Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give a cash reward to the twin who gets the best GCSE results?

342 replies

Stackss · 06/01/2023 11:33

DS and DD are both in year 11 so have their GCSEs coming up shortly. Both are bright and of very similar if not identical academic ability and are predicted very similar grades.

Both are relatively hard working (although with a tendency to coast) but DH and I would really like them to knuckle down and push themselves to get the best grades possible.

We therefore came up with the idea of an effort-based reward scheme allowing them to earn treats for completing revision- e.g. 75 hours= a meal out, 150 hours= a night away etc.

However, both twins have suggested that instead, the twin who gets the best results should receive the whole cash reward. They are both competitive with each other and have said this would give them greater incentive to work harder.

My concern is that the twin who doesn't do as well will be doubly disappointed on results day as they will also get no reward. Should I go with the twins' suggestion?

OP posts:
Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:50

@redskydelight

They will do well if they work really hard. However, we will also be setting a minimum revision amount that needs to be completed on a weekly revision goal that has to be completed to make then eligible for the grade-based rewards.

OP posts:
pa1ace · 06/01/2023 12:50

This is very sad. Why are you putting a monetary value on their grades?

Nowfeeltheneedtopost · 06/01/2023 12:49

This is so sad in so many ways. Mainly that you say your twins came up with the original idea. I would be questioning where I had gone so wrong that they see competing with each other as ok. Did you never have conversations about avoiding comparisons, focusing on your own efforts, and supporting your sibling?

hotchocs · 06/01/2023 12:49

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:42

After discussing with the DC and DH, we have agreed on the below reward scheme:

£100 for each 9
£75 for each 8
£25 for each 7
They pay us £25 for each 6 or below- it is worth noting that they asked for this consequence. I don't know whether we would actually follow through.

They will also get £2 for each hour of revision completed so long as there js evidence that work has been done.

Sure.

Think this needs to be looked at by MN, lots of trolling threads about recently! Wish I hadn’t wasted my time giving help tbh.

redskydelight · 06/01/2023 12:46

If your DC do as well in their GCSEs as they've done in getting money out of you, then they will do very well.

(Was I the only one thinking they'd introduced the competition idea because both of them were planning to coast, but they thought it would throw you off the scent, and they'd then plan to share the money?)

TimeForTeaAndG · 06/01/2023 12:45

What happened to natural consequences? Don't study, won't get a good grade. Passed well, congratulations let's celebrate. Didn't pass well, let's have a look at clearing/next year's options.

Chickenly · 06/01/2023 12:45

mnchat · 06/01/2023 12:27

@Chickenly you've missed the point. They aren't on the same team . Each twin will sit their individual gcse . Ones success (or failure) has no bearing on the other's success (or failure).

If you want to compare to your firm think of it like a graduate programme assessment day. Everyone who meets the mark gets in. You are working hard individually and together on specific tasks to ensure YOU get the job.

Your example gives the impression of each twin sabotaging the other which isn't the case. You quoting me then giving your example is comparing apples and oranges.

The competitive arseholes at assessment centres don’t get hired. Those assessment centres have group exercises for this exact reason.

And the bloody should be on the same team. A twin should be hoping that they both get the best grades possible, not hoping that the other one does badly. One doing well doesn’t damage the achievements of the other but this set up convinces them that it does.

Imagine one gets all 8s - in this set up, whether or not they’re a success depends on whether their twin got a 7 or got a 9. They still got all 8s, regardless, but they feel like they’ve succeeded or failed based on the actions of someone else (which is an unhealthy mindset) and they have an incentive to want bad things for their twin. They’re being paid to hope that their twin got a 7 instead of a 9 - that’s an unhealthy mindset too.

At the firm, we firmly believe we’re hiring candidates that are most suited to us. That means that when we see a candidate pushing out others, hoping they’ll fail or not supporting them to be their best - they don’t pass. A common example is in a presentation, a candidate wanting to tag their point on someone’s section onto the part the other candidate said instead of just having it put into that candidate’s part - they’re trying to make sure that they get the glory for the point that they thought of. But it’s to the detriment of the group because it makes the whole presentation look unrehearsed and disjointed. The candidate put their personal gain ahead of the group and we don’t like that so we won’t hire them.

