Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shaming people on Facebook

105 replies

Jessiejines · 06/01/2023 18:41

AIBU that shaming people on Facebook should be illegal?

I'm on about the ones on local community Facebook groups who post pictures of people.

Example of some from my local:

Image of some man walking his dog with a woman in the early hours. Quite a grainy shot so can't really see their faces.

"Anybody recognise these two? I think they've let their dog poop on my front garden and not picked it up".

Picture of a young lady itting on a field.

"Just seen this young girl throw rubbish on the field. Should be taught some manners"

Picture of a white van with the license plate on show

"Watch out for this van. Seems a bit dodgy knocking on doors"

I know a lot of the time it's about problems like rubbish, littering etc. but I think posting photos of people online is a bit like a witch-hunt. Especially when other people comment aswell.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BunchHarman · 15/01/2023 10:20

Velda · 06/01/2023 18:52

Sometimes it’s the only way to shame these people into changing their behaviour. I saw a post recently where a child’s wheelchair had been stolen by a scrap man. Scrap man then commented saying yes it was me, so what, I got £2 for your (disabled slur) chair and I don’t care. Judging by the comments nobody will ever be giving him any scrap ever again.

That is fucking horrendous.

musicandpassion · 15/01/2023 09:28

I agree with most of the posts but when there is something genuinely dodgy it's good to know about it!
On our local FB page recently there was a post about dodgy looking men, going around in a white van offering services (they offered to seal my driveway, others to clean their roof etc). Loads of people commented on the post saying they might be legitimate businessmen, there was accusations of racism because they had Irish accents and the OP was accusing them of being travellers etc. Turns out, they were actually dodgy men who scammed an elderly neighbour out of a lot of money, the police were involved and it ended with a police campaign about not trusting door to door salespeople.
I can't help but feel this was a good thing and that people were more vigilant afterwards.

123woop · 15/01/2023 09:23

I think it depends - we live in quite a wealthy area so it's often targeted by gangs etc. I looked out of the window in the summer to see three men stood on our driveway looking at our cars. As soon as I went out and they realised I was home they scarpered in an old van. I posted on our local group (not very detailed description), having called 111 or whatever it is, and it turned out these same guys had been driving around all day and night and been spotted in people's back gardens/sheds and had stolen some building supplies off someone's driveway. It just made people more vigilant, especially those who were away on holiday etc.

MortimerTheCat · 15/01/2023 09:22

A friend of mine was targeted in the same way.

a local field/play area, there had been several incidents of a man flashing kids. My friend went up there to walk his dog. Some meathead decided that he is obviously dodgy and confronted him. Friend left, he had driven there in his works van with his business name on it. Meathead followed him home, posted pics of his van and his home address on Facebook accusing him of all sorts. Police got involved, but my friends life could have been ripped apart.

cariadlet · 15/01/2023 09:16

Nemora · 06/01/2023 20:00

Try going trail hunting - which is perfectly legal btw.

Photos of my kids have been on hunt sab fb pages with comments calling them cunts and saying they should be tortured to death. People feel justified to have a go at anyone online.

I don't agree with posting photographs of children but don't have any sympathy for adults who go trail hunting.

Since the hunting ban , it's been used as cover for the hunting of foxes.

My Twitter feed yesterday included several photographs of the corpses of foxes which had been killed by hunts (different hunts in different parts of the country). I see them every Saturday.

And then there are photos and videos of hunt monitors and hunt sabs being attacked, out of control hounds causing disruption, hounds being mistreated etc etc

Scooopsahoy · 15/01/2023 09:08

I agree OP. A lot of the posters also claim an uncanny ability to recognise someone’s ethnicity / nationality. So there’s posts saying “There’s a white van on our road with three East European men”.

I commented once when someone was blustering on about a group of Albanian men in a car park, and asked politely how they knew the men were Albanian. Did she speak Albanian herself maybe? Got a response along the lines of “I could just tell”.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 15/01/2023 09:05

LolaMoon · 15/01/2023 08:24

Not sure, I have mixed feelings about it. Catching someone in the act of doing something awful like the man stealing the wheelchair is good. But vague posts where someone thinks a wrong has been committed with no actual proof are appalling. Eg during lockdown there was a lot of shaming people for going out when in fact it turned out they were nurses working in hospitals etc. Unless you have actual evidence and know all the facts it shouldn’t be allowed.

Oh lockdown brought out all the scumbags on local gossip sites here.

They couldn't see the travellers so they all became amateur sleuths shaming people who they felt had been out their house more than once

One vile cow on my local street was one of the worst. She photographed a house 4 doors up from me as a "persistent offender" who she had "reported to the police" as they were a "covidiot" and had a constant stream of females in their property. The language she used to describe these females was out the Bill.

It caused others in the "I am suddenly Sherlock Holmes" to be abusive and offer to make complaints to police too as a "concerned citizen" and that she should consider a Covid compliant citizens arrest on one of the ladies. There was even the far fetched suggestion that they most be sex workers.

Police did turn up and hammered on the door but one of the ladies popped her head out the door and the police left quite quickly.

This caused further anger that police were useless and should've raided the house and arrested them all.

Imagine the shame of them when a lady who has lived on my street for about 40 years and who knows many on the street popped up, told them all off as the house was owned by a very elderly man, and the ladies were nurses as he was having end of life care. She said that the poor guy was very near the end and thank goodness wasn't on social media. She said she was disgusted in the one who had started it off and as she knew her landlord would be telling him what had gone on and the harassment she had tried to cause that man.

She did indeed leave not that long after, not due to the landlord but because it was very obvious that she knew she fucked up. The elderly guy passed away about two weeks after it calmed down and before she moved out.

Anytime I did see her she looked very uncomfortable. Good!

You literally couldn't sneeze here though without someone having an opinion on it. We got shamed because apparently, we had someone sit in a car parked in the street outside our house whilst we stood at the door. Yes we did, it was a mate who was struggling with his mental health and lived alone. He literally came nowhere near us but that 10 minutes chat made him feel better as he said he was finding it very difficult to get by and his mental health was terrible.

Summersolargirl · 15/01/2023 09:04

Sometimes I think it’s justified

recent examples of mine, someone coming along after midnight and stealing some produce that had an honesty box , like taking rhe lot, and doing it repeatedly

someone’s who walked their dogs off lead in a field with sheep , the second time the dogs attacked. The owner put out the images.

someone filmed stealing a car.

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 08:58

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 06/01/2023 19:54

I reckon they deserve it, if you don't want to be shamed then don't act like a pig 🤷🏼‍♀️

I have been on the receiving end of a campaign of harassment by a former neighbour who made it her life’s mission to shame me for putting empty bin liners in her wheelie bin.

I wasn’t doing anything of the sort. But it didn’t stop her from:

  • Calling me repeatedly at my office and asking me to remove the bin liners
  • Putting in CCTV to “prove” I was doing it
  • Writing to the council and the police accusing me of fly-tipping
  • Putting unpleasant messages on Facebook groups/Nextdoor and gossiping to anyone who would listen

It was genuinely intimidating and completely false.

A PP is right: this is an extension of the “neighbourhood watch” mentality and a lot of it is cheap one-upmanship, control and small mindedness. It’s usually people who feel they have little control over their own lives and project onto near strangers who they perceive to be a soft target.

Yes these groups can identify real crime and antisocial behaviour but 75% of it is petty stickybeakery.

I don’t think it can be banned really because it’s impossible to know where the line is and there is some genuinely neighbourly behaviour. People just need to approach it a bit more critically.

Ripasso · 15/01/2023 08:58

We got a camera as someone was letting their dog toilet in our tiny front garden and never picking it up. As soon as the camera was up the problem stopped however if it had not I would probably have shared an image to our local group as it was disgusting.

Catspyjamas17 · 15/01/2023 08:51

Mumsnet is far worse than local Facebook groups for spreading hatred and fear at times, plus it gets picked up by traditional media who make it their speciality to spread hate and fear, and have done for many years.

Local FB and special interest groups can be extremely helpful and positive and add to community cohesion if well-moderated. I've had to hide entire topics on Mumsnet and try not to go on it much at all these days as it's pretty much all doomscrolling stuff.

Endlesssummer2022 · 15/01/2023 08:49

Catspyjamas17 · 15/01/2023 08:44

🤔Spot the irony there, and win a 🍪

I’m not an idiot so you can keep your biscuit. I know this is social media but overall I don’t think social media is a good thing. It has more negatives than positives in my opinion even if I’m still using it. It I wish it had never been invented.

I drink alcohol and can understand there are more negatives than positives in that and have wished I’d never drank the morning after a big night. There are nuances so your little biscuit isn’t the gotcha moment you’d hoped for.

Weddi · 15/01/2023 08:48

Best one I saw was ring doorbell footage of a ‘dodgy looking man skulking around’ in her garden. She was warning everyone in our area to be vigilant, convinced he was trying to break in.

It was the local Evri courier delivering parcels just before Christmas, he commented on the post to confirm he was the dodgy looking man.

Catspyjamas17 · 15/01/2023 08:44

Endlesssummer2022 · 15/01/2023 08:30

This.

🤔Spot the irony there, and win a 🍪

Catspyjamas17 · 15/01/2023 08:34

I left the group for my neighbouring village in 2020. Previously it had been friendly and often amusing but suddenly there were several posts moaning about outsiders walking or jogging there. I'd always walked and ran routes through or past the village with my dog - there are several public footpaths that go through or around it and it's only two miles away at most! It was just ridiculous.

Endlesssummer2022 · 15/01/2023 08:30

RocketIceLollie · 15/01/2023 08:13

Social media is the worst invention of the 21st century in my opinion. It's only served to give a platform for bellends to spread hate, division and negativity.

This.

LolaMoon · 15/01/2023 08:24

Not sure, I have mixed feelings about it. Catching someone in the act of doing something awful like the man stealing the wheelchair is good. But vague posts where someone thinks a wrong has been committed with no actual proof are appalling. Eg during lockdown there was a lot of shaming people for going out when in fact it turned out they were nurses working in hospitals etc. Unless you have actual evidence and know all the facts it shouldn’t be allowed.

alloalloallo · 15/01/2023 08:23

Nemora · 06/01/2023 20:00

Try going trail hunting - which is perfectly legal btw.

Photos of my kids have been on hunt sab fb pages with comments calling them cunts and saying they should be tortured to death. People feel justified to have a go at anyone online.

My daughter ended up in one of these posts once when she was out with the local blood hounds

I mean, if you’re going to start shaming everyone, at least make sure you’ve got the right type of hunting.

I quite like these types of posts, it shows me who the idiots are. There is one local business owner on ours posting constant shaming shite - at least I know never to use his business

MissingMoominMamma · 15/01/2023 08:22

treesurgeonsarefemaletoo · 15/01/2023 08:12

I am afraid I have seen it too 😢. No excuse for abuse towards children though. I live in a very rural area and the most aggressive posts on our village page I can guarantee will have guns on their profile picture. Some sort of insecure projection of masculinity.

I agree, they shouldn’t be targeting children.

The torture and death is what happens to the fox though, and that makes some people feel very upset. I can’t imagine wanting to take my children into an environment where that might ‘accidentally’ happen.

treesurgeonsarefemaletoo · 15/01/2023 08:21

RocketIceLollie · 15/01/2023 08:13

Social media is the worst invention of the 21st century in my opinion. It's only served to give a platform for bellends to spread hate, division and negativity.

It is, people online miss the facial responses or interactions that would stop misinterpretation or anger. Those with the loudest mouths and most stupid thoughts dominate it.

pinkfondu · 15/01/2023 08:17

A spotted a post with a warning message about a van taking things from a front garden. Was my friends house do messaged her as I knew it had been agreed for them to take the stuff. She posted and explained and got kicked out!

RocketIceLollie · 15/01/2023 08:13

Social media is the worst invention of the 21st century in my opinion. It's only served to give a platform for bellends to spread hate, division and negativity.

treesurgeonsarefemaletoo · 15/01/2023 08:12

I am afraid I have seen it too 😢. No excuse for abuse towards children though. I live in a very rural area and the most aggressive posts on our village page I can guarantee will have guns on their profile picture. Some sort of insecure projection of masculinity.

MissingMoominMamma · 15/01/2023 08:09

Nemora · 06/01/2023 20:00

Try going trail hunting - which is perfectly legal btw.

Photos of my kids have been on hunt sab fb pages with comments calling them cunts and saying they should be tortured to death. People feel justified to have a go at anyone online.

Trail hunting often ends with a fox being ripped apart anyway ‘by accident’. Dogs will be dogs, eh? 🙄

It’s legal because people with money (Tories) still want to hunt and this is a loophole.

You'll argue I’m wrong, but I’ve seen it.

strawbfield · 15/01/2023 08:03

Nemora · 06/01/2023 20:00

Try going trail hunting - which is perfectly legal btw.

Photos of my kids have been on hunt sab fb pages with comments calling them cunts and saying they should be tortured to death. People feel justified to have a go at anyone online.

No, i wont try 🤬

Swipe left for the next trending thread