Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset about my mum’s attitude to the NHS?

321 replies

Beautifulblues · 06/01/2023 11:39

She’s turning 64 this year and so has benefited from the NHS all of her life.

She came from a fairly poor background, council house, working class, she had to leave school at 16 to get a job as they needed to contribute to the household. She shared a bedroom with her siblings until she was 14, very little in the way of luxuries.

Despite all of that she’s now a staunch conservative and she has said several times recently that she believes the NHS is no longer fit for purpose and we should be looking towards a health insurance system like other countries (she referenced France here but I have no idea of their healthcare system). I’m feeling very angry about it…she’s benefitted this long but doesn’t want me or her 4 year old grandson to benefit from the wonderful NHS as he gets older.

OP posts:
WilmaFlintstone1 · 08/01/2023 17:04

ILoveeCakes · 06/01/2023 11:42

The NHS is a greedy mess. They have spent years cutting beds while sucking in more and more money - and pocketing it themselves, spending it on non-jobs and lovely days out on "training courses".

They need calling out and a good shake up - not worship and all the treading on eggshells that goes on around them.

Tell me you’ve no experience of the NHS without saying the words lol

ELOU1111 · 08/01/2023 17:00

And how will these beautiful private hospitals be staffed? We are 50,000 nurses short. More nurses will leave and less will train if the pay doesn't improve. I am a qualified nurse with 25 years experience 7 of which at a private hospital..as I'm sure many nurses reading will agree private hospitals are not the Shangri-la the public imagine. They have many problems and risks of their own.

MarshaBradyo · 08/01/2023 16:38

Private insurance is ok but NHS covers much more so you can’t just rely on it here

We have both but mostly use NHS anyway (not that it’s frequent)

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 08/01/2023 13:55

KnittedCardi · 08/01/2023 12:33

Can anyone, anywhere, show evidence that the Tories want a US system? Even if they did, who would vote for it? The commons, inc. Tory MP's, nor the Lords would pass it. It's a red herring. We need change. No-one has the balls to do it. Labour's answer still seems to be following the same trajectory as the Tories. Tinker round the edges, use the private sector more.

No-one needs to vote for it.

It is already happening by stealth. More and more people will take out private health insurance. More and more employers will provide private cover as a "perk" (but really it's in the interests of keeping their employees working and not off sick). The NHS will offer fewer and fewer services.

None of this needs votes in parliament. It's the do nothing option, and the insurance companies and the shareholders win.

Cattenberg · 08/01/2023 13:18

It’s happening by stealth, @KnittedCardi

amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/dec/07/public-nhs-the-new-health-and-care-bill-alarm-bells-privatisation

KnittedCardi · 08/01/2023 12:33

Can anyone, anywhere, show evidence that the Tories want a US system? Even if they did, who would vote for it? The commons, inc. Tory MP's, nor the Lords would pass it. It's a red herring. We need change. No-one has the balls to do it. Labour's answer still seems to be following the same trajectory as the Tories. Tinker round the edges, use the private sector more.

MissyB1 · 08/01/2023 10:48

poetryandwine · 08/01/2023 10:05

In today’s Observer, the article Crisis: Why our health system is falling apart quotes the following statistic from the OECD. France has 5.7 hospital beds per 1000 people, the average OECD member country has 5 beds, and the UK has 2.4 beds.

So our bed-blocking crisis is built on a base where we have less than half the hospital beds of the average First World country to begin with

I wish we could get this message out much louder and clearer to the general public. I want any journalist or news presenter to hammer any Tory minister they interview with this statistic and demand to know why it is!

Crikeyalmighty · 08/01/2023 10:48

@WiseUpJanetWeiss I don't disagree- having moved back from Copenhagen earlier this year it's 46% tax- (mind you no NI or council tax and very cheap childcare) -healthcare is good but they don't stand for nonsense- and certainly don't over prescribe- you can't actually find many drugs over the counter either. They are very into preventative health- mind you they still drink and smoke and eat a lot of fatty food- but they do cycle and run a lot- go figure!!

poetryandwine · 08/01/2023 10:05

In today’s Observer, the article Crisis: Why our health system is falling apart quotes the following statistic from the OECD. France has 5.7 hospital beds per 1000 people, the average OECD member country has 5 beds, and the UK has 2.4 beds.

So our bed-blocking crisis is built on a base where we have less than half the hospital beds of the average First World country to begin with

blackpearwhitelilies · 08/01/2023 00:33

MaryMcCarthy · 07/01/2023 14:29

What department of the NHS do you work in?

Where did you gain such insight?

Same place as she got her insight into academia. The VCs may hage huge wages; hardly anyone else does.

blackpearwhitelilies · 08/01/2023 00:31

Actually I really like the French system. What frightens me, though, is that the Tories are exploring options with US pharma and show no interest in the European systems at all.

Aaron95 · 08/01/2023 00:24

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 18:47

@poetryandwine PFI is a difficult one, the 2 alternatives to PFI were to build up high levels of national debt (and where would that have left us if they'd done when we needed to borrow for the financial crash and then Furlough?) OR not build, again, leaving the NHS in even more of a mess, just imagine if those hospitals build under PFI didn't exist now?

Yes after Truss and BJ, amazing the Tories score highly on the economy, though hasn't that changed recently?

PFI debt is still public debt. Technically it doesn't appear on the UK's balance sheet but it is backed by the UK government and therefore UK PLC is on the hook should the individual public institution fail.

Add to that, no organisation can borrow at lower rates than the government and it is just another way to allow private companies to skim money off the UK public sector.

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 18:47

poetryandwine · 07/01/2023 15:47

@GPTec1 I agree the obvious problem is that the Government won’t spend money on the NHS (at least, this is one of the problems). It does pander. But I think that is because it knows its supporters.

Labour have been out of power for 13 years and did much, much better on the NHS but have something big to answer for in terms of PFI. Unfortunately the Tories maximised this, even while driving the NHS into the ground. Polls still regularly show that the Tories are more trusted on the economy overall. Incredible.

@poetryandwine PFI is a difficult one, the 2 alternatives to PFI were to build up high levels of national debt (and where would that have left us if they'd done when we needed to borrow for the financial crash and then Furlough?) OR not build, again, leaving the NHS in even more of a mess, just imagine if those hospitals build under PFI didn't exist now?

Yes after Truss and BJ, amazing the Tories score highly on the economy, though hasn't that changed recently?

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 07/01/2023 16:08

Crikeyalmighty · 07/01/2023 15:57

@StrawberryShortcake01 I'm actually not remotely a Tory but I do think we need to take a good hard look at how other systems operate. France has a similar population- Germany even higher - just saying our marvellous NHS no longer stands sadly- I don't know if it's lack of money or investment, management, lack of social care, problems at GP level or the fact we have a population where very large numbers of people currently seem to be in the grips of chronic illness- but whatever it is , we've got to examine why other systems are working better without simply dismissing the idea- Britain isn't always best and we don't have to go down the US kind of system either

France and Germany spend more per capita than the UK on healthcare. The idea that we can have the French system with the current level of spending is pie in the sky.

You say we don't have to have the US system, but that's where we're heading. The Tories want it, and Labour are too scared to have a sensible conversation about alternatives.

Crikeyalmighty · 07/01/2023 15:57

@StrawberryShortcake01 I'm actually not remotely a Tory but I do think we need to take a good hard look at how other systems operate. France has a similar population- Germany even higher - just saying our marvellous NHS no longer stands sadly- I don't know if it's lack of money or investment, management, lack of social care, problems at GP level or the fact we have a population where very large numbers of people currently seem to be in the grips of chronic illness- but whatever it is , we've got to examine why other systems are working better without simply dismissing the idea- Britain isn't always best and we don't have to go down the US kind of system either

poetryandwine · 07/01/2023 15:47

@GPTec1 I agree the obvious problem is that the Government won’t spend money on the NHS (at least, this is one of the problems). It does pander. But I think that is because it knows its supporters.

Labour have been out of power for 13 years and did much, much better on the NHS but have something big to answer for in terms of PFI. Unfortunately the Tories maximised this, even while driving the NHS into the ground. Polls still regularly show that the Tories are more trusted on the economy overall. Incredible.

