Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taxi driver emotionally blackmailing me

381 replies

AmberAndAlexsMum · 06/01/2023 05:54

Sounds drastic I know, but my ds (17) goes to an SEN college, which is 25 miles away. He gets a taxi, paid for by the council, to take him and bring him back.

Now ds has severe sleep issues, he's had all his life, and sometimes he simply cannot sleep at night and ends up too exhausted to go in. If this happens I always text the driver as early as possible.

Over the last 6 months or so, every time I've texted him to say ds isn't going in, he's responded by complaining that he's losing money as he only gets paid when the kids go in.

I appreciate that, but surely he doesn't have the right to emotionally blackmail me? He knows I'm empathic and don't like causing problems, but I'm beginning to think that he is deliberately doing this.

AIBU to expect him to accept that ds can't always go to college? I've had no problems with previous drivers and I always make sure to let them know before they leave home.

OP posts:
BritAbroad101 · 07/01/2023 15:38

browneyes77 · 06/01/2023 18:19

As someone who has a young nephew with Autism, I am absolutely disgusted and bewildered with some of the attitudes on this thread.

Even if you don’t have much understanding of SEN, the OP’s initial post was perfectly clear in terms of the struggles her DS has because of it.

Some real ignorant thicko’s on here.

If you’re going to call people thick then at least use correct grammar yourself 😂🥴

(no apostrophe in thickos clever clogs)

EightChalk · 07/01/2023 13:37

I am so surprised by the number of posts saying it's reasonable for the taxi driver to express his frustration to the OP. On what planet is it ok for him to make ANY comment, negative or positive, about his working arrangements to her?! It is completely inappropriate that he has ever mentioned this to her, never mind repeatedly doing so. His emotional response to this has literally nothing to do with her whatsoever, and it's not ok in the slightest to make her aware of it.

Tiani4 · 07/01/2023 12:45

JudgeRudy · 07/01/2023 04:11

I don't think he BU by expressing his disappointment/frustration unless of course he's demanding you drag your son in.
If it's happening regularly would it be more practical to call/text him in the morning when you DO want a lift. That way at least he gets a lie in.

Transport contracts don't work like that at all. Not when the council are arranging and have contracted for it.
Besides the taxi driver ought be paid as I'm almost 95% certain that the taxi firm are being paid for short notice cancellations.

Tiani4 · 07/01/2023 12:42

Our LA adults transport arrangement is that taxi firm has a standard contract with set day and timed bookings that taxi firm invoice for monthly and are paid if less than 24 hours notice of cancellation.

Besides the LA finance dept doesn't monitor if you cancelled or not, they just pay out on what contract says, so you'd have to let them (council) know. Not in your interest to do so really for an odd day here - only worth doing for eg a (known ahead of time) week off due to sickness or holiday that can be put on as a break or variation.

@AmberAndAlexsMum please be reassured that missing one day a month out of 3-5 days a week attendance at college really is not a big deal at all in terms of transport arrangements. The council benefit from lower rates with set booking so it more than evens out.
Infact missing one day a month on average is an excellent average success rate for a young adult or minor child with SEN disabilities. His needs are known because they've been assessed, so don't worry about that aspect.

You're doing brilliantly. Glad you are letting the council deal with it. Everything you are doing is what we'd expect a reasonable (by contacting taxi driver direct as soon as you know) and caring Mum of a disabled child to do.

As others have said if you rang the council or even the taxi company direct the individual driver wouldn't get the message until too late!

JudgeRudy · 07/01/2023 04:11

I don't think he BU by expressing his disappointment/frustration unless of course he's demanding you drag your son in.
If it's happening regularly would it be more practical to call/text him in the morning when you DO want a lift. That way at least he gets a lie in.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/01/2023 03:33

on our area at least (& I expect most others) there's not much work, lots of jobs that actually cost to do, but drivers do to help people out.

Round here school runs are sought after.

They’re two guaranteed hires at quiet times of the day, 5 days a week, 39 weeks of the year. Much more reliable an income than they get at any other time.

Whenever DD has a temporary driver (her usual one has had some health issues this year) they’re always super friendly and extra helpful and never fail to mention that if she has preference we can always let the company know.

