Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To use inheritance to pay for private school?

214 replies

Pondformarch · 06/01/2023 17:16

We have a two year old and are due a second baby this summer. Our combined income is around £120,000, a bit more with a bonus.

My parents died when I was young and I inherited a flat. It is now worth around £125,000, not a fortune, but it would pay for private school fees.

I always had it in mind to send one child but finding out I was having a second made me think the fees would be too tight. Wondering if selling the flat might be most sensible. This is a fairly small school, not a big name one (obviously) fees for senior school are around £15,000 p/a. One of the main reasons I would prefer the private school (apart from local state choices not being brilliant) is the fact that wraparound care is really high quality and it would mean that we wouldn’t have to worry about pick ups and drop offs. Also, the school is right by my workplace, which helps.

But I also know it might be better to hang onto the flat long term. So interested in seeing what others think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Womencanlift · 09/01/2023 13:22

People are not berating you, they are giving you advice based on their own experience

You have budgeted (according to what you have posted on here) for everything up to but excluding A levels. You keep saying it will be fine financially but again posters are only going on by what you have stated which in a lot of opinions looks like not enough if you had to pay for 6th form too

It appears that you are only considering private to help out with childcare and not what is best educationally for your DC which imo would include A levels. Yes it’s in the future but it is being impacted by decisions now

Pondformarch · 09/01/2023 12:36

The thread has been really helpful - thank you - but being berated for something that won’t happen until 2037 is not helpful!

I have explained my thinking on this - the final decision on where they sit their A levels is on my DC. But equally I think it would be very good for them to get used to a bigger, more diverse and mixed environment before they go on to university. My worry would be struggling to cope with the demands of being away from home and with a very different environment from the one they’ve grown up in. It would be a suggestion, not a command, however.

You are right re CGT and we have gone through this. I think this is where taking financial advice would be good whether we go down the independent school route or not.

OP posts:
Hello12345678910 · 09/01/2023 12:36

If I could, I would!

Sandinmyknickers · 09/01/2023 12:27

Also think someone night have already mentioned it but if rhe flat is worth £125k and not your main home I wouldn't assume you will get the full £125k...have you calculated your capital gains tax?

Sandinmyknickers · 09/01/2023 12:20

Pondformarch · 06/01/2023 18:56

@JulieMarooley i am counting seven years at primary and five at secondary not seven, I think that’s where the discrepancy has come from. I would strongly encourage spreading wings at sixth form before university.

I don't get this at all...why invest in all those formative years to then stop paying when they are making key decisions that will affect what they do after school and would do well to benefit from teachers who know them and their character well and can help prepare them for the next steps.
I went to a different sixth form but I was in a crap school to begin with. A levels and future decisions (and having teachers who know you to bounce those thoughts off) is more important than GCSE grades imo.....

rookiemere · 09/01/2023 11:37

@Jarstastic I think it depends how many others are moving.

DS16 would have been devastated if I'd moved him at the end of Nat5s as all his pals and sports are linked into the school.

Jarstastic · 09/01/2023 11:07

I don’t see the issue with moving at 16.

It’s a good way to start getting used to being more independent in readiness for university with the safety net of still living at home. It’s an easier transition.

I did at 16 myself. sixth form college I attended had a lot of ex private school children. Admittedly many from single sex schools who wanted to mix with the other!
it really broadened my horizons and I made some great friends.

The change of school and friendship group at 16 can’t be a massive thing otherwise some state secondary schools wouldn’t stop at 16. Our best-performing local state secondary stops at 16.

Pondformarch · 09/01/2023 11:04

I hope it doesn’t: we shall see. I would be surprised if it did if only because the resulting spill into state just isn’t something that would be able to be absorbed and plus, many of Labour’s core voters are a bit ‘champagne socialist’ and I don’t think it would go down well. But we’ll both just have to cross our fingers. It’s very sensible to have that backup plan and that’s what I want to be absolutely sure of before committing to anything. It’s been a really helpful thread in terms of getting down figures and analysing them and exactly what we(I!) can afford.