Curledupwithagoodbook · 07/01/2023 15:35

Butterfly44 · 06/01/2023 21:11

It's just a comment. And an uneducated one as I'm sure she doesn't know about healthcare in other countries. She's repeating something she heard/read. I would ignore tbh

I've got plenty of experience of the French healthcare system (it's fantastic) and I worked in the NHS for over 20 years. I agree with the OP's mother's view regarding the two systems. Am I also uneduated and just repeating something I've heard/read?

There's a reason outcomes are better in France...

StrawberryShortcake01 · 07/01/2023 15:00

I am French and when I describe the state of the NHS to my family, they just can’t believe it. The French system is so much better and fair, as people on low income/unemployed/ with chronic conditions get 100% free treatment.

It’s also much simpler to see a doctor, you just book an appointment with a specialist and that’s it, no need to see a GP, exaggerate the condition so you definitely get a referral (which I’ve done before, as advised by another consultant and hospital!), wait to hear from the hospital, etc.

Virtually every woman has a gynaecologist (unless you don’t want to). I love living in the UK but I would give some much to have the same healthcare as in France.

The level is care is higher but also the comfort. No hospital wards anymore in France since the 1990s (but you can get a double room, with a shared bathroom). Most rooms are private rooms with your own bathroom. And you don’t share a bathroom with 4-6 different women after giving birth, you have your own (or share with one other lady).

sst1234 · 07/01/2023 14:41

What’s wrong with she’s said? You don’t don’t actually seem to have an argument against it, just a rant about your mum.

MaryMcCarthy · 07/01/2023 14:29

ILoveeCakes · 06/01/2023 11:42

The NHS is a greedy mess. They have spent years cutting beds while sucking in more and more money - and pocketing it themselves, spending it on non-jobs and lovely days out on "training courses".

They need calling out and a good shake up - not worship and all the treading on eggshells that goes on around them.

What department of the NHS do you work in?

Where did you gain such insight?

cantba · 07/01/2023 14:28

I think people like your mum are actually old enough to compare the shitshow the nhs has become against what we used to have. I agree with your mum. I'm not aware of any other developed country with an aging population havjng an entirely free at point of use service. Additional tax won't solve the issues in the NHS.

GPTec1 · 07/01/2023 14:18

poetryandwine · 07/01/2023 13:00

@raffegiraffe This is exactly the problem. I am also happy to pay more. The data from countries with better health care and outcomes show that those who can afford to, need to. But the country does not seem to have the will to do so. Of course the extra money must be well spent and perhaps at this point there is no trust that either of the main political parties would spend it wisely

Thats not strictly true.

Its is Government that will not tax the people who can afford to pay more, indeed, its the opposite, they give them the cash the health service needs.

E.g 12m Pensioners, regardless of wealth, get a 10% pensions increase, the Nurses (& total nhs 1.1m staff) are offered 4%.

Universal energy support to millions who do not need it.

Unless retention and getting more staff in place is sorted, everything else will fail and even more needed in social care.

This is what is so disappointing with Labour & Starmer, yes they say they will increase staff but unless they pay more, they will not be able to do this or stop HCP's leaving for better paid work either in the public or private sectors.

However, you can't really criticise Labour on what they would spend monies on, they have not been in power for 13 years.

poetryandwine · 07/01/2023 13:00

@raffegiraffe This is exactly the problem. I am also happy to pay more. The data from countries with better health care and outcomes show that those who can afford to, need to. But the country does not seem to have the will to do so. Of course the extra money must be well spent and perhaps at this point there is no trust that either of the main political parties would spend it wisely

snowsilver · 07/01/2023 12:56

I am interested in the comments about the Dutch system. A modest contribution from all regardless of health or age and free for the poorest.
In a way some of that's what we already have here except that we don't see it. Everyone pays tax unless on the lowest of incomes and the tax pays for the healthcare.
I am starting to think that some kind of tax or charge might be part of the way forward. Problem is it doesn't address organisational failures and waste and it doesn't tackle one of the biggest obstacles which is social care.

raffegiraffe · 07/01/2023 12:13

And the understanding by most that for it to get better it needs more money. None of the alternatives suggested are cheaper for the country. I'm happy with that but is everybody?