Wanting others to fail because you view their failure as your success isn’t something to be encouraged - it won’t get you far in life.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 06/01/2023 12:43

Paying per hr for revision is not a good idea unless you are setting caps. Burnout isn't healthy. But tbh, it's consistent with the whole fucked up picture here...

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:42

After discussing with the DC and DH, we have agreed on the below reward scheme:

£100 for each 9
£75 for each 8
£25 for each 7
They pay us £25 for each 6 or below- it is worth noting that they asked for this consequence. I don't know whether we would actually follow through.

They will also get £2 for each hour of revision completed so long as there js evidence that work has been done.

OP posts:
Face2facet · 06/01/2023 12:42

My FIL did this with his children, thinking that by getting them to compete off each other they will do better in life. They all
are doing well for themselves, but hate each other. it’s so sad. Don’t do this.

Sartre · 06/01/2023 12:39

Horrible idea. Put yourself in the shoes of the twin who doesn’t ‘win’, even worse if they’re just one grade off winning or something. They will kick themselves and feel like a failure. They shouldn’t be comparing themselves to one another full stop, they’re both great in their own ways.

SnowlayRoundabout · 06/01/2023 12:39

However, both twins have suggested that instead, the twin who gets the best results should receive the whole cash reward.

You do realise that, on that basis, if both of them do really badly but one is slightly better than the other, you will be rewarding that one?

lanthanum · 06/01/2023 12:37

Terrible idea. But it came from them, interestingly.
I wonder whether the best thing is to distance yourself from the competitive aspect by suggesting that if they want to gamble on their results, they do that between themselves - perhaps they agree that the loser gives the winner £20. And try and persuade them to keep it well below whatever you're giving them.

You might also remind them that it might not seem so fair when the results come out. Suppose the difference in grades boils down to couple of marks difference across a grade boundary - and in fact the loser has far exceeded the winner in other subjects where it wasn't across the grade boundary.

wincarwoo · 06/01/2023 12:37

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:29

@AreOttersJustWetCats

No- as they will be adults at that stage. However, school exam results are, despite what some say, vitally important in terms of opening future doors and opportunities.

If one of the twins decides at a later stage that they want to do a non-academic career that makes them happy, that's totally fine with me. But I do want them to make sure that have as many options as possible by working as hard as they can at this stage.

That's all fine. But the monetary reward is still a dreadful idea. It's dysfunctional.

yoyo1234 · 06/01/2023 12:35

DS worked hard at various times. I bought him presents after doing the work and before results . I was proud of his work ethic and rewarded that. I did also reward grade improvement between his mocks and his actual results as well on results day. The only person he was working for and trying to improve was himself (ps if he dropped a grade between mocks and result he would not have been penalised).

Crunchingleaf · 06/01/2023 12:35

Awful idea. Do they normally get along because this is a recipe for resentment especially if one of them has an off day and loses.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 06/01/2023 12:34

I find it bizarre that the OP can't see that, while they may suggest this as an idea at the age of 16, if she were to actually do it they would look back on it as adults (probably in conversations with their therapist) and say "Wtf? Can you believe our childhood was so toxic that our mother agreed to pit us against each other at exam time?"

They're kids. The OP is an adult. She has no excuse for entertaining this idea.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/01/2023 12:30

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 06/01/2023 11:55

But how do you reward effort? It’s very difficult to measure how much effort someone else puts in. And effort should lead to better results. I don’t mean every better result in comparison to another person/subject means more effort but if I put in more effort I should get a better result than what I would have done without that effort.

Observe whether they’re doing their work/ revision or not

Im not saying you reward one who did more than the other, just observe if they are giving it their best shot.

Or that’s what my parents (my Mum tbh) did.

