Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset about my mum’s attitude to the NHS?

321 replies

Beautifulblues · 06/01/2023 11:39

She’s turning 64 this year and so has benefited from the NHS all of her life.

She came from a fairly poor background, council house, working class, she had to leave school at 16 to get a job as they needed to contribute to the household. She shared a bedroom with her siblings until she was 14, very little in the way of luxuries.

Despite all of that she’s now a staunch conservative and she has said several times recently that she believes the NHS is no longer fit for purpose and we should be looking towards a health insurance system like other countries (she referenced France here but I have no idea of their healthcare system). I’m feeling very angry about it…she’s benefitted this long but doesn’t want me or her 4 year old grandson to benefit from the wonderful NHS as he gets older.

OP posts:
Bard6817 · 06/01/2023 14:00

Beautifulblues · 06/01/2023 11:39

She’s turning 64 this year and so has benefited from the NHS all of her life.

She came from a fairly poor background, council house, working class, she had to leave school at 16 to get a job as they needed to contribute to the household. She shared a bedroom with her siblings until she was 14, very little in the way of luxuries.

Despite all of that she’s now a staunch conservative and she has said several times recently that she believes the NHS is no longer fit for purpose and we should be looking towards a health insurance system like other countries (she referenced France here but I have no idea of their healthcare system). I’m feeling very angry about it…she’s benefitted this long but doesn’t want me or her 4 year old grandson to benefit from the wonderful NHS as he gets older.

Sounds like she has her head screwed on more than you.

Those of us who have seen the nhs and all it’s flaws know that it’s dying. It’s not the people, it’s the structure. Too many 6 digit salaries and not enough medical staff.

The france system is competative, the customer has choice. People go where the get service. Poor services don’t survive.

Alexandra2001 · 06/01/2023 13:59

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/01/2023 13:55

Everyone I know who works, or has worked for the NHS, in many different capacities from consultant to admin, has said there is a shocking amount of waste, and too many managers.
The trouble is, the NHS is such a sacred cow, no govt.of whatever colour has ever dared to tackle it properly, root and branch.

Might dd that I do think we need to start charging small amounts at the point of use. Other countries whose health services are often praised as so much better than ours, do this. For starters Sweden - popularly supposed to be a socialist Utopia - does.

My DD currently works in the NHS, as did my Mum, neither said that.
The NHS consistently scores well on efficiency, i don't know how anyone thinks a system where you pay up front but then claim back is somehow going to be more efficient?

I do agree on charging though & and on paying for missed appointments (with the usually exemptions)

Yes Sweden does, it doesn't put people off, i lived there.

RavenclawsPrincess · 06/01/2023 13:58

Phos · 06/01/2023 11:44

YABU. She's entitled to an opinion whether you agree with it or not.

This.

You are free to not like her opinion, but it feels a bit unreasonable to take it so personally.

orbitalcrisis · 06/01/2023 13:58

We used to have the most efficient healthcare system in the world, the problem is the government defunding and privatising parts of it all the time.

MarshaBradyo · 06/01/2023 13:58

GPTec1 · 06/01/2023 13:43

No they have not, if by real terms you mean accounting for inflation and demand/ageing population.

In simple cash terms yes.

Real terms will take into account inflation.

Notonthestairs · 06/01/2023 13:57

"We are short staffed because it's more lucrative to work for an agency, rather than work for the nationally set NHS pay bands."

The answer is bettering current terms and conditions rather then spending £3 billion per annum on agency staff - crucially we'd be more likely to retain existing experienced staff and recruit new ones. We went in to the pandemic with 42,000 nursing vacancies and now have 47,000.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/01/2023 13:55

Everyone I know who works, or has worked for the NHS, in many different capacities from consultant to admin, has said there is a shocking amount of waste, and too many managers.
The trouble is, the NHS is such a sacred cow, no govt.of whatever colour has ever dared to tackle it properly, root and branch.

Might dd that I do think we need to start charging small amounts at the point of use. Other countries whose health services are often praised as so much better than ours, do this. For starters Sweden - popularly supposed to be a socialist Utopia - does.

Mybonnielad · 06/01/2023 13:50

someonemakeitstop · 06/01/2023 13:27

I've just been reading about the French healthcare system and it honestly sounds really sensible to me. It's also consistently rated as one of the best in the world.

From what I can gather, 70% of healthcare costs are covered by the Government with the remaining 30% being paid for by citizens/residents. You can choose to purchase a monthly health insurance policy for about £30 to cover the 30% difference. Anyone who has chronic illnesses/unemployed etc is fully 100% covered by the government.

I might not have got all the details right but to me this sounds like a sensible way of managing the needs of a growing population. As everyone is fond of saying, the NHS was created at a time when it was impossible to predict what healthcare could look like today.

I am fully in support of the concept of the NHS and believe medicine should not be 'big business' like it is in the US but at the same time, the world has changed massively and I think the NHS model is creaking because it hasn't adapted with the times. If the structure is broken, all the good will and great people in the world, will still struggle to turn it around.

From what I can see in the French healthcare system, if you have an insurance policy to offset your 30% contribution, you pay a small amount each time you access medical services, so a trip to A&E might cost you £25. To me, this would be a great way of helping people to decide if it really was an emergency or not. You'd pay £25 in a split second for a heart attack but you'd probably think twice before going with a bad cold or an ingrown toenail.

I 100% believe in majority state-funded healthcare but if the current system isn't coping, suspect we need to look at the underlying structure.

I agree with this. DH and I lived in a small French village, population less than 2000, and there were 5 doctors surgeries. (Just the one doctor at each one). Most people stuck with the same doctor's surgery that had treated their parents and grandparents.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 06/01/2023 13:50

PuggyMum · 06/01/2023 12:01

@WiseUpJanetWeiss it was a few years ago now to be fair but I don't doubt there's plenty of improvements to be made.

I used to work for a company where if you had a money saving idea you could present to the management and if they liked it and adopted it you could get involved with implementing and then they'd give you the savings for the first year as a bonus!

It's been like that in every department I've worked in - without the bonus of course!

Gingernaut · 06/01/2023 13:46

We are short staffed because it's more lucrative to work for an agency, rather than work for the nationally set NHS pay bands.

If trusts were allowed to vary the pay according to need, more staff would become permanently employed.

As it stands, there are increasing numbers of patients with long term conditions who don't look after themselves and rely on a dwindling number of medical staff to look after them.

Notonthestairs · 06/01/2023 13:46

"Remember the Tories have been in power for 13 years and have not looked at an alternative health system, not once nor are they planning too, its just remove it.. slowly."

Well they certainly couldn't reform it 13 years ago - patient satisfaction was at its highest ever levels, ambulances were meeting call out targets, waiting lists were low.

13 years later and they've got people wanting to change the system. Worked out pretty well I'd say.

GPTec1 · 06/01/2023 13:43

MajorCarolDanvers · 06/01/2023 13:40

Thing is though your mum is not wrong - its not fit for purpose, it is completely broken and something is going to have to change.

Labour increased spending on the NHS by many billions when in power and that put lots of plasters on it. Even the Tories have increased spending real terms. Its not working though.

Change is needed.

No they have not, if by real terms you mean accounting for inflation and demand/ageing population.

In simple cash terms yes.

GPTec1 · 06/01/2023 13:42

I don't believe the present Govt want a privatised system, let alone the very complex French one, i mean who could afford that? plus no insurer would cover pre existing or chronic.

We'd need a completely new & huge medical insurance industry & as we have chronic labour shortages, where would the staff come from to run it, along side existing insurance industries.

What i think they want is a return to pre NHS where you died if you couldn't get treatment (as is happening and accepted by the public) and/or charity and insurance for those that could pay.

If you couldn't pay, the Government would just say you spend too much at Costa and Avocado's.

Remember the Tories have been in power for 13 years and have not looked at an alternative health system, not once nor are they planning too, its just remove it.. slowly.

MajorCarolDanvers · 06/01/2023 13:40

Thing is though your mum is not wrong - its not fit for purpose, it is completely broken and something is going to have to change.

Labour increased spending on the NHS by many billions when in power and that put lots of plasters on it. Even the Tories have increased spending real terms. Its not working though.

Change is needed.

Autumndays123 · 06/01/2023 13:39

She's not wrong though, is she? The NHS is not fit for purpose and hasn't been for decades. It may have suited the 1960s/1970s but it is not suitable for modern day. No amount of money fed into it will make it better because it is completely and utterly broken.

We absolutely need a new system. It amazes me that anyone thinks handing out more money to nurses will actually change anything - it won't.

YouJustDoYou · 06/01/2023 13:37

Crikeyalmighty · 06/01/2023 12:46

I'm not a Tory and I'm actually with your mother on this. Places like Germany and Netherlands do have a different insurance kind of scheme but it doesn't mean that lower income people don't get treatment. When you say insurance based people tend to think US type system. That is one vast money making cartel and not how these other country's work. The NHS isn't working properly because Brits aren't prepared to pay more tax and various decisions have been made over the years that mean there is insufficient local provision .

This. We're a mixed-race East Asian family and there are good subsidised healthcare in some of the countries in our neck of the woods that work far, far better than the NHS. You pay for insurance and then again for treatment, but very, very minimal costs. Quality of care is better, it's easier to get appointments, staffing levels are high....the NHS needs to desperately be reformed.

KTheGrey · 06/01/2023 13:36

I think YABU because the French insurance system puts some of the financial burden on employers - health insurance is a compulsory part of a package. It's effectively ring fenced money. Every time the government are expected to spend Inthe NHS they spend the money on something else. I find it very suspicious that the Tories could afford so much money for things that didn't work during COVID and there was so little for the NHS. And I would rather an insurance scheme than a bloody revolution.

