Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give a cash reward to the twin who gets the best GCSE results?

342 replies

Stackss · 06/01/2023 11:33

DS and DD are both in year 11 so have their GCSEs coming up shortly. Both are bright and of very similar if not identical academic ability and are predicted very similar grades.

Both are relatively hard working (although with a tendency to coast) but DH and I would really like them to knuckle down and push themselves to get the best grades possible.

We therefore came up with the idea of an effort-based reward scheme allowing them to earn treats for completing revision- e.g. 75 hours= a meal out, 150 hours= a night away etc.

However, both twins have suggested that instead, the twin who gets the best results should receive the whole cash reward. They are both competitive with each other and have said this would give them greater incentive to work harder.

My concern is that the twin who doesn't do as well will be doubly disappointed on results day as they will also get no reward. Should I go with the twins' suggestion?

OP posts:
SproutsLCerVEGNoEgg · 06/01/2023 11:44

BAD IDEA!!

You need to teach them to work hard for their OWN sense of accomplishment NOT external reward.

You need to teach them to support each other, not compete with each other.

if you persist in bribing them to work, they'll never learn to be self motivated. A levels/Uni... when will you stop?!

additionally paying them for the time they 'study' ?!?! WTAF? How the hell would you even know what they were doing? I was brilliant at appearing to study, whilst actually doing other things (no tech then really, but I was great at decorating my books/generally titting about!).

BritAbroad101 · 06/01/2023 11:43

Why not just set an amount per grade. So they’ll both get something, and can both get decent (and similar) amounts if they both do well. One doing slightly better then the other won’t have a massive impact on what they receive etc. Rather than winner takes all

I agree about rewarding results and not effort though

Effort that doesn’t translate to results is worthless in life (although obviously effort is required to get results!)

maddy68 · 06/01/2023 11:43

Awful idea

ILoveeCakes · 06/01/2023 11:43

Make 2 badges:

"Prince Harry"
"Prince William"

Hand them out on results day. That'll stay in their heads for life.

bloodyeverlastinghell · 06/01/2023 11:43

I wouldn’t and I have twins who are bright but only seven so this sort of thing hasn’t quite come up.

If they want cash fair enough. Work out what you are prepared to spend divide by two and then number of subjects. Top grades get full amount for each subject. Then you can either have a sliding scale or for that competitive element if they don’t get As or whatever grade then money will go into a winners pot. If they are bright they will both get decent grades in multiple subjects. So winners pot will be relatively small.

mnchat · 06/01/2023 11:43

My DD isn't at GCSE yet but I think it's a great idea. Life rewards results not effort - learning that now will help them in the future.

Find it odd so many are against it given the number of threads I read about parents making kids sit 11+ and multiple selective private school exams etc 🤷‍♀️

RunnerBum · 06/01/2023 11:43

Awful, awful, awful idea.

Your rewards for revision hours completed are also somewhat ridiculous. Time revising doesn’t mean effective revision. I used to be a teacher and so many kids spent hours staring at a textbook taking absolutely nothing in.

My DM gave my brother (one year older) £50 for each GCSE he passed. I then got nothing the next year because she couldn’t afford it and because she said I’d have worked hard anyway. Even though I’d done much better than my brother, I was made to feel like shit. Imagine how shit I’d have felt if I’d actually done worse.

TeenDivided · 06/01/2023 11:42

ILoveeCakes · 06/01/2023 11:39

They have the same genetics, so the one who doesn't do as well hasn't worked as hard.

Still, no need for you to punish them for laziness. The world will do that.

They aren't identical twins so don't have same genetics.
They may well have different teachers.
They may not have even chosen all the same subjects (OP hasn't said).

SnowyGiveAway · 06/01/2023 11:42

jtaeapa · 06/01/2023 11:36

Shock

just do something like

£90 per 9
£80 per 8
£70 per 7
£60 per 6
etc

scale it down if they are likely to receive all 8/9 obviously

This is also a bad idea (sorry). Reward effort and determination. Help them set smart targets and reward them for the revision goals they meet (not necessarily money). Discuss their goals and strategies with them, focus on metacognition and reflection: what went well and why? What could they change next time? Why? How?

What didn't work? How do they know that strategy A was better than strategy B, and what strategies would they apply next time?

Give them a present at the end of it all if you want to

twoshedsjackson · 06/01/2023 11:42

It sounds as if they are set fair to progress to A-levels, and then university. How do you move up a notch from GCSE's if this precedent is set? Expensive, with vicious sibling rivalry and resentment as an extra bonus?

ErinAoife · 06/01/2023 11:42

No it is a bad idea to have only one of the twin get a reward especially if they both try their best. Why not set it up a reward chart for example if they get between 65 -80 % they get £ 2 per subject 81 - 90% £ 5 over 90% £ 20.

LtJudyHopps · 06/01/2023 11:40

When I did my GCSE’s my dad said he would give me an amount of cash per grade - I don’t remember how much but it was an incentive to do better to get more cash!
I think that’s a kinder way of doing it. They can still see who can get the most money but they both get something.

MaverickGooseGoose · 06/01/2023 11:39

It's a terrible idea.

BenchOfCompany · 06/01/2023 11:39

We rewarded effort rather than grades and Ds1 got a much wanted gift after his exams but before his GCSE results were out.

However, if they are motivated by cash then use that but not to the detriment of the other child. You could set grades or revision although you can "revise" for 4 hours and it not be productive. I was able to help Ds with testing him, he had online apps that also tested him, he resat past papers for revision so we could see that he was revising effectively if that makes sense, rather than just reading through notes etc.

Deathraystare · 06/01/2023 11:39

Jesus! What a totally stupid idea!

MilkyYay · 06/01/2023 11:39

This is an awful, awful idea. Do not do it.

Carriemac · 06/01/2023 11:39

Terrible idea . My twins knew that we reward effort not results

InDubiousBattle · 06/01/2023 11:39

Awful idea.

NoSquirrels · 06/01/2023 11:39

If they want a competitive edge and rewards for results as well as effort, you could reward each grade with a different amount e.g. 7s = £X, 8s = £X+Y, 9s = £X+Y+Z etc

That way if one does better they ‘win’ and get more money but the other one doesn’t lose out.

I would also stick with the rewarding effort alongside this anyway.

ILoveeCakes · 06/01/2023 11:39

They have the same genetics, so the one who doesn't do as well hasn't worked as hard.

Still, no need for you to punish them for laziness. The world will do that.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 06/01/2023 11:38

And don’t come back and say a variation of ‘it was their idea’.
You’re the adult, they are children.

Movingonup2023 · 06/01/2023 11:38

I’m sure they think it’s a great idea as I’m sure they both feel confident they will win. Both of them not thinking about how shitty it will be if they lose. What if they get exact same grades except in one subject that would be even more gutting.

I like @jtaeapa’s idea.

Ihatethenewlook · 06/01/2023 11:38

Of course it’s a terrible idea. So one tries their hardest but loses out anyway?? Do as pp said and pay them per grade.

RewildingAmbridge · 06/01/2023 11:38

Can you say you will go along with their plan, let them study competitively then on the day give them both a reward/present. Maybe something trivial for the 'winner' like a chocolate medal

StrawberryWater · 06/01/2023 11:37

I think it’s a bit unfair. Yeah one twin might get all 9s but the other might get all 8s which is still fantastic and needs rewarding.

Personally I would offer (for example) a certain £££ amount for each grade. So each A gets £20, each B gets £15 and each C £10 (obviously you can change each monetary amount according to what you can afford).

I think that’s fair and both get rewarded for effort in some way.