Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your worst TV and movie castings

308 replies

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 06/01/2023 21:41

For me it’s Alan Rickman (who I absolutely love in everything else) as Colonel Brandon in Sense and Sensibility. He came across so unbelievably creepy and repulsive and not the gallant kind soul he is in the book.

OP posts:
Ididanamechange · 06/01/2023 22:16

Emily Blunt in Girl on the Train. She's a great actor but too pretty to match the description in the book.

Russell Crowe in Les Miserables.

GlitteryShinyShit · 06/01/2023 22:15

Emmamoo89 · 06/01/2023 22:02

Nothing wrong with Jason statham. Love his films

I enjoy Jason Statham films. Goldie Hawn isn't a favourite. I really like Diane Keaton and Danny DeVito (and his wife), I think they have done their various roles justice.

Kanaloa · 06/01/2023 22:15

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 06/01/2023 22:10

Yes I saw the same. None of the characters were right and the story totally changed. I didn’t like Nate who was meant to be a sexy biker but was an extremely unattractive drug dealing prick

I do really like seeing some diversity in YA drama - just seemed odd to cast an African American actor to portray a character who is described so so specifically as blond hair blue eyes type. The only explanation I could think was that they saw he was described as looking ‘like Captain America,’ typed Captain America into Google, and decided to go with the new Captain America.

Or possibly they just didn’t read the book at all.

MooseBreath · 06/01/2023 22:14

Michael Gambon as Dumbledore in Harry Potter 3-8. Reading the very popular and easy to read source material should've been a prerequisite to the role.

Muststopeating · 06/01/2023 22:14

AndyWarholsPiehole · 06/01/2023 21:49

Daniel Radcliffe as Harry Potter

Came on to say exactly this!

Infuriating because everyone else was great but he couldn't act for toffee.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 06/01/2023 22:13

stonebrambleboy · 06/01/2023 22:07

Sally Hawkins as Philippa Langley in The Lost King.

I loved the film but when I saw photos of the real Phillips Langley after it I was really confused as to why they dressed Sally Hawkins as an overgrown toddler and gave her an abominable haircut when the real Phillips wore normal clothes and had long blonde hair. We’re they supposed to be making her look like there was something wrong with her?

OP posts:
felulageller · 06/01/2023 22:11

Rene Zelwegger as Bridget Jones.

She tried hard but it should have been an Englishwoman. And a naturally plump one at that.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 06/01/2023 22:10

Kanaloa · 06/01/2023 21:54

Last year, I read a teen/YA type thriller called One of Us is Lying that my niece lent me, and then we watched the Netflix adaptation. Every character was wrong. We kept talking about it, it was so distracting. The character with dark hair was blond, a character described as the all American blond haired, blue eyed Southern type was African-American etc. It sounds daft but it put me off. I would try to make at least some effort to cast somebody who looked a little like the description in the novel. I didn’t like the novel too much anyway though!

I think if you love a book the adaptation is almost always miscast, because you watch and think ‘that’s not how I imagined you.’

Yes I saw the same. None of the characters were right and the story totally changed. I didn’t like Nate who was meant to be a sexy biker but was an extremely unattractive drug dealing prick

OP posts:
Hobbesmanc · 06/01/2023 22:08

I read the beach by Alex Garland and mentally cast Ewan McGregor. And then Danny Boyle was announced as the perfect director post Trainspotting.

And they cast Leonardo Di Caprio. So wrong. See also Andi McDowall in Four Weddings. Zero chemistry.

Thinkwicebeforeyouleavemylife · 06/01/2023 22:08

Emma Watson in anything. 😂

stonebrambleboy · 06/01/2023 22:07

Sally Hawkins as Philippa Langley in The Lost King.

UncleHerbie · 06/01/2023 22:07

One Day - Emma should’ve been played by Anna Maxwell Martin - in repose she is on the plain side but IMO can look occasionally look rather beautiful (not the Wallace face as in Motherland). She’s who I cast (in my head) when the book came out. I like Anne Hathaway but her Yorkshire accent was all over England.

The Time Traveler’s Wife - I would’ve cast Cate Blanchett as Clare - Rachel McAdam didn’t do it for me

I had great expectations both films (having read the books) but was definitely left wanting

Kanaloa · 06/01/2023 22:04

Ooh yes! Tom Hanks would have been great in that part. I kind of get what you mean, because we only find out what happened with the student & Danny later in the book, it’s all revealed to us bit by bit so it’s like shocking layers of awful. I do think it’s difficult to make good adaptations of horror genre novels, because they lean so much into the jumps and simplify them too much.

No shame on Maximum Overdrive though - although I think Stand By Me would have to be my favourite adaptation!

Emmamoo89 · 06/01/2023 22:02

JD90 · 06/01/2023 21:49

Jason Statham or Vin Diesel in... well absolutely anything. 🤣🤦🏻‍♀️ as much charisma as a brick wall

Nothing wrong with Jason statham. Love his films

PolarBlair · 06/01/2023 22:02

EsmeShelby · 06/01/2023 21:46

Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher. Reacher is 6.5 Cruise is 5.8

I came on to say this!

PuppyMonkey · 06/01/2023 22:02

Ken Barlow in Coronation Street Grin

SocksAndTheCity · 06/01/2023 22:01

Somebody like Tom Hanks (or the equivalent of the day) would have been far more shocking, I think.

SocksAndTheCity · 06/01/2023 22:00

Kanaloa · 06/01/2023 21:57

That’s not how I saw it at all! That character is already not the kind/mild mannered type before he ever hears of the hotel. He’s an alcoholic who has attacked one of his students and broken his own toddler’s arm. I don’t think it was just the malevolent force of the hotel.

For me the issue was how comical the part after he goes mad was. I don’t know if that’s just the dated aspect of the film though, where some things become comical.

Speaking on Stephen King, a lot of his adaptations are soooo miscast. Although on the flip side he has some that are brilliantly cast.

Ah, I'd always read it as the mild mannered family man who was horrified by the effects of his alcoholism on his behaviour and took the job partly to escape them and rebuild his normal life. He was definitely sane, at least.

Then again, my favourite SK film is Maximum Overdrive 😀

PAFMO · 06/01/2023 21:59

AndyWarholsPiehole · 06/01/2023 21:49

Daniel Radcliffe as Harry Potter

This. Awful acting.
I'll add Stacey in Gavin and. Weakest link in a magnificent show. (Pamelaaa however being amazing)
Martine McCutchen in Love Actually. Just to make it even more ridiculous that the Prime Minister would fall in love with the tea girl /file carrier.

Eyesopenwideawake · 06/01/2023 21:59

Tom Hanks as Robert Langdon in the Da Vinci Code. Should have been Liam Neeson or Harrison Ford.

princessspotify · 06/01/2023 21:58

Jamie Dornan as Christian Gray

Kanaloa · 06/01/2023 21:57

SocksAndTheCity · 06/01/2023 21:52

Jack Nicholson in The Shining.

The whole point of the story was the main characters descent into madness because the malevolent influence of the hotel, so why pick somebody who was so totally unconvincing as a kindly and mildmannered family type that it completely fucks up the entire premise?

That’s not how I saw it at all! That character is already not the kind/mild mannered type before he ever hears of the hotel. He’s an alcoholic who has attacked one of his students and broken his own toddler’s arm. I don’t think it was just the malevolent force of the hotel.

For me the issue was how comical the part after he goes mad was. I don’t know if that’s just the dated aspect of the film though, where some things become comical.

Speaking on Stephen King, a lot of his adaptations are soooo miscast. Although on the flip side he has some that are brilliantly cast.

Kanaloa · 06/01/2023 21:54

Last year, I read a teen/YA type thriller called One of Us is Lying that my niece lent me, and then we watched the Netflix adaptation. Every character was wrong. We kept talking about it, it was so distracting. The character with dark hair was blond, a character described as the all American blond haired, blue eyed Southern type was African-American etc. It sounds daft but it put me off. I would try to make at least some effort to cast somebody who looked a little like the description in the novel. I didn’t like the novel too much anyway though!

I think if you love a book the adaptation is almost always miscast, because you watch and think ‘that’s not how I imagined you.’

Justcallmebebes · 06/01/2023 21:53

Daniel Craig in that Onion thing on Netflix at the moment. I couldn't watch it. His dreadful acting and even worse southern American accent

SocksAndTheCity · 06/01/2023 21:52

Jack Nicholson in The Shining.

The whole point of the story was the main characters descent into madness because the malevolent influence of the hotel, so why pick somebody who was so totally unconvincing as a kindly and mildmannered family type that it completely fucks up the entire premise?

Swipe left for the next trending thread