Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I lied about money. Now I want a divorce. Am I being an idiot/unreasonable?

264 replies

TinselTinselTinsel · 06/01/2023 11:22

DH is a difficult/lazy man. Had lots of support on MN in the past. Going to leave him. He won't listen or change.

Before we married (6 years ago), I inherited from an aunt £60k. We then married. The money has always stayed in my name and in my account.

We spent £20k on the new house and a second car.

Over the last few years, we've had various things go wrong with the house plus childcare for 2 x toddlers, plus pandemic etc.

Anyway - he gets very stressed about money. He doesn't do anything to do with money. Mortgage, bills, car, childcare costs - all down to me to sort to pay and know about. He doesn't even know who our mortgage is with.

Over the last couple of years, I've just downplayed how much things are costing. Because if I tell him "Oh the plumber cost £200" - he will go quiet for 3 days or throw stuff or shout "we haven't got any fucking money" etc, so I just used to say "the plumber cost £100"

I now only have £20k left. He thinks we have £30k to £40k of it left. He last asked how much is left of our savings 6 months ago and I said £35k.

Anyway - I lied. It's £20k.

I now want to leave him. I am the breadwinner. All bills, money, everything in my name. Everything from our savings went on nursery bills and fixing stuff in the house/cars.

I am considering waiting until I've saved up another £10-£15k in my savings account so he doesn't know I spent more on childcare and house that I admitted. But is that crazy behaviour? Does it matter if he finds out that everything cost a bit more than I said it did?

Now one of the kids has got free hours, i am saving every month and probably will get the savings back up to £30-£40k over the next year or two. And then I leave him and he takes half?

Any advice? Should I just leave now and when he asks say "ah yes, there is only £20k left actually"

I know I was wrong to lie. He just gets so angry and stressed about things and he doesn't' really ask anymore but when he did I would just say "it's all fine" because I didn't want to upset him.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WoeBeCome · 13/01/2023 18:42

Awesome!!

bonzaitree · 13/01/2023 17:41

Well done OP this is amazing update!!

how was your day?

UsuallySuze · 12/01/2023 06:46

Hope you enjoy it!

TinselTinselTinsel · 11/01/2023 22:18

I've just booked myself a one night hotel stay with a spa treatment. Out of my savings.

I've never done anything like that.

Fuck it. I'm going to get 8 hours sleep for the 1st time in 4 years.

Hurrah!

OP posts:
Wiluli · 08/01/2023 16:36

Can I ask you a few things I’m unsure , are you in the U.K. and if so what part of the U.K. . When you say he will start screaming , are you scared of what he might do to you or the kids ?

whatthefactuall · 08/01/2023 11:08

Shutthegatepeter · 08/01/2023 10:32

Argumentative woman on mn. Typical. He sounds abusive and controlling to me, so certainly not entirely different circumstances. Nobody needs to continue to live with an abusive, coercive and controlling partner regardless of their financial or living situation. It’s really not hard to get a restraining order, YOU clearly haven’t been through it so 🤫

This 💯

niugboo · 08/01/2023 11:04

@Onebelow the statement you made on 6 Jan is incorrect. She would have to take legal steps to get him out the house but crucially in a mortgaged property this would almost always involve a forced sale unless she wins the house in court and can cover all future costs and potentially pay him out. It’s certainly not as straight forward as you have suggested. It requires a court order, which includes restraining orders which I’m sure you know are court ordered.

niugboo · 08/01/2023 10:58

@Onebelow you told the OP to kick him out. All I clarified was you can’t just do that.

niugboo · 08/01/2023 10:54

@Shutthegatepeter no. Not argumentative. But telling someone they can just kick someone out of their home is not helpful advice and is wrong.

Onebelow · 08/01/2023 10:43

Shutthegatepeter · 08/01/2023 10:32

Argumentative woman on mn. Typical. He sounds abusive and controlling to me, so certainly not entirely different circumstances. Nobody needs to continue to live with an abusive, coercive and controlling partner regardless of their financial or living situation. It’s really not hard to get a restraining order, YOU clearly haven’t been through it so 🤫

This. Exactly this. Thank you. No woman should have to live with someone like this. It’s awful information and down right damaging and incorrect to say that they do. But this is mn, you could say the sky is blue and some woman will argue with you that it’s actually green 🙄 🥱

Shutthegatepeter · 08/01/2023 10:32

niugboo · 08/01/2023 07:58

@Onebelow so entirely different circumstances to the OP. typical. You didn’t just kick him out did you. Because you can’t.

Argumentative woman on mn. Typical. He sounds abusive and controlling to me, so certainly not entirely different circumstances. Nobody needs to continue to live with an abusive, coercive and controlling partner regardless of their financial or living situation. It’s really not hard to get a restraining order, YOU clearly haven’t been through it so 🤫

niugboo · 08/01/2023 07:58

@Onebelow so entirely different circumstances to the OP. typical. You didn’t just kick him out did you. Because you can’t.

Onebelow · 07/01/2023 21:14

niugboo · 07/01/2023 15:20

@Onebelow have you ever tried to get a restraining order?

I referenced occupation order because that would be awarded as part of the restraining order to solve property issues.

it’s far from easy to do and in case here unlikely to be successful. But regardless she can’t just kick him out as you suggested.

Yes, hence why I said I’ve been through it. It really wasn’t difficult for me at all. The police arrested him, his bail conditions said he couldn’t come on the same street our house was on. They fitted 2 silent alarms in my house that when pressed sent a silent signal directly to the police and they would be at my house within minutes. If he was seen hanging around near my house, he would be instantly arrested. I got the restraining order after he answered bail. I asked my landlord to remove him from the tenancy which he did, and he never stepped foot in our house again. Nobody needs to continue to live with an abusive partner, don’t make out to women that it’s really difficult to get rid of an abusive person because it’s really not once you ask for help.

TheMatriarchy · 07/01/2023 17:14

Use the 20K to pay for the best lawyer you can. When you have access to funds in a divorce and your partner does not, it makes a big difference as plenty of SAHMs have discovered sadly. Give him nothing. Take your advantage to get this bullying useless layabout out of yours and your children's lives.

niugboo · 07/01/2023 15:20

@Onebelow have you ever tried to get a restraining order?

I referenced occupation order because that would be awarded as part of the restraining order to solve property issues.

it’s far from easy to do and in case here unlikely to be successful. But regardless she can’t just kick him out as you suggested.

Tiani4 · 07/01/2023 12:24

butterfliedtwo · 06/01/2023 11:31

You want to wait to leave until there is more money to share in the divorce? Nuts.

Agree with this

Make sure it's safe from him as once you leave and have bulk of childcare you'll need that money. By the time you have to put in your finance forms for the divorce you'll find you have even less!! And what you spend until then doesn't count if it's on reasonable expenses. I know because in the year it took to get my divorce finalised my ExDH had spent all our joint savings AND deliberately run up £70k in debt on his own credit cards ! Judge ignored his personal debts but didn't take account of the money he'd wasted from our joint accounts & he burnt through it with expensive holidays and weekends away in hotels.

Make sure you notify your mortgage lender that you are divorcing and no loans are to be made against the house.

Cosmos123 · 07/01/2023 12:07

TinselTinselTinsel · 06/01/2023 11:22

DH is a difficult/lazy man. Had lots of support on MN in the past. Going to leave him. He won't listen or change.

Before we married (6 years ago), I inherited from an aunt £60k. We then married. The money has always stayed in my name and in my account.

We spent £20k on the new house and a second car.

Over the last few years, we've had various things go wrong with the house plus childcare for 2 x toddlers, plus pandemic etc.

Anyway - he gets very stressed about money. He doesn't do anything to do with money. Mortgage, bills, car, childcare costs - all down to me to sort to pay and know about. He doesn't even know who our mortgage is with.

Over the last couple of years, I've just downplayed how much things are costing. Because if I tell him "Oh the plumber cost £200" - he will go quiet for 3 days or throw stuff or shout "we haven't got any fucking money" etc, so I just used to say "the plumber cost £100"

I now only have £20k left. He thinks we have £30k to £40k of it left. He last asked how much is left of our savings 6 months ago and I said £35k.

Anyway - I lied. It's £20k.

I now want to leave him. I am the breadwinner. All bills, money, everything in my name. Everything from our savings went on nursery bills and fixing stuff in the house/cars.

I am considering waiting until I've saved up another £10-£15k in my savings account so he doesn't know I spent more on childcare and house that I admitted. But is that crazy behaviour? Does it matter if he finds out that everything cost a bit more than I said it did?

Now one of the kids has got free hours, i am saving every month and probably will get the savings back up to £30-£40k over the next year or two. And then I leave him and he takes half?

Any advice? Should I just leave now and when he asks say "ah yes, there is only £20k left actually"

I know I was wrong to lie. He just gets so angry and stressed about things and he doesn't' really ask anymore but when he did I would just say "it's all fine" because I didn't want to upset him.

I would have spend the 20k too.n
Said big fat zero.

Pixiedust1234 · 07/01/2023 12:05

Offer him half if he signs the house over.

Ffs don't do this without discussing with a solicitor first! A judge could overturn that and you would still have to give him half. Offer nothing without legal representation, give nothing until rubber stamped by the judge.

Ok, now explain why you married him and had his children when he's an allegeded abusive bum.
Ignore this poster. They can't even be bothered to find out how abusive relationships work.

KnitterNat · 07/01/2023 11:24

Addicted2Kale · 07/01/2023 07:24

What does he contribute? I don't believe you're giving us the full picture, because you married him and stayed for 6 years for a reason. We got the "man bad, tell me to tell him to fuck off, gang" red meat.

Ok, now explain why you married him and had his children when he's an allegeded abusive bum.

You could say this to anyone whose marriage has broken down. People change over time, life (especially having children) can reveal aspects of a personality that weren’t apparent before. Or maybe OP knew her husband was like this pre-marriage and kids but thought he might rise to the occasion, which was a mistake but I’m not sure OP’s claiming not to have made any mistakes 🤷‍♀️

Angeldelight81 · 07/01/2023 09:42

TinselTinselTinsel · 06/01/2023 23:07

Thank you. You've all made me see his anger about the lie about the savings isn't my problem and that I must not go to an effort to fix the lie e.g save more money.

The house and the kids are far far bigger deals. The kids the biggest obviously. I just got fixated on the lie and that if he found out it would confirm that I wasn't to be trusted or that I am sneaky or manipulative (what he accuses me of). If he tries to get 50% custody and 50% of hosue or even worse gets more than 50% then I'll have real issues and this saving account will be the least of my problems

So when are you booked in to see this Solicitor ? Because I’ve been reading about this now for five weeks. A divorce could be done in 12. You could be halfway there by now.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/01/2023 07:25

Addicted2Kale · 07/01/2023 07:24

What does he contribute? I don't believe you're giving us the full picture, because you married him and stayed for 6 years for a reason. We got the "man bad, tell me to tell him to fuck off, gang" red meat.

Ok, now explain why you married him and had his children when he's an allegeded abusive bum.

🙄

If you read OP's posts, you'll see why.

What a rubbish, inaccurate summary of what's been said.

Addicted2Kale · 07/01/2023 07:24

What does he contribute? I don't believe you're giving us the full picture, because you married him and stayed for 6 years for a reason. We got the "man bad, tell me to tell him to fuck off, gang" red meat.

Ok, now explain why you married him and had his children when he's an allegeded abusive bum.

EarringsandLipstick · 07/01/2023 06:46

@TinselTinselTinsel

I'm in the middle of divorce proceedings - 9 years separated, that's how long it's taken to get to this point - with an extremely manipulative ex, who as I mentioned up thread, spent every penny and more that he could get his hands on in our marriage.

I would bet any money that regarding the DC, whatever he purports to want, in practice, he will not want to have to care for them on his own, and you will end up having them most of the time.

I think the house will be an issue - it's certainly a huge sticking point in my situation, notwithstanding that I've paid the mortgage for 9 years.

I also think he'll use the fact of his p/t work as evidence of being a SAHD for part of the time and will look for spousal maintenance. (From MN I gather that's much harder to get in the UK than Ireland - where I am).

You need to get proactive. Research a good solicitor, ask around for first-hand experience. Get moving on this asap, this man has taken enough of your life, time to move on. 💐

JudgeRudy · 07/01/2023 06:07

Are you under the impression that the savings are yours because they're in your account/name? It's really not as clear cut when you're married. I wouldn't be saving anything at this stage (in a bank account).
You don't want to stay with him. There's nothing to be gained by staying (unless there's a backstory).
Get legal advice, then tell him you want a divorce and take it from there. When he asks why admit that your sick of being responsible for everything including protecting him from your money problems and just cant do it anymore (without your buffer it would be a problem).
Do you own your home? If you intend to stay there maybe a lumpsum could be just the incentive he needs for a clean break. Offer him half if he signs the house over. You can sort childcare maintenance out later (but don't hold your breath)

Onebelow · 07/01/2023 01:58

niugboo · 06/01/2023 14:04

@Onebelow you are wrong I’m afraid. If the property is in both their names she cannot just kick him out. You would need an occupation order.

If he is abusive, she can get a restraining order, and he literally won’t be allowed on that street, never mind in the house. I’ve been through it so I know. You do not have to live with an abusive man just because his name is on the mortgage.