Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give a cash reward to the twin who gets the best GCSE results?

342 replies

Stackss · 06/01/2023 11:33

DS and DD are both in year 11 so have their GCSEs coming up shortly. Both are bright and of very similar if not identical academic ability and are predicted very similar grades.

Both are relatively hard working (although with a tendency to coast) but DH and I would really like them to knuckle down and push themselves to get the best grades possible.

We therefore came up with the idea of an effort-based reward scheme allowing them to earn treats for completing revision- e.g. 75 hours= a meal out, 150 hours= a night away etc.

However, both twins have suggested that instead, the twin who gets the best results should receive the whole cash reward. They are both competitive with each other and have said this would give them greater incentive to work harder.

My concern is that the twin who doesn't do as well will be doubly disappointed on results day as they will also get no reward. Should I go with the twins' suggestion?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
tattygrl · 09/01/2023 10:49

k1233 · 09/01/2023 10:04

Instead of posting gleeful posts of your children over working, I suggest you do some work yourself and look into the impacts of poor study techniques

www.sec-ed.co.uk/best-practice/getting-exam-revision-right/

And from this article www.sec-ed.co.uk/best-practice/when-revision-can-be-bad-for-you/

"It found that revision taking longer than two and a half hours or more to complete diminished the positive effects of studying and led to increased stress and declining health among students."

I was a straight A, A+ student. I did not do excessive revision to get those grades.

Exactly this. These kids are being set up for a lifestyle of "look how many hours I work! Isn't it great! Oh no, why am I feeling burnt out?".

Glorification of over-working is so damaging, and the effects of it don't often come out until adulthood, and the person doesn't know how to rest, and doesn't know the value of an actual work/life balance.

MaryMcCarthy · 09/01/2023 10:06

If both the kids want the all-or-nothing prize then go for it. It'll be a valuable life lesson for both of them. Obviously more for the loser.

My mum gave me £5 per GCSE back in the 90s and it felt great.

k1233 · 09/01/2023 10:04

Instead of posting gleeful posts of your children over working, I suggest you do some work yourself and look into the impacts of poor study techniques

www.sec-ed.co.uk/best-practice/getting-exam-revision-right/

And from this article www.sec-ed.co.uk/best-practice/when-revision-can-be-bad-for-you/

"It found that revision taking longer than two and a half hours or more to complete diminished the positive effects of studying and led to increased stress and declining health among students."

I was a straight A, A+ student. I did not do excessive revision to get those grades.

whatthefactuall · 09/01/2023 02:04

awLspo · 08/01/2023 22:19

Yawn - give up OP, no one's buying the bullshit 🥴

Exactly. 5 hours a day on the weekend. Jesus. I hope this is bullshit, it’s certainly batshit

NameInUseAlreadyAgain · 08/01/2023 22:53

I broached the subject of cash reward for exams last year. DS said he really wanted an Apple Watch and said if he passes them all then could he have one. I said of course. He didn’t pass them all but not through lack of revision - he failed one - he said as he came out of school, no watch then but I did really try and perhaps I can put on birthday list

we gave him the watch later that day that we had secretly bought weeks before to recognize his effort. He actually cried when he opened it

don’t be too harsh on them if they don’t get 7-9 grades ….. it may seem like a good idea to a 15/16 year old but the reality may be devastating come august. At that age they won’t be processing their own suggestion properly.

Hereforthekicks · 08/01/2023 22:45

I remember begging my daughter to not put too much importance on GCSES. She was coming home from school stressed to hell because school led her to believe a decent career life depended on these exams. What a load of bollocks.

awLspo · 08/01/2023 22:19

Stackss · 08/01/2023 11:09

Well, the reward structure is working well so far. Both DC have mocks coming up soon and have timetabled 5 hours of revision a day for this weekend and 3 hours after school.

Finally they are knuckling down and working hard to achieve the best results they are capable of.

Yawn - give up OP, no one's buying the bullshit 🥴

SpicyFoodRocks · 08/01/2023 21:45

Stackss · 08/01/2023 11:09

Well, the reward structure is working well so far. Both DC have mocks coming up soon and have timetabled 5 hours of revision a day for this weekend and 3 hours after school.

Finally they are knuckling down and working hard to achieve the best results they are capable of.

Why has it taken financial bribery to make them study do you think? When many other kids don’t need this incentive.

CoolSlinky · 08/01/2023 12:56

redskydelight · 08/01/2023 12:33

You've gone from the sublime to the ridiculous.
That's a lot of revision for this stage of the year. I hope they don't have homework on top of that as well?

And you do realise creating a revision timetable is not the same as actually doing the revision?

I'm afraid the sceptic in me finds it hard to believe that a teenager that was previously planning to do nothing or very little has, on the basis of being paid for work, suddenly decided that actually they will revise for multiple hours every day. Either they were always intending to do this, or you are being quite spectacularly played.

The problem with trying to solve motivational problems with monetary incentives is that there's often loads of effort applied in the very short term - in the long term these incentives don't work, the money loses it's appeal - it's not even a massively great motivator at work - if someone is lacking in motivation a few thousand rarely produces that extra effort - and I would say this is especially true for kids who have easy access to monetary funds anyway - they just aren't hungry enough.

redskydelight · 08/01/2023 12:33

Stackss · 08/01/2023 11:09

Well, the reward structure is working well so far. Both DC have mocks coming up soon and have timetabled 5 hours of revision a day for this weekend and 3 hours after school.

Finally they are knuckling down and working hard to achieve the best results they are capable of.

You've gone from the sublime to the ridiculous.
That's a lot of revision for this stage of the year. I hope they don't have homework on top of that as well?

And you do realise creating a revision timetable is not the same as actually doing the revision?

I'm afraid the sceptic in me finds it hard to believe that a teenager that was previously planning to do nothing or very little has, on the basis of being paid for work, suddenly decided that actually they will revise for multiple hours every day. Either they were always intending to do this, or you are being quite spectacularly played.

tiredmama23 · 08/01/2023 11:30

Awful idea.

Stackss · 08/01/2023 11:09

Well, the reward structure is working well so far. Both DC have mocks coming up soon and have timetabled 5 hours of revision a day for this weekend and 3 hours after school.

Finally they are knuckling down and working hard to achieve the best results they are capable of.

OP posts:
Paternosta · 08/01/2023 01:24

jtaeapa · 06/01/2023 11:36

Shock

just do something like

£90 per 9
£80 per 8
£70 per 7
£60 per 6
etc

scale it down if they are likely to receive all 8/9 obviously

We did something like this for our DS but with a more modest budget.
He got a bonus for increases on predicted grades too, which might be worth doing. He spent a long time on his English revision because he wanted to up the grade.

Sophie89j · 08/01/2023 00:03

I can see the twins wanting to compete against each other and that’s totally healthy but instead offer x amount per A or B etc whatever they grade in these days. That way they can still compete against one another for whoever gets the better grades but equally both receiving some form of reward. Then perhaps book something for the whole family as a reward for hard work at the end.

Nacknick · 07/01/2023 17:49

I haven’t read the whole thread so I might be out of step with everyone else, but why on earth do they need any kind of reward for doing what they are supposed to do anyway. Surely the reward is the exam result itself, as that will allow them to move onto whatever they want to do next in life?

Nevermind31 · 07/01/2023 17:33

I completely disagree with rewarding hours of study - study smart, not hard. This sort of presentism is really outdated now.
in fact, my expectation would be that they study hard, full stop. How are you going to get them through uni if you they cannot study without incentive?

Citylab · 07/01/2023 15:58

What about if instead you give the winner a card telling them they're your favourite child?😏

harrassedmumto3 · 07/01/2023 15:57

Why are you giving them money for doing something that will benefit their future?! Confused

laurenlodge · 07/01/2023 15:52

This is nuts. A per grade payment doesn't instill a work ethic. All you're doing by incentivising bright children is setting them up to fail at a later date, unless your plan is to bribe them all through university etc. It's one thing to reward them for doing well but this won't have the long-term outcome you need. I say this as someone who got straight A* in my GCSEs and was blindsided by how much discipline and hard work was needed at uni to achieve to the same standard.

If your children are as bright as you say they should be able to appreciate that hard work at this stage will benefit them in future, and that should be incentive enough. If they're planning on going into competitive careers every grade might count. That's the motivation and encouragement you should be providing.

niugboo · 07/01/2023 15:38

You have messed up. You have and continue to reinforce money as a motivator. They don’t value education or hard work. They value money. They’re going to be quite unpleasant when they’re older and in for a huge shock when they enter the workforce and no immediate financial reward for going above and beyond.

Grrrrdarling · 07/01/2023 13:55

Stackss · 06/01/2023 11:33

DS and DD are both in year 11 so have their GCSEs coming up shortly. Both are bright and of very similar if not identical academic ability and are predicted very similar grades.

Both are relatively hard working (although with a tendency to coast) but DH and I would really like them to knuckle down and push themselves to get the best grades possible.

We therefore came up with the idea of an effort-based reward scheme allowing them to earn treats for completing revision- e.g. 75 hours= a meal out, 150 hours= a night away etc.

However, both twins have suggested that instead, the twin who gets the best results should receive the whole cash reward. They are both competitive with each other and have said this would give them greater incentive to work harder.

My concern is that the twin who doesn't do as well will be doubly disappointed on results day as they will also get no reward. Should I go with the twins' suggestion?

If they have suggested this is how they would like the reward to be awarded then they know one of them may miss out but how amazing would it be if they both got exactly the same grades 😀
Maybe have an extra surprise in your pocket that they both get rewarded for their hard work. They don’t need to know this as their push to do well is the competition & both being rewarded for doing well would remove that competition.

Testina · 07/01/2023 13:49

@Onebelow “I can’t imagine sitting down to do an exam, and making a conscious decision to answer a question correctly so I get the money, and without the money incentive I’d have just answered incorrectly.”

Uh? Why do you think that’s what happens?

No child just decides to not answer a question they know correctly because they’re not getting money. Whether you agree with OP or not (and I don’t) the point is that because of the money, they revise more, so can answer more questions correctly.

Onebelow · 07/01/2023 13:38

Testina · 07/01/2023 13:10

@Onebelow “Paying a fine for flunking their GCSEs? So if they pass 9 they get £100, if they fail 9 that’s £225”

You’ve misunderstood.
It’s not about 9 GCSEs, but about achieving a level 9 in them.
£100 for every GCSE level 9 (so potentially around £1000).
£25 “fine” for any failed or passed at Level 6 and below.

Although the latter sounds horrendous, it was coming from the kids. I’d say no to them on that!

Oh right, I’ve read it wrong. So potentially up to a grand each for doing their GCSEs?! Jesus. Must have more money than sense. I can’t imagine sitting down to do an exam, and making a conscious decision to answer a question correctly so I get the money, and without the money incentive I’d have just answered incorrectly. Surely everyone just works to their own ability?

Testina · 07/01/2023 13:20

There you, that’s 2011 on 3 years of exam data, but I doubt it’s much different today.
You might argue that some of the reason it’s not a perfect correlation is the effect of your bombing coasters who don’t realise that in time… but I’d need the data to be convinced. The best A level students (measured by final grade) are the best GCSE students.

To give a cash reward to the twin who gets the best GCSE results?
Testina · 07/01/2023 13:15

“Ime the kids who have had to bust a hump to get Cs at gcse do a lot better at A level because they have that work ethic.”

Which sounds great and just the kind of tale that appeals to our sense of justice.
I don’t doubt that some kids are able to coast their GCSEs and get a kick up the arse when they have to learn study skills in Y12.
However, IME - GCSE grades very much correlate strongly with A level grades.
The bust a hump C graders bust a hump and get a C at A level. The lucky coasters learn to work and get an A, or continue to coast and get a C - still no worse than the bust a humpers 🤷🏻‍♀️