide by my employers policies so I get paid. It happens every bloody year these inspections and I know roughly when it's due (the month) and have even rang before the random call ins and threats for missing appointments - to be told I have to wait until they contact me with a date and then change it.
Tbf I've had this with private LL's too though.

Ohgoodyanotherone · 09/01/2023 17:47

*30 years

vodkaredbullgirl · 09/01/2023 17:04

Every year HA up the rent.

Ohgoodyanotherone · 09/01/2023 17:00

ProhibitedSteps · 08/01/2023 22:05

@Ohgoodyanotherone On my friend's street, there's a couple who are early 50s in a large 3 bed HA (yes, I know for a fact they're with the same HA). They've never had a rent increase since they moved in, in 1993 when the houses were built so they only pay £250pm (that's half local HA average!). Their kids grew up & married many years ago and ever since it's been exotic holidays, brand new car each, all the latest tech and they each have a spare room to do what they like with. They've said themselves that they can only have their luxury lifestyle due to the low rent. If they were forced to move, they'd have to pay £500+pm. They were offered a 2 bed HA apartment with a £2000k 'incentive' about 10 years ago but they declined! So they'll undoubtedly be there for many years yet as the HA's in this area are not yet forcing downsizing. I'm very glad they will be doing though.

I'm in a HA house as a widowed parent but only a 2 bed so I'll be unlikely to be made to downsize for a very long time yet.

You're talking nonsense. HA rent is increased every year it is not possible that they have been paying the same rent for 20 years and 2 people in a 3 bed house can't have a "spare room each".

JenniferBooth · 09/01/2023 14:27

Its about time that social housing and their contractors move into the 2020s Friend of mine has had a letter saying he has to have a new intercom fitted. Apparently this will happen over the course of two days this week. No time or date given. Just 11th to 12th Jan. And Mears have written to him saying he HAS to be in for an inspection next week on a certain day. So what happens if a tenant has a medical appointment or like his neighbour works for the NHS. Back in 2019 when we had new fire doors fitted we got a letter saying we had to be in Mon to Fri. An ALL WEEK call. I shit you not. Its obvious they dont want to make proper appointments and just want to go house to house flat to flat on the day FFS

Seymour5 · 09/01/2023 10:42

@PrincessOfWaiIs I agree, we need more social housing, and we should withdraw the RTB as Scotland has done.

PrincessOfWaiIs · 09/01/2023 10:27

Seymour5 · 09/01/2023 09:14

Bedroom tax (not really a tax) doesn’t affect anyone who pays their own rent in social housing. Its actually a deduction of a % of benefits paid to tenants of working age where a property is under occupied, ie a single person in a three bedroomed house would lose 25% of their housing benefit . There are some circumstances where it may not apply, and it doesn’t affect those over state pension age.

www.citizensadvice.org.uk/benefits/help-if-on-a-low-income/housing-benefit/how-an-extra-bedroom-affects-your-housing-benefit/check-if-a-room-counts-as-an-extra-bedroom-for-housing-benefit/

It affects you if you claim any UC, and if you're on a lower income you're very likely to be doing so. Most UC claimants are in work.

If you have two DC in a 3 bed house and they're deemed able to share a room (there are age/sex rules on this), you will likely find you have to pay 'bedroom tax'. You will also have to pay if, for example, you need an extra room because a household member has a health condition where they need to sleep separately from siblings/partner. There is discretionary help available from LAs but this is a limited pot and not everyone qualifies for it.

The reality is that there is no housing availablity for all the tenants who could technically downsize. There are simply not enough one and two bedroom properties for everyone, so moving people into temporary accommodation in order to house a family simply moves the problem around. Making a single person or a couple homeless (and given they're likely to be of an age where family has left home, we're talking about people in late middle age/older people) doesn't solve the issue, it just creates a new one.

Perhaps what the envious, outraged posters on this thread could use their energy better and more constructively by campaigning for more affordable social housing for all and the abolition of RTB. Far more useful than making up goady stories about friends of friends and deriding SH tenants.

DontStopMeNow7 · 09/01/2023 10:04

I can understand why you might feel this way because of all of hard work involved in owning your own home.

I’ve lived in social housing all of my adult life. Where I live now is very nice and I know some people are envious. Likewise, I know of people who either pity me and/or look down on me for it. It just goes to show that it’s all relative and a matter of perspective.

What they don’t know is why I’m here, nor how I got here. I ended up in social housing because I escaped an abusive relationship and was homeless with a baby. We first had to live in a 1 bedroom flat in a very dodgy area and didn’t qualify for a 2 bedroom until my DC was 8 years old.

Likewise, your friend has depression and PTSD. I suffer from both (I should add that my experiences in social housing have contributed to these) but want my own home so I’m working like crazy to save up. It is very nearly impossible and like walking through hell.

But the benefit of being a homeowner is that you can choose where to live and what home you want. If you can’t afford it then you can downsize. A mortgage can feel like a prison sentence when it’s not really affordable. But otherwise, to me that freedom is priceless.

There are always going to be people who are in many ways better off on benefits and social housing. That’s great for them if they want to stay in the same house probably for the rest of their lives. But it wouldn’t truly be yours.

