Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask why it's seen as rude, unreasonable or seen as taboo to point out certain things

189 replies

pillow56 · 06/01/2023 17:57

Example I have seen many threads on mn saying how expensive it is to have kids and how people can't afford them/more kids which is fair enough.

Yet when people both in real life and on mn say that struggling parents who had alot of kids shouldn't have had so many kids if they couldn't afford them then it's an unreasonable thing to say and they get criticised for pointing it out?

Like it's different if the parents had good jobs before the kids came along but they lost them or some unforeseen thing happened that hit the finances but I'm talking about parents who never had cash or a great career before the kids came along. It is perfectly their right to have kids but surely they know that kids equate to expense before they have them so are they surprised?

I'd love to have kids myself but I can't afford them but I wouldn't find it offensive somebody pointing out the financial realities of kids if I suddenly planned to have kids tomorrow. So why do people get offended by this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
daisychain01 · 08/01/2023 16:47

What is sometimes lost in the 'argument' / discussion about having children, is that society as a whole gets to benefit from the families that people sacrifice their time and life to raise and nurture. The children in our schools today are the taxpayers and (hopefully) well educated law abiding citizens of tomorrow who will input their future skills into all sectors of industry and commerce.

That's why it's in the government's best interests to support families who are struggling. Instead they do daft things like pull the plug on childcare support, close down Sure Start centre etc, when they should be prioritising those facilities because that should be the fabric of our society.

NettleTea · 08/01/2023 14:29

I notice OP has spent most of the time replying to semantics about her previous posts, but not addressed the several points raised about eugenics and who gets to decide which parents should or should not have children.

Ultimately we are mammals and driven to a greater or lesser degree by our hormones to reproduce. Obviously life puts other things into our existance which may, or may not, interfere with that drive, and affect whether we decide we want to give them up in exchange for children, and some people are overwhelmed by a unwavering need to have a child, maybe several times over. But everyone who actually has them makes the best of it, whatever their circumstances. Its a legal human right to enjoy a family life, if thats what we choose. And very few people who have their children would decide they would rather give them up for a few more pounds in their pockets. Some have them so that there will be someone to look after them in their old age - in many cultures this is an accepted fact and not the kneee jerk horrified response of us in the west - and you could argue that many many children's contributions to unpaid care for their parents in later life more than compensates for any benefits that may have been paid whilst they were children.

itsgettingweird · 07/01/2023 17:24

I actually agree with the premise of what you're saying.

If you don't have financial security and are struggling financially you don't plan to have more children and then even more.

There absolutely are people who had kids and then circumstances change. I know that - I just have the 1 DS but experienced this.

There are people who do have genuine contraceptive failures (again me!) and even have coil failure and pregnancy.

Abortion isn't everyone's choice.

Some people are assaulted even within marriage.

But I'd love to know the statistics of hat percentage of larger families who are financially struggling from the moment number 4/5/6 etc were born come from these categories.

And what percentage of those have made that active choice to continue a family or not protect against pregnancy despite their circumstances.

I think those who could control the circumstances far outweigh those who found themselves unlucky.

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 17:17

@HarrysNeighbourhood well thats your choice isn't it and your the one who brought up your families side , you quoted me first remember criticising my choice not the other way around

HarrysNeighbourhood · 07/01/2023 17:07

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 16:34

@HarrysNeighbourhood whats your point ? Op is talking about people like you anyway , she is talking about those who have more and can't put food on the table that sort of thing
Your choice doesn't make yours better than mine , yet you seem to think it does
Why didn't you have 10 children or more , presumably at one point you decided you had what you could manage
Op wasn't getting at people like you , yet it seems to hit a nerbe

I have 11 children so .......
Anyways I'm out, I wasn't the one that turned the thread onto large families. Everyone is taking everything personally not just myself, it seems that healthy debate has become sour.

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 16:40

@ilovesooty my choice to have kids full stop has potentially cost the tax payer money , I'm not silly enough to think none of my choices affect anyone else
If people who don't work at all for no reason other than they keep having children then yes that affects the-taxpayer , what if everyone done that ? It wouldn't be sustainable

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 16:38

@ilovesooty other peoples choices oftem do cost the taxpayer though so therefore do affect everyone
Every choice we make affects someone potentially thats how the world revolves

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 16:37

@HarrysNeighbourhood how have I chosen to live rurally ?
Ffs are you that deluded , I said I live in a council house so I had no choice where I took it, also if you have grown up in a said area etc
Your just being silly and taking it personally
Op was talking about someone complaining they can't have xyz yet they have 6 children so im sure you have had to go without some things like anyone with kids and the more you have , you have said yourself the more you have to give up but your not complaining
For us we couldn't afford to rent privately or get a mortgage and lived in a small council house
Plenty of people choose to have less children than they may like due to childcare and financial reasons
You don't have those financial restrictions , for one you have an iphone or computer etc to post

ilovesooty · 07/01/2023 16:36

@pillow56 it might not be a bad idea to develop a personal filter and realise that not all your opinions and judgements need to be vocalised, either in rl or online. Other people's choices are in general nothing to do with you.

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 16:34

@HarrysNeighbourhood whats your point ? Op is talking about people like you anyway , she is talking about those who have more and can't put food on the table that sort of thing
Your choice doesn't make yours better than mine , yet you seem to think it does
Why didn't you have 10 children or more , presumably at one point you decided you had what you could manage
Op wasn't getting at people like you , yet it seems to hit a nerbe

HarrysNeighbourhood · 07/01/2023 16:31

2ApplesShortOfABasket · 07/01/2023 15:15

@healthadvice123

I have 5 children. We make it work!

This! We make it work with the budget that we have.

HarrysNeighbourhood · 07/01/2023 16:30

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 14:51

@HarrysNeighbourhood well i disagree with you
My children loved their sports they also had swimming lessons as i think its a life skill we all should have
But why should they not do a sport they love and enjoy ? Why make them miss out when they were already doing said sport and its helped one so far get quite far in life

And I have said in my post that my kids have had swimming lessons. They also have music lessons that they love, I was pointing out that these things are a choice and not essential. What's your point?

HarrysNeighbourhood · 07/01/2023 16:28

pillow56 · 07/01/2023 11:41

As someone with a lot of children I find this incredibly rude. Both myself and DP work full time and are by no means rich but manage on our wages. The cost of living increase could have put us in poverty if we had debts to manage ( as many low income families do) or didn't have our emergency fund. It doesn't take much to tip the balance if one of us lost our job for some reason.
Families that are large are usually very hard working and for me personally I am proud of the fact that we both work hard and do have our own income without having to rely on the state

Yes but for the zillionth time I'm talking about the parents who DO NOT work, have NO cash, struggle with multiple kids yet keep having more. GO READ MY POSTS BEFORE JUMPING IN WITH THIS BOLLOX,

You said it was a work colleague, not someone who doesn't work so your the one talking bollocks.

HarrysNeighbourhood · 07/01/2023 16:25

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 14:46

@HarrysNeighbourhood when you live rurally and need to work a car is pretty essential
Its also not essential to have 6 kids etc for most thats a want not a need

Like I said it's a lifestyle choice, you have chosen to live rurally, the need for a car is something I had to factor in when we moved rurally. I live in the rural south west of Scotland, but this was a choice. Just like you have chosen that. I haven't said anywhere that having kids is essential, infact if you read my previous posts correctly you would see that I have admitted that having a large family was my choice and not essential. I have chosen a large family over holidays, a nice car, luxuries.

2ApplesShortOfABasket · 07/01/2023 15:15

@healthadvice123

I have 5 children. We make it work!

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 15:11

Op the thing you are wrong with is we can't always say our thoughts
But I have said before to a friend who questioned how we afforded something , that we both work and she currently is a sahm with younger kids and we were in that position then , so when she is able to get back to work them she will able to do the same and that you can't compare when at different stages in life etc

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 15:09

@2ApplesShortOfABasket but you have the amount of kids you can support, so taking them to their activities
Would you have had another 3 kids on top knowing the ones you have then have to stop all they do
I my circumstances we had 2 children we could provide a basic life for really , when i say holiday we did the sun £9.50 when little etc
If we had added a third all of the sports would of had to stop , the basic holiday
The op means people that go on and have more and more when they cannot afford the ones they have
Not people who have 2 or 3 and work hard but can provide food and heat the home etc
Or people who loose a job or dh walks out so situation changes
Most people can stretch to 1 or 2 kids , having more has a bigger impact as childcare costs , larger homes , cars etc are needed
The poster said a car isn't essential , well where i live many kids couldn't get to school without a car , parents couldn't get to work
Buses are irregular , they stop at 5.30/6 pm
Anyone having kids should think about what they can offer and the more you have the more you have to consider your finances and your current children
Obviously accidents happen and if it had happened to me I would of had 3 and I guess we would of managed somehow , but we made a choice to stick with 2 and did something to make it stay that way as much as was possible
I don't think its wrong that people should think how they are going go make it work when they are actively choosing bow many kids to have

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 14:51

@HarrysNeighbourhood well i disagree with you
My children loved their sports they also had swimming lessons as i think its a life skill we all should have
But why should they not do a sport they love and enjoy ? Why make them miss out when they were already doing said sport and its helped one so far get quite far in life

healthadvice123 · 07/01/2023 14:46

@HarrysNeighbourhood when you live rurally and need to work a car is pretty essential
Its also not essential to have 6 kids etc for most thats a want not a need

AllOfThemWitches · 07/01/2023 14:34

I think OP wants a 🏅 for not having children.

Yeahrightthen · 07/01/2023 14:09

So, Your question seems to basically be “why can we not voice our thoughts at all times about people - even if it may be a true and valid point”??

Surely you are not so thick to understand why most people don’t go through life doing this, even though they’d often like to?

(Clue: because they’d likely end up with no friends and have people going out of their way to avoid them)

OlympicProcrastinator · 07/01/2023 13:52

Because you really don’t know the situation. I couldn’t afford my fourth child but as I bled heavily throughout the pregnancy and was on tablets to control my ‘heavy periods’ and was also on the depo shot, the doctor (nor me to be fair) tested for pregnancy. (Also because I was 40 and had only 1 fallopian tube) By the time the pregnancy was discovered I was very close to the abortion cut off date. Contrary to popular belief, very few places do late term abortion and the ones that do have a waiting list. The government at that time brought in a two child rule so we couldn’t claim for extra financial support. I had a nervous breakdown, lost my budding new career and struggled so badly after the forced birth I nearly took my own life.

My little girl never needs to know that. I love her just the same as the others. Imagine telling anyone in real life the truth? Why would anyone need to know that? Just to stop the arsehole comments?

If anyone said, ‘well you shouldn’t have had her’ if I dared to say I was struggling I’m not sure I’d be responsible for my actions. You just don’t know why people are in the situations they are in OP so maybe just don’t voice ignorant opinions.

Needtoseethatbiggerpicture · 07/01/2023 13:25

You know the intimate details of this woman’s circumstances? You know exactly what she goes home to? Why her husband is unable to work? You know how she was brought up, her religious beliefs? You know what she was brought up with in terms of what family looks like? What she believes about people who are divorced or children brought up on broken homes? You know her husband never coerces her or flat out rapes her?

see, we could turn it on you. There is huge disability discrimination on this site. You can’t be that bad, you’re sat on a computer half the day on MN, why not find a job that that does the same as that? Why are you scrounging off tax payers when you can clearly work?

or is it more complex than that? Is there stuff we can’t see, going on in the background?

Coffeellama · 07/01/2023 12:26

There is also a difference to somebody pointing out to me the financial realities of children if I decided to have 1 to telling the woman at work who claimed to be broke to bluntly stop having kids then

Yeah there is, but the whole point of your thread is that you don’t get why it’s rude… clearly do you get why it’s rude. Glad that’s resolved!

Though actually, whilst it may not offend you, if you pointed out to this work colleague the financial implications of her having more children, it’d still be rude! Nothing wrong with lending an empathetic ear and moving on with your day. The woman may take offence, she may not. But if it’s not a close friend or someone asking for your advice, it’s rude.

pillow56 · 07/01/2023 12:16

But That's not saying it openly to the woman who was complaining about her being broke to bot have more kids. There is also a difference to somebody pointing out to me the financial realities of children if I decided to have 1 to telling the woman at work who claimed to be broke to bluntly stop having kids then,

OP posts: