Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give a cash reward to the twin who gets the best GCSE results?

342 replies

Stackss · 06/01/2023 11:33

DS and DD are both in year 11 so have their GCSEs coming up shortly. Both are bright and of very similar if not identical academic ability and are predicted very similar grades.

Both are relatively hard working (although with a tendency to coast) but DH and I would really like them to knuckle down and push themselves to get the best grades possible.

We therefore came up with the idea of an effort-based reward scheme allowing them to earn treats for completing revision- e.g. 75 hours= a meal out, 150 hours= a night away etc.

However, both twins have suggested that instead, the twin who gets the best results should receive the whole cash reward. They are both competitive with each other and have said this would give them greater incentive to work harder.

My concern is that the twin who doesn't do as well will be doubly disappointed on results day as they will also get no reward. Should I go with the twins' suggestion?

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 06/01/2023 13:49

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/01/2023 12:30

Observe whether they’re doing their work/ revision or not

Im not saying you reward one who did more than the other, just observe if they are giving it their best shot.

Or that’s what my parents (my Mum tbh) did.

I did well in my exams and would have cleaned up if they paid per result, and esp if they had paid for whichever of the three of us did best (albeit with a four year wait). However, although all three of us have good jobs, I am the least well paid (public sector) with the best A level results and brother who did least well is the best paid. So it’s not all about exam results!

But the parent shouldn’t be micro managing revision to the extent that they know exactly how much is done. Also things that paying attention in class etc will have a huge impact. What if the child says I won’t pay attention in class but do an hour of staring at a book tonight instead, from the parents perspective they have done great as it was visible to them but in reality maybe not so much.

Stackss · 06/01/2023 13:47

@Needmorelego

GCSEs very much are a competition as they are graded on a bell curve. Only X percentage can achieve a 9 in each subject for example due ti the way grade boundaries work.

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 06/01/2023 13:45

@Stackss GCSEs shouldn't be a competition though.
They are exams to show the person has understood the subject and to lead them on to the next stage in life.

Stackss · 06/01/2023 13:44

@Ssmiler

Thanks- that's useful advice. How many hours of revision did you expect per day to earn the reward?

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 06/01/2023 13:43

redskydelight · 06/01/2023 12:52

I always wonder if the children who get "money per grade" actually do any more work than they were planning to anyway.
I have a strong suspicion that most don't.

I got paid for my exam grades and it did not influence the work I did at all. It was nice to receive some cash but I worked for the grades and not the money.

pa1ace · 06/01/2023 13:41

OP, twins or groups of friends will naturally compete with each other (openly or otherwise). I'm not sure why you think this is so unique to your twins or why you are making such a hoo-haa about it.

What most families do not need to do is pay their DC to revise. Nor di they need to make grades transactional. This element is 100% about you.

lifeturnsonadime · 06/01/2023 13:37

There is a massive difference between having no issue with them competing against each other and actively encouraging it by using money to reward the 'winner' which is what your incentive scheme does.

Nowfeeltheneedtopost · 06/01/2023 13:37

Stackss · 06/01/2023 13:28

@Nowfeeltheneedtopost

To be clear the competition comes from themselves and is not driven by us at all. They have always been competitive with regard to test results etc.

It is no bad thing in my view as it is totally self-driven.

I disagree. It is, of course, a bad thing. It has kept your children in some kind of “4 yr old” play patterns. I have a Y11 DC and they have learnt the importance of understanding their own levels vs their friends / cousins etc. And even if they had similar predictions, they understand that their friends or cousins getting 9s doesn’t impact their own ability to get 9s. I feel really sorry for your DC. What do you think your “approach” will deliver beyond GCSEs?

PurplePinecone · 06/01/2023 13:37

I would go with the monetary amount per grade. In addition you could have something like the winner with highest grades gets to pick the celebration event. I.e. location of holiday or restaurant to go etc? So interests their competitive side, but both still get something for good grades

Ssmiler · 06/01/2023 13:36

If it’s helpful I offered to pay a set amount at the end of the study period, prior to exams starting, for good study effort. How this was to be assessed was based on x number of hours daily with no electronics ever in the room -phone etc only to be used on planned breaks and only in the family room.

This was a huge issue as I’d had no success in taking the electronics out before. I offered this money and was told no as the electronic restriction wasn’t acceptable! A few days later it was accepted as the draw of the money was too great. It made a huge difference to the grades as compared to previous performance - the phone had been a huge distraction

Obviously if their work is on iPads etc you need will need work arounds with devices on aeroplane mode etc. But this was our way of ensuring quality of revision and it worked for us.

Stackss · 06/01/2023 13:35

@redskydelight

In my view it is no different to winning a race or an art competition. Both twins are of equal ability- if they want to compete against themselves on grades, I have no issue with it.

OP posts:
BashfulClam · 06/01/2023 13:34

I like this idea. They both get a reward then.

lifeturnsonadime · 06/01/2023 13:33

It's not 'between themselves' or 'self driven' when you are offering them cash incentives!

You are kidding yourself.

redskydelight · 06/01/2023 13:32

Stackss · 06/01/2023 13:28

@Nowfeeltheneedtopost

To be clear the competition comes from themselves and is not driven by us at all. They have always been competitive with regard to test results etc.

It is no bad thing in my view as it is totally self-driven.

Doesn't mean it is healthy or desirable or that the twin that "loses" doesn't have their self esteem knocked.

You should encourage your twins to compete against their own standards and not those of other people (even their sibling).

pa1ace · 06/01/2023 13:31

If it was "totally self-driven," money wouldn't even be mentioned!

Can you not see this OP?

Testina · 06/01/2023 13:29

My friend’s twins are “friendly” competitive too. They’d also draw up a timetable but then want a formula to reward more points for who got the best grades with the least effort 😉

JangolinaPitt · 06/01/2023 13:28

This
all this payment by grade etc is appalling
give them both a nice treat after the exams and before the results

Stackss · 06/01/2023 13:28

@Nowfeeltheneedtopost

To be clear the competition comes from themselves and is not driven by us at all. They have always been competitive with regard to test results etc.

It is no bad thing in my view as it is totally self-driven.

OP posts:
Testina · 06/01/2023 13:27

mummabubs · 06/01/2023 13:14

This isn't how "intelligence" or learning works. Genes are a part of the picture, but certainly not all. It's not as neat as the nature/nurture divide, so I'd discourage this attitude that being twins puts them on an identical footing for academic attainment.

🤣 @ILoveeCakes you don’t understand genetics do you?

Even leaving aside @mummabubs reply to you about nature / nurture, and the fact that epigenetics would blow your mind… didn’t you clock the DS / DD combo? Even same sex twins aren’t always identical twins, but here’s a tip: they sure as hell aren’t identical when one’s a boy and one’s a girl.

I’m guessing your parents didn’t have to find £100 for a Grade 9 Science GCSE result for you? Or even a tenner for a 4, if you think boy/girl twins are identical 😉

Nowfeeltheneedtopost · 06/01/2023 13:26

Stackss · 06/01/2023 13:02

Again, I don't agree that parents shouldn't set high expectations for their DC. Of course it needs to be done in a healthy way, but in my view, DC knowing that there is an expectation from their parents to work hard and achieve the best they can is not a bad thing.

Part of the purpose of GCSEs is about developing work ethic and self-discipline. Surely the fee months before these exams should be about working and revising hard to achieve the best results possible for the individual?

But you aren’t planning to encourage your children to develop an intrinsic sense of satisfaction or achievement from their own efforts which will set them up for life.

Instead, you are micromanaging by paying them per hour of revision and encouraging them to (unhealthily) compete against each other.

neverbeenskiing · 06/01/2023 13:23

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:42

After discussing with the DC and DH, we have agreed on the below reward scheme:

£100 for each 9
£75 for each 8
£25 for each 7
They pay us £25 for each 6 or below- it is worth noting that they asked for this consequence. I don't know whether we would actually follow through.

They will also get £2 for each hour of revision completed so long as there js evidence that work has been done.

This is fucked up beyond belief. I hope you're a troll because otherwise it's just depressing what some people think passes for parenting.

Stackss · 06/01/2023 13:21

They are now both making their revision timetables and there is even an element of competition in how much revision they're going to do.

We certainly won't be discouraging it.

OP posts:
SocksAndTheCity · 06/01/2023 13:21

Stackss · 06/01/2023 13:04

They have also agreed between themselves (with no encouragement from me) that the twin who gets the best results will pay the other £25.

🤣🤣🤣

Stackss · 06/01/2023 13:17

@mummabubs

Both have always been very similar achievers academically and have almost identical predicted grades.

OP posts:
mummabubs · 06/01/2023 13:14

ILoveeCakes · 06/01/2023 11:39

They have the same genetics, so the one who doesn't do as well hasn't worked as hard.

Still, no need for you to punish them for laziness. The world will do that.

This isn't how "intelligence" or learning works. Genes are a part of the picture, but certainly not all. It's not as neat as the nature/nurture divide, so I'd discourage this attitude that being twins puts them on an identical footing for academic attainment.