Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taxi driver emotionally blackmailing me

381 replies

AmberAndAlexsMum · 06/01/2023 05:54

Sounds drastic I know, but my ds (17) goes to an SEN college, which is 25 miles away. He gets a taxi, paid for by the council, to take him and bring him back.

Now ds has severe sleep issues, he's had all his life, and sometimes he simply cannot sleep at night and ends up too exhausted to go in. If this happens I always text the driver as early as possible.

Over the last 6 months or so, every time I've texted him to say ds isn't going in, he's responded by complaining that he's losing money as he only gets paid when the kids go in.

I appreciate that, but surely he doesn't have the right to emotionally blackmail me? He knows I'm empathic and don't like causing problems, but I'm beginning to think that he is deliberately doing this.

AIBU to expect him to accept that ds can't always go to college? I've had no problems with previous drivers and I always make sure to let them know before they leave home.

OP posts:
Namechange828492 · 06/01/2023 16:21

He has no right to vent at OP, she has no control over the situation. He could vent to thr council and try and negotiate being paid if the job is cancelled last minute.

2bazookas · 06/01/2023 16:11

what "emotional blackmail"?? He's not demanding anyhting from you, just pointing out a fact of life.

LaDamaDeElche · 06/01/2023 15:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

waynesworldpartytimeexcellent · 06/01/2023 15:29

Perplexin · 06/01/2023 15:24

I used to work in the call centre for a taxi company and I can empathise with the driver.

Based on my own experiences, the driver is taken out of service for the time it takes to get to you and collect the passenger, drive to the destination and return back to 'home area'. The pay rate for these jobs are fixed and are also undervalued for what would be a 'normal' booking. This means that when you cancel, jobs at the full rate that could have been assigned to the driver but weren't as he was allocated you are either given elsewhere or told their journey can't be done.

Most of the drivers at my work ended up refusing to do 'school account' runs for this very reason. They would lose out on a substantial amount of money weekly because of absences and the lower rate.

I sympathise with you and think it's difficult from both sides to be honest. I wouldn't say he's emotionally blackmailing you though, probably just venting his frustration.

Finally some sense!

Perplexin · 06/01/2023 15:24

I used to work in the call centre for a taxi company and I can empathise with the driver.

Based on my own experiences, the driver is taken out of service for the time it takes to get to you and collect the passenger, drive to the destination and return back to 'home area'. The pay rate for these jobs are fixed and are also undervalued for what would be a 'normal' booking. This means that when you cancel, jobs at the full rate that could have been assigned to the driver but weren't as he was allocated you are either given elsewhere or told their journey can't be done.

Most of the drivers at my work ended up refusing to do 'school account' runs for this very reason. They would lose out on a substantial amount of money weekly because of absences and the lower rate.

I sympathise with you and think it's difficult from both sides to be honest. I wouldn't say he's emotionally blackmailing you though, probably just venting his frustration.

Bepis · 06/01/2023 14:37

AmberAndAlexsMum · 06/01/2023 14:22

There's another boy in the taxi, also with sen, who is there 2 out of the 3 days they go.

My DH used to be a passenger assistant for SEN children on the school runs (it's how we met 😁). He said that if there is 1 child in the taxi then he will still get paid. So if the other boy was going on the days your son had off, the driver would have still been paid for the run. If not, DH said he could have just gone on the taxi ranks anyway and earned money.

AmberAndAlexsMum · 06/01/2023 14:22

There's another boy in the taxi, also with sen, who is there 2 out of the 3 days they go.

OP posts:
SensationalSusie · 06/01/2023 14:13

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/01/2023 13:56

The boy is now 17 and there may be other treatments and medications/dosages available that were not in childhood. It’s a very valid point that revisiting medication/therapies at this point for sleep issues is necessary. Particularly at a stressful time.

I always love it on these threads when people feel the need to talk to the parents of disabled (or ill) children like they’re stupid and haven’t thought of things.

Its not a remotely valid point when it’s not the point of the thread.

Its insulting to the OP when people suggest there are things she could be doing but isn’t

@YetMoreNewBeginnings

I am a parent of a disabled child and a disabled person myself.

Sometimes you are so tired dealing with the shit it is hard to step back and see all options available.

I have always appreciated people giving me input and support when things are challenging.

Any suggestions made are supportive and are not to critique OP or undermine her intelligence and experience. But to give her confidence and hope in pursuing further treatment now that her son is becoming an adult.

Also, it is relevant to the thread. If he was able to sleep easier and more settled the issue with the taxi driver would not have escalated.

Tessisme · 06/01/2023 14:07

Sorry, repeated myself a bit there!!

Tessisme · 06/01/2023 14:06

Fearnecuptea · 06/01/2023 13:43

If you cancel within 24 hours the driver should still be paid, that's completely reasonable.

Cancelling 4 times since September plus unknown number of sick days (should we assume a week?) means that poor driver has not been paid during those times. That adds up. If the shoe was on the other foot how would you feel to rely on those wages and then not get them?

It's definitely not emotional blackmail.

Do you think the OP should pay him? If not, then how is telling her his tale of woe going to make any difference? Do you think the OP should pay him? If so, why, when it's a service funded by the council? Who do you think should pay him?

By the way, I'm not suggesting for one minute that he shouldn't be paid, just that it's really not the fault/responsibility of the OP, whose child has an unpredictable health condition.

waynesworldpartytimeexcellent · 06/01/2023 14:05

Well, no, we shouldn't assume a week of sick days without evidence. School taxi drivers must surely be well aware of the risk of their charges getting ill in the autumn term, particularly with risking flu and covid infections. If they can't accommodate that risk they're in the wrong business.

So who does it then? Rich people who don't mind if their wages are down? How would you like if you were available for work and your job said...ahhh no, don't need you this morning and by the way... you don't get paid. Cop the hell on.

Bepis · 06/01/2023 14:04

Op is there only your son in this taxi or are there other children too?

SnowlayRoundabout · 06/01/2023 14:03

Fearnecuptea · 06/01/2023 13:43

If you cancel within 24 hours the driver should still be paid, that's completely reasonable.

Cancelling 4 times since September plus unknown number of sick days (should we assume a week?) means that poor driver has not been paid during those times. That adds up. If the shoe was on the other foot how would you feel to rely on those wages and then not get them?

It's definitely not emotional blackmail.

Well, no, we shouldn't assume a week of sick days without evidence. School taxi drivers must surely be well aware of the risk of their charges getting ill in the autumn term, particularly with risking flu and covid infections. If they can't accommodate that risk they're in the wrong business.

waynesworldpartytimeexcellent · 06/01/2023 14:01

I was thinking that he would probably get paid regardless of whether he took the child too? That’s what various taxi firms have told me when they have been contacted to take my child to school/college. Of course they prefer to have notice that they’re not needed but we know it doesn’t always work like that

WHY on EARTH would he berate the mother if he was getting paid anyway? That makes NO fucking sense. He gets a phone call saying he doesn't have to do the drop is a godsend for those who get paid anyway. You stay put and don't have to do the bloody run. The man WANTS to do the drop because he DOES NOT get paid otherwise.

Christ Alfuckingmighty. This is an issue with the Cab firm for not paying him.

SnowlayRoundabout · 06/01/2023 13:57

LancelotsLeftArm · 06/01/2023 11:41

Therefore the taxi driver is lacking empathy

But the taxi driver is being expected to keep himself available at all times that the DS needs transport, even if it's then cancelled. WOuld you like being on call like this, and receive no payment?

This is a crappy employment/self employment setup with the council.

The issue here is the council taking the piss with a man who has bills, a mortgage etc.

Driver shouldn't be putting this on the service user (OP) but the real issue is the council exploiting workers.

I doubt that it's down to the council. They will have their own contract with the cab firm, almost certainly on the basis that they pay a set amount irrespective of how many children are travelling each day - I doubt that the bureaucracy involve in tracking each journey is really justified. If there is a crappy employment set-up, it will relate to the arrangement between the cab company and its drivers.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/01/2023 13:56

The boy is now 17 and there may be other treatments and medications/dosages available that were not in childhood. It’s a very valid point that revisiting medication/therapies at this point for sleep issues is necessary. Particularly at a stressful time.

I always love it on these threads when people feel the need to talk to the parents of disabled (or ill) children like they’re stupid and haven’t thought of things.

Its not a remotely valid point when it’s not the point of the thread.

Its insulting to the OP when people suggest there are things she could be doing but isn’t

stopringingme · 06/01/2023 13:54

VegetableGyoza · 06/01/2023 10:11

@stopringingme I was thinking that he would probably get paid regardless of whether he took the child too? That’s what various taxi firms have told me when they have been contacted to take my child to school/college. Of course they prefer to have notice that they’re not needed but we know it doesn’t always work like that.

The amount of ablism on this thread is depressing but not surprising.

@VegetableGoyoza I had to step away from this thread because of the sheer number of posters who do not know what they are talking about and still feel the need to comment and insult people who live this life all day every day.

You are correct the money from the LA does go to the taxi firm and they pay the drivers and chaperones, with my DD'S school she gets the same driver and chaperone every day and the taxi firms contract comes up for renewal every year. They get over £6k per child per school year, they also get money for cleaning if the child has an accident.

Your last line says it all : The amount of ableism on this thread is depressing but not surprising.

SensationalSusie · 06/01/2023 13:48

@SnowlayRoundabout

Of course my experience is not universal - there is a spectrum, and individual differences too.

It doesn’t really matter if there is an A level syllabus or whatever, any missed work or dipping in and out of the normal routine will be stressful and cause disorientation in an autistic person, particularly if it is repeated.

The boy is now 17 and there may be other treatments and medications/dosages available that were not in childhood. It’s a very valid point that revisiting medication/therapies at this point for sleep issues is necessary. Particularly at a stressful time.

As for the “autumn sickness is normal”… if it is repeatedly and of extended duration it isn’t normal. And any sickness will be less tolerated when an autistic person is stressed and sensory experiences are heightened.

I hope OP is able to resolve the issue by getting a new driver, and that some progress can be made to make things easier for her son to manage.