Testina · 06/01/2023 13:36

“we should be looking towards a health insurance system like other countries (she referenced France here but I have no idea of their healthcare system).”

How can you be upset by your mum’s views when you don’t even understand what she’s proposing?

I work in a European role for a French company, my colleagues are from all over Europe. None of them is envious of our NHS. They’ve grown up with a system that works and they’re happy with what they pay for it. Sure, on an individual level, free is good! But they do not see the NHS as “the envy of the world”.

Do you even know what the population has been in the period of your mum’s life? Or the demographics? Or the extension of life expectancy? The scope of the NHS on its creation is vastly different to what it has to deliver now.

You can research all that and still have a different opinion than your mum of course - but I don’t think you’ve any business being “upset” with her when you’re ill informed

MerlinsButler · 06/01/2023 13:36

Beautifulblues · 06/01/2023 12:07

Just to add her default reasoning for the NHS being in such a state is the increase un immigration, which in turn has increased the general population…

AIBU - most people - yes. Ok well she's racist as well. Way to drip feed OP as this thread isn't going your way.

JangolinaPitt · 06/01/2023 13:35

ILoveeCakes · 06/01/2023 11:42

The NHS is a greedy mess. They have spent years cutting beds while sucking in more and more money - and pocketing it themselves, spending it on non-jobs and lovely days out on "training courses".

They need calling out and a good shake up - not worship and all the treading on eggshells that goes on around them.

This /appalling stories on here recently about how people are (not ) treated in hospital and by GPS.

Notonthestairs · 06/01/2023 13:35

Average health spend per person in EU14 (EU members prior to 2004) between 2010-2019 - £ 3655.

Average spend in UK was £3055.

Spending did not keep pace with demand.

Demand is greater because of ageing population, Covid and multiple failures in social care.

twitter.com/bbcrosatkins/status/1611260116069744641?s=46&t=KpCsguMUmTdsITtakeXJMw

You can't underfund a service for a decade (and resist long term workforce planning) and then complain the service doesn't function as you'd like it to.

If changes are needed that needs to be part of a national discussion.

In the meantime I'd like the Government to resolve existing issues so people can know an ambulance is coming, that A&E will not be a war zone and patients can be discharged in a timely fashion.

MarshaBradyo · 06/01/2023 13:33

rwalker · 06/01/2023 13:10

Somebody hit the nail on the head the other day
OP mums right the NHS hasn’t evolved enough to keep up with what’s expected
people live longer
complex expensive treatments
years ago some people wouldn’t of made it out of childhood now with medical advances the live long life but need lifelong medical care
the problem is it needs dismantling and starting again
tories won’t do it as labour would crucifie them
labour won’t do it as the unions and public would turn against them

we seem to be stuck in an endless loop of political bitching and back biting between the parties

and on top of that the general population are one of the unhealthiest and fastest in Europe
wi there a big mindset of an individual’s health isn’t there personal responsibility it the governments

I agree with you

Although not sure who people think should be paying more when they say reform. Not you but just generally.

TheDietStartsTomorrowOrMaybeTheDayAfter · 06/01/2023 13:33

Just because her opinion is different to yours, it doesn’t mean she’s wrong.

Luredbyapomegranate · 06/01/2023 13:32

SlagathaChristie · 06/01/2023 11:47

Not nurses, but possibly the "Directors of Lived Experience" on £110,000pa....

@op Whatever your thoughts on the NHS are, you are entitled to them. Your mother is entitled to hers. You don't get to stamp your feet and demand that mummy agree with you all the time, she's her own person. I thought people stopped doing that after their teen years?

And how many directors of lived experience are there?

The NHS has many problems, but I don’t think siphoning of cash for mates is one of them. You may perhaps have mistaken them for the government.

Anyway OP, your mum is entitled to an opinion. Something does have to change with the NHS and you mum may see that more clearly as she remembers it in less lean times.

MerlinsButler · 06/01/2023 13:31

YABU. Saying the NHS is not fit for purpose is not saying you shouldn't benefit from free healthcare. It's saying that the whole NHS needs to be looked at.

It was never envisioned or designed to do what it now does. Absolutely there should be access to all especially for emergency care but it needs to change.

From the little I know of French healthcare I believe it is a system with elements of free care and compulsory insurance via the social system ( though happy to be corrected).

Your mum isn't saying we should switch to the US model but we do need to look at other systems and adopt the best elements of some of the European models. It cannot continue to be a bottomless pit of money thrown at it.

It needs better investment - in IT, staff training and especially doctor / nurse wages but we also need to think about what should and shouldn't be provided free.

People don't want to pay more tax but a grown up approach to remodelling the system should be taken. It doesn't need to be privatised. But maybe it's time we as individuals started contributing towards NHS care in a more meaningful way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread