Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give a cash reward to the twin who gets the best GCSE results?

342 replies

Stackss · 06/01/2023 11:33

DS and DD are both in year 11 so have their GCSEs coming up shortly. Both are bright and of very similar if not identical academic ability and are predicted very similar grades.

Both are relatively hard working (although with a tendency to coast) but DH and I would really like them to knuckle down and push themselves to get the best grades possible.

We therefore came up with the idea of an effort-based reward scheme allowing them to earn treats for completing revision- e.g. 75 hours= a meal out, 150 hours= a night away etc.

However, both twins have suggested that instead, the twin who gets the best results should receive the whole cash reward. They are both competitive with each other and have said this would give them greater incentive to work harder.

My concern is that the twin who doesn't do as well will be doubly disappointed on results day as they will also get no reward. Should I go with the twins' suggestion?

OP posts:
daybroke · 07/01/2023 09:23

This is an awful idea.

Mooda · 07/01/2023 09:13

I don't get this thing of paying children to get good exam results. Doing well is in itself the benefit - pride in oneself, opens doors to better life opportunities etc. That's the prize, they should be doing it for themselves. Why would you pay them? I pay my DC to do jobs because that has a benefit for me. Why would I pay them to get good exam results when the benefit is all theirs? There's no logic to this, it teaches a really weird lesson.

Butterlover1 · 07/01/2023 09:05

Dreadful idea

fajitaaaa · 07/01/2023 09:03

Terrible idea

MissTrip82 · 07/01/2023 08:11

It’s time for them to move away from competitive behaviour if they want to excel.

I work in a field in which everyone has had significant academic success. Without exception, the people who are most successful amongst this cohort of successful people are those who are only competing with themselves. The least successful are those who always have their eye on the ‘competition’ - they simply cannot focus as well, and their goals are limited to being slightly better than the next person.

If they want to succeed they need to learn to focus, and to set more ambitious goals than doing a bit better than someone else in your house.

Oh - time-based revision is also not the basis for excellence. There’s lots of good information available on evidence-based study practices

FelicityFlops · 07/01/2023 08:01

I don't think offering money to the highest achiever is a good way to motivate either of them.
If you feel you have to "bribe" with cash just set up a sliding scale of money versus grade.
Alternatively you could ask them, individually, what they would like for doing well in their exams. One might prefer driving lessons or similar, whilst the other might want to go on a special holiday with friends.

TwoPointFourCatsAndDogs · 07/01/2023 06:57

My DC did GCSEs last summer. Our cash reward scheme was based on predicted grades = £50 and £25 + or - for anything above or below predicted and £100 for a 9, plus a Reading Festival ticket for the hard work.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/01/2023 06:56

Swiminanglesey · 07/01/2023 00:44

This was painful to read.
such a dysfunctional, unhealthy dynamic.

Exactly. I'm hoping it's not true, which seems likely.

Ericaequites · 07/01/2023 03:32

Reward results, not effort. That’s what the real world is like.

k1233 · 07/01/2023 02:08

I don't see this as good. You're setting your kids up with warped ideas when it comes to their careers. The people who work the hardest aren't necessarily the ones who get promoted or get ahead . Effort is not directionally proportional to result.

Months of revision is not needed to achieve good results.

ClareBlue · 07/01/2023 01:50

BritAbroad101 · 06/01/2023 11:51

Find something they can excel at that doesn’t involve intellect

So if you’re not very bright then don’t try to work in the city, but maybe you’d be a first class manual worker

We’ve all got to hustle

You think our elite inteligensa work in the city gambling with other people's money. You're wrong. The city is about entitlement and connections and adds little value to our societies.
This whole thread shows why we place no value on empathy and caring in our society and why we only value achiement in monetary terms. Beat your twin and you get the cash. If you read about Trump's upbringing this was exactly his family dynamic. Whilst his case is extreme, you see the traits in people everywhere.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 07/01/2023 01:47

watchfulwishes · 06/01/2023 11:44

Anyone paying for results is a shit parent. Sorry to be blunt but you are employing really shit techniques that harm your kids.

Better to follow my mother's method - 'I don't care whether you do well or not. You could get a job in a shop without them and then you'd be doing something useful like bringing some money in like your brothers'.

Dancingdragonhiddentiger · 07/01/2023 01:47

Horrible horrible idea. Tell them a hard no and explain why- that you want them to both succeed and to celebrate each other too!

SproutsLCerVEGNoEgg · 07/01/2023 01:35

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:57

@redskydelight

They will need to work the scheme agreed as there is a minimum revision threshold that needs to be met to qualify for the grade rewards. There is also a £2 per hour reward for each revision hours completed.