OP posts:
edwinbear · 09/01/2023 10:58

And yes, London schools are definitely more, we're paying c.£20k pa for each DC which is a lot. Don't get me wrong, I'm a big advocate of private schools, we're very happy with ours and have had them in since Reception, but just do the sums with fee inflation and VAT to work out what the absolute worst cost scenario is, and also think about contingency if one of you isn't working through redundancy/ill health etc. You'll want at least a years worth of fees in savings to give you a cushion.

edwinbear · 09/01/2023 10:55

The general view in the private sector is that it will happen. All the heads in our area are canvassing parents for their views and the impact it will have. We're in the position to be able to pay full fees up front, in advance before it's levied if it goes ahead, so we won't be impacted, but many people aren't in that position.

Pondformarch · 09/01/2023 10:54

You’re in London though @edwinbear IIRC. That makes a huge cost difference to everything - not just school fees.

I mean, to put it another way - let’s say I wanted to give up work and I created a thread asking if we could ‘live off’ £80,000 a year, plus a bonus, plus around £500 rental income. I’d be absolutely torn apart for even asking, wouldn’t I?

OP posts:
Pondformarch · 09/01/2023 10:52

Please don’t think we wouldn’t or would begrudge paying for A levels. If that’s what they want, that’s what we’d pay for. It would simply mean the ‘difficult’ (most expensive) years would be extended to five rather than three but that isn’t an insurmountable problem.

We shall have to see what happens with the 20%. I would be surprised if it happened - it’s a bit like shortening the summer holiday: I’ve been hearing it muttered about for over twenty years but haven’t actually seen it yet. Of course, I could be here in two years eating my words!

OP posts:
edwinbear · 09/01/2023 10:50

You really need to rework your figures adding 10% fee inflation on each year to get a more accurate reflection of costs. And then add 20% VAT on top. I have 2 DC at private school, we have a household income of c.£200k and are finding it quite tight out of take home income. It was especially tough when DH lost his job and took a while to find another one.

champagneandsparkles · 09/01/2023 10:25

Having very much the same type of dilemma ourselves atm, OP! It's very difficult. Uncertainty over that added 20% in a couple of years is also making us worry.

I do agree with PPs that your calculations should include a concrete plan to afford those last two years unless you find that the DC themselves actively want a change at that point. If you'd prefer them to experience more than one school setting (whether for social, financial or combined reasons) then I'd be much more inclined to start them in state and then plan to move them to private later (doesn't have to be as late as secondary age). I think it's a lot easier to make new friends when you are primary school age rather than at 16, and if the private school is a really good one then it should be very much worth paying for educationally at that stage. Though obviously that doesn't solve your wraparound care problem.

deplorabelle · 09/01/2023 09:28

Pondformarch · 09/01/2023 08:21

Oh, I wouldn’t force them to leave if they really didn’t want to, but I do think they should. Assuming they intend to go on to university, I think it would be best to put a toe in the water of a more mixed setting before that point.

But we are arguing over something that will only happen in 2037 if at all Smile

No you have deliberately removed the most expensive years of private education from your calculations. If you put those years back in you have a shortfall. It might work out okay but it might not. It indicates you should think again about your plans.

You clearly want to buy the wraparound care which will suit you. Fine. But it's nuts to plan to pay indie from 3-16 and then say you're on your own mate on the grounds they need to "dip a toe in the water". I think it's more like being shoved out of the boat tbh.

Pondformarch · 09/01/2023 08:21

Oh, I wouldn’t force them to leave if they really didn’t want to, but I do think they should. Assuming they intend to go on to university, I think it would be best to put a toe in the water of a more mixed setting before that point.

But we are arguing over something that will only happen in 2037 if at all Smile

OP posts:
deplorabelle · 09/01/2023 08:12

The big problem with your calculations is you're only planning to fund your children in private education up to 16. You have justified this with the idea they will "spread their wings" but it is extremely cruel and unfair to give them an entire school career at private and then kick them out at 16. It is a big hole in your calculations which you're covering up rather blithely.

