Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To insist on science GCSEs

158 replies

Hippolyte · 06/01/2023 18:47

DD is yr 9. She's a bright all rounder on paper but no real interest in STEM. She is keen to ditch a science for GCSE so that she can carry on with more of the humanities subjects that she enjoys. This would leave her with 2 sciences (which ones to be decided) and an extra humanity that she will probably get a higher grade for. I think she should do the 3 just because I don't want her to rule things out too early but aibu? Will this impact on university entrance at all ? She's obviously thinking arts rather than science degree at the moment. Thank you all!

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 06/01/2023 19:16

I did science GCSE because we had too. I had zero interest. It was moduler coursework back then so I probably got a better grade than if it had been a final exam like now. I got D. Probably would have got F if it was down to a final exam.
I simply didn't want to be in the lessons. One module I ignored the teacher and worked on an art project I was doing instead. It was quite frankly a waste of my time and the teachers time.
I so wish I could have had the opportunity to do more art subjects or humanities subject (we could only do one art, one humanities).
Let her do the subjects she wants.

NerrSnerr · 06/01/2023 19:16

Megan1992xx · 06/01/2023 18:56

Essential to do the three sciences at GCSE.

For every single child?

LIZS · 06/01/2023 19:16

Double science is still all three, just to a lesser depth than triple (separate).

womanontheedge2022 · 06/01/2023 19:14

Chickenly · 06/01/2023 19:11

I’m a former science teacher. There’s no reason at all to do all three sciences if it means giving up a subject she enjoys. Many schools do not offer triple science at all so universities don’t require it for courses. It’s only beneficial if you’re taking A Levels because there’s less content to bridge the gap. If she doesn’t intend to take all three sciences at A Level then there’s no reason to take all three at GCSE. I’m obviously a science advocate but nope, no reason to do this. It is odd that the school are letting her take two full GCSEs though instead of double award across them - a general base in the three is important for life so I think that was ill-advised and I assume it’s been done because the school want to get parents like you to panic and force their kids to take triple so their stats look good on the number of students who choose triple.

Thanks so much that's a really interesting perspective, I had wondered about the reasoning. Much appreciated

surreygoldfish · 06/01/2023 19:14

To all the people saying you can’t sit separate sciences. This is not correct. My DDs school also offers all 3 individually and not combined. She is actually doing physics and biology. The school encourages them all to do all 3 but she was adamant not to and I supported her - she isn’t strong at science and is better served getting a good grade in something else than scraping a pass in Chemistry. If able to secure good grades Biology / Chemistry is a better combo.

Testina · 06/01/2023 19:12

Have you asked her school what their Y12 policy is for picking up the dropped science again? I would imagine that if she had two 8s in the other sciences and a parent committed to supported a “hot house” Y12 (e.g. getting a tutor) they’d let her pick it.

Chickenly · 06/01/2023 19:11

I’m a former science teacher. There’s no reason at all to do all three sciences if it means giving up a subject she enjoys. Many schools do not offer triple science at all so universities don’t require it for courses. It’s only beneficial if you’re taking A Levels because there’s less content to bridge the gap. If she doesn’t intend to take all three sciences at A Level then there’s no reason to take all three at GCSE. I’m obviously a science advocate but nope, no reason to do this. It is odd that the school are letting her take two full GCSEs though instead of double award across them - a general base in the three is important for life so I think that was ill-advised and I assume it’s been done because the school want to get parents like you to panic and force their kids to take triple so their stats look good on the number of students who choose triple.

Feelallright · 06/01/2023 19:11

thesnow · 06/01/2023 19:08

Let her do combined science (2gcses).

I did double combined at GCSE. Then three science a levels, a science degree, an MSc and then a career in science!

Double is fine.

Combined isn’t on offer, though, is it?

Highlyflavouredgravy · 06/01/2023 19:10

My son didn't do triple sciences. The science teacher pointed out that involved 16 hours of teaching a week and he just couldn't face it. He did double instead, got 8-8 and was able to fill the slot with Latin.
He is now doing languages at uni and it has been very useful!
Triple science is a big undertaking and if she doesn't like science...

Feelallright · 06/01/2023 19:10

Completely fine to drop a science, and quite normal. This is not a combined or dual award. They are completely separate subjects. I did physics and biology. I didn’t do chemistry at all.

thesnow · 06/01/2023 19:08

Let her do combined science (2gcses).

I did double combined at GCSE. Then three science a levels, a science degree, an MSc and then a career in science!

Double is fine.

womanontheedge2022 · 06/01/2023 19:08

Coasterfan · 06/01/2023 19:06

The OP is not wrong, for everyone trying to tell her she is. At my DD school they do a minimum of two of physics, chemistry and biology. DD is doing all three as she wants a career in a science or medical profession but plenty of her friends have dropped one.

You are right though OP she should do all three so as not to rule anything out, she is only 13/14 way too soon to make life altering choices!

Thank you makes sense. If your DD is looking at medicine that's probably the route

123woop · 06/01/2023 19:08

I only did one science at GCSE (biology) and have never had an issue. Reading your post it sounds like she has to do 2 sciences? 2 should be fine unless she wants to do something specifically sciencey? (Even then, I have a BSC and didn't do a science subject at A level 🤣)

Testina · 06/01/2023 19:06

@AFS1 “A lot of PPs seem fixated on dual science which is clearly not what you’re talking about”

That’s not quite fair! OP herself said that her school is unusual, so it’s no surprise that posters think it’s dual science from the first post… and then when OP does clarify, she does it under a name change, so it doesn’t stand out!

Saltywalruss · 06/01/2023 19:06

AnxiousPancreas · 06/01/2023 18:48

Science is compulsory. Even if she doesn’t do a GCSE in it (which is very rare and reserved for the students who aren’t capable of even coming close to passing) they still have to do lessons in science.

Nothing is compulsory. Doing GCSEs isn't compulsory. Your school might have made it "compulsory" for their students.

OP it's unlikely to hold her back unless she wants to do science and even then that's not a given.

womanontheedge2022 · 06/01/2023 19:06

Hankunamatata · 06/01/2023 19:04

Drop physics - keep chemistry and biology. I'd say it would keep enough doors open if she changes her mind. She could still do physics and chemistry A level and go into a science degree.

Not a bad idea

Coasterfan · 06/01/2023 19:06

The OP is not wrong, for everyone trying to tell her she is. At my DD school they do a minimum of two of physics, chemistry and biology. DD is doing all three as she wants a career in a science or medical profession but plenty of her friends have dropped one.

You are right though OP she should do all three so as not to rule anything out, she is only 13/14 way too soon to make life altering choices!

Echobelly · 06/01/2023 19:06

Let her study what she wants. She won't be shutting down options by not taking triple science, and if she's not into it now, she's never likely to be, you'll just have to accept that.

Indiana2021 · 06/01/2023 19:05

How exactly are you going to 'insist'?
Let her do the subjects she enjoys. You've had your time. Why do parents do this to their kids? Advise by all means, but insist? Really?

Karwomannghia · 06/01/2023 19:04

womanontheedge2022 · 06/01/2023 19:00

I'm leaning that way tbh. No not 3 or combined dual award. 3 separate or 2 separate.

I think 2 is fine, I mean I did physics and chemistry and would have hated my parents telling me to do 3! But several friends did - whose parents wanted them to be doctors etc. didn’t end well. And even if you do medicine (which is not what you’re hoping for I know) you can get in with 2 sconces and maths.

AnxiousPancreas · 06/01/2023 19:04

Megan1992xx · 06/01/2023 18:56

Essential to do the three sciences at GCSE.

You don’t even need triple science GCSE in order to study medicine at Oxford so it’s clearly not “essential” for anything. There’s literally nothing you can do with it that you can’t do without it.

Hankunamatata · 06/01/2023 19:04

Drop physics - keep chemistry and biology. I'd say it would keep enough doors open if she changes her mind. She could still do physics and chemistry A level and go into a science degree.

Testina · 06/01/2023 19:03

womanontheedge2022 · 06/01/2023 18:57

Just to re-emphasise it isn't a dual award although I know this is common. 3 are offered separately and she can take them all or replace one with something else. Unusual but this is the offering

That would have put me off choosing the school in the first place!

I said that only 30 of 300 get offered Triple at my kids’ school. One of mine was offered (in the combined test she was #4, the teacher told me) but she wanted to do Art & DT Graphics. I’m really glad that Double Science meant she was still able to study all 3 sciences for another 2 years.

Cherrysoup · 06/01/2023 19:03

Most schools decide if a student does double or triple, not the parent. I don’t think you should force her to do triple if you really can choose separate ones, it’s her future and whilst you should be supportive and advising, if she hates eg physics, why make her take it?

wonderstuff · 06/01/2023 19:02

well that is unusual, but I’d still let her do humanities, I am biased, as a humanities teacher, but ability to structure an argument, think critically, analyse sources, write factual essays are all really useful, particularly if she’s looking at hums/social sciences post-16.