Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To use inheritance to pay for private school?

214 replies

Pondformarch · 06/01/2023 17:16

We have a two year old and are due a second baby this summer. Our combined income is around £120,000, a bit more with a bonus.

My parents died when I was young and I inherited a flat. It is now worth around £125,000, not a fortune, but it would pay for private school fees.

I always had it in mind to send one child but finding out I was having a second made me think the fees would be too tight. Wondering if selling the flat might be most sensible. This is a fairly small school, not a big name one (obviously) fees for senior school are around £15,000 p/a. One of the main reasons I would prefer the private school (apart from local state choices not being brilliant) is the fact that wraparound care is really high quality and it would mean that we wouldn’t have to worry about pick ups and drop offs. Also, the school is right by my workplace, which helps.

But I also know it might be better to hang onto the flat long term. So interested in seeing what others think?

OP posts:
Mumtobabyhavoc · 08/01/2023 21:16

I'd hold onto the unit and have a tennant for income. Use that money for nanny/after school help.

WillBeatJanuaryBlues · 08/01/2023 21:10

@FromTheFront2theBack

I'm going to disagree on tutors.
There are tutor's and tutors.
A good tutor, working one: one with a child can make all the difference to a child's life in terms of drilling down and creating a bespoke education for your child!

Even more than a maths teacher would do with smaller than state classes.

However I completely understand what you mean about general cohorts and attitudes.

The whole experience is just usually nicer...even the building and locations!

As well as everything else including teachers being nice!

Unicorn2022 · 08/01/2023 20:55

I always found that although the uniform was slightly more expensive, it was better quality and lasted for years. Also at our independent schools they always had used uniform for sale in excellent condition if anyone wanted it, plus a lot was passed around the parents. It's not something I would count as an excessive cost. The school trips were no more expensive than state school residential trips either.

Jarstastic · 08/01/2023 20:43

I’d sell the flat and invest the money.

pay for no 1 out of salary this gives time for the investment to grow before you start drawing down. Hopefully your income would have gone up and paying for no 1 will help focus and stop too much lifestyle creep.

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 08/01/2023 19:27

I'd look on the website for uniform costs (not that I think it would be a deal-breaker if all else was in place). Don't assume it's the same as state because it looks it. They could 3/4/5 times as much for things like blazers and sports kit.

OP , as you rightly say, none of us can know what might happen but you do the best you can. Mine are in indie now because state was failing them. I'm a single parent, it's v v tight and I will have debt. Uni fees, if needed, will be loans that they'll have to be responsible for and they'll be no house deposits when they're older. But for them, now, it's the best thing and I must find the money. You will make your choice based on whatever your particular concerns or drivers are and the specific schools available.

Pondformarch · 08/01/2023 18:05

I know no one can ever say anything for absolute certainty, but I’m pretty sure DH and I won’t be splitting up - and there are assets in addition to the flat if we did. Realistically, divorce is very unsettling for children and I would want to make sure I did everything in my power to keep everything stable for them if that was to happen but equally it’s hard to live your life on the assumption that it will, if you see what I mean.

I think people get confused between the very big public schools and smaller private ones - the mentions of the costs of uniform show this. There are two private schools in our town and both have a uniform that is the same really as the state ones: skirt/trousers, blouse/shirt, blazer. It’s a nicer colour Smile but I won’t have to fork out for expensive hats (which DC will lose if they take after their mother!) or capes or anything.

OP posts:
Unicorn2022 · 08/01/2023 18:01

A mortgage of £1200 is quite low on your combined salaries. You must be saving a hefty amount each month?

The only thing that would put me off selling the flat and paying for independent school is that the flat is your inheritance from your parents. If you throw that money into the education pot and you and your DH split up down the line (I'm sure you won't, but just saying) then when your assets are split you would have nothing to show for that £125k.

It always surprises me that people think independent school is unaffordable on such high salaries on here. When my DD1 moved from preschool to independent primary it actually cost less money. You get used to paying it each month.

WerkinMum · 08/01/2023 18:00

I'd definitely do it. What better investment than in your DCs future?

Pondformarch · 08/01/2023 17:39

I have looked on the websites @BigotSpigot . There are only realistically two schools DC could attend. I’m not keen on either to be honest but the wraparound care on offer has to be block booked.

OP posts:
Pondformarch · 08/01/2023 17:38

VAT is a concern but it’s one of those I’ll believe it when I see it, to be honest. The next election is for end of 2024 at present and DC1 doesn’t start school until 2025, so will have to see how likely it looks at that point.

OP posts:
BigotSpigot · 08/01/2023 17:37

I think you need to actually contact local schools and find out what their provision is. I have one in state, one in private and the before/after school provision in the state is actually better and with longer hours. The before school club needs to be booked the evening before and the after school club (until 6.30pm) can be booked on the day before 12pm. Then you have the much longer school terms too.

Pondformarch · 08/01/2023 17:36

We have the property we live in and we have another property plus the flat.

It is very true we don’t know what’s around the corner but we both have very generous death in service benefits, life insurance and so on.

Selling the flat is a contingency ‘not around the corner’ plan - should DH leave me it would ensure I could still pay for the fees in worst case scenario Smile

OP posts:
Bluebellysmell · 08/01/2023 17:35

Not read the full thread, bit

Have you factored in CGT on the sale of the flat? And other fees, solicitors, estate agents etc

Would you still be able to afford fees if VAT was added? This is increasingly likely to happen with a change in government.

PasturesN3w · 08/01/2023 17:26

We don't know what's round the corner Pondformarch; esp' if that's the only nest-egg or capitol you have, I'd think very carefully about this. I had one DC in state ed and one in grammar. The comp was as very good and my DS ended up at Bristol Uni, where his privately educated mate also got in with the same results. Both my DC's did well academically, but DD hated the hot-housing at her grammar. In hindsight, wish she'd gone to the local mixed comp, she'd have had a much nicer time and done just as well. Pondfor', consider all aspects of your DC's schooling. Paid for is not better necessarily. You may need this money down the line. Seeing an IFA is important here. This flat earns you income - do tutoring with that instead perhaps? I put all my inheritance into our marriage. Then out of the blue OH ended the marriage, taking hidden assets with him but he got 50% of everything I had to give. Wish I'd kept some back in a nice off shore acc somewhere!

queenofarles · 08/01/2023 17:25

OP , I’d totally do the same thing sell the flat to partially fund school fees ,
The flat is not worth much , and perhaps rent is not much either.
if it means financially securing the education you want without Making other financial sacrifices that will affect your lifestyle then why not?

Pondformarch · 08/01/2023 17:04

I know that, but then there’s the fact I would have to pay for before school provision too (or stay part time) and combined with not brilliant school choices it does seem like the best option.

It isn’t purely about one thing. It’s a combination of practicality and it genuinely being the best option.

OP posts:
FunctionalSkills · 08/01/2023 17:00

Even if you do pay for afterschool childcare as a block (have you checked they all do that? There's weekly booking systems here) it would still be FAR cheaper to pay for a block of childcare and only use occasionally than it would to pay private schools fees (which in effect you also pay for a block of childcare but only use ad hoc, on top of fees)

Pondformarch · 08/01/2023 15:41

I could @bridgetjonesmassivepants but it really is something I’d prefer not to do. It really is all the drawbacks to part time with none of the benefits. I’m in every day, I don’t cut down on petrol costs or get to enjoy a day catching up with my own interests or even the housework, but I also get the crappier element of the timetabling, shared classroom and classes and so on.

OP posts:
Pondformarch · 08/01/2023 15:40

lowercaseletter · 08/01/2023 15:21

Our indie has wraparound until 5pm (not much help) + extra cost. Our local state has wraparound until 6pm + cheaper!

This is not intended unpleasantly, but what is the point of these sorts of posts? Of course, not all areas have the same schools, same after school provision, same costs or same anything!

What I need is provision that I can take up as and when I need it. As far as I can see, this is not on offer at any local primary. If I wished to sign my children up for after school care, I would need to pay for it as a block when chances are I would only need to use maybe two or three of those spaces a term. In addition to this, I would need to pay for before school care or stay part time myself in order to drop the children off.

Or, if I opt for private school, I can drop them off more or less as the school day starts and pick them up when it ends, with the exception to those handful of ‘awkward’ days - and they are easily managed. This would remove a lot of stress. There are other advantages but for primary, that’s the main pull.

Doing the sums was very helpful as I could see that the sticky point would be when both children were in senior school at the same time - this is fortunately only three years. I haven’t definitely decided but I think it will be possible to hang onto the flat certainly until that period and probably even then. We shall see.

OP posts:
bridgetjonesmassivepants · 08/01/2023 15:36

Have you considered asking for an early start or finish at school? I did thus for around 6 years until my youngest was at secondary and it worked really well. I missed the last lesson every day I was in school so I could pick up my kids from their school. I am sure it was a right pain for timetabling but they needed staff and I am good at my job so they were willing to accommodate me.

We also live rurally but there was a before school club in the very small town where the kids went to school. I could drop them off at 7:30 and still manage quite a long commute to get to school.

Therefore needed before school care only and I could book them in for occasional after school care too.

Much cheaper to drop a bit of your salary than to lose £125,000. Your pension will take a hit for the years you do this but you get to see more of your kids.

bumpytrumpy · 08/01/2023 15:35

Pondformarch · 08/01/2023 15:02

Well, yes, that is a consideration. But a nanny really wouldn’t work for us - what we need is too ad hoc for that, and I think even in urban areas where nannies are plentiful (such as London) finding one willing to work just a couple of hours after school is a challenge. And when you do find one, they leave, you have to find another, or they are unwell, or go on maternity leave - we need absolutely watertight for when we need it, which isn’t always predictable!

So use a school with an after school club then?! Still doesn't have to be private for purely that reason. If you're worried about relying on an individual childminder / nanny, the after school will run every night and you can book in as needed.

To be fair, as a teacher your hours must be pretty regular?! It's not like you're off to America 1 week a month!
I think you may be fixating on the wrap around worries a bit too much - many families are in the same boat and there are lots of options which can work.

pornyshroudofturin · 08/01/2023 15:35

Have you looked into the tax situation OP? Depending on how you’ve structured it, isn’t there CGT to pay on the sale? So your £125k might be substantially depleted?

WillBeatJanuaryBlues · 08/01/2023 15:22

@HariKris .
Interesting.

Surely any capital is the feed the village approach though?

Would 125 generate enough income for 15 grand a year fees?

Wouldn't ops capital be better persevered by keeping it as a flat and having it generate rent? With the building going up and the rent yield.

Can any us slant investment guarantee at least 15 % per annum?

Stocks are v low at the moment so how could she draw down now?

op having said all that in your case I would do as Hari says because you have that second property anyway.

lowercaseletter · 08/01/2023 15:21

Our indie has wraparound until 5pm (not much help) + extra cost. Our local state has wraparound until 6pm + cheaper!

Fairydustandsparklylights · 08/01/2023 15:20

We are in a similar situation. We have decided to keep the flat and deal with the hassle. The flat is a house deposit for our 2 dc. When the day comes, it will be sold and the money divided in two. It means that we don’t have to worry about saving for their future and can just enjoy the money we earn whilst putting some away for university/ our retirement / general savings.