Bepis · 06/01/2023 13:47

Fearnecuptea · 06/01/2023 13:43

If you cancel within 24 hours the driver should still be paid, that's completely reasonable.

Cancelling 4 times since September plus unknown number of sick days (should we assume a week?) means that poor driver has not been paid during those times. That adds up. If the shoe was on the other foot how would you feel to rely on those wages and then not get them?

It's definitely not emotional blackmail.

What is OP meant to do though? She can't man handle her son and make him go.

Fearnecuptea · 06/01/2023 13:43

If you cancel within 24 hours the driver should still be paid, that's completely reasonable.

Cancelling 4 times since September plus unknown number of sick days (should we assume a week?) means that poor driver has not been paid during those times. That adds up. If the shoe was on the other foot how would you feel to rely on those wages and then not get them?

It's definitely not emotional blackmail.

Herejustforthisone · 06/01/2023 13:33

He really shouldn’t be putting that onto a parent of a child with SEN. He should take it up with his employer. I’d be tempted to show the messages to his employer to see if I could be allocated a driver that wasn’t going to send me emotional claptrap because my child with additional needs wasn’t able to attend their educational placement sometimes due to complications of said needs.

SnowlayRoundabout · 06/01/2023 13:33

SensationalSusie · 06/01/2023 11:28

Because she’s said he has been sick a lot and off college too which just creates a vicious cycle. (Missing work = more pressure = higher stress)

When I’m stressed my cortisol levels go up which impacts the immune system and I tend to get sick A LOT.

This has been my whole life, and tends to occur when I’m changing college/Uni/job in particular with the huge change and new things/people to get used to.

Happens a lot with autistics.

If the sleep is disrupted majorly this also has major impact on health. If it could even be resolved for a short period maybe 6-8 weeks it could help him to stay more resilient, not get sick and cope with the transition to college better… is my thinking.

I found it helped me when moving somewhere new/around assessment times - had less time off as wasn’t exhausted and got sick much less.

She didn't say he had had a lot of time off for sickness, just that he had had some sickness in addition to the four days attributable to the tiredness problem. That is hardly surprising in the autumn term. For all we know, it was a couple of days. He is at an SEN college which has already said he should not come in if he is overtired, so it's likely that they have a system in place to deal with missing work - it's not like, say, missing a chunk of the A level syllabus.

If OP could resolve the sleep problem easily, do you imagine she would not be doing so? As has been pointed out, your experience really is not universal for all people with ASD.

Stravaig · 06/01/2023 12:16

Well done, OP. The taxi driver is being unprofessional in complaining to you.

It is two distinct issues. The driver should contact his taxi firm and ask to be reallocated. The taxi firm should renegotiate with the council if their contract has unreasonable cancellation terms. However, it may be the taxi firm exploiting their driver by not passing on payment made irrespective of cancellation.

OP's contact is with the council who provide her son with transport. The driver allocated does not have the necessary awareness or experience for this booking. The council should have ensured appropriate diversity training before awarding the contract. It sounds like they'll sort this out.

AtomicRitual · 06/01/2023 12:08

As someone with a SEN sibling the ignorance of other posters is, unfortunately, not a surprise to me.

The amount of times over the years my DP's have been shouted at for parking in a disabled bay. "You shouldn't be parking there - you can walk!", then not even backing down when they see a massive wheelchair being brought out of the boot, because, you know, disabled spaces are only for disabled drivers.

Or the people that just stand there and stare when they see a severely disabled person...

Or the ones that tell you you're "lucky" that the LA put on transport (that picks up at 7am) so your DC can go to a school an hour away, while their poor little darling has to walk half a mile to their primary school.

Times were really tough for our family due to my sibling. There was no way my DM could work as there was no holiday care provision and no family support for looking after my sibling. They got one week's respite care a year and that was in term-time. As a result, my DF regularly worked 60 hour weeks, just to make ends meet and we were still really hard up. My DM admitted over Christmas that as much as she loves my sibling, it really had a massive negative impact on their lives and things could have been so different for them.

Parenting a SEN child is hard. It nearly broke my DM, who later told me she was so depressed she'd even chosen her suicide method, so that no-one would ever find her.

As my sibling's SEN is due to a genetic condition, seeing my DM going through that is probably the main reason that I don't have any children. In my head my DM is the strongest woman I know and it nearly broke her. I was so worried that there was no way I'd cope if it happened to me too.

I can understand why OP has taken the taxi driver's comments to heart.

MsRosley · 06/01/2023 12:06

watchfulwishes · 06/01/2023 06:07

YANBU. Is texting him direct the usual way to contact - he doesn't work for a firm?

I often go ultra polite when people piss me off and I might reply 'Oh, I quite understand, would you prefer I ask the council for a different driver to be allocated so that you are free to do other work? There is no way I can guarantee every day due to complex needs, as you know, and I think the driver we use needs to understand that'.

He is being unprofessional IMO, he knows that taxi driving is unreliable work, it is the nature of the business.

You presumably do have the option of discussing this with whoever pays - or did you pick the driver yourself?

Also, cop out but sometes easier, do you have a male partner who could take over the taxi comms? Bet they'd get less shit.

Bang on the nail.

Swipe left for the next trending thread