Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have expected subject specialists at secondary school

140 replies

notsallyrooney · 06/01/2023 11:55

My children (Y7 and Y9) have the same teacher - one for science, one for geography. The teacher is an English teacher.

They seem to be a great teacher, have behaviour under control and both my kids are really happy with this set up. But is it weird/worrying that they aren't a subject specialist (or, indeed, teaching just one subject so able to focus on that)? Or is this just how it is now with (state, comprehensive) secondary schools?

The school have a number of vacancies they are clearly struggling to fill, so I assume they have had to be creative with staffing and totally appreciate that it's all a bit of a nightmare in the education sector at the moment. Just wondered how normal this is and whether we should be worried?

OP posts:
Yuja · 06/01/2023 12:34

You are right to be worried but it is very common. Why would graduates of science and maths etc go into teaching when graduate salaries are so much higher elsewhere?

NewYearNora · 06/01/2023 12:32

I work in one of the most oversubscribed, state schools in the whole of my large city. You'd think it would be a dream to teach there, high achieving, generally well behaved children from middle class, engaged families.
We can't appoint either, for all sorts of subjects but especially sciences - and often end up advertising for unqualified recent graduates who would like to try out life in the classroom before committing to a PGCE.

ILoveeCakes · 06/01/2023 12:32

Might as well stay home and read a textbook. Any half way intelligent kid would get through it in a fraction of the time they do in school and have time for worthwhile developmental pursuits.

Whycanineverever · 06/01/2023 12:29

I think my daughters school prioritise GCSE years. So my daughter is Y7 had a sub for Spanish. Her Spanish teacher was in but because she is experienced she was used to cover the older class rather than put a sub in there.

loopyb · 06/01/2023 12:25

Chickenly · 06/01/2023 12:08

To add some context. I was a science teacher. In my PGCE cohort, there were 76 of us training to become teachers. 34 we’re doing an SKE, which means they didn’t have a degree in science. Only 36 passed and were awarded QTS. Only four are still teaching. Four. I left and within three years, I was on a six figure salary and I’m not relentlessly abused. We have no teachers.

Second this! I was a science teacher but could get paid far more working in the science industry with better work-life balance so I left!

If schools want to retain experts they need to pay accordingly, improve work life balance and actually implement effective behaviour policies. Unfortunately behaviour is such an issue in some schools having a subject expert is frankly a waste of time.

3WildOnes · 06/01/2023 12:24

twistyizzy · 06/01/2023 12:06

It hasn't happened in our independent school. All subject teachers have MSc/MA in that subject as a minimum (there are several with PhDs) as well as their teaching quals.

Same. I wouldn't be happy paying for an English grad to teach Maths.

Phos · 06/01/2023 12:24

In lower school it's fine.

I used to teach MFL. I was allowed to teach French and German to A-level because I had a degree in those but I was allowed to teach Spanish to GCSE with just an A-level in it and I had a colleague with only GCSE Spanish who taught it to Y7 and 8.

It would be nicer to have specialists but especially in a comprehensive, I imagine this isn't uncommon.

I'd have a problem with A-levels being taught by non specialists.

twistyizzy · 06/01/2023 12:20

Nimbostratus100 · 06/01/2023 12:15

Independent schools are better at hiding this sort of thing from parents, but some of the stories I have heard recently are alarming to say the least, certainly they break the guidance on ratios, which would never happen in a state school. We send children home if we cant keep up a certain adult to child ratio

I'm not saying it doesn't happen but maybe more in the indys who are struggling? Certainly class sizes are never more than 18 for Yrs 7-9 and 16 for Yrs 10 + 11.

notsallyrooney · 06/01/2023 12:20

katepilar · 06/01/2023 12:14

And to be honest, as a student I always appreciated a good teacher. Surely Y7-Y9 science or geography isnt rocket science and I would certainly prefer a good teacher with common knowledge of science/geography to a good scientist who cant teach.

Think you're right - I was at a questionable school and my specialist science teachers had absolutely zero control of the behaviour in the class, so it made no difference what their degree was in!

OP posts:
LovelyDayInnit · 06/01/2023 12:19

How good they are as a teacher matters more than their subject specialism. My A-Level chemistry teacher had a degree in earth sciences and had got a D at A Level Chemistry but he was a pretty good teacher and I got 100% in most of my chemistry papers. Similarly, my biology teacher only had a GCSE in biology but taught A-Level. She was one of the best teachers I ever had and I still remember some of her lessons now! I don't think this is a new thing in state schools - certainly it was part of my experience over 20 years ago.

notsallyrooney · 06/01/2023 12:17

pinkflop · 06/01/2023 12:09

My son is in Year 11 and doing GCSE Food Prep and BTEC Construction. He's not had a consistent, qualified teacher for either subject since September. He currently has random supply teachers. At this stage he might just about pass the BTEC. I know the school are doing everything to recruit a teacher but have failed so far. I'm at a loss as to what we can do about it.

Really sorry to read this, I feel so sad for this generation of kids who are being failed - especially when they have missed out on so much due to Covid. I hope your son gets what he needs to move onto the next step!

OP posts:
Mischance · 06/01/2023 12:16

This is how it is - it shouldn't be, but it is.

And then there is the nonsense of "specialist" academies. One local school set itself up as a "Modern Languages Academy" and is unable to offer A-level German due to not having suitably qualified teachers. Hmm .....

Nimbostratus100 · 06/01/2023 12:15

twistyizzy · 06/01/2023 12:06

It hasn't happened in our independent school. All subject teachers have MSc/MA in that subject as a minimum (there are several with PhDs) as well as their teaching quals.