I did well in my exams and would have cleaned up if they paid per result, and esp if they had paid for whichever of the three of us did best (albeit with a four year wait). However, although all three of us have good jobs, I am the least well paid (public sector) with the best A level results and brother who did least well is the best paid. So it’s not all about exam results!

Unikeko · 06/01/2023 12:30

Don't do it. If they are competitive they are going to compete against each other regardless of a reward at the end. Better to encourage them not to rub their successes in eachother's faces.

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:29

@AreOttersJustWetCats

No- as they will be adults at that stage. However, school exam results are, despite what some say, vitally important in terms of opening future doors and opportunities.

If one of the twins decides at a later stage that they want to do a non-academic career that makes them happy, that's totally fine with me. But I do want them to make sure that have as many options as possible by working as hard as they can at this stage.

OP posts:
hotchocs · 06/01/2023 12:29

hotchocs · 06/01/2023 12:11

Please read my comment

Do not do this. I cannot stress that enough.

i was a massive perfectionist throughout school- straight As, 100% in mocks, studied for 12+ hours a day, barely slept, I was encouraged by the fact I was getting good grades and making everyone happy (they had no idea how miserable I was). The better my grades, the happier everyone was, and the worse I treated myself.

I took an overdose at 17, ended up burnt out and exhausted and did shit in my final exams. I could have been anything I wanted result and brain wise, but I couldn’t because I had completely decayed as a person. It’s only now - a decade later - that I’m able to study and actually work without feeling like an utter failure for not getting 100%

You reward them for effort. If you start giving money for grades you’re saying that one is more worthy and better than the other. Do not do that. It’s a very slippery slope and you do not want to encourage perfectionism. Don’t equate good grades with being the end all and be all

Bumping my own post as I want you to see it.
And to add to it, from your further posts it sounds like if they’re predicted or capable of an A you expect them to get it. Again, it’s a very slippery slope to go down. And speaking from experience, my family were like that in that I had always got As and was therefore presumed and expected to get As. But that created a whole extra level of pressure- what if I don’t get the A? Everyone is going to be extra disappointed and annoyed because they expect me just to get it? What if I have an off day and do badly and don’t get the A?

I then developed a fear of doing well because I knew it set the bar higher. I continually got 100% in my mocks and it became sort of expected- so when I got 95% in one suddenly that was a bit like oh, only 95%? Because the bar gets set higher and higher each time. Can you imagine the inner turmoil of being a perfectionist and wanting to succeed more than anything, but also being scared to succeed because that meant the pressure was higher next time? And people would be disappointed if you didn’t get it just because they expected you to get it?

im not trying to go on and on and I’m not trying to scare you. But I left school a decade ago and I was not the only one like this from it. The pressure on teens is monumental- from society, family, each other, school. Do everything you can NOT to add to it

neverbeenskiing · 06/01/2023 12:29

AreOttersJustWetCats · 06/01/2023 12:26

This reminds me of that quote from Glengarry Glen Ross ("first prize is a Cadillac El Dorado. Anyone wanna see second prize? Second prize is a set of steak knives. Third prize is you're fired.")

And just as toxic.

Completely agree. This thread has been a real eye-opener and explains why so many of the Year 11 kids I work with are either nervous wrecks or incredibly entitled.

Dixiechickonhols · 06/01/2023 12:29

Horrible. Difference between 8 or 9 is often a hairsbreadth or luck.
No cash per grade for my dc last year and I don’t know anyone who did.

Demeter1978 · 06/01/2023 12:29

As a twin myself I would say it was an awful idea. Although you say it was their idea, pitting siblings against one another can only end in tears.

ILoveeCakes · 06/01/2023 12:28

AreOttersJustWetCats · 06/01/2023 12:26

This reminds me of that quote from Glengarry Glen Ross ("first prize is a Cadillac El Dorado. Anyone wanna see second prize? Second prize is a set of steak knives. Third prize is you're fired.")

And just as toxic.

"Your besht, only losers whine about their besht. Winners go home and fuck the prom queen."