Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give a cash reward to the twin who gets the best GCSE results?

342 replies

Stackss · 06/01/2023 11:33

DS and DD are both in year 11 so have their GCSEs coming up shortly. Both are bright and of very similar if not identical academic ability and are predicted very similar grades.

Both are relatively hard working (although with a tendency to coast) but DH and I would really like them to knuckle down and push themselves to get the best grades possible.

We therefore came up with the idea of an effort-based reward scheme allowing them to earn treats for completing revision- e.g. 75 hours= a meal out, 150 hours= a night away etc.

However, both twins have suggested that instead, the twin who gets the best results should receive the whole cash reward. They are both competitive with each other and have said this would give them greater incentive to work harder.

My concern is that the twin who doesn't do as well will be doubly disappointed on results day as they will also get no reward. Should I go with the twins' suggestion?

OP posts:
SocksAndTheCity · 06/01/2023 12:28

I'd love to know what the OP thinks she's going to do if they decide 'coasting' is what they're going to do and what 'not accepted' would entail 🤣

When I was that age and doing likewise it entailed me giving the whole thing an almighty fuck off and leaving school at 16.

Parrotid · 06/01/2023 12:27

I don’t know how the OP got to this stage thinking this is a good idea. Day One of being a twin parent is “treat them as individuals.” Hmmmmmm

mnchat · 06/01/2023 12:27

@Chickenly you've missed the point. They aren't on the same team . Each twin will sit their individual gcse . Ones success (or failure) has no bearing on the other's success (or failure).

If you want to compare to your firm think of it like a graduate programme assessment day. Everyone who meets the mark gets in. You are working hard individually and together on specific tasks to ensure YOU get the job.

Your example gives the impression of each twin sabotaging the other which isn't the case. You quoting me then giving your example is comparing apples and oranges.

Bythesea315 · 06/01/2023 12:27

God absolutely awful what happens if they just go to pot in an exam after putting in lots of effort or if one just happens to have studied whats in the exam and one hasn't
Reward both for trying not the results

CoQ10 · 06/01/2023 12:26

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:15

I do have to say I don't agree with the idea that any rewards for achievement are bad. In my view, GCSE grades are inherently linked to effort and hard work.

Obviously any reward should be linked to the ability of the DC. If a DC is capable of a 9, that should be what is expected and rewarded. On the other hand, if a 5 is a great achievement, they should be rewarded for that.

I agree with you OP.

I don't understand why some posters think rewarding a great achievement is a no-no. Look at Olympic runners, for example. Their reward for winning is the gold medal. That medal is won by tonnes of hard work and sacrifice and training.

Apply that to your children and you're right to reward input ie effort) and output (ie grades). I will do the same with my twins when the time comes 🙂

AreOttersJustWetCats · 06/01/2023 12:26

This reminds me of that quote from Glengarry Glen Ross ("first prize is a Cadillac El Dorado. Anyone wanna see second prize? Second prize is a set of steak knives. Third prize is you're fired.")

And just as toxic.

Parrotid · 06/01/2023 12:26

ILoveeCakes · 06/01/2023 11:39

They have the same genetics, so the one who doesn't do as well hasn't worked as hard.

Still, no need for you to punish them for laziness. The world will do that.

I’m sorry, what? What genetics? They’re no more similar than any other full siblings. This is a very daft post.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 06/01/2023 12:26

If you do give rewards in exchange for hours studied make sure that there is a cap on it. Over studying and burning out is a real danger. Also, be careful about one of them claiming they have done lots of study and being rewarded more than the other who has actually put in more effort.

3sthemagicnumber · 06/01/2023 12:25

Fellow parent of twins here (and an older DD in Y11). I can just about imagine my twins suggesting something like this. But it's obviously a terrible idea!

I think it's a bad idea in terms of their relationship. Being a teenage twin strikes me as a difficult thing from observing my own twins, and encouraging them to define themselves in relation to the other doesn't seem healthy or helpful at all.

And it's a bad idea because it doesn't address the problem of their apparent lack of intrinsic motivation. If they're bright enough to gets 8s/9s anyway, I'd be inclined to let them find their own way with this, given that they'll get a decent set of GCSE results whatever. (I say this as someone who coasted through GCSEs and A Levels on ability, and then really struggled to organise and motivate myself at university.)

Y11 DD (who is on course for very good GCSE grades) asked if we would do a per grade monetary reward. Easy 'no' from me - she works pretty hard, but she finds academics easy. If my younger DS gets a 7 in English in a couple of years, that will be far more reward-worthy than her getting a 9. I'll be happy to get her/them some sort of post-GCSE treat, but it won't reward individual grades. I know lots of people do reward grades though, but it definitely shouldn't be in comparison to each other in my view.

BadGranny · 06/01/2023 12:25

SproutsLCerVEGNoEgg · 06/01/2023 11:44

BAD IDEA!!

You need to teach them to work hard for their OWN sense of accomplishment NOT external reward.

You need to teach them to support each other, not compete with each other.

if you persist in bribing them to work, they'll never learn to be self motivated. A levels/Uni... when will you stop?!

additionally paying them for the time they 'study' ?!?! WTAF? How the hell would you even know what they were doing? I was brilliant at appearing to study, whilst actually doing other things (no tech then really, but I was great at decorating my books/generally titting about!).

This^^ absolutely.

The reward for hard work is the best results they are capable of, and they are the ones who benefit from good results.

Monetising effort or results doesn’t work, in any case. It makes kids greedy, not hardworking.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 06/01/2023 12:24

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:19

@wincarwoo

That's definitely not an option! We want to encourage the DC to try their hardest at everything they do and coasting won't be accepted.

So if they eventually find a job that makes them happy, with a good work life balance, and want to just stay doing that job rather than working all the hours on earth in order to get promoted and get ahead of everyone else, that won't be accepted by you?

Poor kids. You seem to have lost sight of what actually matters in life.

KnittingDiva · 06/01/2023 12:24

"They have the same genetics, so the one who doesn't do as well hasn't worked as hard."

If they are brother and sister twins they clearly don't have the same genetics!

They are same genetically as any full siblings.

Even identical twins don't have the same brain development (same genes do not mean same neurological function).

SeaToSki · 06/01/2023 12:24

I would tell them that I would like them to help and encourage each other to work hard and do well as they are a team and siblings should be able to rely on each other for support and help (twins or no twins).

How about at the end of every week you have a feedback session with both of them thinking about how well they worked that week, what went well and what didnt. Then they and you can make suggestions on what they could try doing differently the next week and what they should keep on doing. After the session everyone gets a treat for operating in a supportive way. After a couple of the sessions, if they are working well, suggest the idea that if they both want an incentive to help spur them on, then it should be for both of them, if both of them achieve their goals. Then get them to set themselves and each other reward goals. So twin A wants to get x grade and twin b wants to get y grades. But they both think the other twin is reaching too high and will likely get slightly lower grades. Set a reward for them to share if they both get the lower grades, and then a bonus for both if one gets the higher grades and a bigger bonus for both if they both get the higher grades.

This way you are driving supportive behaviour between then and they will hopefully both be inspired to work hard.

but you must keep up the weekly meetings and then review the incentive scheme after a few months and ask them if they think it is helping or harming their motivation. You also want to learn how they can motivate themselves going forward, its a useful life skill

redskydelight · 06/01/2023 12:23

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:19

@wincarwoo

That's definitely not an option! We want to encourage the DC to try their hardest at everything they do and coasting won't be accepted.

You want to "encourage" but coasting is "not accepted".

They sound fairly mutually exclusive.

Do you, as an adult, try your hardest in everything you do? Most adults don't.

Cherryblossoms85 · 06/01/2023 12:23

I'm a twin. Definitely don't do that.

Vinylloving · 06/01/2023 12:22

Absolutely no way. They may like the idea now, but in the thick of it would cause no end of unnecessary stress and upset. It sends an awful message too. I don't see why they should be pitted against anyone but themselves, think how they reflect on it later. Poor kids. This is their life, their education, not a race at the park - as parents you should know better

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:22

@AreOttersJustWetCats

Personally I don't believe all competition is a bad thing- it can be a great motivator for some people.

Having said that, I do think this proposal went too far and that rewards for individuals grades will provide enough of a competitive element.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 06/01/2023 12:22

Hard no.

Absolutescum · 06/01/2023 12:22

ILoveeCakes · 06/01/2023 11:39

They have the same genetics, so the one who doesn't do as well hasn't worked as hard.

Still, no need for you to punish them for laziness. The world will do that.

Absolute crap! I have twins, one is very clever academically, the other is incredibly artistic and creative. The academic one got good exam results in comparison to their sibling but the artistic one worked 1000x as hard to get their average results.
I was so proud of the one with lower grades and (privately) disappointed in the one with higher grades.

On another note, I think awarding kids more money for higher grades is absolutely disgusting and makes kids ill with worry.

KnittingDiva · 06/01/2023 12:22

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:19

@wincarwoo

That's definitely not an option! We want to encourage the DC to try their hardest at everything they do and coasting won't be accepted.

What you're actually doing is encouraging them to win the most money. As long as you realise that I suppose.

neverbeenskiing · 06/01/2023 12:21

Both ideas are terrible. Just really awful. Pitting siblings against each other for cash rewards is particularly grim though.

One of my Y11 students who came to this country as an unaccompanied Asylum seeker was talking about this sort of thing recently. He was appalled to find out that some of his friends are getting cash bribes from their parents to revise for their exams, show up to afterschool revision sessions or achieve decent grades. He sees education as a privilege and can't believe his peers are so entitled that they have to be bribed to make an effort.

redskydelight · 06/01/2023 12:21

Just because a DC is capable of getting a 9 doesn't meant that this should be expected. That just puts huge pressure on them. Maybe they should choose to focus their attention in a weaker subject and "only* get a 7. Maybe they should work at a more relaxed pace and not get super stressed. Maybe doing "well enough" actually is "good enough".

It's the huge pressure on getting amazing grades that is one of the contributors to mental health problems in teens today.

wincarwoo · 06/01/2023 12:21

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:19

@wincarwoo

That's definitely not an option! We want to encourage the DC to try their hardest at everything they do and coasting won't be accepted.

I hope you don't helicopter them all their lives.

Plant2628 · 06/01/2023 12:20

Terrible idea
Poor twin that gives it their all and gets nothing

KnittingDiva · 06/01/2023 12:20

Absolutely hate the idea of cash rewards for exam success. Know loads of people who do it here for JC and LC exams (Ireland). At some point our children have to learn the concept of intrinsic motivation (some are born with it) and rewarding their successes in life literally robs them of this. This is even more true for the more unmotivated child.
Their exam results are for them, for their futures and successes not ours.

This is a hill I'm prepared to die on + not boasting but ds1 just got 613 points (out of 625) in LC 2022!

Swipe left for the next trending thread