@Stackss

your kids, your life, I'd start saving though...

they're going to need therapy & I think it's only fair YOU pay for it.

Swiminanglesey · 07/01/2023 00:44

This was painful to read.
such a dysfunctional, unhealthy dynamic.

Smoom · 06/01/2023 23:47

Just wow. Almost speechless.

But I have to say I’m against motivating kids to learn (or do stuff around the house) for money or whatever. In my opinion, the best motivation (in the long run) is intrinsic motivation: Genuine ambition vs status/ money.

lailamaria · 06/01/2023 23:15

this is gonna cause your children intense burnout and you are putting so much weight on theirrevision and grades it's disgusting in my opinion, you are aware retakes are an option

Ssmiler · 06/01/2023 23:05

Stackss · 06/01/2023 13:44

@Ssmiler

Thanks- that's useful advice. How many hours of revision did you expect per day to earn the reward?

@Stackss DD set the revision timetable / plan herself at the very beginning. So then to earn the reward it was just to stick to her own plan and importantly never have electronics during the scheduled study time - unless on the planned break

The removal of the electronics changed her work ethic dramatically

AFS1 · 06/01/2023 19:17

This is so messed up. It’s been a while since I came across such intense helicopter parenting as OP is displaying.

Your children should not need financial incentive to work to the best of their ability. Surely the grades should be sufficient incentive. If they’re naturally competitive (which may or not be true but has almost certainly been encouraged by the parenting they’ve received, based on your replies to this thread), simply getting better grades than their sibling will motivate them enough.

Oh, and unless you’re sitting with them while they revise which would be utterly bizarre at their age, you will have no idea how much revision they’re doing. My mother was sure I was working hard in my room. I coasted to straight As at GCSE. Bright kids can often get away with it at that level. It can catch up with you at A-level, though.

willstarttomorrow · 06/01/2023 19:12

DC did her GCSE's last year. She worked hard (after a bit of a tricky time in covid) was motivated and did really well- enabling to get into the college she wanted where she is thriving. This was her reward and she is proud of herself (although she knows we are all proud of her as a family- she suffered the loss of one parent during her childhood and had to work through this as well). Some aunts/uncles sent a token amount but I cannot overstate how much I disagrre with the 'pay each A' or whatever mentality. It is a really questionable way of motivating young people who are at an age when they need to start understanding what they 'put in' and their behaviours will have consequences from forward.

DD had friends who were paid for grades but agrees it is not logical. Putting aside that this undermines the message of personal responsibility and an early understanding of consequences for actions, it is just not a level playing field. Some subjects are just much easier for some children- however hard one works, for example, in Maths, their getting a C (in old money) will be a far more significant achievement than a child who has always 'got' the subject from year 1 and is naturally talented and was always destined to get grade 9.

Subjects such as drama, health and social care etc. have very different demands to languages and history/geography etc. There is also the issue that every year there seems to be a particular subject that seems to have a very difficult paper/marking. DD was predicted a 9 in history ever since she took it as an option(year 8 in her school). She got a 7 which is amazing- but teaching staff were very surprised by the marking by the exam board this year. Not really an issue going forward because she has her place for A-levels and it is already forgotten

Dumbo18 · 06/01/2023 19:09

As soon as I seen the word twins I knew this was a wind up thread… OP we all know you’re a troll, give it up

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 06/01/2023 19:07

I am not against cash rewards based on grades put paying them to revise seems wrong. What incentive will they have to work hard throughout their a level course if they can coasts and then get paid to cram at the end.

what will you do at a levels if one of them ends up having to do way more revision as they did less work over the rest of the course? Will that one end up financially better off?

SpicyFoodRocks · 06/01/2023 18:57

Stackss · 06/01/2023 18:47

@Vates

It's nothing to do with favourites- the DC suggested this idea themselves. Both are almost identical when it comes to academic abilities.

In any event, they will now both receive a reward based on grades and revision hours.

Why do you think your children don’t value education for education’s sake? If you value education as parents, why have you not passed that ethos down to your kids? Why is getting the top grades not a sufficient motivator in itself?

Stackss · 06/01/2023 18:47

@Vates

It's nothing to do with favourites- the DC suggested this idea themselves. Both are almost identical when it comes to academic abilities.

In any event, they will now both receive a reward based on grades and revision hours.

OP posts:
Vates · 06/01/2023 18:40

It doesn't matter. They already know who is the favourite. Nothing you can do now will change that. Damage is done!

Swipe left for the next trending thread