Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give a cash reward to the twin who gets the best GCSE results?

342 replies

Stackss · 06/01/2023 11:33

DS and DD are both in year 11 so have their GCSEs coming up shortly. Both are bright and of very similar if not identical academic ability and are predicted very similar grades.

Both are relatively hard working (although with a tendency to coast) but DH and I would really like them to knuckle down and push themselves to get the best grades possible.

We therefore came up with the idea of an effort-based reward scheme allowing them to earn treats for completing revision- e.g. 75 hours= a meal out, 150 hours= a night away etc.

However, both twins have suggested that instead, the twin who gets the best results should receive the whole cash reward. They are both competitive with each other and have said this would give them greater incentive to work harder.

My concern is that the twin who doesn't do as well will be doubly disappointed on results day as they will also get no reward. Should I go with the twins' suggestion?

OP posts:
Testina · 07/01/2023 13:10

@Onebelow “Paying a fine for flunking their GCSEs? So if they pass 9 they get £100, if they fail 9 that’s £225”

You’ve misunderstood.
It’s not about 9 GCSEs, but about achieving a level 9 in them.
£100 for every GCSE level 9 (so potentially around £1000).
£25 “fine” for any failed or passed at Level 6 and below.

Although the latter sounds horrendous, it was coming from the kids. I’d say no to them on that!

TheOriginalEmu · 07/01/2023 13:08

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:15

I do have to say I don't agree with the idea that any rewards for achievement are bad. In my view, GCSE grades are inherently linked to effort and hard work.

Obviously any reward should be linked to the ability of the DC. If a DC is capable of a 9, that should be what is expected and rewarded. On the other hand, if a 5 is a great achievement, they should be rewarded for that.

You have just said that your kids are predicted all 8/9 grades, but also that they have a tendency to coast, so clearly there is a disconnect between effort and grade. Kids who coast are gcse level but do well tend to have a very hard time when it comes to a level and higher because they don’t know how to work. Ime the kids who have had to bust a hump to get Cs at gcse do a lot better at A level because they have that work ethic.

Onebelow · 07/01/2023 13:06

Paying a fine for flunking their GCSEs? So if they pass 9 they get £100, if they fail 9 that’s £225? Just a note, you can still have a career without your GCSEs, and you can pay to resit them too if you needed one or two for a certain course. The pressure some parents and teachers put on kids for their GCSEs is just awful and damaging. They’re really not the be all and end all. I have 4 diplomas and I didn’t get any GCSEs above a C grade.

Onebelow · 07/01/2023 13:02

Do you compare your twins in other areas too or just academically? It’s awful to pit one child against the other like this. That’s messed up. How about seeing them as individuals and praising their own individual strengths rather than making them compete for your praise?

Sharon1985x · 07/01/2023 12:54

All I can say is I am glad your not my mum.i think all your ideas are terrible

celticprincess · 07/01/2023 12:50

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:42

After discussing with the DC and DH, we have agreed on the below reward scheme:

£100 for each 9
£75 for each 8
£25 for each 7
They pay us £25 for each 6 or below- it is worth noting that they asked for this consequence. I don't know whether we would actually follow through.

They will also get £2 for each hour of revision completed so long as there js evidence that work has been done.

If you decided to go ahead with this then please get your children to to keep it to themselves. I could never in a million years afford this kind of expense as a reward for exam results and if my children came home telling me their friends would be getting this reward it could potentially cause many more issues. Clearly you can afford to do this, but not all parents can. And clearly you kids have some savings as well as if they flunked their exams and had to pay you the fine for each exam they must have access to it.

You are then setting yourself up for even bigger costs when they do their A levels or what we 16+ qualifications they go for.

What would have happened if one of your twins had a learning disability and would never have been able to achieve those results anyway. What would your thinking be? Are you de valuing anyone who doesn’t achieve high academic grades?

For what it’s worth, I was predicted ABC in a levels and ended up with EEE. I was absolutely heartbroken. It wasn’t due to laziness. I revised a lot. It was down to a combination of things including no one at the time understanding my learning style. My excellent GCSE results (As, Bs, and Cs) did not prepare me for the challenge of A level. An additional pressure of not gaining a financial reward and potentially paying a fine would have tipped me over the edge

goldfootball · 07/01/2023 12:39

It is sad really that this is what our education system has come to - and schools are fully complicit in this. It’s not about being clever and having interests it’s about revision.

celticprincess · 07/01/2023 12:38

No no no. Not fair to reward either revision or outcome. A frat for both at the end for getting through would be better. My sister and I got very similar GCSE results. I put in a lot of effort but struggle with short term memory and retaining all the information needed to pass an exam. Have always hated exams as they don’t test ability just test memory. I had a lot of help revising too and still struggled. My sister put in zero effort with her revision and got pretty similar results. Some people can pass exams with little effort and other struggle. Encourage them to revise by all means. But then putting them up for competition on results day is just awful too. GCSEs are not a competition. Their results will be whatever they are. They then make choices after results day based on results as to what to do next. We all live our lives following a different path. My current path has been very windy with stops and starts and diversions all over the place. I achieved a masters degree at the age of 45 and some people get them in their 20s. Our journeys to those qualifications were very different and that’s fine.

Sarahjaykay · 07/01/2023 12:33

Worst idea ever. I have twins in year 11 also and this horrified me.

goldfootball · 07/01/2023 12:33

I knew parents who did this when I was doing my gcses and it blew my mind.

im not sure it’s going to embed the habits you want it to as there is evidence that external rewards for behaviours can reduce the intrinsic desire to do that thing. So cash rewards for revising won’t necessarily establish a good work ethic for A- levels.

i did very well in my gcses after spending most of study leave sat around knitting a jumper. If your kids are predicted 8s and 9s while coasting then they don’t need to be doing all that revision for the sake of it. They could be reading loads of classic literature and would be of as much use. 🤷🏻‍♀️

CoolSlinky · 07/01/2023 11:58

My twins were in the same GCSE Maths class - teacher didn't realise until parents' evening - when he rubbed his hands with glee and suggested we set them up in competition with each other - that idea didn't go down well with us. The idea of rewarding them to achieve good results at school wouldn't either - they don't get good grades for us - they do it for themselves, their future - they take responsibility for it and in doing so develop the internal motivation necessary to dig down deep and work hard.
We planned to celebrate their exam results (or commiserate with them - because the fancy dinner in London was planned either way) - they got the same overall for GCSE and A-level scores - which was quite a relief in the end.

ArtixLynx · 07/01/2023 11:53

i am not keen on the grade based reward.

Obviously you know your kids best, but at this age you REALLY need to be taking their mental health into account too.

I'd be more inclined to reward for effort, then give them both the same reward for results.

Sometimes it doesn't matter how HARD you study, the exam can trip you up. I'm AMAZING at studying, exams not so much.
My coursework i consistently got all A, A*, I only managed 9 Cs and 2Bs in my actual exams.

Willyoujustbequiet · 07/01/2023 11:46

Absolutely terrible idea.

And of course grades acheived is no meaure of effort...a child can have natural ability and get top marks doing next to nothing or a child can study really hard and still fail which is incredibly disheartening.

Its like attendance awards - a clumsy, discriminatory target which often rewards selfish actions.

BritAbroad101 · 07/01/2023 11:39

ClareBlue · 07/01/2023 01:50

You think our elite inteligensa work in the city gambling with other people's money. You're wrong. The city is about entitlement and connections and adds little value to our societies.
This whole thread shows why we place no value on empathy and caring in our society and why we only value achiement in monetary terms. Beat your twin and you get the cash. If you read about Trump's upbringing this was exactly his family dynamic. Whilst his case is extreme, you see the traits in people everywhere.

The game we all have to play is the game we all have to play - you’ve got to get good at playing it.

Whether you like or agree with the game is a different (and ultimately irrelevant) question

AreOttersJustWetCats · 07/01/2023 11:13

Hawkins001 · 07/01/2023 10:16

Besides to all, is this not any different than corporations use when it's eg performance related bonus ?

Yes, because your parents acting like your boss is an ideal family dynamic. Not dysfunctional or toxic at all.

MasterBeth · 07/01/2023 11:10

Hawkins001 · 07/01/2023 10:16

Besides to all, is this not any different than corporations use when it's eg performance related bonus ?

No, it's not very different. But you are your children's parent, not their boss.

whoyougonnacallGOATSBUTTER · 07/01/2023 11:08

Stackss · 06/01/2023 12:42

After discussing with the DC and DH, we have agreed on the below reward scheme:

£100 for each 9
£75 for each 8
£25 for each 7
They pay us £25 for each 6 or below- it is worth noting that they asked for this consequence. I don't know whether we would actually follow through.

They will also get £2 for each hour of revision completed so long as there js evidence that work has been done.

The twins original suggestion was not good. They don’t have the emotional intelligence yet to realise impact on the ‘loser’.

This new idea is much better. Nothing wrong with competition, they will be competing all their lives.

nopeasplease · 07/01/2023 10:40

This is horrendous. Your poor children.

Hawkins001 · 07/01/2023 10:18

ClareBlue · 07/01/2023 01:50

You think our elite inteligensa work in the city gambling with other people's money. You're wrong. The city is about entitlement and connections and adds little value to our societies.
This whole thread shows why we place no value on empathy and caring in our society and why we only value achiement in monetary terms. Beat your twin and you get the cash. If you read about Trump's upbringing this was exactly his family dynamic. Whilst his case is extreme, you see the traits in people everywhere.

without the city their would be little economy, we need wall Street etc,

Hawkins001 · 07/01/2023 10:16

Besides to all, is this not any different than corporations use when it's eg performance related bonus ?

Hawkins001 · 07/01/2023 10:15

Stackss · 06/01/2023 11:33

DS and DD are both in year 11 so have their GCSEs coming up shortly. Both are bright and of very similar if not identical academic ability and are predicted very similar grades.

Both are relatively hard working (although with a tendency to coast) but DH and I would really like them to knuckle down and push themselves to get the best grades possible.

We therefore came up with the idea of an effort-based reward scheme allowing them to earn treats for completing revision- e.g. 75 hours= a meal out, 150 hours= a night away etc.

However, both twins have suggested that instead, the twin who gets the best results should receive the whole cash reward. They are both competitive with each other and have said this would give them greater incentive to work harder.

My concern is that the twin who doesn't do as well will be doubly disappointed on results day as they will also get no reward. Should I go with the twins' suggestion?

If they came up with the Ida and are willing to try and know what's involved, then may the best twin win,

Orangepolentacake · 07/01/2023 09:45

RewildingAmbridge · 06/01/2023 11:38

Can you say you will go along with their plan, let them study competitively then on the day give them both a reward/present. Maybe something trivial for the 'winner' like a chocolate medal

So, lie to them on top of it?

HikingforScenery · 07/01/2023 09:37

How would you police the number of hours they’d revised? I’m guessing they’d be revising in their rooms?

I’d go with the suggestion of money per grade for one of my DC. For the other, I’d reward effort.

They’re not close in age so it’d be fine

JustDanceAddict · 07/01/2023 09:34

I can’t think of anything worse tbh! Reward effort not results. Or reward th both for doing well.

ZooMount · 07/01/2023 09:33

My parents set up a reward system for grades which was a good incentive but we both got paid the same amount in the end, I think it was more like an average between the two or the highest amount or something. It was equal but it made us both work and encourage each other. It depends on the twins though, competition does not work for me and would have had the opposite result.

Swipe left for the next trending thread