Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family member shocked I get universal credit

228 replies

JungleJungle · 06/01/2023 22:40

Had a long conversation with a family member today. I've just started a new job so not sure how much UC I will get this month, but previously was earning about 1800 a month, £950 childcare costs and £950 rent and would get, around £800 in universal credit. They seemed to think that I earn enough money to pay for myself and said nobody on 30k a year should be getting universal credit. They were quite shocked that I was getting anything. Childcare costs and rent come to more than my wage (£1900). I would likely have to give up work if I didn't get universal credit. My outgoings would be more than my incoming. I still struggle even with the £700 I have left after rent and childcare costs. Bills are so high, fuel, food, clothes, emergencies etc. Not sure what I'm looking for from this thread. I work so hard, full time, and never considered that I shouldn't be entitled to universal credit. I'm not being unreasonable am I in thinking that this is what UC is for, am I? Apologies for the slightly waffly post, just feeling a bit shit.

OP posts:
NothingHoldingMeBack · 07/01/2023 07:05

I wouldn't be discussing money with anyone. It's not their business. It's a bit distasteful also.

Crazydoglady1980 · 07/01/2023 07:03

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 07/01/2023 01:09

I disagree re state pension, you pay NI with the promise that if you contribute for xx number of years, you get yy amount per month when you reach retirement age, it is not a benefit.

That is very very very different from universal credit and should not be compared.

But it is a benefit, that you receive when you reach pension age. Most don’t pay in as much as they end up claiming.
You also pay NIC on the understanding that you will be able to claim financial support if you lose your job or need help to maintain a basic living standard. It is comparable.

Crazydoglady1980 · 07/01/2023 06:57

SpringsRightAroundTheCorner · 07/01/2023 00:56

Hmm I have 3 degrees, work ft and by the time I have paid my student loan, tax, ni and into a pension I'm only taking home £400 more than you on nearly 40k. I get 0 help with my costs (I have 3 kids) but I'm married. We live in a cheaper part of the country and saved for many years to buy a house with a large ltv so that the mortgage itself was very manageable.

It's a sad reality that so many people have children in rocky relationships before marriage and real commitment, not owning their own home and so people like us who spend years saving, establishing ourselves end up propping up people who could have done the same, saved, established themselves instead of diving in, having children and then realising actually this person is awful, oops I have children and now can't afford to live. You read it time and time again on here women having kids, unmarried early into a relationship. Piss poor planning I'm afraid. Don't worry though the state will prop you and your kids up and pay your childcare and rent costs, meanwhile we'll pay our own childcare and mortgage. It's annoying for anyone who doesn't expect handouts earning a similar amount.

Marriages do break down of course, a good friend of mine divorced last year, she's on 37k and couldn't get any help. She took over the mortgage and bought her husband out the house, so I'm quite surprised you get that. Her husband pays minimum child maintenance earning 60k, it isn't a lot though, certainly nowhere near your £800 a month. Maybe she shouldn't have got married and bought a house she'd probably be better off now living on a handout topup.

Wow, what an entitled reply, showing that you have no understanding of the lives that some people live.
It is not always as easy as planning a life and doing this, that and the other. OP has explained that this is a situation that was not of her choosing and unfortunately there are a lot of people who also have had to make difficult decisions or not had the privilege of making some of the choices you have been able to!

SmokeyPaprika · 07/01/2023 06:17

A state pension is entirely different. You’ve paid into that all your working life through NICs.and are more than entitled to it. It’s not a benefit.

But it's today's tax payers who are funding it there's not a stash of money somewhere - some people live to 67 some live to 105 so not a level playing field on payouts.
The Gov, due to raising the state pension age, should have had a pensions 'holiday' as people waited to get it but that money seems to have disappeared down a rabbit hole.

FancyFran · 07/01/2023 05:36

OP your relative is being an unkind idiot. It must have taken an enormous amount of hard work to achieve your doctorate. Personally I think you are underpaid at that level of education. I went back to work after 10 days post partum and 3 years after my dd. The latter was a mistake. I lost ground in my career. I think you are doing the right thing by working. Good for your mental health too.
We had a decade of poverty due to a burglary and l had caring duties so I had to stop work. I also developed a life long condition. I can earn pots of money (which I am happy to pay big tax on) or nothing. What I do find wrong as a married person I can't have my unemployment benefit as I have a DH on low public sector wages. If I don't have a job I have no personal money. Savings don't go very far when you live close to London.
Most ex council houses end up in the hands of private landlords and they charge £950 for a 2 bedroom property which would be capped at £400 for a social rent. This is what has caused house inflation. I also agree with the poster that says that many that could afford a mortgage don't move on freeing up social housing because they prefer more disposable income. I remember a Labour politition still hogging his council house! Post war council housing was designed to enable people to save and become socially mobile. Hence the low rents.
We claimed UC during covid as I was clinically vulnerable. It wasn't much but it helped keep a roof over our head. We had to give up our home and move somewhere smaller. I appreciate you can't do that. There is no shame in it. The shame is with the policy makers who haven't got a clue.

Tricolette · 07/01/2023 05:33

@Antst lots of boomers didn't support council houses being sold off. Who do you think ousted the Tories in 1997?

My db's dc are the most Tory right wingers I've met. They're all in their 30's and would be much more likely than any boomer to blame you for your situation.
I'm a die hard labour supporter who was really affected by the rail strikes but still supports the workers.
If you want things to change you have to do something other than whinge on MN.

JudgeRudy · 07/01/2023 05:31

Oh I agree however it's always going to be more expensive running 2 homes so it depends how much residual income they have, but in theory, yes unless it's a 50/50 share.
BTW I don't feel all boomers are naive but sadly a lot are. My mother was in shock when after she suggested I look for a home with a 2nd bedroom and a garden, l explained I could not afford over £1000 each month.

Mummyoflittledragon · 07/01/2023 05:26

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 07/01/2023 03:44

Agree with this.

Though I'm old school and don't think people should reproduce if they aren't prepared to support offspring.

That would rule out the majority of people as only a minority are net contributors.

Mummyoflittledragon · 07/01/2023 05:19

Ponderingwindow · 06/01/2023 23:08

Sites like mumsnet have been very helpful improving my understanding of the wide variety of people who use assistance programs. We aren’t always privy to the financial details of all but the closest people in our lives. For some of us, no one In that inner circle has ever claimed uc so we simply lack real world experience.

your family member learned a lesson today about life for one working parent. You, op, have nothing to be embarrassed about.

This. I was also surprised that people need UC on a 30k salary but I hadn’t done the sums. They do sound a bit thick though to make you feel as though you don’t deserve it. Their joint salary is about 100k for one person. Surely they can see the chasm?

NewNameFor2023 · 07/01/2023 05:15

You can be earning over £50K and be entitled to UC if you have high rent and childcare costs. I was surprised too but it makes such a difference.

My rent is £1250 and childcare costs are the same. Doesn’t leave much per month for bills and food.

For context, this is the average rent in my area and the cheaper end of childcare costs for two kids. Can’t move anywhere else for anything cheaper, so UC is a lifeline for a lot of people.

Tricolette · 07/01/2023 05:15

JudgeRudy · 07/01/2023 03:58

Your family member is unreasonable to be so shocked and oblivious to childcare and housing cost....are they a boomer by any chance. I'm pleased people are gradually being educated that the reason I'm broke is not because I have a mobile phone or the occasional takeaway!
The government is BU though because in my eyes you should be able to survive on £30k without needing government handouts.
You might fit into the catorgy of 'well paid' workers being shamed for using food banks and advised to 'learn to budget'.

I think boomer's are more aware than most as it's them having to help with childcare. This boomer is helping with dgc nursery fees.

It's time both parents were equally responsible for childcare fees regardless of the relationship status.

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 04:55

@NameChagaiiiin you would be entitled on. Your dh wage if 30 k but if yours is 45k then combined iits 75k so yes not entitled , would it not be better you dh is the sahp if you earn £15 k more
But. Lot depends on if rent or mortgage as they don't pay towards a mortgage

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 04:50

@Antst are you not aware anyway that even if fathers do pay , maintenance isn't taken into account for benefits ?
Plus plenty of men change , have affairs and leave , people don't know that will happen in many cases
On paper most can't afford kids but you have to look at wether you would be entitled to help , happy fo give up luxuries etc etc

Mellymoon · 07/01/2023 04:48

I don’t think that sounds right tbh.. I earn less than you and have two kids and get less universal credit than you so yeah I’d be shocked too.

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 04:48

@Antst another ageist post , we have also had low txes for the last 12 years or so and people have voted many under 40 for last 20 years
Also nothing wrong with selling council houses the issue was not replacing them with newer cheaper sustainable houses

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 04:46

@JungleJungle a couple will need slightly more though s thats 2 adults to feed not just one and no council tax discount etc

nobodygirl2023 · 07/01/2023 04:32

I guess I'm a bit surprised you qualify on 30k too - but my surprise is more that I had no idea our systems were so fair and took the enormous cost of childcare into account 😊 Did they say anything negative about it or just that they were surprised?

JudgeRudy · 07/01/2023 03:58

Your family member is unreasonable to be so shocked and oblivious to childcare and housing cost....are they a boomer by any chance. I'm pleased people are gradually being educated that the reason I'm broke is not because I have a mobile phone or the occasional takeaway!
The government is BU though because in my eyes you should be able to survive on £30k without needing government handouts.
You might fit into the catorgy of 'well paid' workers being shamed for using food banks and advised to 'learn to budget'.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 07/01/2023 03:51

" If we didn't pay for it, I bet there are woman out there who would make better decisions when picking the father."

Totally agree with this.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 07/01/2023 03:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 07/01/2023 03:44

Suziesz · 06/01/2023 22:56

Why are they wrong for being shocked though? To be honest before mumsnet I never would have assumed someone earning 30k would get something like £800 in benefits. I always assumed it was much lower than that based on rhetoric I had heard about benefits.

Agree with this.

Though I'm old school and don't think people should reproduce if they aren't prepared to support offspring.

Danikm151 · 07/01/2023 03:20

I’m a single parent working full time and getting UC.
Family members know I get UC but are shocked when I tell them I still have to pay for prescriptions, dentist, full council tax(with the 25% discount) and that my son won’t qualify for free school meals because I earn over £7400 a year. I also didn’t get healthy start vouchers.
The expression given by the media means that people presume you get all that if on UC but there are income thresholds for all of that.
UC basically pays for
my childcare and I have to ensure that I upload all receipts and even then sometimes it’s less than what I should get because of how the claim periods work!

Unless you are actually receiving UC it’s difficult to understand. There are also people who would be entitled but presume they aren’t so struggle even more.

WineIsMyMainVice · 07/01/2023 03:11

I admire you OP! You are working hard and setting a good example for your DC of a great work ethic. I can only think that the person you were talking to is from a different generation and a bit out of touch!
dont let them get you down x

SpringIsTooFarAway · 07/01/2023 03:08

Antst · 07/01/2023 00:07

Boomers have taken it all. It's because they've consistently voted to pay less tax and to take our council houses at rock-bottom prices and to weaken worker protections that we're in the situation we're in, where so many people can't afford rent and other necessities.

That said, it makes me grind my teeth to read about women who are taking taxpayers' money when the father is not contributing. Why should I pay for your kids when I can't afford to have them?

Men don't magically turn into no-hopers after the baby is born and no one forces people to have children they can't look after. The father should be forced to pay his share--and not the pathetic amount that British men often get away with, but what it actually costs to raise a child. The UK has shocking rates of teen parenthood and of single parenthood. If we didn't pay for it, I bet there are woman out there who would make better decisions when picking the father.

Aim your ire at the absent father not the women who stay and do the work of two parents.

The UK now has a very low rate of single parenthood.

A high rate of single parenthood in itself is not a problem. The outcomes are very similar for children as long as you don't have a system that deliberately forces single parent households into higher levels of poverty, per my post about the tax system above.

SpringIsTooFarAway · 07/01/2023 03:05

I wish it was done on a household basis rather than separating couples and single people. Or it was spread more equally. Seems odd that more should be awarded per person because someone is in a relationship.

More than odd. They have 48 hours per day to split work and childcare between them. A single parent is trying to do all of this in 24 so will obviously have higher costs, but gets less help/ is charge more tax. Go figure. It's completely deliberate and it's astonishing that nobody cares about this deliberate discrimination. Which is very deliverately aimed at women who make up around 90% of single parents.