Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To use inheritance to pay for private school?

214 replies

Pondformarch · 06/01/2023 17:16

We have a two year old and are due a second baby this summer. Our combined income is around £120,000, a bit more with a bonus.

My parents died when I was young and I inherited a flat. It is now worth around £125,000, not a fortune, but it would pay for private school fees.

I always had it in mind to send one child but finding out I was having a second made me think the fees would be too tight. Wondering if selling the flat might be most sensible. This is a fairly small school, not a big name one (obviously) fees for senior school are around £15,000 p/a. One of the main reasons I would prefer the private school (apart from local state choices not being brilliant) is the fact that wraparound care is really high quality and it would mean that we wouldn’t have to worry about pick ups and drop offs. Also, the school is right by my workplace, which helps.

But I also know it might be better to hang onto the flat long term. So interested in seeing what others think?

OP posts:
Pondformarch · 07/01/2023 10:34

Isn’t it @Nanamuffin - complete pain in the arse! It’s a good idea to talk to a financial advisor and I think I will do so.

OP posts:
Nanamuffin · 07/01/2023 10:32

@Pondformarch

It is completely doable as I see it from your posts. Your salary alone would cover the fees and then you’d have the additional £125k you could draw on to cover shortfall. Your DH husbands salary for a few years would have to cover everything else.

I was in a similar position but it was my flat. I sold the flat and reinvested the money -£125k
The income from that covers the school fees for my son.
I also have a salary as does my husband which could cover fees if needed.

I would think about speaking to a financial advisor and investing the money to give you solid returns.

the other issue with flats and keeping it is the maintenance and service charges. It was too much of a hassle for me to keep it for more years so I sold it. It was a huge relief to be done with it!

CrazyGolfee · 07/01/2023 10:17

I think it is a good idea. You earn enough to cover a shortfall. If I had the money I would use private school.

Volkswagenitalia · 07/01/2023 10:15

All this talk of 'investing' in your children is what puts me off sending my kids to private school (we could now afford it, but we could also use that money for other stuff). I feel like it must put quite a lot of pressure on the children - their parents have 'invested' money in them and will be expecting a delivery on that 'investment' which presumably will be a successful career, a network rich in useful contacts, a strong, confident adult etc.

What if the child doesn't live up to that? What if the child ends up happiest working in a low paid job or raising a family or whatever instead?

I wouldn't want to put that sort of pressure on my kids. Even if you never say it out loud, the fact you sent them to private school will be message enough.

It's different if there is loads of wealth and they were always going to go private and state wasn't even an option.

Pondformarch · 07/01/2023 10:14

Mortgage is on the hefty side - just over £1200. We can afford it but it’s not small.

OP posts:
Pondformarch · 07/01/2023 10:13

I don’t know what my childrens abilities are yet, @UnknownElement Smile one is two and is following a roughly normal timeline, if ‘normal’ can be defined by babbling ‘oh no teletubby’ at 5am, and one is not born yet!

It isn’t just about academic achievement or ability. My children may not be bright. If they are like DH and I, which is reasonable, they will be bright enough, but certainly not geniuses and not gifted. I do think a lot of people confuse gifted with bright.

I don’t think the local primaries are awful, but they also aren’t quite what I am looking for. I think like a lot of public services, schools are struggling a bit and that’s not a reflection of the staff in them, it’s just a myriad of factors.

OP posts:
LoveAHolidayOrTwo · 07/01/2023 10:12

Another way of looking at is you and your DH have a combined income of 120k plus a non guaranteed bonus, can you afford fees for two at a ‘cheapish’ private school considering you have a 125k flat you can sell and use the proceeds for any shortfall you have?
Your DH’s salary is likely to increase and the school fees definitely will.
How much are your outgoings such as mortgage?

ButterflyBiscuit · 07/01/2023 10:03

I think you should reconsider local primaries. They can't all be awful!? They are most likely fine and your kids will do well with interested parents.

The cha ge to private secondary is really really easy. Kids at primary go to a range of secondary schools - it's the natural point for change as a secondaries are a melting pot from any primaries.

Starting a private secondary would be easy as everyone starts from a variety of backgrounds.

zingally · 07/01/2023 10:01

I'm a very experienced state school primary teacher. I also do some holiday play scheme work at a local private school. And when the opportunity presents itself, I like to have a little nosy around, which might include a look through the children's exercise books... And, hand on heart, the work these kids are being set, and the level they're working at, is no better than the work the average state school kid is achieving.

UnknownElement · 07/01/2023 09:59

As a teacher surely you must know that unless a school is actually dangerous or unless the child is bullied which can happen at private or state school their natural ability and parental input are the biggest factor in outcome. Also the Mothers educational attainment is a big indicator. What people have to remember is that women were not encouraged to attend University in the past, so I personally had a very intelligent Mother who worked her way up as Manager of a branch of huge global corporation but she was not University educated. No one gets a sniff at job in that company these days unless you have a degree and they run a graduate scheme.

We sent DS to the local below average state school, much to the horror of some our friends. The horrified ones paid for private schooling or bussed their children to the very leafy outstanding school a few miles away.

If you have confidence in your own child’s abilities I think it’s unnecessary. I knew my child, the level he was functioning at and what he was like as a communicator so I had every confidence in him.

Being bright alone is not an indicator of success. One of the cleverest children I have ever met who was the DS of a friend of mine has a sort of sneering attitude. He just cannot get on with people at all.

Pondformarch · 07/01/2023 09:53

Ideally from reception. I’m really not keen on local primaries and I also have reservations about having children settled and making friends and then moving them to a different type of environment.

At present, fees are:

Reception - 9840
1 and 2 - 10,155
3 and 4 - 10,365
5 and 6 - 10,650
7-9 - 13,755
10-11- 14,310

So a total of 142,065. X 2 = £284,130.

Obviously, a lot of money, and I recognise the fees will go up.

However, if I look at the most expensive ‘point’ on there, which is when DC1 is Y11 and DC2 is Y9, that is £28,065. That is still affordable on just my salary, without selling the flat. Only just admittedly - going by current figures it would leave me the grand total of £109 left to myself, but I’m not a single parent and we have another salary of over £80,000 to pay the bills and essentials. Plus, if I was to keep the flat that would give another £500 or so of disposable income. And if I had sold the flat, that very expensive point - two in senior - would be exactly where I’d be utilising the money.

In other words, we have the following figures:

25/26 - 9840 R
26/27 - 10,155 1
27/28 - 19, 995 R + 2
28/29 - 20,520 1 + 3
29/30 - 20,520 2 + 4
30/31 - 21,015 3 + 5
31/32 - 21,015 4 + 6
32/33 - 24,405 5 + 7
33/34 - 24,405 6 + 8
34/35 - 27,510 7 + 9
35/36 - 28,056 8 + 10
36/37 - 28,056 9 + 11

So really it is only around nine/ten years we would be getting into that very expensive category where pretty much all my salary would be eaten up with school fees, and while it is true there are extras, I would think DHs salary could fairly adequately provide uniform and school lunches. We aren’t looking at extremely prestigious public schools with costly trips to exotic places. It really is about in the first instance, somewhere they will feel nurtured and cared for after school as well as in school, respected and comfortable. As they go through their schooling career, somewhere that isn’t huge and impersonal, supports and guides, encourages and so on.

We may well have a further inheritance from Dhs parents at some point too, obviously I hope this is a long way in the future as they are lovely people and also you never know and it could go on care home fees. But it is a consideration.

OP posts:
LoveAHolidayOrTwo · 07/01/2023 09:31

OP do you mean just secondary school or from
4 to 18?

edwinbear · 07/01/2023 09:28

You could also consider sport/art/drama/music scholarships if they have any aptitude. They are fiercely competitive but usually in the region of 10%-20% which can make quite a difference.

Pondformarch · 07/01/2023 09:16

The VAT is a worry - will have to see if it happens or not. I rather suspect not.

Of course fees will go up, but so will DHS salary - mine won’t as much of course, but we did get 5% this year so shall see!

If I only had one child, which is what I expected, I would send to private. Two children are tighter, but then that’s what the flat sale could fund if needed to.

OP posts:
edwinbear · 07/01/2023 09:13

Honestly OP, I think things will be really tight on your income + inheritance. It’s affordable now, but you need to build into your figures fee inflation of 10% each year, plus 20% VAT being added from 24/25 when Labour get in. At my DC’s school I also have to buy them both a £1,500 laptop next year, plus uniform, school trips, sports equipment etc is another £1-1.5k pa. Check also if there are compulsory school lunches which can add another £1k p.a.

Andrew101 · 07/01/2023 08:46

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 06/01/2023 20:58

@Outtasteamandluck that simply isn't true. Being bright is only one aspect of someone doing "well" at school. Firstly, success is not just defined by academic results but social confidence, resilience, exposure and opportunities to explore many different interests. There are a million different variables and its utterly ridiculous to suggest that one simple factor will guarantee a smooth ride..ditto to @Andrew101 ..just because YOUR kids got good grades in the state school they attended absolutely does not automatically mean that the same will be true for everyone. Anecdata is completely pointless. As I said upthread, it's about each individual school and child.

Also, OP, I teach in my kids school, as do many of my colleagues. There are some situations that have to be handled differently but on the whole it's absolutely fine and I couldn't send them anywhere I didn't work as I couldn't afford it. Don't rule it out.

Calm down. Actually I agree with you mostly but my opinion remains, if you have money to burn, fine, but if a close call the money could be better spent by helping your child through Uni debt free and/or help onto the property ladder.

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 06/01/2023 20:58

@Outtasteamandluck that simply isn't true. Being bright is only one aspect of someone doing "well" at school. Firstly, success is not just defined by academic results but social confidence, resilience, exposure and opportunities to explore many different interests. There are a million different variables and its utterly ridiculous to suggest that one simple factor will guarantee a smooth ride..ditto to @Andrew101 ..just because YOUR kids got good grades in the state school they attended absolutely does not automatically mean that the same will be true for everyone. Anecdata is completely pointless. As I said upthread, it's about each individual school and child.

Also, OP, I teach in my kids school, as do many of my colleagues. There are some situations that have to be handled differently but on the whole it's absolutely fine and I couldn't send them anywhere I didn't work as I couldn't afford it. Don't rule it out.

SparkyBlue · 06/01/2023 20:28

OP it's really one of those things that only you know if it's the right decision. My own opinion is that you should give one of the local primary schools a try and see how your DC get on. They might thrive there. Things change in schools and a lot depends on staff at any given time. I wouldn't rule it out just yet (I'm not in the UK and private primary schools don't even exist where I am ) but I totally understand having a gut instinct about certain schools. I had my DD enrolled in a particular local school and I went to the Christmas fair and just got such a bad vibe. I decided to go with what would have been perceived as a less popular school but I absolutely loved the principal when I met him. You know what's right for your own family.

Pondformarch · 06/01/2023 20:22

Even if that was true, it isn’t just about success.

Thanks @saltinesandcoffeecups . You’ve been really helpful.

OP posts:
Outtasteamandluck · 06/01/2023 20:18

YABU.

If the child is bright, they will succeed anywhere.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/01/2023 20:17

@Pondformarch I think you’ve crystal clear about what you are considering. If nothing else the people who keep saying that flat sale won’t cover 2 tuitions make it easier to filter relevant thoughts.

FWIW, I think you have some good options to work with and now probably do need to sit down with a few only financial adviser to fine tune the options that you have. I won’t say you should or shouldn’t do anything but will say that if you were to gashed with the private school, on the surface it doesn’t sound like you’re overextending yourselves and have alternatives if the situation changes.

ICanHideButICantRun · 06/01/2023 20:16

I would use the money to move nearer to better schools.

Pondformarch · 06/01/2023 20:07

I think people are misunderstanding, and I can’t make it clearer that I know the sake of the flat will not pay for two sets of school fees. However, it would almost pay for one, especially since if I do sell it, this will be in around ten years.

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/01/2023 20:05

Pondformarch · 06/01/2023 18:55

@saltinesandcoffeecups we recently remortgaged it (it was owned outright beforehand) to move to where we are now (the house is great, just the schools are not what I’d ideally want.)

There is a fair amount of equity in it, but there is a long term tenant and I think she may struggle to rent somewhere else which was a consideration in remortgaging rather than selling.

Makes sense. It’s something to consider though in the background as a Plan B … It gives you more options and takes out some of the risk.

lowercaseletter · 06/01/2023 19:54

All friendship groups get split up when children move at the start of secondary.
Selling the flat will not give you enough for 2 sets of fees for 14yrs.