Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend is having an affair both are married.

333 replies

Themind · 06/01/2023 18:18

My friend has been married to her husband for 10 years two girls age 8 and 5. As far as I am aware no particular issues with their marriage we have been friends for about 6 years and re quite close. Husband seems like a nice guy but I don't know him as well. I was aware about two years ago she'd had a fling but it had allegedly ended before she'd told me. My husband and I went to the theatre yesterday and ther she was with the man she'd had the fling with earlier. She realised I'd seen her and looked shocked but sat down so I didn't approach. Queue a phone call this morning and several others throughout the day begging me noto to say anything to her husband. She confessed that she had never ended it with him first time round and had carried on cheating. He has lots of money wife doesn't understand him all the usual tripe and he won't leave because his wife will be entitled to half his cash.
She loves him apparently and would leave her husband in a heart beat. Please tell me what to do? I have a incline to walk away and never talk to her again, my husband suggested give her an ultimatum and tell her that if she doesn't tell him I will. I'm scared to death that I wouldn't want to be responsible for ruining their girls lives but ultimately she has cheated her husband and children hasn't she? I'd rather know I I was her husband.
Any ideas welcome, I hate this.

OP posts:
5128gap · 07/01/2023 09:21

Sqqueeeeeeee · 06/01/2023 23:15

It’s pretty clear that some posters on this thread have had affairs, apparently an estimated 15% of women have (obviously no one knows for sure). I wonder what impact that has on their view of this?

By that you mean the dont tell people? Thats a very lazy assumption.
I've never had an affair, in fact I've been cheated on, and I still have given valid reasons why people should not disclose affairs unless they know the person cheated on very well. A suicide attempt by a young man I'm close to being one.
To add to them, I work with vulnerable and abused women. More often than any one wants to think, accusations of cheating, whether real or imaginary, are the trigger for serious violence. However much people want to see a cheat get their comeuppance, I'd have thought they'd draw short of wanting them to be hospitalised or murdered. And while you may think that 'unlikely', its not a risk you should be taking.
Few people in the don't tell camp are motivated by concern for the cheat. Most of us just have a more thoughtful and considered approach to the welfare of their partne, rather than the blunt tool weilded by so many on here to punish a cheat at all costs.
We understand that just because some people prefer to be told, this isn't the right thing for everyone. And unless you're sure, surely it's better to err on the side of caution?

Delatron · 07/01/2023 09:21

Sandra1984 · 07/01/2023 09:16

Plus you don’t know if the husband is going to be welcoming your news.

This is a good point. And he’s not even a close friend.

Sandra1984 · 07/01/2023 09:16

Plus you don’t know if the husband is going to be welcoming your news.

Sandra1984 · 07/01/2023 09:13

Yes, if I where you OP I would not interfiere with this shit show because you don’t have all the info and don’t know what’s going on behind closed doors.

Sandra1984 · 07/01/2023 09:11

@Themind Another phonecall this evening moving from upset to elated telling me she'd leave her husband in a heartbeat if the other man would leave his wife.

she does sound really messed up but then you don’t know what’s going on between her and her husband behind those doors. I would let her know that I think what’s she’s doing is messed up and that I don’t want to be her confidant but telling her husband is going to blow on your face big time, unless you were good friends with him I would really stir away from this shit show and cut a bit ties with her.

sparkellie · 07/01/2023 09:04

Mummadeze · 06/01/2023 19:08

People who are saying to tell him are projecting so much. Just because they would want to know doesn’t mean he would. You don’t know anything about their relationship behind closed doors. Maybe they haven’t had sex in five years and are just staying together for the children which is not that unusual. I definitely wouldn’t interfere.

But surely in that case he would just choose to ignore. He doesn't have to do anything with the information, but he does deserve to have it in the first place.

5128gap · 07/01/2023 09:02

Stravaig · 07/01/2023 01:44

@5128gap You replied to the effect that I'd better hope my cheating partner was discreet then, by which I assume you meant you'd tell me anyway.

Your assumption here is wrong. Also illogical: how would 'a stranger' know you, know about cheating, and know how to contact you?

In reality, if you never want to hear difficult information about your partner's infidelities, you have four options:

  • Forgo a partner altogether. Only way to be sure.
  • Pick a partner who won't cheat on you. Still not guaranteed.
  • Pick a partner who will be reliably discreet when they do cheat on you. As previously suggested.
  • Make sure you only have friends who are happy to collude with your partner in their deceit and betrayal of you. Or rather, 'friends'.
Choose one of these and you should be fine. Or at least happily oblivious.

What you don't get to do is make the entire world responsible for protecting you from painful information about your partner's activities. That's not our job.

You are conflating two different things here.
Telling someone you know well enough to be sure that your news is in their interests, and with their welfare in mind.
Telling someone who, albeit may not be a total stranger to you, but who, in the case if the OP and the cases of neighbours, colleagues wives you barely know.
And if you think I'm the only person discussing Telling strangers, you've clearly overlooked the posts from the people saying she should tell the APs wife!
The pertinent point is not semantics around 'stranger' or 'acquaintance' it's whether you're close enough to know how your news will land.
And, for the avoidance of doubt, those of us who would prefer you to stay out of our relationships are not seeking your 'protection' or indeed anything from you.
All I'd be seeking is for you to concentrate an your own life and leave me to do the same, supported and informed by those who know and care for me, not a meddlesome acquaintance with an agenda.
In short much as it dents your self importance: You don't have a job.

sparkellie · 07/01/2023 08:57

I can't believe how many people are saying stay out of it. I wouldn't want a friend who would do that. Would you?
I would tell him. And then I would walk away from the friendship.
If it was the other way around, and her dh knew my partner was cheating and didn't tell me I would be devastated. You are not damaging her marriage or her kids. She is doing that all by herself. If she tries to pin it on you it just shows what kind of person she really is. He deserves to know. He may or may not thank you for the information, he may or may not leave her, that is up to him once he knows what is happening. There is the chance he may not believe you, but that, again, is his choice. You should do the right thing by him, because she sure as hell won't.

Bellsbeachwaves · 07/01/2023 08:43

Themind · 06/01/2023 22:59

If you read the OP my husband suggested that I tell not that anyone is going wading in. I definitely wouldn't do it anonymously that's just shit. I deliver difficult news regularly so I certainly don't have any problem taking ownership of my opinions.
Another phonecall this evening moving from upset to elated telling me she'd leave her husband in a heartbeat if the other man would leave his wife.

Honestly she needs your help if she's your friend. But she may not listen. But as a friend your job is to be there for her. Not tell her husband.

Orangeba · 07/01/2023 06:43

If I was the husband I would want to know. It would really rock my faith in people if I knew people knew but didn't say anything.

If you don't tell then I'd at least give it my best shot at trying to get the friend to stop.

Stravaig · 07/01/2023 02:25

I've not seen anyone condoning affairs.

Many posters on this thread advocate condoning affairs.
Here is the definition of condone:

Friend is having an affair both are married.
Stravaig · 07/01/2023 01:44

@5128gap You replied to the effect that I'd better hope my cheating partner was discreet then, by which I assume you meant you'd tell me anyway.

Your assumption here is wrong. Also illogical: how would 'a stranger' know you, know about cheating, and know how to contact you?

In reality, if you never want to hear difficult information about your partner's infidelities, you have four options:

  • Forgo a partner altogether. Only way to be sure.
  • Pick a partner who won't cheat on you. Still not guaranteed.
  • Pick a partner who will be reliably discreet when they do cheat on you. As previously suggested.
  • Make sure you only have friends who are happy to collude with your partner in their deceit and betrayal of you. Or rather, 'friends'.
Choose one of these and you should be fine. Or at least happily oblivious.

What you don't get to do is make the entire world responsible for protecting you from painful information about your partner's activities. That's not our job.

SpangledShambles · 07/01/2023 01:42

You do not know if there is a risk of violence if she is found out. I am deeply unsympathetic to any cheater but if you interfere, you do not know possible ramifications. In the unlikely but sadly possible event she is in an abusive rs, remember this- 2 women a week are killed by their partner in UK. Pathetic though her behaviour is, think carefully before you interfere between husband and wife (or any other sort of partnership).

user1499128287 · 07/01/2023 01:38

I don't judge my friends that way, to be honest. Romantic relationships are inherently different to any other relationships and far more complex. They're the only relationship that requires exclusivity and a level of physical intimacy no other relationship demands. Consequently, only the people directly involved are the ones who should be invested enough to get involved.

OldFan · 07/01/2023 01:10

So many different opinions!

@Themind Do you have a priest/clergy you're under that you could ask?

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 07/01/2023 00:29

user1499128287 · 07/01/2023 00:19

Stay out of it. You're not much of a friend if you dump her for what is absolutely nothing to do with you. You don't know what goes on in other people's marriages.

Do your friends morals not matter to you?
How badly do they have to treat people they purport to love before you decide their ethics don’t align with yours!

user1499128287 · 07/01/2023 00:19

Stay out of it. You're not much of a friend if you dump her for what is absolutely nothing to do with you. You don't know what goes on in other people's marriages.

Fuuuuuckit · 06/01/2023 23:55

I'm agog at the number of posters that say they'd remain friends!

I've known my best friend over 30 years. If I ever found out she'd started an affair never mind lied about it for 6 years I would drop her like a stone and tell her dh (who I'm also close to). How on earth can you support someone who is wilfully betraying their husband, her marriage, her family life for the sake of some rich cock?

Stravaig · 06/01/2023 23:41

5128gap · 06/01/2023 23:36

Yes, yes, it's concern for the husband, and you may or may not tell him depending on how close you were. That's perfectly clear.
But it doesn't address my question about your motivation for telling a complete stranger who has told you that would not want to hear it from someone like you, does it?

You're still not reading accurately. Where is this 'complete stranger'. The OP is discussing a friend and her friend's husband, and that is what we are all replying to. No-one is discussing telling a complete stranger. Except you.

5128gap · 06/01/2023 23:36

Stravaig · 06/01/2023 23:21

Well I'm not clear on your motivation I'm afraid.

Then reread my original post. Here is the relevant part. What do you find unclear?

Her husband is entitled to all the information he needs to make informed, empowered and healthy decisions for himself and his children. That is also definitive. Just as we would say to any woman here being cheated on. What if she passes on an STD from her lover to her husband? Or a child? Etc, etc.
^^
Whether or not I personally would tell her husband, and how, I'm less sure. It would depend on how close I or my husband were to him.

Yes, yes, it's concern for the husband, and you may or may not tell him depending on how close you were. That's perfectly clear.
But it doesn't address my question about your motivation for telling a complete stranger who has told you that would not want to hear it from someone like you, does it?

Stravaig · 06/01/2023 23:21

Well I'm not clear on your motivation I'm afraid.

Then reread my original post. Here is the relevant part. What do you find unclear?

Her husband is entitled to all the information he needs to make informed, empowered and healthy decisions for himself and his children. That is also definitive. Just as we would say to any woman here being cheated on. What if she passes on an STD from her lover to her husband? Or a child? Etc, etc.
^^
Whether or not I personally would tell her husband, and how, I'm less sure. It would depend on how close I or my husband were to him.

Winniewonka · 06/01/2023 23:18

I haven't waded through all the pages but I have read OP updates. It sounds like she's enjoying all the drama and so called excitement of the affair. My advice is to step away from it all now including the friendship. In the unlikely event her husband asks why you're no longer in contact, say it's a strong difference of opinion
Never presume that how you have been affected in the past will be same for someone else, I feel you're over projecting.
It's not going to end well. Don't put yourself in the role of the catalyst.

5128gap · 06/01/2023 23:17

Stravaig · 06/01/2023 22:58

You are accusing others posters of - and I quote you directly again - blundering in to satisfy your own thirst for revenge by proxy.

There is absolutely nothing in this thread to support the accusation that anyone here is 'satisfying a thirst for revenge by proxy'.

Posters here who would consider telling the husband have been clear about our motivations. You have not troubled yourself to read us accurately. Instead you project your own prejudices onto us.

Well I'm not clear on your motivation I'm afraid.
I've told you that I wouldn't want you, a stranger, telling me I was being cheated on. I told you why. You replied to the effect that I'd better hope my cheating partner was discreet then, by which I assume you meant you'd tell me anyway. So as its against my wishes, clearly your motivation wouldnt be my welfare.
I can only assume that means you have fairly powerful motivations of your own. If not revenge on the cheat, then, what?

Moraxella · 06/01/2023 23:15

Stay out and avoid friendship. She is clearly getting twitchy by the rate and emotional swing of the phone calls.

Sqqueeeeeeee · 06/01/2023 23:15

It’s pretty clear that some posters on this thread have had affairs, apparently an estimated 15% of women have (obviously no one knows for sure). I wonder what impact that has on their view of this?

Swipe left for the next trending thread