Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask why it's seen as rude, unreasonable or seen as taboo to point out certain things

189 replies

pillow56 · 06/01/2023 17:57

Example I have seen many threads on mn saying how expensive it is to have kids and how people can't afford them/more kids which is fair enough.

Yet when people both in real life and on mn say that struggling parents who had alot of kids shouldn't have had so many kids if they couldn't afford them then it's an unreasonable thing to say and they get criticised for pointing it out?

Like it's different if the parents had good jobs before the kids came along but they lost them or some unforeseen thing happened that hit the finances but I'm talking about parents who never had cash or a great career before the kids came along. It is perfectly their right to have kids but surely they know that kids equate to expense before they have them so are they surprised?

I'd love to have kids myself but I can't afford them but I wouldn't find it offensive somebody pointing out the financial realities of kids if I suddenly planned to have kids tomorrow. So why do people get offended by this?

OP posts:
Coffeellama · 07/01/2023 12:10

pillow56 · 07/01/2023 11:53

the point is the OP doesn’t see why it’s rude to openly tell the person that they shouldn’t have had more kids

nobody said it's openly to the woman.

I'd love to have kids myself but I can't afford them but I wouldn't find it offensive somebody pointing out the financial realities of kids if I suddenly planned to have kids tomorrow. So why do people get offended by this?

From your OP…

Coffeellama · 07/01/2023 12:08

Yes but for the zillionth time I'm talking about the parents who DO NOT work, have NO cash, struggle with multiple kids yet keep having more. GO READ MY POSTS BEFORE JUMPING IN WITH THIS BOLLOX,

The woman you are talking about was someone you WORKED WITH. People have given you plenty of explanations of why it is rude to say it.

pillow56 · 07/01/2023 11:53

the point is the OP doesn’t see why it’s rude to openly tell the person that they shouldn’t have had more kids

nobody said it's openly to the woman.

OP posts:
IlIlI · 07/01/2023 11:46

pillow56 · 07/01/2023 11:38

The children are here, what is the point in saying shouldn't have had them

She said shouldn't have MORE, not had any.

Yet when people both in real life and on mn say that struggling parents who had alot of kids shouldn't have had so many kids if they couldn't afford them then it's an unreasonable thing to say and they get criticised for pointing it out?

You can't just get rid of them though. They're here, advice about what they should or shouldn't have done however many years ago their child was conceived isn't doing anything. It's not just pointing out the truth as you say, it's just being rude. If I tell somebody with a big nose that they have a big nose, does it being the truth make it not rude somehow?
And that's just aside from the fact we have no idea how a child came to be, so many instances of abuse and coercion that we hear about. Or even just plain old making a silly decision they can't go back on, which again is very common in all different aspects of life.

pillow56 · 07/01/2023 11:45

I know people around me who have kid after kid etc and then moan about money but they had no money with 3 kids so why then have another 3

And that was the ethos of my posts and what my colleague was pointing out but most posters here choose to ignore it

OP posts:
BritAbroad101 · 07/01/2023 11:43

There are loads of “matter of fact” things that whilst true and indeed obvious (if you boil it down) but which we as a society have determined over hundreds of years are socially unacceptable and/or impolite to say them (for a variety of complex and evolved reasons)

Do you often struggle with social/societal or cultural norms?

NamechangeOxbridge · 07/01/2023 11:41

Your question is about why it’s rude, not why people have kids when they’re hard up, so I’m going to address that. Not everyone finds social nuances easy, and for a lot of people it can be hard to understand why saying something ‘true’ or direct might be ‘rude’.

It’s about the emotional function of conversation.

The most likely effect of telling someone they’ve made decisions you wouldn’t have made in their position, is that they will feel isolated and ashamed. When someone is already having a hard time, it’s not kind or helpful to rub their nose in it by pointing out the ways you feel they have exercised poor judgement.

It would be rude to sit at the bedside of someone dying of lung cancer and say, ‘well, that’s what you get for smoking.’ This might be logical, but is not going to be helpful or comforting. And it won’t be news to them. When someone is already having a hard time, it is unkind to say things that will likely increase their suffering. It’s a case of if you don’t have something nice to say, don’t say anything at all.

Also, as a pp pointed out, it is hurtful to say that someone should not have been born. It is hurtful to people who grew up poor to hear that their very existence would have been best avoided. Sure, that may not be what you mean by saying ‘don’t have kids when you can’t afford them’, but once the kids are there, commenting on whether or not they ought to have been brought into the world is insensitive at best.

We all go through life and make various decisions that make our lives harder. We know the ways our own decisions and behaviour have contributed to our struggles.

I also wonder whether, as someone who does not feel in a good position to have children, some of your own feelings of grief and loss colour your reaction here. It can seem so unfair that people go ahead and have children, when you don’t ‘get’ to have them - because of your own circumstances beyond your control, and the choices you make in light of them. It can feel unfair that other people
feel able to forge ahead regardless of practicalities, and you don’t.

These are such emotive topics. And I am sorry for the r struggles you are dealing with.

pillow56 · 07/01/2023 11:41

As someone with a lot of children I find this incredibly rude. Both myself and DP work full time and are by no means rich but manage on our wages. The cost of living increase could have put us in poverty if we had debts to manage ( as many low income families do) or didn't have our emergency fund. It doesn't take much to tip the balance if one of us lost our job for some reason.
Families that are large are usually very hard working and for me personally I am proud of the fact that we both work hard and do have our own income without having to rely on the state

Yes but for the zillionth time I'm talking about the parents who DO NOT work, have NO cash, struggle with multiple kids yet keep having more. GO READ MY POSTS BEFORE JUMPING IN WITH THIS BOLLOX,

OP posts:
pillow56 · 07/01/2023 11:38

The children are here, what is the point in saying shouldn't have had them

She said shouldn't have MORE, not had any.

OP posts:
pillow56 · 07/01/2023 11:36

If they’re able to clothe and feed them and give them the love they needs, what’s your issue

i'm talking about the ones that can't afford to do this, know it but keep having kids....

OP posts:
BabyOnBoard90 · 07/01/2023 10:31

People want to hear what soothes their ego, but what the truth is.

Purpleberet · 07/01/2023 10:25

My POV is I agree with the your viewpoint however it doesn’t need vocalising.

I haven’t read all the previous posts but a lot of the early replies are quite defensive and not addressing the situation you described, that someone struggling financially decided to have more children.
But if you are asking whether it’s ok to air that opinion, I don’t think it’s helpful or necessary.

There will always be people who make decisions to live a lifestyle being their means and feel entitled to be financially supported by the government. And there are others who take personal responsibility for funding themselves and their life choices without expectation of financial support.

IlIlI · 07/01/2023 09:59

after she left the room my other colleague said to us she shouldn't have any more kids then. It was a fair point but the others told her it was a rude comment and I secretly agreed and could see nothing wrong with it

Even IF something were true, doesn't make it not rude to point out.
For example, looks- we all have our flaws, that's true, so why not point them out to everybody? It's true so that's all that matters after all.

The children are here, what is the point in saying shouldn't have had them? It's no different to idiots who give 'helpful' life advice along the lines of "should have done it my way" hmm. Ok, but they didn't do it your way and now it's done and can't be taken back, so unless you have anything useful to say don't say anything

Minimalme · 07/01/2023 09:51

Everyone has opinions on how other people choose to live.

It is polite to keep them to yourself.

I cannot fathom how people who are very well off would rather spend £50k extending their four bedroom detached house rather than give the money to a food bank.

But I don't say anything because we can all live our lives how we choose.

5128gap · 07/01/2023 09:40

If we remove the social taboo around criticising people's choices about having children, we step onto a slippery slope.
Some circumstances are considered by some people to be better than others for bringing children into the world.
So unless you want to live in a world where the only societally approved parents are in their late 20s, in a stable relationship, physically fit and healthy, with income above a certain level, pass a test for a certain intelligence level, live in the ideal type of housing in the perfect child friendly locations near the best schools...or whatever else people may argue to be optimum for bringing children into the world; its probably best that we preserve the current social norms, and accept that there are all different types of choices made about parenting and there is no consensus that some are more valid than others.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 07/01/2023 09:36

Other posters have touched on eugenics so let's unpack that a bit shall we?

Humans are evolutionarily wired, for the most part, to reproduce, otherwise the species will die out.

For many reasons we live in a technologically enhanced world based on an economic system that is essentially a pyramid scheme - a minority reap huge rewards from the labour of the many. Yes, it's a simplified view but bear with me.

The system is rigged in many ways to create marginalised sections of society - often certain races, cultures, religions, the disabled, the poor etc bear the brunt of that.

Currently the pursuit of wealth and social stature is regarded as the holy grail of existence but the system does not support that for everyone - by design.

The design means that it appears we are running out of resources, we are killing the planet, we are dooooomed as a species unless we reduce the population.

Obviously most people would find a mass cull unpalatable - the last advocates of that ended up with really bad optics - and those "pragmatists" not opposed to such measures have had to find ways to advance their agenda via the long game. Or, as one might consider it "eugenics by stealth".

It's not that we can't create an equitable, environmentally aware society, it's that some don't want to, because it would require redistribution of wealth and resources, and they enjoy their elite status.

So what to do?

Create division is number one on the list. Do it by as many means possible. Technology gives propaganda and mind control the biggest reach it has ever had. Psychology is better understood and pressing peoples buttons has never been easier.

It's the oldest trick in the book - "People like that shouldn't reproduce".

Of course no-one will point to a particular group that is easily identifiable due to systemically ingrained and historical prejudice. This has to be done fairly.

So one solution is to persuade people, via various propaganda campaigns, to make their own decisions not to reproduce because it is the moral and responsible choice. (Allegedly)

Then peer pressure can be applied. The environmental crisis and crumbling economy is painted as occurring because there are too many people, when actually, before the rapid advance of technology, those people were needed to create an infrastructure allowing that advancement. Now, not so much.

But, I hear you cry, why all the valiant efforts to save everyone during the pandemic? Surely that proves this is a huge, tin foil hat worthy conspiracy theory.

Well, firstly, while lives were undoubtedly saved, it wasn't until it was economically advantageous to do so. The aforementioned minority who revel in wealth and power tripled their assets in a very short time. Many elderly and vulnerable did perish.

The economies and infrastructures of most countries are completely destabilised. Our healthcare system is crumbling. People are dying. People are complaining but the playbook turns it back onto the individual and their responsibility to society, yet society has less and less responsibility to those within it.

Jam tomorrow, carrot and stick, bread and circuses - t'was ever thus but the scale of the manipulation is far greater due to technology.

We are hardwired for survival but we live in a system designed for dependency on it - once it fails we can't all go off grid and grow our own food and be self sufficient, so some will fade away and others will have to compete via whichever means are available - scapegoating those on the ladder rungs below is inevitable.

So a post like yours, OP, is the result of careful manipulation to pit us all against each other and divert attention from the real problem, the bigger picture if you like.

If you want an idea of the way the "elite" think things should be going, look into some of the Silicon Valley higher ups, and their thoughts on having big families themselves because they are intellectually and economically superior and can thereby keep the future population to a desirable standard.

While the gen pop are chasing their tails and pointing fingers at the "feckless" these underlying ideologies are given a re-brand and the carrot that we can all benefit from certain sacrifices in the short term is held out. There is always just enough hope held out to keep us on the virtue treadmill.

So, essentially your "uncomfortable truths" are driven by the worst parts of human nature, and have been planted there in that form to keep us all fighting amongst ourselves and too busy trying to survive to see the bigger picture.

Fortunately it seems from this thread that a good number of people do see the bigger picture...., but as I say, the powers that be are playing a long game. Who knows how it will play out?

2ApplesShortOfABasket · 07/01/2023 09:22

@HarrysNeighbourhood

I totally agree with you. it also depends on how much the adults are willing to give up. Some people would believe things to be essentials when in fact they are luxuries.

Both DH and I are in public sector jobs. Children have all been supported in their interests and I give up my weekends to ensure that they all get to where they are going.

Uni was a negotiation, DD was offered a place at Oxford but decided to accept a place in London. I am sure that it was down to her knowing the financial strain it would place us under. She is so happy with her uni experience and I thabk my lucky stars that I have well rounded, compassionate children who place value on relationships and experiences over anything else.

