Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To insist on science GCSEs

158 replies

Hippolyte · 06/01/2023 18:47

DD is yr 9. She's a bright all rounder on paper but no real interest in STEM. She is keen to ditch a science for GCSE so that she can carry on with more of the humanities subjects that she enjoys. This would leave her with 2 sciences (which ones to be decided) and an extra humanity that she will probably get a higher grade for. I think she should do the 3 just because I don't want her to rule things out too early but aibu? Will this impact on university entrance at all ? She's obviously thinking arts rather than science degree at the moment. Thank you all!

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 06/01/2023 21:08

Feelallright · 06/01/2023 20:47

Why is it bad to cut one of the sciences out at 14? Is it equally bad to cut one of the MFLs out at 14? Or to cut out one of the humanities? Or one of the arts/design subjects?

Tha difference is that all 3 sciences are compulsory subjects at the vast majority of schools so it’s a potential disadvantage to be out of line with contemporaries. It’s fine to have dual award combined science but potentially limiting to drop one so early on.
in most schools triple science don’t get more lessons, they’re the more able scientists who cover extra material at a faster pace and study an extra gcse.

Wisenotboring · 06/01/2023 21:05

Feelallright · 06/01/2023 20:53

It’s not bonkers or restrictive. When I was at school, doing two sciences was normal. Some only did one. Only the very keen did three. That meant choosing which precise sciences you wanted to do. You didn’t do all three to an easier level. We don’t do that with languages and everyone has to study French, German and Russian.

Yes, I realise that in the past this was a far more common option. I guess that it was changed due to the sorts of issues being discussed here. Y9 is still very young to be making these decisions. The advantage of the combined award is that it provides a way of keeping all three sciences open without using an extra option. The extra studied isn't a massive amount in each science so there is still plenty of worth in the combined option and it is a perfectly good preparation for A-Level if necessary. I guess the reason for combining sciences and not languages is the degree of overlap that exists.

Feelallright · 06/01/2023 20:53

Wisenotboring · 06/01/2023 20:47

Apologies. I got confused with name change. It's a really strange way of a school doing it but I would allow her to still drop one such as physics if maybe she is less keen or strong in maths. The reality is there are very few careers that would be closed to her without a GCSE in a particular science. What I would do is complain to the governors about such a bonkers and restrictive approach to the science offering at KS4.

It’s not bonkers or restrictive. When I was at school, doing two sciences was normal. Some only did one. Only the very keen did three. That meant choosing which precise sciences you wanted to do. You didn’t do all three to an easier level. We don’t do that with languages and everyone has to study French, German and Russian.

Wisenotboring · 06/01/2023 20:47

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 06/01/2023 20:42

@Wisenotboring But it's not the combined award! OP clarifies in the thread that her daughter is at an independent school where the choice is continuing with all three sciences or cutting one of them out entirely. So she wouldn't be able to take, say, Biology A level if she only took Chemistry and Physics GCSE, whereas if she was doing the combined award that wouldn't be an issue.

Apologies. I got confused with name change. It's a really strange way of a school doing it but I would allow her to still drop one such as physics if maybe she is less keen or strong in maths. The reality is there are very few careers that would be closed to her without a GCSE in a particular science. What I would do is complain to the governors about such a bonkers and restrictive approach to the science offering at KS4.

Feelallright · 06/01/2023 20:47

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 06/01/2023 20:36

If the choice is 3 separate rather than 2 separate, rather than 3 separate or the combined one, I would say do three. I was an all rounder who didn't end up going into STEM but did do triple, although at my school it didn't replace another option. But yes, I think entirely cutting out one of the sciences age 14 is a bad idea - plenty of students in my year only really got to know what they did and didn't enjoy subject-wise and/or science-wise during the GCSE years.

Why is it bad to cut one of the sciences out at 14? Is it equally bad to cut one of the MFLs out at 14? Or to cut out one of the humanities? Or one of the arts/design subjects?

GracieLouFreeebush · 06/01/2023 20:43

I’m not a science teacher but I am a high school teacher, we offer the option to do standard double science, two full sciences (school picks the two, I’m not sure which we do) or triple science. They would only allow students predicted 7+ to do triple.

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 06/01/2023 20:42

@Wisenotboring But it's not the combined award! OP clarifies in the thread that her daughter is at an independent school where the choice is continuing with all three sciences or cutting one of them out entirely. So she wouldn't be able to take, say, Biology A level if she only took Chemistry and Physics GCSE, whereas if she was doing the combined award that wouldn't be an issue.

Wisenotboring · 06/01/2023 20:39

You want her to use one of her options to study separate sciences rather than the combined award. I have lots of experience of this and it is a very bad idea. When students do separate sciences they spend absolutely masses of time in science lessons. A terrible idea if she isn't keen! Allow her to keep her options open by choosing a different option. She can still take science A-Levels so the STEM pathway is still available if she has a change of heart further down the line.

Ericaequites · 06/01/2023 20:38

It’s disgusting that some schools don’t offer triple science. It strongly disadvantages STEM oriented students, and part of a race to the lowest possible standards. It’s cruel to make semiliterate children struggle with English Literature GSCE when they need fundamental skills like reading manuals and writing letters.

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 06/01/2023 20:36

If the choice is 3 separate rather than 2 separate, rather than 3 separate or the combined one, I would say do three. I was an all rounder who didn't end up going into STEM but did do triple, although at my school it didn't replace another option. But yes, I think entirely cutting out one of the sciences age 14 is a bad idea - plenty of students in my year only really got to know what they did and didn't enjoy subject-wise and/or science-wise during the GCSE years.

Pugtails · 06/01/2023 20:35

Let her pick what she wants to do…….

Feelallright · 06/01/2023 20:24

Ilovegardens · 06/01/2023 20:20

Yes,science is compulsory. She'll either do combined science which incorporates all 3 sciences but just 2 exams (4 papers 1 and 2) and will allow her space to pick an additional humanities subject, or triple science which involves studying all 3 subjects in greater depth and will have 3 exams (6 papers 1 and 2). It will not harm her chances of getting into a good uni at all if she just does combined science. Trust her judgement on this and let her decide for herself. GCSEs are stressful for them so let her pick subjects that she will readily apply herself to and be happier.

That is not what the OP has said. The sciences are separate. The daughter wants to pick two of them. Not combined, not three sciences but awarded two GCSEs. Two separate GCSEs in only two sciences. That’s what I did too.

Abra1t · 06/01/2023 20:22

My daughter will graduate from medical school this year.

She took two science GCSEs. Then two science A levels plus drama.

No problems at all with applications. For a lot of careers, two sciences at GCSE are just fine.

Testina · 06/01/2023 20:21

@Ilovegardens the thread has long since clarified that it’s not Dual / Double / Combined science - but actually 2 separate sciences. It’s not clear though cos OP name changed so See All doesn’t show the clarification quickly!

Ilovegardens · 06/01/2023 20:20

Yes,science is compulsory. She'll either do combined science which incorporates all 3 sciences but just 2 exams (4 papers 1 and 2) and will allow her space to pick an additional humanities subject, or triple science which involves studying all 3 subjects in greater depth and will have 3 exams (6 papers 1 and 2). It will not harm her chances of getting into a good uni at all if she just does combined science. Trust her judgement on this and let her decide for herself. GCSEs are stressful for them so let her pick subjects that she will readily apply herself to and be happier.

ThingsChristmasJumper · 06/01/2023 20:19

ThingsChristmasJumper · 06/01/2023 20:17

Just to throw in- our local secondary lets students do two of the separate science gcses rather than offering double award, rare but it does happen. It’s almost always chem and physics that they do not biology. I think it’s all shades of wrong but there you go.

That’s a state school. The local private school has had pupils who only do one science (biology) for GCSE but they’re usually overseas students.

ThingsChristmasJumper · 06/01/2023 20:17

Just to throw in- our local secondary lets students do two of the separate science gcses rather than offering double award, rare but it does happen. It’s almost always chem and physics that they do not biology. I think it’s all shades of wrong but there you go.

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/01/2023 20:13

Yes, YABU.

BungleandGeorge · 06/01/2023 20:12

I don’t think it’s particularly relevant what people did or didn’t do in the past, I’d get some current advice from school about whether it will limit her choices later on. Someone up thread suggested she could do a level physics without physics gcse which given the content of a level physics would be nigh on impossible! I don’t think people are saying stem subjects are more important but it’s true that some subjects you can pick up at a level and beyond with transferable skills and some you can’t. Eg history you could probably pick up with transferable skills from English. Some subjects are only available at a level anyway. I do think she will be limiting herself by dropping one completely but it may be that it’s no problem to do that if sure of what she wants to do next

womanontheedge2022 · 06/01/2023 20:05

Yes independent school. Thanks everyone for your comments, really appreciated.

luckylavender · 06/01/2023 20:04

I really dislike the opinion that everyone is the same. Of course we need students to do STEM subjects but in order to have a diverse society & a functioning economy we need to encourage other subjects too. Arts, humanities, languages etc etc. We are not all the same and we should celebrate that.

mishmashh · 06/01/2023 20:01

Many schools that do IGCSE allow them to drop a whole science, rather than do the double science award. Independent schools can do what they like really. As long as they're replacing a science with another traditional academic subject - no issue. Not everyone wants to do STEM subjects at uni!

PeekAtYou · 06/01/2023 19:57

My dd did 2 sciences at GCSE then a science at A-level. I would let her pick 2 humanities. I think that many kids know what kind of subjects they like and why not do 2 humanities ? My dd did 2 sciences and 2 humanities for GCSE and no regrets.

timetorefresh · 06/01/2023 19:57

Is this a private school? As a science teacher in a state school I've always been under the impression that the "rules" are that all 3 sciences are compulsory to GCSE, either has double award or triple science. Even very low ability students have studied all 3 as entry level. We've looked in the past at entering students coming in from different countries etc for just one or two of the triple science GCSEs and been told it's not possible

mishmashh · 06/01/2023 19:56

DC was in one of the top independents in the U.K. It was absolutely possible to drop a whole science.m there and still is. It meant DC could swap Chemistry for History - so ended up doing 10 GCSEs in Maths, Eng Lang, Eng Lit, Biology, Physics, Geography, History, French, Spanish, Music. Then did A-levels in Geography, Economics, French (plus an EPQ). Now at Oxford. No Chemistry GCSE needed!