And do you really want the life circumstances that would make you eligible for it?

sashh · 09/01/2023 10:02

NewBootsAndRanty · 09/01/2023 09:21

Thanks - I didn't realise it didn't apply to people not on HB.

It also affects you if you are on Universal credit and most people on UC are working.

Also when I accepted this property with two bedrooms social housing was fully paid by housing benefit (I wasn't working at the time I moved) so people like me did move to properties that had extra bedrooms.

I don't think a private landlord could just up your rent by 25% with no warning, effectively that is what the bedroom tax did.

My property is designed for a wheelchair user, if you think finding social housing is difficult then try finding something suitable for a wheelchair user.

Zebedee55 · 09/01/2023 09:29

PrincessOfWaiIs · 09/01/2023 08:11

As people have said several times, you're not allowed to do your own repairs, particularly on things like kitchen units. If you do the council will come and redo the work to their standards and charge you for it.

This must depend on what council/HA it is - I've put in a new kitchen and bathroom here. The HA were fine with it - they just wanted to see it afterwards to make sure it had been done properly.

Technically, if we leave, they might charge to put back their units, but they never do.

It suits them, because now we are responsible for any repairs/maintenance of the stuff we had put in.

We can also do indoor repairs - providing it doesn't affect gas or electricity.

But, they probably vary - most have their own rules.

Zebedee55 · 09/01/2023 09:23

ProhibitedSteps · 08/01/2023 22:05

@Ohgoodyanotherone On my friend's street, there's a couple who are early 50s in a large 3 bed HA (yes, I know for a fact they're with the same HA). They've never had a rent increase since they moved in, in 1993 when the houses were built so they only pay £250pm (that's half local HA average!). Their kids grew up & married many years ago and ever since it's been exotic holidays, brand new car each, all the latest tech and they each have a spare room to do what they like with. They've said themselves that they can only have their luxury lifestyle due to the low rent. If they were forced to move, they'd have to pay £500+pm. They were offered a 2 bed HA apartment with a £2000k 'incentive' about 10 years ago but they declined! So they'll undoubtedly be there for many years yet as the HA's in this area are not yet forcing downsizing. I'm very glad they will be doing though.

I'm in a HA house as a widowed parent but only a 2 bed so I'll be unlikely to be made to downsize for a very long time yet.

Social housing rent has to increase every year. Their rent might be cheaper than a private let, but their rents pile have gone up, year on year.

NewBootsAndRanty · 09/01/2023 09:21

Seymour5 · 09/01/2023 09:14

Bedroom tax (not really a tax) doesn’t affect anyone who pays their own rent in social housing. Its actually a deduction of a % of benefits paid to tenants of working age where a property is under occupied, ie a single person in a three bedroomed house would lose 25% of their housing benefit . There are some circumstances where it may not apply, and it doesn’t affect those over state pension age.

www.citizensadvice.org.uk/benefits/help-if-on-a-low-income/housing-benefit/how-an-extra-bedroom-affects-your-housing-benefit/check-if-a-room-counts-as-an-extra-bedroom-for-housing-benefit/

Thanks - I didn't realise it didn't apply to people not on HB.

realmsofglory · 09/01/2023 09:17

Even if you don't oat off the mortgage you will still benefit from an increase in value and hence equity

Seymour5 · 09/01/2023 09:14

NewBootsAndRanty · 09/01/2023 09:04

No bedroom tax either. Amazing.

Bedroom tax (not really a tax) doesn’t affect anyone who pays their own rent in social housing. Its actually a deduction of a % of benefits paid to tenants of working age where a property is under occupied, ie a single person in a three bedroomed house would lose 25% of their housing benefit . There are some circumstances where it may not apply, and it doesn’t affect those over state pension age.

www.citizensadvice.org.uk/benefits/help-if-on-a-low-income/housing-benefit/how-an-extra-bedroom-affects-your-housing-benefit/check-if-a-room-counts-as-an-extra-bedroom-for-housing-benefit/

NewBootsAndRanty · 09/01/2023 09:04

No bedroom tax either. Amazing.

PrincessOfWaiIs · 09/01/2023 08:45

Also @ProhibitedSteps how can two people 'each have a spare room' when it's a three bed house?

Perhaps don't involve yourself in gossip about a friend's neighbours, then you won't get the wrong end of the stick. Or don't make random stuff up to get people indignant about the evils of SH tenants, whichever.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 09/01/2023 08:29

ProhibitedSteps · 08/01/2023 22:05

@Ohgoodyanotherone On my friend's street, there's a couple who are early 50s in a large 3 bed HA (yes, I know for a fact they're with the same HA). They've never had a rent increase since they moved in, in 1993 when the houses were built so they only pay £250pm (that's half local HA average!). Their kids grew up & married many years ago and ever since it's been exotic holidays, brand new car each, all the latest tech and they each have a spare room to do what they like with. They've said themselves that they can only have their luxury lifestyle due to the low rent. If they were forced to move, they'd have to pay £500+pm. They were offered a 2 bed HA apartment with a £2000k 'incentive' about 10 years ago but they declined! So they'll undoubtedly be there for many years yet as the HA's in this area are not yet forcing downsizing. I'm very glad they will be doing though.

I'm in a HA house as a widowed parent but only a 2 bed so I'll be unlikely to be made to downsize for a very long time yet.

There is some pure bs on this thread.