Independent schools are better at hiding this sort of thing from parents, but some of the stories I have heard recently are alarming to say the least, certainly they break the guidance on ratios, which would never happen in a state school. We send children home if we cant keep up a certain adult to child ratio

AmeliaEarhart · 06/01/2023 12:15

I was taught GCSE physics by a teacher who had a degree in RE and would cheerfully admit he barely understood what he was teaching us! And that was in the mid-1990s.

notsallyrooney · 06/01/2023 12:14

Nimbostratus100 · 06/01/2023 12:08

For your year 9 child:

Find out what exam boards the school uses for each subject, download the specification. Buy the exam board specific text books for each subject , or as many as you can afford. Ideally, these should have questions to practice, and answers to check. Get your child to be looking up the work covered on the specification, and noting any strengths and gaps, and using the text books to reinforce what is covered, and fill any gaps.

This is good for any child, but particularly KS4 children in schools with staffing problems ( more than half of UK schools have vacancies they cant fill at any given moment)

For your year 7 child, just encourage all work set to be done well

Having an involved parent taking an interest is actually, statistically, more important than the teacher, you may be surprised to hear, so your children clearly have that advantage

Thanks so much for this - I muddled through an A level in Psychology by similar means (some time ago) so will definitely have a closer look at the specifications with my Y9.

I can't afford private education, probably can't afford tutoring (certainly not extensive tutoring) - but I CAN definitely be an involved parent taking an interest so that's really nice to hear!

OP posts:
katepilar · 06/01/2023 12:14

And to be honest, as a student I always appreciated a good teacher. Surely Y7-Y9 science or geography isnt rocket science and I would certainly prefer a good teacher with common knowledge of science/geography to a good scientist who cant teach.

L1ttledrummergirl · 06/01/2023 12:13

My dd is yr 13 so sitting her a levels this year.
My first question when she gets home is how was your day?
My second, did you have a teacher in all your lessons today?
One of her teachers (new to the school) is teaching themselves the A level subject at the same time as they've never taught it v
before.

The school are doing the best they can with limited resources.

katepilar · 06/01/2023 12:11

Perhaps the teacher is specialised in other subjects other than English but hasnt been teaching it recently?

EarringsandLipstick · 06/01/2023 12:11

God I'm amazed at this.

I'm in Ireland, very significant staff retention issues too, especially with cost-of-living increases.

However, it's really uncommon - actually I haven't heard it at all, not a teacher but work at a university that offers teaching degrees - to have teachers with no subject qualification in their primary degree teaching a subject. It's far more common for someone with only say, first year university Maths to be landed with a Maths class in senior cycle (ages 16 - 18) which is never great.

There is also a tendency to land teachers with the 'extra' subjects like SPHE / Religion without them having any core knowledge.

So maybe not wildly different to OP's scenario now I come to think of it!

notsallyrooney · 06/01/2023 12:09

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 06/01/2023 12:05

Very common but at KS3 not necessarily a disaster provided they are good teachers, do their prep and follow the schemes of work set by the head of dept. More of an issue at GCSE / A level but again, depending on the subjects and the individual concerned, it doesn't have to be awful. I can and have taught three subjects up to A level, related but not the same. I'm a good classroom teacher, know how kids learn and take the time to learn what each syllabus, exam paper etc requires. Schools cannot magic people up out of the air. Having said that, I would refuse to do maths, science or languags as I would be totally out of my depth. Humanities, English, Politics etc I could do.

Thank you, this is reassuring! Their teacher seems great and I don't have huge concerns, but I wondered how common this is or how important subject knowledge necessarily is..

OP posts:
pinkflop · 06/01/2023 12:09

My son is in Year 11 and doing GCSE Food Prep and BTEC Construction. He's not had a consistent, qualified teacher for either subject since September. He currently has random supply teachers. At this stage he might just about pass the BTEC. I know the school are doing everything to recruit a teacher but have failed so far. I'm at a loss as to what we can do about it.

littlemousebigcheese · 06/01/2023 12:09

I had to teach geography, history and religious education and my specialism was in none of those!

Chickenly · 06/01/2023 12:08

To add some context. I was a science teacher. In my PGCE cohort, there were 76 of us training to become teachers. 34 we’re doing an SKE, which means they didn’t have a degree in science. Only 36 passed and were awarded QTS. Only four are still teaching. Four. I left and within three years, I was on a six figure salary and I’m not relentlessly abused. We have no teachers.

Nimbostratus100 · 06/01/2023 12:08

notsallyrooney · 06/01/2023 12:02

& then I guess my next question is - aside from supporting teachers strikes (100%) - as a parent, what can I actually do?!

For your year 9 child:

Find out what exam boards the school uses for each subject, download the specification. Buy the exam board specific text books for each subject , or as many as you can afford. Ideally, these should have questions to practice, and answers to check. Get your child to be looking up the work covered on the specification, and noting any strengths and gaps, and using the text books to reinforce what is covered, and fill any gaps.

This is good for any child, but particularly KS4 children in schools with staffing problems ( more than half of UK schools have vacancies they cant fill at any given moment)

For your year 7 child, just encourage all work set to be done well

Having an involved parent taking an interest is actually, statistically, more important than the teacher, you may be surprised to hear, so your children clearly have that advantage

notsallyrooney · 06/01/2023 12:08

twistyizzy · 06/01/2023 12:04

Vote for a party that values education ie NOT conservative/move into the private sector as we have done for DD/pay for private subject tutors if your child shows a natural ability or interest in a particular subject.

I did that in the last election but it doesn't seem to have worked ;)

OP posts: