Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have absolutely lost my cool at teen.

304 replies

BABYASLEEP · 06/01/2023 14:08

I'm at home today with 1.5year old DS and 14 year old DSS. Husband at work.

DS is being a bugger at the moment, not sleeping great and a whirlwind during the day so by the time his nap time comes about mid day I'm absolutely desperate for the peace and quiet for an hour.

Anyway, I can't explain the amount of times I have BEGGED DSS to keep it down in his room on his games console whilst DS is asleep. Every time I go in first and say X is having a sleep now please just be mindful and I'd say at least 80% of the time he'll wake DS up at some point shouting at his games or with his friends.

Anyway, really REALLY needed DS to have a sleep today as didn't sleep great last night and he's also got a bit of a cold type thing so grouchy as hell.

Same thing happened, asked DSS to keep it down whilst DS slept and within 10 mins he's woken DS up who won't go back to sleep.

I absolutely lost my cool and shouted at DSS that this was his fault and why can't he just do as he's told. He got upset and is sulking in his room now. I'm downstairs with DS feeling fucking frazzled.

I'm so sick of it, I feel like unplugging the WiFi whenever DS naps now so he can't play his games anymore if he can't just keep it down. I don't expect silence but just no screeching and shouting!!

OP posts:
SillySausage81 · 06/01/2023 21:39

natural teenage behaviour as making him appear an irritation.

I think we're jumping the gun slightly by calling this "natural teenage behaviour".

When I was a teen, we didn't sit in our rooms shouting to the point we were unable to stop for even one hour, because collaborative online gaming didn't exist back then, which means you can hardly call it a natural instinct, it's not like they have a developmental need to do it, or that they are unable to prevent themselves from doing it. Yes, if it is their primary source of socialising then it is nice to let them do it but that doesn't mean it's unreasonable to ask them to keep the noise down for ONE HOUR a day.

Goldenbear · 06/01/2023 20:58

musingsinmidlife, I agree, quite apart from anything, I want to live in peace with my teenager, I also want him to go on to have a good relationship with me as a young adult, the way I see it is that if he goes to university he only has a couple of years with us full time and I want those to be as happy as they can be.

Crackof · 06/01/2023 20:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

musingsinmidlife · 06/01/2023 19:58

I think a lot of people on here have little experience with teens. The authoritarian approach of you are the child and I am the adult and you will obey me and do as I say...really isn't very effective with teens. Many of you and OP seem to think that is how a parent-teen relationship works best. You order them around and demand obedience and they comply or else you consider removing them from the home or punishing them into submission. Yelling at a teen is rarely effective in any way.

In reality collaborative approaches work much better. Talking to them with respect and working with them to find a mutually agreable solution will be far more effective at actually cohabitating in peace. Develpmentally teens want autonomy and independence and to be able to have opinions and input. And apologizing when you mess up and do something you would consequence them for (yelling at you when frustrated) also helps build trust and respect with them.

Goldenbear · 06/01/2023 19:57

Far from it I'm afraid to disappoint you, he is out and about loads as gaming is not a massive thing in our area at his age. They are in to music, parties, socialising Equally, my DS is going to study politics at A level and asked for three politics books for Christmas - sorry this doesn't live up to your oh so funny description.

Goldenbear · 06/01/2023 19:51

Goodgrief82, I think you are being deliberately obtuse as it is clear that my comments are intended to be understood in the context OP finds herself in. Switching of the WiFi is not severe but following some of the advice of other PPs on how to treat him is severe. His Dad has a new baby, his step Mum shouts at him for shock horror a baby crying and punishing him by switching off the WiFi with no pre warning or attempts at negotiation in that context seems rash and franky just spiteful. I think in that context this old tripe American style, do as I say not as I do parent style is harsh and simply unnecessary.

SpaceshiptoMars · 06/01/2023 19:46

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 19:29

@GoldenCupidon

your children must be absolutely gamed obsessed and tied to their devices if you regard turning off the WiFi for an hour as severe action

Surgically attached, perhaps 😂 although not funny if they are still living with you at 50 ,and ignore your cries when you fall and break your hip. Until they finally emerge, expecting dinner on the table.

