Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried DD 8 is growing breasts?

114 replies

Scandimama · 06/01/2023 13:51

They say anything after 8 is now considered within normal range for puberty to start.
but when DD, who just turned 8, showed me last night that she’s growing breast buds (just started within last weeks apparently) I felt very freaked out. Just think it’s too early? She also has had colorless discharge for a while and her upper lip had got more hairy. I’m really worried she’ll start periods soon and worried she’ll feel uncomfortable developing so soon. She’s still quite childish and into My little pony and dolls. I just think she should be allowed to be a child for longer without having to worry about becoming a little woman. I didn’t have my period until 15 and breast by 13, so think I’m also just really surprised she’s developing my so much sooner.

OP posts:
marrymeadam · 06/01/2023 15:37

You can buy little padded crop tops/bras. I was very against padding because I saw it as accentuating their breasts but they smooth their outline and helps their embarrassment of seeing their nipples

xogossipgirlxo · 06/01/2023 15:28

Hmm don't remember when I started having breast buds, but definitely earlier than period. My first period was when I was 15, and I had breasts the size they're now when I was 13 and they grew like this within less than a year. Breast buds earlier than this, maybe 10? I wouldn't be too concerned TBH.

FeedMeSantiago · 06/01/2023 15:25

I had breast buds at 9, my period started when I was 13 and a half. Her periods could be imminent or they could still be several years away.

One of my school friends started her period at 8 and this was a good 25 years ago. She still played with toys etc. like the other girls in our class. Try not to worry, there's a large range of time in which it is normal for puberty to start.

My mum panicked a bit with me at 9 and hurriedly got me pads etc and told me what to expect. I was no where near as bothered as she was. Just reassure your DD, educate her on puberty and be there for her when her periods do eventually start.

PomPomChatton · 06/01/2023 15:24

I started my periods at 8, so I feel like I can empathise with my DD9, who is also going through it. I think they just need lots of kindness as it is confusing for them. We talk about it as much/as little as she wants to. And tried to be excited for her that is reflected in her attitude. Honestly, the mood swings are the hardest part as she doesn't know why she wants to cry 'for no reason'.

Scandimama · 06/01/2023 15:23

@MrsRandom123 thank you! This thread is helping me see that the range is quite wide and think of ways to causally talk to DD about her body changing. The good thing is she feels confident and close enough w me that she came to me herself and told me about her breasts growing so that’s a good sign I think

OP posts:
Sunrisemouse · 06/01/2023 15:22

My daughter turns 9 next week and she started her periods last July. Thankfully quite light at the moment and is handling it really well. School have been helpful.

MrsRandom123 · 06/01/2023 15:19

theres a big range of “normal”

my oldest was 9 when i noticed the start of breast buds but was another 18 months or so before they resembled any sort of breasts and needed a first bra. She was 11 (& 7 months) when she started her period but had noticeable discharge from 8/9 development pretty similar to mine. She’s now nearly 13 & a size 6/8 and her hips have widened and her bum has grown too as well as the breasts - about half at high school are similar & the other half are tiny & haven’t developed much yet but my daughter is similar to how i was at school and alrhough she felt self conscious at primary at secondary it’s more diverse.

my other daughter almost 9 & very tall with skinny legs, straight up & down, no sign of breast buds but has recently started with the discharge so will see how next 18 months go but it wouldn’t surprise me if she’s the age of my daughter & no boobs / periods as they all develop differently but it takes years from 1st sign & lots of her friends started their period at 10/11 its actually quite common & she wasn’t the first in her class.

physically growing up in now way changes emotional maturity / likes and dislikes and its important you are aware that your feelings & actions will influence how your daughter deals with all the changes that will come as she grows and develops

Scandimama · 06/01/2023 15:15

@GentlyBen thank you for your kind and non-judgmental advice.

OP posts:
FatGirlSwim · 06/01/2023 15:14

There’s nothing wrong with your posts, op, people have misinterpreted you. My dd isn’t self conscious nor is she the only one in the class. She’s quite excited about being like her older sisters! We have the Usborne books about puberty.

FatGirlSwim · 06/01/2023 15:09

my dd too, same age. I’m not concerned. It’s a long and individual process and she won’t be the only one. I have an older dd who started periods at primary school and it was fine, and another who developed later. I wouldn’t want to take my dd to gp as I wouldn’t want her to feel self conscious about it and the only reason for hormone treatment would be future height… she is tall so I wouldn’t be concerned about that.

fwiw, for the older two it was around two to three years after breast buds that periods started.

Glitterblue · 06/01/2023 15:09

DD started with breast buds towards the end of ths summer holidays after year 5 so she was 10.5. I'd had to start her on deodorant at the easter of that year. She's now almost 13 and still no sign of starting her periods yet.

OP - Next crop tops are great as they're thicker material than places like Asda so cover up well. I got DD a pack of 3 white ones and a pack with a white, a grey and a black.

Imabitbusyatthemoment · 06/01/2023 15:05

My daughter developed breast buds at the age of seven. I was so worried that this would mean early puberty. It was also so unexpected as she was small and I didn’t start growing breasts until about 11. The paediatrician was completely unconcerned.
However, after a short time they disappeared again. Reading up on it I learned that they can have a surge of hormones at this age that can cause breast buds to appear.
Dd is now 11 and they have finally returned but not before we have had tears because she was the only one (according to DD!) in her class without breast growth and crop tops!

Sartre · 06/01/2023 15:05

They usually start within two years after breast buds appear so it isn’t instant, she might be ten before she starts which is totally usual. My DD developed buds at 9 I’d say, she’s 11.5 now in year 7 and still no period.

GentlyBen · 06/01/2023 15:02

Scandimama · 06/01/2023 14:54

@gently I’m not expecting her to be am
adult, when did I say that? If it isn’t clear, I’m looking for advice and experience sharing on how to handle someone developing on the early side because I don’t have that experience myself. Im
not saying it’s something to be ashamed of and I certainly don’t send those signals to her either. I treat it as if it’s normal, but in this forum im
openly Sharing my feelings in order to get advice and process. It’s not helpful to be shamed for my feelings.

I didn’t shame you at all. You said she’s a “little woman” and that you think her “hormones” will mean she won’t play with toys anymore. Feel free though, carry on. Make your DD feel like a freak when there’s nothing wrong with her because you can’t get over your own issues. You asked for advice, you got it but you don’t like it. The doctor has already told you that it’s normal and she’s fine but you’re planning to go back because you’ve convinced yourself there’s something wrong with her. There’s not. She’s a child that’s going through puberty - she’s a child.

Scandimama · 06/01/2023 15:01

@SchnauzerEyebrows we live in Denmark, they do that here

OP posts:
Scandimama · 06/01/2023 15:00

@Regularsizedrudy I’m confused while several posters in here seem to have understood my posts as me saying I’m expecting my DD to stop being a child? When and where did I say that? I’m worried about how SHE will handle being (so far) the only girl on her class growing breast buds and herself having noticed this and commented on it. So far I’ve hugged her and kissed her and told her she’s fine and normal but she still feels self conscious. So I’m looking for advice how to best support her AS WELL as trying to clearly understand IF there anything to worry about from a development perspective if if this is just “normal but in early side”.

OP posts:
SchnauzerEyebrows · 06/01/2023 14:59

Scandimama · 06/01/2023 14:22

Yeah she doesn’t want to shower in PE

Shower in PE? What? I have a DD who is 8 in 2 weeks and they most certainly do not shower nor do they have any showers in the building! Except for in the disabled changing

Regularsizedrudy · 06/01/2023 14:55

She’ll still be a child ffs

Scandimama · 06/01/2023 14:54

@gently I’m not expecting her to be am
adult, when did I say that? If it isn’t clear, I’m looking for advice and experience sharing on how to handle someone developing on the early side because I don’t have that experience myself. Im
not saying it’s something to be ashamed of and I certainly don’t send those signals to her either. I treat it as if it’s normal, but in this forum im
openly Sharing my feelings in order to get advice and process. It’s not helpful to be shamed for my feelings.

OP posts:
Natsku · 06/01/2023 14:51

It can still be a couple or more years from breast buds until periods so that would still put her in the early side of normal (starting around 10 years old). DD developed breast buds at 9 but didn't start her period until 11 and a half.

Have you talked to her much about puberty yet? If not then start talking, no need for a big talk just little chats now and then. I always ended up talking to DD about puberty when we were in the sauna at that age as the conversation always seemed to naturally spring up then. Get her a book that explains what to expect too, I gave DD the usborne book about girls and growing up (can't remember the title now but I read it through first and it was pretty alright)

Scandimama · 06/01/2023 14:50

But all of this confuses me - some of you say 8 is perfectly normal for breast buds and others say it’s too early? Confused
considering taking her for a check up w Gp but also don’t want to make her feel something wrong w her or anything to worry about if there isn’t

OP posts:
Scandimama · 06/01/2023 14:48

@rainydaysandcake thank you! Will carefully prepare her, she already knows all about periods as I’ve always been open to her about my periods and explained what they are, so I guess if she were to start soon she’d know what it is but she may be surprised she’d be getting it already as I guess I’ve kind of painted a picture she’d be getting it far in the future as that’s what (silly me I know realise) was assuming, as early development just wasn’t on my radar at all. So maybe I do need to monitor closely at least but don’t want to spook her either by suggesting she may get periods soon if they could be years off..but maybe get her a book on how the body develops?

OP posts:
GelPens1 · 06/01/2023 14:45

8 years old is very young, especially one who has only just turned 8. I’m guessing she’s in Year 3? I developed breast buds in Y5 and started my period in Y6 (period started a couple of months after the discharge began). Proper breasts in Y7. I was at the lower end of healthy weight (still am). Most of my friends started in Y8 and Y9.

GentlyBen · 06/01/2023 14:44

Scandimama · 06/01/2023 14:26

@Chickenly I’m trying to help her and understand how this may affect her. As I’ve explained I was the total opposite, very late developed (even was taken to GP for assessment due to not having period yet by 15, had it just before turning 16) so my own experience was having the body of a child until pretty much 14. So to me breast and periods are associated w being a teenager which is why I’m looking for advice from people who may themselves have developed early or have kids who have, and how best to support your child when the child themselves feel uncomfortable as my DD has expressed she’s shy because “no one else in my clas has boobies”

Gently, your attitude towards this is going to do a lot more harm that good. Treat it how you would if it were something that you didn’t (incorrectly) equate to being an adult. If she, for example, were conscious about freckles that had come up then you wouldn’t be questioning whether she’s still going to want to play with toys - treat these things how you’d treat that. If she had nose bleeds every month then you wouldn’t think she’s an adult now - you’d just put tissues in her school bag. She’ll pick up on your attitude that it’s something to be ashamed of (it sounds like she already has) and it’ll destroy her confidence and her self-esteem. She’s nothing to be ashamed of and it’s not even that unusual either. Just breathe and relax - she’s exactly the same child she was before and she has just as much childhood whether her periods start at 8 or 15 (unless adults around her insist on expecting her to be an adult sooner just because her uterus is shedding it’s lining).