SproutsLCerVEGNoEgg · 07/01/2023 02:47

SpicyFoodRocks · 06/01/2023 10:44

He has bills to pay too & if you're regularly telling him not to come because you're letting DS stay home because he's tired, it's not surprising he's frustrated (IF it's correct that he doesn't get paid)

But what should OP do? Her son’s school has told him not to come in if he is exhausted. His brain will not allow him to fall asleep some nights. It isn’t that he is up all night partying or on his Xbox. If her son has not slept and cannot go to school exhausted, what exactly do you think she should do?

The driver’s lot is not easy. But that is not for the OP to be able to sort out.

@SpicyFoodRocks

I'm well versed (sadly) with the issues of teenagers (and now young adults & adults) with SEN of varying degrees) but I don't expect other people to understand & what they hear is 'didn't sleep, tired, not going in'.

I haven't said the OP can or should' deal with it'. I've simply pointed out the issues from the drivers point of view to counter act all of the posts against the driver and tried to explain why 'get a different driver' isn't as easy as all that.

It's not blackmailing, not in any way. He's just stating facts (and you'd be surprised at how personal some parents get about things & how much they complain about personal things) & having a whinge (admittedly to the wrong set of ears) but to accuse him of blackmailing is beyond the pale/pail.

SproutsLCerVEGNoEgg · 07/01/2023 02:38

amyneedssleep · 06/01/2023 10:53

And all of this should have been explained to him by his employer (ie not the OP) before he agreed to the job.

You make it sound as though taking on a contracted job isn't worth it. Clearly it is, as thousands of drivers up and down the country are doing them quite happily every day.

I feel for taxi drivers on a employee level as they don't seem to have very good protection in place, but they should under no circumstances be expressing their frustration to people like the OP who has nothing to do with their employment rights.

@amyneedssleep

would you care to c&p the part where I said he was correct to bent his frustration to the OP?

you won't be able to because I didn't.

also I dispute the Quite Happily!! It's necessity not joy.

on our area at least (& I expect most others) there's not much work, lots of jobs that actually cost to do, but drivers do to help people out.

councils (at least in our area & I assume all throughout England at least) deal with the school runs. Often drivers don't generally work for companies, because that's even more shit than working for yourself. It's a long & complicated tale how certain companies companies got allowed to bid for school runs & for several years no new ones have been allowed to bid. So the old companies have them all and allocate them to drivers (they don't have enough drivers, so they give them to self employed taxi drivers for a cut. Drivers then invoice them for runs completed.

If a driver can't do a run one day (illness, or car problem), they have to find another driver, that driver has to have a taxi licence, a DBS, and be available. It's fucking hard to find anyone (it's a bit of a dog eat dog industry and so if you find one, they want the netted rate, which is usually at least twice as much, if not more, than the school run rate, so they're well out of pocket too. If the can't find someone, they lose the contract.

they take the contracts because at least it's money coming in. But Sod's law means they then turn down more valuable work.

councils won't budge
companies that get these runs aren't in it for love
& the driver gets the worst if it.

yes it's their choice, but with things how they are, it's not much of a bloody choice, just a necessity & a gamble.)

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/01/2023 22:49

waynesworldpartytimeexcellent · 06/01/2023 19:55

No, you need to cop the hell on. That's the nature of taxi work, and the nature of self-employment. Who the hell do you imagine guarantees a minimum level of work to taxi drivers in the normal course of things

Most taxi drivers work from a base and are sent as jobs come in. Or they work for themselves and work from an app. This man has been commissioned for work that he cannot do. Cannot pick up someone else or make up the money. Like booking a beautician’s time and cancelling 15 mins before your arrival. So your argument doesn’t stand. Bet you would feel differently if it were your other half coming home short changed from work he was booked in for you were struggling with bills. COP ON!

Well no he can’t take another job because it turns out there’s another child.

which begs far more questions about the not getting paid part

When my DD doesn’t go to school her driver hits “job cancelled” on his app and the system has him as available for other work instantly. So can get on with the next job available

ASimpleLampoon · 06/01/2023 22:35

AmberAndAlexsMum · 06/01/2023 10:06

Thank you all.

I have just spoken to a lovely lady at the LA, who contacted the relevant officer. They have already started the ball rolling and have promised to contact me ASAP.

Also thanks to everyone who clearly understand what it's like having a disabled child. I was feeling that maybe ds problems are my fault rather than his autism, but you have made me see that his sleep problems are not unusual or a product of lazy parenting. Even melatonin only worked for a week 🙂, and I have not had a full night's sleep in 17 years.

Gets a bit tiring from time to time 🙂

Oh Op! Breaks my heart to see parents internalize that blame...

Both me and my D'S are autistic my D'S in specialist school too. I haven't slept more than 2 hours at a time in my life. Nothing can be done its just how I am! It's nothing to do with your parenting..

FeinCuroxiVooz · 06/01/2023 21:28

where in the country is so over supplied with taxis that this driver can't get assigned an alternative fare within 4 minutes of having the regular job cancelled? around school run time if you try to call for a private hire car of any kind you'll be told it's a half hour or 45 minute wait if you haven't prebooked as all drivers are out on school contract work. any car becoming unexpectedly available will be snapped up in moments

Jakadaal · 06/01/2023 21:15

The contract is between him and the local authority not with you and your son. Contact your LA and let them know what he is saying

waynesworldpartytimeexcellent · 06/01/2023 19:55

No, you need to cop the hell on. That's the nature of taxi work, and the nature of self-employment. Who the hell do you imagine guarantees a minimum level of work to taxi drivers in the normal course of things

Most taxi drivers work from a base and are sent as jobs come in. Or they work for themselves and work from an app. This man has been commissioned for work that he cannot do. Cannot pick up someone else or make up the money. Like booking a beautician’s time and cancelling 15 mins before your arrival. So your argument doesn’t stand. Bet you would feel differently if it were your other half coming home short changed from work he was booked in for you were struggling with bills. COP ON!

GlomOfNit · 06/01/2023 19:11

Lots of people here who don't seem to understand how LA-funded SEN transport works! (or should do)

Surely OP, the LA/council have a contract with this guy or his firm because it's a daily booking, not a matter of someone ringing him up every morning? And if so, he's retained by them and ought to get paid regardless. DS is in a minibus from a taxi firm to his special school and shares it with others - if they were all ill, I have no doubt that his driver and escort would still get paid. So if the council are being slapdash or shoddy, he should take it up with them, but I can't imagine how a council would have a long-term booking with a taxi firm that falls through every time the client (your son) is unable to travel.

At any rate, it's NOT your problem and not your son's fault. The driver may well be out of pocket if the council's being crap but clearly that's where he needs to take any complaints. These sorts of setbacks are just part of the territory of transporting people with SEN.

SnowlayRoundabout · 06/01/2023 18:31

wormshuffled · 06/01/2023 18:28

@SnowlayRoundabout

I'm afraid you don't know what you're talking about. They are mostly Private Hire taxis that do school runs. Also all licensed drivers must be DBS checked and most LA's require them to be signed up to the update service for easy checking.

On the contrary, I know exactly what I'm talking about. If private hire taxis do school runs, it is almost always on a sub-contract arrangement with taxi firms.

wormshuffled · 06/01/2023 18:28

@SnowlayRoundabout

I'm afraid you don't know what you're talking about. They are mostly Private Hire taxis that do school runs. Also all licensed drivers must be DBS checked and most LA's require them to be signed up to the update service for easy checking.

browneyes77 · 06/01/2023 18:19

As someone who has a young nephew with Autism, I am absolutely disgusted and bewildered with some of the attitudes on this thread.

Even if you don’t have much understanding of SEN, the OP’s initial post was perfectly clear in terms of the struggles her DS has because of it.

Some real ignorant thicko’s on here.

SnowlayRoundabout · 06/01/2023 17:47

wormshuffled · 06/01/2023 16:30

It's not accurate to say that the taxi firm will get paid anyway. The contract is for the firm to provide taxis, not a set fee for this. The taxi firm then invoices the council for the requested lifts. Yes in some councils there will be a late cancellation clause but not all.
Not to add more fuel to the fire but the same taxi firms will also have contracts to ferry nurses and doctors to hospitals that are not their usual place of work. Again invoiced after the event as it is an unknown quantity/ distance in advance.
Another inaccuracy here is to assume the 'emotionally blackmailing' taxi driver is employed by a firm. There are thousands of individuals who are set up as Private Hire Operators and the only person driving is themselves. Most Uber drivers are also Private Hire Operators.

But it's highly unlikely that a private hire operator has a contract with a local authority to provide school transport. LAs have to go through a tendering process and have to impose various requirements, e.g. that there is a stand-in with the appropriate DBS checks if any individual driver isn't available.

ASimpleLampoon · 06/01/2023 17:43

Yanbu. This goes with the territory of SEN . And too many people in the SEN system think it's OK to speak to Mums as if they are s hit on their shoe.

SnowlayRoundabout · 06/01/2023 17:40

waynesworldpartytimeexcellent · 06/01/2023 14:05

Well, no, we shouldn't assume a week of sick days without evidence. School taxi drivers must surely be well aware of the risk of their charges getting ill in the autumn term, particularly with risking flu and covid infections. If they can't accommodate that risk they're in the wrong business.

So who does it then? Rich people who don't mind if their wages are down? How would you like if you were available for work and your job said...ahhh no, don't need you this morning and by the way... you don't get paid. Cop the hell on.

No, you need to cop the hell on. That's the nature of taxi work, and the nature of self-employment. Who the hell do you imagine guarantees a minimum level of work to taxi drivers in the normal course of things?

Tessisme · 06/01/2023 17:20

2bazookas · 06/01/2023 16:11

what "emotional blackmail"?? He's not demanding anyhting from you, just pointing out a fact of life.

Right, so he's saying it just because it's true? Why? Why bother if it isn't to imply that OP should make sure her child gets into that taxi come hell or high water. Sounds a bit like ... oh I dunno, emotional blackmail perhaps? At the very least, he's taking out his frustrations on the wrong person.

Bignanny30 · 06/01/2023 17:14

So they should

Perplexin · 06/01/2023 17:07

(I realised I'd missed out some of what I wanted to say in my previous comment)

It was wrong of the driver to message you regardless of x amount of previous absences or frustration on his part. Drivers would have been disciplined at my work for that behaviour, more so of it being an account booking.

All councils are different with their contracted account clauses. Some jobs will be paid only if completed, others will only have payment if there is a collection, some will be paid once the driver has began his journey even if cancelled on the way e.t.c. It really does vary council to council and contract to contract.

The frustration for the account bookings comes from time doing them in comparison to the pay.
As an example, let's say a journey from A to B that takes 30 minutes of a drivers time to fully complete. A normal job with the usual rates would be, let's say £25. However, if it were an account job it could be as little as £17 in comparison. This also doesn't factor in that on an account job there are no extra charges for getting stuck in traffic e.t.c so time is money unless it's an account. This is why there is such a frustration with account bookings in my experience.

That being said, I would maybe mention this situation to the taxi company or the council. His frustrations is not your problem.

Namechange828492 · 06/01/2023 16:38

Previous posters have said that their driver does indeed get paid if they are a no show. It seems to vary between councils.

Glad it's being sorted OP x

wormshuffled · 06/01/2023 16:30

It's not accurate to say that the taxi firm will get paid anyway. The contract is for the firm to provide taxis, not a set fee for this. The taxi firm then invoices the council for the requested lifts. Yes in some councils there will be a late cancellation clause but not all.
Not to add more fuel to the fire but the same taxi firms will also have contracts to ferry nurses and doctors to hospitals that are not their usual place of work. Again invoiced after the event as it is an unknown quantity/ distance in advance.
Another inaccuracy here is to assume the 'emotionally blackmailing' taxi driver is employed by a firm. There are thousands of individuals who are set up as Private Hire Operators and the only person driving is themselves. Most Uber drivers are also Private Hire Operators.

Swipe left for the next trending thread