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 19:41

Sorry the above was for @Goldenbear

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 19:29

@GoldenCupidon

your children must be absolutely gamed obsessed and tied to their devices if you regard turning off the WiFi for an hour as severe action

SnowlayRoundabout · 06/01/2023 18:55

Goldenbear · 06/01/2023 17:38

SnowlayRoundabout well a) I'm not ignoring posts addressed to me b) i haven't started the thread and I'm not answerable to you or anyone. Hope that's satisfactory.

It is on overaction to shout at a 14 year old about behaving like a 14 year old on a computer game. Computer games where that have deliberately been designed the to be used in this over excited way! That's why it is better to look at the context and discuss it calmly.

I asked you directly "How is turning it off for an hour "severe action"? And where does OP ever suggest she wants to get rid of him?" - both things you suggested. After you suggested she should take her stepson out, I asked you how she could do that if the younger child was asleep. You don't have to answer, of course, but (a) I'm entitled to ask since you keep coming back to make similar points and (b) it's clearly incorrect to say that you aren't ignoring posts addressed to you.

You're quite selective in talking about OP's reaction. Shouting at her DSS didn't come out of the blue, it's in the context of his having ignored numerous perfectly reasonable requests on her part. To suggest that a 14 year old can't control his response to a computer game when asked, if necessary by turning it off and doing something else, is a massive generalisation. OP has obviously tried to discuss it calmly, it hasn't worked.

Nanny0gg · 06/01/2023 18:49

Goldenbear · 06/01/2023 16:05

If you haven't understood, I'm highlighting how ludicrous, severe action on the 14 year Old's toy is. Leave the teenager alone and just be calm and chat - don't be an arsehole and make him feel unwelcome as you want rid.

The consequences would be the same for everyone in my house.

Nanny0gg · 06/01/2023 18:47

Goldenbear · 06/01/2023 17:20

I think treating my DC respectfully has paid off actually so yes, it is a good to be as laid back as you can as a parent. You are going to be in for a rocky ride in the teenage years if you think you can just tell them to do as they are told, you do realise biologically they are not supposed to do that.

Well, in my case we've all survived and we have a pretty good relationship now they're married with their own families

GoldenCupidon · 06/01/2023 18:43

Blimey, asking people not to shout out in the house (for any reason!) is not controlling.

He can go outside and shout with his friends to his little heart's content.

Cherrydropsandchocolatemice · 06/01/2023 18:34

*If there wasn't a baby, some teens live with a grandparent who might need an afternoon nap, or a family member who's ill. It's called family life. No one is entitled to live a life where they don't have to be considerate of anyone else's needs. It's hardly unreasonable to expect a teenager to keep the noise down for ONE HOUR a day.

Yes, he probably has poor impulse control when he's in the moment. That's why OP needs to help him by removing the temptation (turning off the wifi during that hour).*

Yes that's true I suppose. I have to tell my teen to pipe down when he's playing, but I also realise that's it's not deliberate and he's just getting excited.

Goodgrief82 · 06/01/2023 18:21

Inastatus · 06/01/2023 17:21

@Goodgrief82 - I don’t think we need a huge back story to unpick. Just take the simple facts the OP has given. She explained that she has begged DSS on numerous occasions to keep the noise down - this implies that it’s a regular problem and there’s no mention of a bad relationship between them. It’s a fairly straightforward request to ask him to keep the noise at a reasonable level for one hour a day whilst her baby is napping regardless of any other factors.

Huge back story?

I asked some questions

not relevant to you

but… relevant to my view on the issue

ChristmasMovieMarathon · 06/01/2023 18:17

There’s no need to turn off the WiFi. Just tell him he’ll be having a break when his brother needs to sleep for an hour as you need the house to be quiet.

Goldenbear · 06/01/2023 18:17

SpaceshiptoMars it's not just the OP's home though it's the teenage son's home that due to the age gap, natural teenage behaviour as making him appear an irritation.

EverybodyAgrees you sound strict and inflexible. It is not even shouting it is speaking loudly and excitedly. Teenagers are exuberant, no thanks to beating that energy out of them! Also, shouting at them to stop shouting is what most people would refer to as hypocrisy!

SusanPerbCallMeSue · 06/01/2023 18:06

Just turn the wifi off. I've shouted at my own teenagers for making noise and disturbing me (no babies involved) and I've turned the wifi off when I've wanted them to tidy their rooms etc.

They don't seem to hate me for these things.

I don't treat them any differently to how I treated my stepchildren as teens (except there was no wifi back then. oh god, I'm so old, and that was only back in the early 2000s!)

EverybodyAgrees · 06/01/2023 18:01

I don't let my kids shout while gaming and we have no babies in the house. From the very beginning, if they shout it goes off and that's it. They learn not to shout. It's really not an inevitable or uncontrollable thing. I do it because I can't bear shouting and teaching empathy and consideration for others is really important. Teenagers are hard wired to be self absorbed but they aren't incapable, they really aren't. I would never tolerate this - a condition of having a console is using it responsibly. (Obviously it would be different with a ND teen but similarly, i have a medical condition that makes noise extremely painful). Turn off the WiFi and he will learn.

SillySausage81 · 06/01/2023 17:54

The problem here is that you've had a second familymassive age gap. So the teenager can't behave normally and it having to tiptoe around the baby in the school holidays.
He's not really doing anyone wrong he's just being excitable playing with his friends. Your baby will do the same.

If there wasn't a baby, some teens live with a grandparent who might need an afternoon nap, or a family member who's ill. It's called family life. No one is entitled to live a life where they don't have to be considerate of anyone else's needs. It's hardly unreasonable to expect a teenager to keep the noise down for ONE HOUR a day.

Yes, he probably has poor impulse control when he's in the moment. That's why OP needs to help him by removing the temptation (turning off the wifi during that hour).

SpaceshiptoMars · 06/01/2023 17:40

'Oh but it's his home. You have to let him do whatever he wants, whenever he wants....'

No you don't. He hasn't shelled out top dollar for a serviced villa with half a dozen personal servants on call at all times. He's in your home, and there's three other people with needs to consider. He fits in around you, and acts like a civilised individual.

Bananallamarama · 06/01/2023 17:39

I have 3 step DC who live with us FT, teenagers aged 16-19, and honestly I get it.

They can be so loud and inconsiderate.

But that’s because their brains aren’t fully developed yet. They’re self absorbed but they don’t get how annoying that is to people around them. I find it helps to remind myself of that before talking to them.

I also think it’s okay for them to see that actions have consequences, so occasionally losing your rag doesn’t make you a terrible step parent 🤷‍♀️ but on the few occasions when I’ve lost my shit I have apologised to them for that. I’d apologise for the reaction in your case too but also explain that you have asked a number of times for an hour of quiet (which really isn’t an unreasonable request) and say that there are no more chances now and if it happens again the wifi will be turned off 🤷‍♀️

Goldenbear · 06/01/2023 17:38

SnowlayRoundabout well a) I'm not ignoring posts addressed to me b) i haven't started the thread and I'm not answerable to you or anyone. Hope that's satisfactory.

It is on overaction to shout at a 14 year old about behaving like a 14 year old on a computer game. Computer games where that have deliberately been designed the to be used in this over excited way! That's why it is better to look at the context and discuss it calmly.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 06/01/2023 17:38

Goldenbear · 06/01/2023 17:13

I don't really believe in punitive parental techniques. You are really showing your naivety and lack of experience in being a parent of teenagers with that comment. I communicate with my nearly 16 year old and guide him to make good choices but recognise like me he is human and not perfect. Why would expect perfection from him if I'm not perfect. He is in top groups for everything, the most common compliment I receive on both my DC are how kind they are, he has loads of friends because he is just a well balanced kid.

I would say that turning off the Wi-Fi for an hour while the baby sleeps isn’t punitive - it is natural consequences, @Goldenbear. And it really is not going to damage him to be without his console for an hour, or to have to learn a bit of consideration for other people.

It sounds as if @BABYASLEEP has tried and tried to get him to keep the noise down while the baby naps, but it hasn’t worked, so she needs to try something else.

HaloInHell · 06/01/2023 17:31

Kids can get a bit carried away when gaming, he probably just forgets. My son is much older and is a really good lad but he can still get loud when he’s gaming with friends.

When you know it’s nap time, I’d get the older one to have a break from gaming for an hour, he should be having breaks anyway. Get him to make some lunch, send him to the shop for some chocolate or something.