An independent school where most or even many go elsewhere for sixth form is a BAD independent school. Do not waste your money. If most stay but you don't plan to pay for your children that's downright cruel. You say you care about friendship groups at 8+ and 11+ but they are far more important at 16+.

Pondformarch · 09/01/2023 08:07

Yes, although I make it £54,000 take home, plus around £5000 income from the flat being let. I might just be cheap, but it’s never felt like poverty!

There are other considerations that haven’t been mentioned and one of the main ones is wondering if it is just a little too closeted and small a world. Then there is my age - I don’t want to be in a position where I’m exhausted but forced to keep on teaching FT beyond a point I’d like to. But money wise on paper it’s fine. However, since my income would be paying for it we’d need to really talk about it as a family when the time comes.

OP posts:
rookiemere · 09/01/2023 07:42

Pondformarch · 09/01/2023 07:09

See, I know it sounds like I’m being deliberately awkward, but how do you work out well ‘just manage’ with over £80,000 left for the family after school fees are paid at the most expensive point?

I know that sounds combative and I don’t mean it to - I am genuinely wondering what it is I am missing!

Is it your income or take home pay that is £120k ?
If it's take home then I agree you've got a reasonable amount of slack in that budget, if it's pre tax income then your annual take home after school fees is around £50k not £80k.

Choccolatte · 09/01/2023 07:22

As your margins are quite tight be aware that there is a strong campaign to stop Private schools from being charities anymore (quite rightly) so fees may rise by 20%. It's much harder to go from state to private than the other way. I had friends do this any they stuck out like a sore thumb.

Pondformarch · 09/01/2023 07:09

See, I know it sounds like I’m being deliberately awkward, but how do you work out well ‘just manage’ with over £80,000 left for the family after school fees are paid at the most expensive point?

I know that sounds combative and I don’t mean it to - I am genuinely wondering what it is I am missing!

OP posts:
purplefacemask · 09/01/2023 06:56

On your salaries and assets, you will just about manage two kids in secondary only, or comfortably manage 2 kids in primary only/1 child in primary + secondary.

OP, speak to a financial adviser instead of asking MN.

Pondformarch · 09/01/2023 04:13

Well, there’s rather a big difference between four and sixteen. The option is there if they want it but I would encourage moving on.

At four the main concern if you like is not being in huge classes and the wraparound care.

At sixteen, having been in the same environment since being four, I think a change before university would be good. It is a long time from now. I don’t see it as odd - sixth form
colleges do tend to encourage independence a bit more than schools - but then we all see things differently.

Nannies really aren’t an option. Even finding a nanny for just an hour before and an hour after school care would be nearly impossible, never mind the fact that we’d need a nanny who never had sick days, and we wouldn’t need her for 90% of the after school care but would need her to be available anyway …

OP posts:
SnackSizeRaisin · 08/01/2023 21:42

I think it's a little odd that you want your children in private from 4 because you are worried about the experience they will get in state and changing friendship groups at 11, but yet at 16 having been in the same school with the same children their whole lives, you suddenly expect them to leave all their high achieving middle class friends and attend the local college. Aren't you worried about the change socially as well as the effect of the different teaching style affecting the results of their a levels (probably the most important exams of anyone's life)? After being cosseted and spoon fed from age 4 this is surely not the point at which to throw them into the state system where they will be left to get on with it.

If you are going private I would definitely plan to at least give them the option to stay in private until 18.

I have a friend who left private at 16 and went to a good state comp. He didn't end up getting any A levels. Got in with a crowd who, while not unpleasant people, had low aspirations and mostly ended up unemployed or in minimum wage jobs. Just one example but I don't think it's a good age to swap. Particularly if you don't rate the local state options.

WillBeatJanuaryBlues · 08/01/2023 21:20

@Volkswagenitalia .
I don't follow the logic surely you know if your the kind of person who would put pressure on your dc or not?

I' do know if a family who do and I know plenty who never ever did.

Swipe left for the next trending thread