Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask why it's seen as rude, unreasonable or seen as taboo to point out certain things

189 replies

pillow56 · 06/01/2023 17:57

Example I have seen many threads on mn saying how expensive it is to have kids and how people can't afford them/more kids which is fair enough.

Yet when people both in real life and on mn say that struggling parents who had alot of kids shouldn't have had so many kids if they couldn't afford them then it's an unreasonable thing to say and they get criticised for pointing it out?

Like it's different if the parents had good jobs before the kids came along but they lost them or some unforeseen thing happened that hit the finances but I'm talking about parents who never had cash or a great career before the kids came along. It is perfectly their right to have kids but surely they know that kids equate to expense before they have them so are they surprised?

I'd love to have kids myself but I can't afford them but I wouldn't find it offensive somebody pointing out the financial realities of kids if I suddenly planned to have kids tomorrow. So why do people get offended by this?

OP posts:
HarrysNeighbourhood · 07/01/2023 08:44

Swimming lesson are essential rather not music.

HarrysNeighbourhood · 07/01/2023 08:42

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 08:04

@HarrysNeighbourhood my financially huge amounts , holidays , activities , school trips already barely affordable a 3rd would of made impossible
Also both mine did 2 team sports which involved travelling around the county sat and sundays and often in different places so one of us went with one and the other one with one
We had a 2 bed council house ( lucky to have that) a 3rd would of meant 3 sharing a tiny room
Ds1 is now at uni its hard financially supporting him with that and helping even now and we only have one child at college of we also had one at school , no chance we could help ds here and there
His student loan because of our wages don't cover his rent even and he took a year out and worked to cover what he can so our help is only £50. Here and there really
Its ok saying love is all they need and of course thats important but if you can make a choice then you do what you think is best , very different when relationships break down and best plans go amiss so someone is now on their own with 4 kids they could afford
But we wanted to give our kids some of what we never had and when it comes down to it money and finances play a big part

I would have to respectfully disagree with this. Children done 'need' holidays, sports lessons etc, that is an lifestyle choice.
Just like I have my large family and I choose to place some of the children in music lessons, all of them except the smallest are able to swim as had lessons, though I would argue that music lessons are essential where I live as we are right next to a huge and unpredictable body of water.
Children can be very expensive but can also not be. We hand down clothing, share toys/ equipment and don't go on holiday every year. The children are not missing out,we just choose this lifestyle and you choose yours.
We would have to agree to disagree.

5YearsLeft · 07/01/2023 08:39

There’s an extremely short, simple list of how to determine whether you should say something. You need two out of three of the following.

  1. Is it kind?
  2. Is it helpful?
  3. Is it necessary?

People may still not always agree with you, and there may be people who think it always needs to be all three, which is also fine (I don’t think you always need to be kind, but if some people do, that’s their choice). But I think if you follow at least two out of three, you should seldom find yourself saying something that makes you a rude arsehole.

loveyours · 07/01/2023 08:37

pillow56 · 06/01/2023 18:04

How helpful is it to say that once the kids are here though? What are they supposed to do, give them away

a lady in my office had 5 kids and her dh was always unemployed. She'd tell us how broke they were and after she left the room my other colleague said to us she shouldn't have any more kids then. It was a fair point but the others told her it was a rude comment and I secretly agreed and could see nothing wrong with it.

So you suggest a job for him- not slam them for having children? Op you can't be this socially inept to think it's ok to tell people 'the truth' like this?

SmokeyPaprika · 07/01/2023 08:34

I'm 70 - when I was young people criticised others, could be racist, were sexist (still are) and there was an expectation to keep up appearances, be respectable. But underneath was a lot of very bad behaviour eg child abuse.

We are at the other end of the spectrum now where no ones choices are wrong.

And no one deserves respect. You can shop in your jamas. Slag of teachers etc

Hopefully over the next few years there will be a swing back to a more middle ground.

MeinKraft · 07/01/2023 08:28

I have a family member who doesn't realise it's rude to say to me (I have two children) that she thinks it's better to have an only child because she can afford to give her everything she wants. It would be extremely rude of me to point out the benefits of children growing up with a siblings but I did point out that I didn't think it was necessarily beneficial for children to have everything they want in life. Stick your oar in and you might hear some home truths yourself.

2ApplesShortOfABasket · 07/01/2023 08:14

Your OP is a bit pointless here as reading your posts, it seems you know exactly why it is rude but just don't care because you happen to agree. However the reason you agree is because you would like 'said" children.