We have family holidays in the UK or Europe but the children have all been further afield through club or school experiences. We do the best we can and there is no harm in going without.

RampantIvy · 07/01/2023 09:18

Sure they can't send extra children back but they can stop complaining and blaming everyone for their issues

I agree.

I feel that many posters have completely missed the OP's point.

Shit happens. People split up, someone dies, people become ill or someone loses their job. She isn't talking about these people. She is talking about people who actively plan to have a child or multiple children when they aren't in a sustainable place to have them.

Having a child isn't a human right. It is a want or a desire.

The number of times I have had to restrain myself from posting on the education threads when parents of 5 or 6 children complain about the cost of school uniforms/donations/school lunches etc is ridiculous. Surely you factor this in when choosing to have so many children? I am referring to families where the "shit" hasn't happened BTW.

I do point out (very politely) on "shall I have another child/more children" threads how expensive teenagers are emotionally and financially though. It's no surprise that these posters only have primary school aged or younger children and have no idea of the avalanche that is facing them.

HikingforScenery · 07/01/2023 09:12

It’s your choice not to have kids.
It’s theirs to have them. If they’re able to clothe and feed them and give them the love they needs, what’s your issue? Cultural experiences don’t need to expensive to enrich the children’s lives either.

People who are better might complain about how much time consuming their DC’s activities are. Should they not have had them either.

People just complain for all sorts of reasons

I don’t know anyone irl who complains about how they’re struggling to provide for their children but I wouldn’t mind one not.

WandaWonder · 07/01/2023 09:09

Sure they can't send extra children back but they can stop complaining and blaming everyone for their issues

Emergencies and unexpected things happen but how many times can people on making bad decisions and choices and then going round in circles before people end up saying 'enough is enough' or 'think about what you are doing'

HarrysNeighbourhood · 07/01/2023 09:09

Mummadeze · 07/01/2023 08:49

Having five children is excessive if you don’t have plenty of money to take care of a big family in my opinion. One, or two if you believe having a sibling is v beneficial, is understandable. Find it weird that most people can’t see this.

What do you consider is 'plenty of money to take care of them?.
Many people think maintaining an excessive lifestyle is essential IMO. Cars are not essential, holidays are not essential, PlayStations/ iPhones are not essential, holidays etc are not essential to my family but maybe to a family of 1,2,3 children.

daisychain01 · 07/01/2023 09:06

I'd love to have kids myself but I can't afford them but I wouldn't find it offensive somebody pointing out the financial realities of kids if I suddenly planned to have kids tomorrow. So why do people get offended by this?

You wouldn't be offended because in your case you'd appreciate the advice for the future, which would then give you your options as to whether you would go on and have children.

Thats not the same as the woman with money worries who already has 5 children, and having people expressing their unwelcomed opinions about the affordability of children. Can't you tell the difference?

a) it's none of their business
b) it's rude to point that out, not "taboo" just plain rude, embarrassingly so
c) they shouldn't be so judgemental and ignorant about other peoples lives and struggles

Coffeellama · 07/01/2023 09:05

Mummadeze · 07/01/2023 08:49

Having five children is excessive if you don’t have plenty of money to take care of a big family in my opinion. One, or two if you believe having a sibling is v beneficial, is understandable. Find it weird that most people can’t see this.

You’ve obviously just missed the point of the thread. I bet we can all agree it’s excessive and not a good plan, the point is the OP doesn’t see why it’s rude to openly tell the person that they shouldn’t have had more kids. Most of the rest of us think it’s rude and unhelpful to say it.

loveyours · 07/01/2023 08:51

Mummadeze · 07/01/2023 08:49

Having five children is excessive if you don’t have plenty of money to take care of a big family in my opinion. One, or two if you believe having a sibling is v beneficial, is understandable. Find it weird that most people can’t see this.

I don't think any person disagrees that having 5 children you can't afford is excessive and different to 1 or 2

Still bloody rude to bring it up. Especially when you could say something helpful like job advice instead.

Mummadeze · 07/01/2023 08:49

Having five children is excessive if you don’t have plenty of money to take care of a big family in my opinion. One, or two if you believe having a sibling is v beneficial, is understandable. Find it weird that most people can’t see this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread