Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your worst TV and movie castings

308 replies

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 06/01/2023 21:41

For me it’s Alan Rickman (who I absolutely love in everything else) as Colonel Brandon in Sense and Sensibility. He came across so unbelievably creepy and repulsive and not the gallant kind soul he is in the book.

OP posts:
NearlyMidnight · 07/01/2023 09:13

It can make such a difference to the way you enjoy a piece. If someone looks wrong or is obviously much too old or young for a part. Sometimes really excellent skills can transcend that - but they do need to be very good.

You often see it with Hollywood older men being cast in romantic leads because they are stars when really the part needs someone much younger, (but no young actor has the box-office pull the producers want)

I did Anthony and Cleopatra for A-level - and I knew the play inside out. Then I saw it on stage and was crushed with disappointment. Cleopatra was skinny, red-haired, waspish with poor posture, (No!!!! She's a queen, a beauty!!! She's dark!!!). Anthony on the other hand just looked like some bore you'd meet down the pub on a Tuesday night with a beer gut and a leer. (Weep! He was a soldier - a commander of men, a lover!).

It completely ruined it for me.

AnImaginaryCat · 07/01/2023 09:02

WandaWonder · 07/01/2023 01:56

I am now wondering if Ray Winstone would have been good?

Think Ray Winston wouldn't have been good for the younger Henry VIII.

There was another actor (Steve Waddington) who was actually in the Tudors that was way more suited to the role. Tall, broad, attractive and a red head, so suitable for younger Henry. (Also possessed better acting skills than Jonathan Rhys Myers, but that wouldn't be difficult.)

Steve Waddington's character was killed off early and my opinion of JRM went continuously downhill from season 1. Especially as JRM did increasingly more shouting as Henry got older, can presumably to make up for the lack of increasing size.

I mean, there was not a lot JRM could have done about his height so fine. But he refused to bulk up or wear a fat suit for older Henry. That bugged me even more and I ended up literally tutting whenever he appeared on screen shouting lines in the later seasons.

Not sure why I continued watching, especially considering it still annoys me so many years later 😃. (Though to clarify I don't think about it that often 🙂 - just when questions like this or JRM is mentioned.)

NearlyMidnight · 07/01/2023 09:00

I was watching something over Christmas - although I have no idea what now - and all the actors were so clean with good skin and hair and perfect white teeth and fit well-fed bodies that moved easily- yet they were all supposed to be poor peasants, soldiers and farmers in the middle ages - or something. (Obvs not suggesting actors all starve before a film - but they could do more to get rid of their actorish "look").

NearlyMidnight · 07/01/2023 08:53

Johnny Depp as Willy Wonka. Too mannered and weird. Mind you, I hate the whole film
I thought this too - he was awful and just creepy! WW should be fun - eccentric but not creepy like that.

Tok Stephens as Cedric "Charlie" Charlton in the ITV The Larkins. Very unconvincing as an awkward, socially anxious but brilliant accountant. He needs to be weedy, but sharp, bright but bashful. He comes across as bumbling instead.

Keira Knightley as Elizabeth Bennet - agree - completely wrong!

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 07/01/2023 08:49

I agree about Strike, too young, too good looking, I always pictured him more John C Reilly! But I think his accent is better than in the audiobooks, though I love Philip Glenister reading the rest of it, as it’s all a bit “oooarrr Jim Lad”. He was dragged around London and didn’t grow up in Cornwall, so it makes sense he’s got a slightly Cornish London accent.

NearlyMidnight · 07/01/2023 08:44

Initially I agreed about Tom Burke in Strike - felt he was not quite right - but that changed as the stories progressed and I now think he is Strike.

Yes - agree Andie McD in 4Weddings - terrible.

AnotherNameChangeYes · 07/01/2023 08:30

Emma Watson. She has one expression.

InsomniacVampire · 07/01/2023 08:26

Another vote for Ray Winstone but in Of Kings and Prohpets (the main of this was also so bad, but I cant remmeber his name)- I could nto get past the first episode bcause of those two.

InsomniacVampire · 07/01/2023 08:24

JD90 · 06/01/2023 21:49

Jason Statham or Vin Diesel in... well absolutely anything. 🤣🤦🏻‍♀️ as much charisma as a brick wall

You dont need charisma for the films they are in- they know what they are good at and do it well :)

KangarooKenny · 07/01/2023 08:13

FrostieBoabby · 06/01/2023 23:00

Simon Barlow in Cornation Street, still not convinced he's Peter's offspring.

(Disclaimer - yes I know it's a fictional programme 😀 )

I find his eyebrows very distracting, not sure what’s going on with them.

Penguinsaregreat · 07/01/2023 08:08

I often think sone actors can only play one role and that’s usually not far from who they are. Same in every role. Leonardo Di Caprio is a prime example.
Kristen Stewart is another example.
Thousands of actors in the world and look who they cast.
Nicholas Cage is another one with extremely limited range.

Iamthewombat · 07/01/2023 07:35

WandaWonder · 07/01/2023 01:56

I am now wondering if Ray Winstone would have been good?

Ray Winstone has played Henry VIII (opposite Helena Bonham Carter as Anne Boleyn, if I remember correctly) and the answer to your question is ‘no’’

SunshineAndFizz · 07/01/2023 05:20

Hobbesmanc · 06/01/2023 22:08

I read the beach by Alex Garland and mentally cast Ewan McGregor. And then Danny Boyle was announced as the perfect director post Trainspotting.

And they cast Leonardo Di Caprio. So wrong. See also Andi McDowall in Four Weddings. Zero chemistry.

Ewan was originally cast. And then Titanic came out and made Leo a huge star, so Danny Boyle fired Ewan for Leo. Ewan didn't speak to Danny for years afterwards because of it.

MrsBungle · 07/01/2023 02:35

The actress who plays Ginny Weasley in the Harry Potter films. She doesn’t portray book Ginny AT ALL!

verdantverdure · 07/01/2023 02:16

In the 1940 Pride and Prejudice Mary Bennet and Charlotte Lucas are both played by absolutely beautiful movie stars but Mary wears specs and Charlotte's dresses have fewer flounces than the other characters. It's annoying.

verdantverdure · 07/01/2023 02:09

Gwyneth Paltrow as Emma Woodhouse in Emma. Too old, too arch, too American. Romola Garai was much better.

ASeriesOfTubes · 07/01/2023 02:05

It's not "casting" as such, but Paddy McGuiness was a really odd choice to host Question Of Sport.

WandaWonder · 07/01/2023 01:56

AnImaginaryCat · 07/01/2023 00:40

Jonathan Ryce Myers as Henry VIII in the Tudors

Old one but I'm still not over it. Too dainty for the role and thought roaring his lines showed the character had power.

I am now wondering if Ray Winstone would have been good?

SenecaFallsRedux · 07/01/2023 01:52

RockItLikeRocketFuel · 07/01/2023 01:32

It's come up a number of times already (Renee Zellweger, Daniel Craig, Kevin Costner): other than casting Americans to appeal to American audiences 🙄 I've never understood why they don't just hire a native. For e.g. Hugh Laurie might well have been brilliant as House (don't know, didn't watch it, haven't the will to sit through a two-part Taggart) but... why pick a Brit?

Supposedly, Hugh Laurie did his audition tape in an American accent and at least one of the producers didn't know he was American. He was brilliant in House, and only once that I recall, did his native accent peek though: on the word "placard."

ArmyofMunn · 07/01/2023 01:49

JaneJeffer · 06/01/2023 23:26

Keira is perfect in Atonement

Nooo! Atonement is my favourite ever book and the movie was a travesty unfortunately.

SenecaFallsRedux · 07/01/2023 01:45

AssumingDirectControl · 06/01/2023 23:34

I thought Daniel Craig was ok in Knives Out because I assumed he’s supposed to be a parody character. Maybe he’s not, and he’s just terrible. I mean, I find him terrible in absolutely everything else (his accent in Munich was astoundingly poor) so perhaps that’s just what it is.

He is supposed to be a parody character. He's doing a form of bad exaggerated Southern accent that used to be popular in low budget movies a few decades ago. I really liked it because he is playing against type.

SenecaFallsRedux · 07/01/2023 01:40

Squisageandmosh · 06/01/2023 23:04

Me too! Kevin is almost so badly cast, it’s good! 😂

I agree. Plus in some scenes he attempts an English accent and in others, it's pure California. Makes it more fun to watch.

ArmyofMunn · 07/01/2023 01:37

SausagePourHomme · 06/01/2023 22:37

leonardo di caprio in everything. always just playing himself.

Gosh I so agree! And he won an Oscar for basically howling through a movie!

RockItLikeRocketFuel · 07/01/2023 01:32

It's come up a number of times already (Renee Zellweger, Daniel Craig, Kevin Costner): other than casting Americans to appeal to American audiences 🙄 I've never understood why they don't just hire a native. For e.g. Hugh Laurie might well have been brilliant as House (don't know, didn't watch it, haven't the will to sit through a two-part Taggart) but... why pick a Brit?

Teresa777 · 07/01/2023 01:31

John Hannah as Rebus.

Swipe left for the next trending thread