You also stated you are on benefits.....I could make a whole host of observations based on that like "get a job" without knowing your actual circumstances.......but that would be extremely rude of me wouldn't it 🤔

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 08:04

@HarrysNeighbourhood my financially huge amounts , holidays , activities , school trips already barely affordable a 3rd would of made impossible
Also both mine did 2 team sports which involved travelling around the county sat and sundays and often in different places so one of us went with one and the other one with one
We had a 2 bed council house ( lucky to have that) a 3rd would of meant 3 sharing a tiny room
Ds1 is now at uni its hard financially supporting him with that and helping even now and we only have one child at college of we also had one at school , no chance we could help ds here and there
His student loan because of our wages don't cover his rent even and he took a year out and worked to cover what he can so our help is only £50. Here and there really
Its ok saying love is all they need and of course thats important but if you can make a choice then you do what you think is best , very different when relationships break down and best plans go amiss so someone is now on their own with 4 kids they could afford
But we wanted to give our kids some of what we never had and when it comes down to it money and finances play a big part

HarrysNeighbourhood · 07/01/2023 07:39

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 06:23

I get what some are saying obviously the kids are here but maybe if it made others think twice
I know people around me who have kid after kid etc and then moan about money but they had no money with 3 kids so why then have another 3
We have two , would of loved 3 but had to make the hard choice that financially we couldn't afford a 3rd etc especially as it would of meant 2 dc we had missing out on lots

How would the two you have miss out? I'm curious as to what they could miss out on.
Finances aside, most of what children need can be done cheaply or free if you work hard to be frugal.

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 06:23

I get what some are saying obviously the kids are here but maybe if it made others think twice
I know people around me who have kid after kid etc and then moan about money but they had no money with 3 kids so why then have another 3
We have two , would of loved 3 but had to make the hard choice that financially we couldn't afford a 3rd etc especially as it would of meant 2 dc we had missing out on lots

MysteriesOfTheOrganism · 07/01/2023 05:48

Of course it seem daft to say they shouldn't have had so many kids, as it's something that cannot be undone - but that's not the point, surely? When we are being asked to sympathise with somebody we tend to react to the whole scenario, which includes their part in ending up in a mess. I feel more sympathy towards, say, someone injured when hit by a drunk driver than to a drunk driver injured crashing their car. Children are expensive, and the more children you have the more you're exposing yourself to the risk of financial troubles. You may have a great job - but jobs end. Economic downturns happen regularly. We cannot forsee everything, but wilful ignorance doesn't really get my sympathy.

JudgeRudy · 07/01/2023 04:24

YANBU - l think its fair game to respond to something that someone else has mentioned but perhaps a bit provocative to bring it up. Using your example if someone said how they were broke I'd probably not say anything, but if they were banging on about the cost of childcare or how they couldn't afford a better home/car/holiday, I might respond with "that's why we stopped at one".
I got 'blocked' today on a community FB page. Someone looking for a skip but wasn't prepared to pay the going rate which she said was 'ridiculous', 'stupid expensive', and 'a rip off'....I pointed out that if you broke it down, £250/week wasnt a lot to deliver,collect, empty, and maintain a skip, plus all the 'office' overheads. Apparently that's rude. I do not say half what I'd like to though.

HarrysNeighbourhood · 07/01/2023 03:04

pillow56 · 06/01/2023 18:05

What was I supposed to do with them?
I know when I got divorced, lost my home, started again that my kids made that more expensive
Was I just supposed to give them away

i'm talking more about parents who were skint from the beginning but kept having kids in the face of it , not ones whos circumstances changed

As someone with a lot of children I find this incredibly rude. Both myself and DP work full time and are by no means rich but manage on our wages. The cost of living increase could have put us in poverty if we had debts to manage ( as many low income families do) or didn't have our emergency fund. It doesn't take much to tip the balance if one of us lost our job for some reason.
Families that are large are usually very hard working and for me personally I am proud of the fact that we both work hard and do have our own income without having to rely on the state.
Families that struggle and happen to have lots of children likely don't enjoy it being that way and likely didn't set out to struggle as they do.

BubziOwl · 06/01/2023 20:46

Tbh this thread has given me a chuckle, because I have someone currently going round saying that I'm having babies I can't afford (currently pregnant with my second) and how I shouldn't be having another.

Sure, I moan about the cost of living. I put in a lot of effort to live cheaply. I grew up poor, so I'm determined to build wealth for my children. That's why my husband and I view saving and investing as a non-negotiable outgoing, and we will live as frugally as possible to enable that.

We're doing quite well. But I'm sure it looks like we're poor. I certainly talk like someone who is poor. So I'm sure you'd be thinking I ought to abort my well-fed, well-loved, and well-provided-for babies 👍

And of course, I do just inherently believe that procreation isn't just for the wealthy 🤷‍♀️

CantPreventSpring · 06/01/2023 20:38

OP, I think that having a family should be a right. If you want to have children but will remain childless for life because you don't think you can afford to have even one, that's a failure of society.

BubziOwl · 06/01/2023 20:35

pillow56 · 06/01/2023 19:09

or you could have poor parents who struggle financially but give a really wholesome loving upbringing. It’s not as clear cut as you are trying to make out

it's hard to give a loving upbringing when the kids and the parents are starving and the house is freezing.

As someone who grew up with a poor but very loving mother, I'm quite grateful I'm here tbh. I've had a cracking life. But perhaps you'd rather my mum aborted me because it makes you feel better 🤷‍♀️

Letitrainletitrainletitrain · 06/01/2023 20:16

In the last 10 years average house prices have gone up over 60k average rents are up at least 130 per month, average electric bills have risen from 40 per month to 263, council tax has gone up about 32%, meanwhile average salaries have only gone up about 4k.

that's never mind all the other costs that have increased over the past 19 years.

Maybe your colleague could afford the children when she had them, but like the rest of us with or without children, is finding the cost of living rises hard to cope with

Blame profit margins not parents

Supertatato · 06/01/2023 20:15

Having kids is an emotional decision not always based on logic. I wonder if you are forcing a logical view on it to make your circumstances easier to deal with or if you are genuinely a robot.

silentpool · 06/01/2023 20:07

Just because you can (point it out), doesn't mean you should (point it out). It's just not helpful particularly.

I could go around upsetting people by telling them they are overweight, idiotic, boring etc but SHOULD I? Nope.

Coffeellama · 06/01/2023 19:58

Coffeellama · 06/01/2023 19:57

You said a few posts up…

I'm also pointing out those who had a few, couldn't afford it and saw the realities but kept having them.

Wait I’m confused about which bit you’ve taken issue now… you said shouldn’t have had kids, and that once seeing the financial issues shouldn’t have carried on having kids…

Keha · 06/01/2023 19:58

I'm trying to answer the OP about why it's rude, I think it's partly because it is about very personal, intimate decisions. So if you had said it to a colleagues face would you be prepared for the conversation about how contraception failed or differing views on abortion or abuse in relationships or similar. It's a bit like if you had a colleague who'd married someone who seemed quite dodgy, unless you were really close you wouldn't call them out over it at lunch in the office. Secondly there is a sort of implication that the children would be better off not existing which is quite upsetting to the parent. I also think that although people might moan and complain often they don't mean they don't want the kids or are that unhappy, but people just like a moan. It comes across as very judgemental, because basically I think it is very judgemental. Its saying you are stupid/wrong/bad for having those kids - which as a parent is an upsetting thing to be told. It might be true. But basically it's "rude" because it's passing a big judgement on someone's life choices. I don't think I'd want to have a go at my colleagues choice of footwear unless I knew them very well so why would I publicly criticise such personal, family decisions around their children and finances. Would you tell someone you thought they were stupid to move to a certain city or buy a certain house etc? Would you do that in a room full of people who were work colleagues? I don't think I would because I think it would be offensive/nasty and wouldn't help them either.

Coffeellama · 06/01/2023 19:57

pillow56 · 06/01/2023 19:51

Yeah you are… so I’m not sure why you’re quoting me there. You think people with no money shouldn’t have had kids, or carried on having kids. The woman in your OP that you agreed with said ‘shouldn’t have had kids

no she said shouldn't have MORE kids

You said a few posts up…

I'm also pointing out those who had a few, couldn't afford it and saw the realities but kept having them.

pillow56 · 06/01/2023 19:54

Yeah you are… so I’m not sure why you’re quoting me there

and i'm quoting you because you are reporting things I never said to stir shit.

OP posts:
pillow56 · 06/01/2023 19:51

Yeah you are… so I’m not sure why you’re quoting me there. You think people with no money shouldn’t have had kids, or carried on having kids. The woman in your OP that you agreed with said ‘shouldn’t have had kids

no she said shouldn't have MORE kids

OP posts:
pillow56 · 06/01/2023 19:50

Plenty of people who grow up poor grow up happy. My dad was one of ten, raised on a wing on a prayer and had an amazing childhood

real poverty cripples happiness. I also think poverty back in the day was standard was more doable than these days.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread