Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I lied about money. Now I want a divorce. Am I being an idiot/unreasonable?

264 replies

TinselTinselTinsel · 06/01/2023 11:22

DH is a difficult/lazy man. Had lots of support on MN in the past. Going to leave him. He won't listen or change.

Before we married (6 years ago), I inherited from an aunt £60k. We then married. The money has always stayed in my name and in my account.

We spent £20k on the new house and a second car.

Over the last few years, we've had various things go wrong with the house plus childcare for 2 x toddlers, plus pandemic etc.

Anyway - he gets very stressed about money. He doesn't do anything to do with money. Mortgage, bills, car, childcare costs - all down to me to sort to pay and know about. He doesn't even know who our mortgage is with.

Over the last couple of years, I've just downplayed how much things are costing. Because if I tell him "Oh the plumber cost £200" - he will go quiet for 3 days or throw stuff or shout "we haven't got any fucking money" etc, so I just used to say "the plumber cost £100"

I now only have £20k left. He thinks we have £30k to £40k of it left. He last asked how much is left of our savings 6 months ago and I said £35k.

Anyway - I lied. It's £20k.

I now want to leave him. I am the breadwinner. All bills, money, everything in my name. Everything from our savings went on nursery bills and fixing stuff in the house/cars.

I am considering waiting until I've saved up another £10-£15k in my savings account so he doesn't know I spent more on childcare and house that I admitted. But is that crazy behaviour? Does it matter if he finds out that everything cost a bit more than I said it did?

Now one of the kids has got free hours, i am saving every month and probably will get the savings back up to £30-£40k over the next year or two. And then I leave him and he takes half?

Any advice? Should I just leave now and when he asks say "ah yes, there is only £20k left actually"

I know I was wrong to lie. He just gets so angry and stressed about things and he doesn't' really ask anymore but when he did I would just say "it's all fine" because I didn't want to upset him.

OP posts:
Soothsayer1 · 07/01/2023 00:04

@TinselTinselTinsel
I don't think you should even see it as a lie you were just doing what you had to in order to feel safe in your own home & protect yourself from his anger etc
Accusing you of being sneaky or manipulative is just another tactic (although he probably just does it instinctively) to keep you feeling guilty, beholden to him, on the back foot etc. He's not saying it because it's true, rather he's chosen this because he knows it will get to you, it's a stick to beat you with.
He's trying to make you doubt yourself so you dont try to go against him, he doesn't want to give up his comfortable life...which comes at YOUR expense!

TinselTinselTinsel · 06/01/2023 23:07

Thank you. You've all made me see his anger about the lie about the savings isn't my problem and that I must not go to an effort to fix the lie e.g save more money.

The house and the kids are far far bigger deals. The kids the biggest obviously. I just got fixated on the lie and that if he found out it would confirm that I wasn't to be trusted or that I am sneaky or manipulative (what he accuses me of). If he tries to get 50% custody and 50% of hosue or even worse gets more than 50% then I'll have real issues and this saving account will be the least of my problems

OP posts:
Feelallright · 06/01/2023 22:58

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/01/2023 22:53

I thought so, too.

No, because when married, everything is joint. It belongs to both of them.

RandomMess · 06/01/2023 22:57

Inheritance rules are different between England and Wales.

In England if you have spent some of the inheritance on the family/households rather than keeping it ringfenced then it is usually considered a marital asset.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/01/2023 22:53

MrsCarson · 06/01/2023 17:57

I may well be wrong, but I thought Inheritance, especially one from before marriage was not a marriage asset. It belongs to the person it was willed to doesn't it?

I thought so, too.

OldFan · 06/01/2023 19:31

I think I would actually take all the money out or something @TinselTinselTinsel , give it to someone to take care of if you have someone, or put it somewhere he doesn't know about. Say it's all gone when you divorce him. He's already had more than his half of the 60k through you paying for stuff more than him, either from your salary or savings.

Mix56 · 06/01/2023 18:37

"Pulling"

Mix56 · 06/01/2023 18:37

He will feel you oulling away,
So prepare before he realises.
Get copies of all documents, house, savings, pension. Wedding cert etc
Make sure he cant acces your email/computer/bank/phone. You can create a new email for your solicitor
Change your phone log in./ undo any cloud.(say you have been hacked, whatever)
Make sure he cant see your correspondence on ipad.
You need to keep your plan private

Krakenwakes · 06/01/2023 18:28

MrsCarson · 06/01/2023 17:57

I may well be wrong, but I thought Inheritance, especially one from before marriage was not a marriage asset. It belongs to the person it was willed to doesn't it?

No, that’s not usually the case, especially as the OP hasn’t ringfenced it. When married, everything is shared jointly, generally. It doesn’t matter who got what money when.

LateAF · 06/01/2023 18:00

The inheritance is likely your money - ask the solicitor about that. I don't think it will be split in the case of a divorce.

Hopefully you will get 50/50. But whatever you do, don't move out of the house. Could your partner pay the mortgage on his own? If not, you might get to stay in the family home if you can buy him out.

MrsCarson · 06/01/2023 17:57

I may well be wrong, but I thought Inheritance, especially one from before marriage was not a marriage asset. It belongs to the person it was willed to doesn't it?

Moanranger · 06/01/2023 17:33

You really need out. You will not lose your kids (have to be seriously neglectful for that to happen.) Financially divorce tends to be a 50-50 split, but you may well do better if you can demonstrate that you put more cash into your assets (eg house purchase) The worst scenario for you : 50-50 split of assets, you keep living in house as needed for kids, he gets shared custody. As he doesn’t actually like taking care of his children, he won’t actually try for full custody (that is just an idle threat)
You won’t have to support him. The courts see through these idle tossers that don’t want to work (that cuts both ways).
Given his gaslighting, this will not be an easy process for you,but you will be SO happy once you have got rid of him.
Good luck!

HaggisBurger · 06/01/2023 17:21

TinselTinselTinsel · 06/01/2023 15:29

Oh god @guffaux that's a terrifying thought. Paying him support for 5 years???

You're right though. We had an argument a few weeks ago and he said something like "Tinsel, you think you're going to win, but you're never going to fucking win"

I hadn't heard his use that language before - he was talking like there was a battle between us.

Someone up thread said don't presume he is happy. I don't presume he is happy at all. But I don't think he will ever leave. I had been hoping he might just up and leave but realise now it's being v passive in my own life.

I will go see a solicitor. But I can't risk losing the kids to him. That just can't ever happen.

Op - people don’t “lose” their kids in divorce situations. The American idea of “custody” is not what happens here. Assuming you are UK based.

Yes - sadly you will probably have to come to a shared care arrangement but the fact that you work more than him doesn’t mean you will end up agreeing to every other weekend. The overriding concern is the well being of the children - and except in cases of abuse that will mean significant time with each parent, 50/50
etc.

If he is a lazy sod you may find him finding the reality of 50/50 without you cleaning up after him etc less than appealing and you end up 80/20 etc

Speak to a good solicitor. Make sure they are family law specialists.

Soothsayer1 · 06/01/2023 17:20

he will instinctively understand that you are cognitively/intellectually above him and won't be able to cope with the feelings of humiliation/anger/confusion that he experiences if he tries to engage on subjects he doesnt understand. Hence he resorts to belligerence and refusal to engage- it's all he's got.
I suspect his tactic is to create a low level sense of menace so that you always feel you have to keep one eye on him just in case and that's why you feel nervous about the fact you were unable (for fear of his reaction) to be truthful about the cost of things

Soothsayer1 · 06/01/2023 17:10

I don't get how I'm scared of him but he is like a child
a full grown adult man with the mentality of a child can be pretty scary, he's the strength to easily over power you and no impulse control when he loses his temper, lacks ability to rationalize and see sense=dangerous lose cannon
I'd be nervous around him too

bonzaitree · 06/01/2023 17:02

Use some of your remaining inheritance money to get some really good legal advice.

Use the remaining money to rent a small, temporary home for you and your children and move out.

AcrossthePond55 · 06/01/2023 16:52

I don't get how I'm scared of him but he is like a child.

He's programmed you to be scared. Being 'like a child' has nothing to do with it. Even a 'child' can be extremely manipulative and tantrums are intimidating. Knowing that someone will shout and throw things will make one do anything to avoid such a 'scene', even lie. Believe me, I've been there, done that, bought the t-shirt, and worn it to shreds!!!

Remember, you do not have to tell him what's 'really' in the savings until the financial settlement negotiations, nor do you have to give him a penny until the divorce is finalized unless the court specifies otherwise. In fact, it is highly suggested that you do NOT divvy finances until you have legal papers signed right and tight.

So, if I were you, I'd say nothing. At least I'd say nothing until we weren't living under the same roof! Then he can scream and shout to his own 4 walls, because you won't be there. Tell him when you can put down the phone or shut your door on him. Just be sure you have receipts/records for what has been spent out of the savings. This is especially important for anything that you've spent in, oh, the last 12 months or so. You want to be able to document that you have not recently 'hidden' money from the account in preparation for divorce.

See a solicitor and save your money AFTER he's no longer entitled to any of it.

GatoradeMeBitch · 06/01/2023 16:42

If you want to leave and you don't want him to take primary residency of the children, you need to be smart about it. Make sure you have proof that you take them to things, spend quality time with them, and so on.

And rather than saving more money to pacify him with, see about hiding it. You need to talk to a good solictor asap.

DollyDaydream55 · 06/01/2023 16:39

I had to break it to you but, there’s no such thing as “your inheritance”. If it came from your aunt, it may be that it’s a shared financial asset. I say this because I inherited from my mum in March. 120K has sat in the joint Acct. and is now part of the marital “pot”. With no blame divorce assets are split 50/50. That’s the starting point and then negotiating starts (unless you’re good with 50/50).

You need some legal/financial advice.

Sandra1984 · 06/01/2023 16:36

If you leave him now he'll get less money than if you leave him further down the line when you have more savings.

Why wait?

Newestname002 · 06/01/2023 16:16

OP, before you do anything, please see a good family law solicitor. Recommendations from a trusted friend (who will keep your confidence) would be good, otherwise check The Law Society website to Find a Solicitor solicitors.lawsociety.org.uk/.

Ensure you get the most value from your appointment by having as much of your (and your husband's) relevant financial information, including pensions.

Don't give him a heads up on what you are doing - use the time to your advantage. 🌹

shreddies · 06/01/2023 16:10

guffaux · 06/01/2023 15:18

Get really good legal advice as soon as possible and legally split as soon as possible.

However much of an unworldly man-child your husband seems to be,you may well be surprised at how financially switched on he becomes when you split.

I have a friend who was in similar circumstances- her now ex took her to the cleaners and wangled half of all assets,including her pension and 5 years spousal support so he could 'adjust' to his new lifestyle (ie grow up and get a job to support himself.

(He did neither, but used the time being supported by her to identify and snare another meal ticket)

This. Every time.

Gymmum82 · 06/01/2023 16:08

Leave and take the children. He doesn’t actually want them. He doesn’t look after them. He just wants to not have to work and be able to sit on his phone all day. He can’t afford to pay for the house on his salary so it’ll either have to be sold or you’ll buy him out.
Either way do not stay another minute with him. Tell him you want a divorce and that’s it. The solicitors can tell him about the money and everything else. That’s their job

Justwonderinghow · 06/01/2023 15:59

Tell him there’s nothing left. He doesn’t get to f about, make no sacrifices, be grumpy about how much staff cost, and then get to keep some of your inheritance.
make periodic withdrawal and put it away for your children because as it stands, it seems he will not be contributing much. You will need the money for day to day as well as any childcare emergencies you might have.

Crumpleton · 06/01/2023 15:51

If you're going to leave him anyway may as well be now
I wouldn't bother saving anymore only to give half to your DH I think you've stumped up for enough yourself already.

Not sure about your dwindling inheritance being only yours that depends on whether it's deemed a matrimonial asset.
It's so important that if you divorce you get a financial order in place.