Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think I’ve just been banned from mumsnet

70 replies

Letsallgototherapyagain · 05/01/2023 23:12

I recently wrote a post sharing my experiences of being hit by an au pair when I was a child.

I got an email notification saying someone had added a reply to the thread but when I clicked on the link to see my thread, I was shocked and confused to find that it had been deleted for breaking talk guidelines.

I also noticed that I was no longer logged in. It says my account has been deactivated.

I NC for the first time when I wrote that recent post but I’ve been here for years.

I’m really shocked and feel really upset about it actually.

I have no emails from mumsnet explaining what’s happened or why this has happened.

When I tried to sign up again it came up with an error message stating that no new registrations are being accepted!

I wondered if this was personal to me (I.e my email has been banned from being registered) and I think that’s the case because when I attempted to register with my Apple ID and chose not to share my email, it let me sign up and I created this account.

I have emailed Mumsnet and asked them what’s going on.

I will also report this post in the hopes of getting the attention of a moderator so they can help me.

Has anyone ever had this happen to them? It’s a really horrible experience.

Does anyone remember my post? If so, have you any idea at why it got deleted?

OP posts:
SoupDragon · 06/01/2023 07:51

Most likely it was just a mistake.

did you just name change or did you set up a new account?

Tessisme · 06/01/2023 07:47

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 06:43

It doesn't sound the same but I got suspended once. I couldn't login. Turns out it was because I'd used two different usernames on one thread. Total accident but my fault. Once they had an acknowledgement from me of what I'd done, they gave me a warning and reactivated me.
Is it possible you did something similar on a different thread? Or transgressed a different rule? But you should get an email with an explanation, though. (It too me several days to find mine!)

Crikey, I've done that quite a few times - usually when I've changed username, then later gone back to comment on a long running thread. I change back to the name on the old thread for consistency, then forget after one or two comments and pop up looking like a new poster! I haven't had an email though. I suppose someone would have to report it for it to be questioned by Mumsnet.

MayThe4th · 06/01/2023 07:25

Getinajollymood · 06/01/2023 07:14

I reported the thread.

I don’t know if the OP is genuine or not but either way it was an extremely graphic description of child abuse and even if the OP derived no pleasure from recounting it someone will have.

There is a post over a decade old about being hit as a child and experiences of this and there are men all over it - clearly googled some questionable stuff about little girls and discipline Hmm

I didn’t read the thread in question, but if it was as graphic as you say then I can understand why it was reported, and I can understand why it was removed.

But if the OP has a clear previous posting history then MN should be looking at that before banning, even if the thread is inappropriate and not allowed to stand.

Hopefully if someone has reported to MN HQ. They will come on and clarify whether the OP actually does have the posting history she claims, although if it is a graphic thread I don’t think it should be reinstated, and a public forum is probably not the best place to write in graphic detail about abuse you have suffered.

liveforsummer · 06/01/2023 07:25

RambamThankyouMam · 06/01/2023 06:36

But how are you posting if you've been banned?

She explains it right there in the OP. Try reading it again!

HaddawayAndShite · 06/01/2023 07:16

sorrynotathome · 06/01/2023 07:10

Thank you! I thought I was going mad…

Her original account was banned, she created a new account with different log in details. It says it right in the OP

Getinajollymood · 06/01/2023 07:14

I reported the thread.

I don’t know if the OP is genuine or not but either way it was an extremely graphic description of child abuse and even if the OP derived no pleasure from recounting it someone will have.

There is a post over a decade old about being hit as a child and experiences of this and there are men all over it - clearly googled some questionable stuff about little girls and discipline Hmm

Oblomov22 · 06/01/2023 07:11

Very poor.

sorrynotathome · 06/01/2023 07:10

RambamThankyouMam · 06/01/2023 06:36

But how are you posting if you've been banned?

Thank you! I thought I was going mad…

ThreeWheelsGood · 06/01/2023 07:08

There is something wrong with their moderation recently.

I reported a dodgy post on a thread. Got a reply that the OP post was fine and they wouldn't take action. I had definitely reported only the reply not the whole OP. Utterly frustrating.

I don't know if it's lack of moderators or change of experience since the new website.

MayThe4th · 06/01/2023 07:08

I suggest that someone starts a thread about this in site stuff.

Not with the specific example perhaps but to question why there are so many posters who seem to be being banned without valid reason, when they e.g. have a consistent posting history etc etc.

Because this thread is likely to be deleted because A, it will be considered a TAAT, and B, because OP is now a PBP.

But a conversation needs to be had, not just about the OP, but about others who have been through the same.

Intrepidescape · 06/01/2023 06:53

@RambamThankyouMam I was banned 3.5+years ago. Since then mumsnet have updated their site.

I can understand if I was being hateful and spewing awful things or just trolling. But I had some truly hateful comments directed at me and I was the one that was banned.

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 06:43

It doesn't sound the same but I got suspended once. I couldn't login. Turns out it was because I'd used two different usernames on one thread. Total accident but my fault. Once they had an acknowledgement from me of what I'd done, they gave me a warning and reactivated me.
Is it possible you did something similar on a different thread? Or transgressed a different rule? But you should get an email with an explanation, though. (It too me several days to find mine!)

RambamThankyouMam · 06/01/2023 06:36

But how are you posting if you've been banned?

Intrepidescape · 06/01/2023 05:40

Yes! I posted when I was pregnant and I had women telling me that I should abort my baby because I was unmarried and the relationship was doomed to fail. Some may remember - I posted because I wanted my boyfriend to pay my private medical costs. I was blocked and couldn’t register again for years! I gave up and haven’t tried posting again until reading your post.

Update:

My boyfriend never left me. He asked me to marry him before our baby was born.

It was his friends who strongly suggested a private obstetrician and private hospital without even being asked.

I chose a private obstetrician and gave birth in a private hospital. Everything was covered by private insurance & government funds and my boyfriend paid the obstetrician direct. It was about $7k
I opted for a cesarean section so I wouldn’t ruin my VJ and my private (and very quiet) hospital suite over looked a beautiful church. I was there for about 5 days & had a double bed and there was a restaurant we could order food from as well as a nursery that could take our baby over night so I could sleep.

Babies die in the public hospitals in my city because the midwives aren’t doctors and there are resource constraints. I have a friend whose baby died in a public hospital because the midwives did nothing while the baby was in foetal distress and they persevered with a natural birth. My friend nearly died herself and she’s still traumatised over a decade later. There have been other baby deaths reported in the media in my city which is why you avoid going public if you have the money to pay.

I had also been present at a birth in a private hospital and found the midwives there to be lazy and unprofessional and it was the obstetrician who stood up to them. Basically, they couldn’t be bothered doing something with the baby immediately after birth even though it was medically necessary. The obstetrician really put them in their place.

I had two obstetricians, an anaesthesiologist, and a paediatrician and his assistant present at the birth. I didn’t want any midwife at all but I ended up with a male midwife in the operating room and I was fine with this as he didn’t need to do anything but take photos and he wasn’t chatty.

For all of you saying my relationship would fail - it hasn’t. It’s been over 4+ years together.

I vividly recall that some people argued with me about the public health resources in my country being excellent - despite those people never giving birth in my country.

I understand many of you are finding it difficult to even get a GP appointment or even be seen in A&E while your NHS struggles. I can call and make a GP appointment today if I wanted one. I can call a GP out to my house (I did this several times during Covid). I can go to a private hospital and be seen immediately. I actually did this during Covid lockdowns because the private hospitals refused to use beds for public patients.

Our medical system (Australia) is by no means perfect but it is preferable to the the NHS but the dual system (public & private) is necessary to ensure a hospital system that can treat all patients during a global pandemic (i.e. people who have cancer and need chemo or people who have organ failure or people who need elective surgery).

Anyway, so many of you were nasty and I guess I was cancelled because I had indicated beliefs that differed from your own.

purpleme12 · 06/01/2023 01:38

God this is so weird that people have been banned for bring PBP when they haven't.
I never knew and yes if they're going to ban you or whatever they should at least tell you why

Flowersinspringgrowwild · 06/01/2023 01:23

Yep I commented and you rolled to me (thanks). Baffling as to why deleted, didn’t seem troll like at all.

Movingonup2023 · 06/01/2023 00:51

Glitteratitar · 06/01/2023 00:41

Sorry this has happened to you OP. Especially on a thread so personal and sensitive.

It has happened to me. I have had a couple of threads published in the Daily Mail so since then, I NC when starting a thread about a situation and tweak the details so as not to be outing (for example, will refer to DS as DD or change his age by a few months, up to a year).

I started a thread about something that happened on the weekend, and for reasons never explained, the thread was removed and my account was deleted. No word, no email, no contact, nothing.

I got in touch with MN and they said my thread had a number of reports (it really was not a controversial thread!) and they’ve decided my posting history has too many inconsistencies and therefore I must be posting in bad faith. I pointed out that I was protecting my identity and a common theme in all of those posts was that I had one child, a young toddler, but they still insisted I was posting in bad faith.

When I asked for examples of this bad faith posting, they responded with posts which were racially charged, claiming that they were examples of some of my posts…excepts they were posts by other posters which I had reported to MN.

They agreed to reinstate but I’m now super careful about what I post, which is a shame as this was a great support network for me. As a result, I also don’t believe all of the threads deleted because the OP was a troll were actually posted by trolls. I think too many MN users get triggered by the smallest of things and MN just deletes and blocks.

Oh god I do this too! Sometimes fell I have something helpful to say but alter the details as you do just to be safe! Didn’t ever think it could cause an issue I better be more careful.

Glitteratitar · 06/01/2023 00:43

I was declared a “previously banned poster” even though I’d never been banned before

I had that too. That’s also why I don’t believe all trolls are actually trolls.

Glitteratitar · 06/01/2023 00:41

Sorry this has happened to you OP. Especially on a thread so personal and sensitive.

It has happened to me. I have had a couple of threads published in the Daily Mail so since then, I NC when starting a thread about a situation and tweak the details so as not to be outing (for example, will refer to DS as DD or change his age by a few months, up to a year).

I started a thread about something that happened on the weekend, and for reasons never explained, the thread was removed and my account was deleted. No word, no email, no contact, nothing.

I got in touch with MN and they said my thread had a number of reports (it really was not a controversial thread!) and they’ve decided my posting history has too many inconsistencies and therefore I must be posting in bad faith. I pointed out that I was protecting my identity and a common theme in all of those posts was that I had one child, a young toddler, but they still insisted I was posting in bad faith.

When I asked for examples of this bad faith posting, they responded with posts which were racially charged, claiming that they were examples of some of my posts…excepts they were posts by other posters which I had reported to MN.

They agreed to reinstate but I’m now super careful about what I post, which is a shame as this was a great support network for me. As a result, I also don’t believe all of the threads deleted because the OP was a troll were actually posted by trolls. I think too many MN users get triggered by the smallest of things and MN just deletes and blocks.

BradfordGirl · 06/01/2023 00:41

I am sorry some of you have had such terrible experiences.

StrapOnYourHeroHair · 06/01/2023 00:33

@lilymumsnet

Phrenologistsfinger · 06/01/2023 00:26

Yeah, mumsnet did the same to me for talking about my multiple miscarriages on a thread! They thought I was trolling because how can someone lose so many babies and be flippant about it (black humour is a coping mechanism)? I got a lame apology but I was outraged actually. MN has some questionable moderation decisions, the stuff they let through etc.

but yes OP, they don’t tell you your account has been blocked, you just can’t log in - people at least deserve to be told what has happened and why!

GentlyBen · 06/01/2023 00:24

I had that happen to me once. I posted about an incident where I really needed support where my whole family was in hospital and I was separated from my DCs and it was awful. A few posts in, some muppet called me a troll and said my post was clearly invented but of some ridiculous reason (that showed they either hadn’t read the OP or had no understanding of basic science). Despite clear posting history, my post was taken down and I was declared a “previously banned poster” even though I’d never been banned before.

I was then in hospital, in the early hours of the morning, unwell and alone, banned after posting for a hand hold. Mumsnet never contacted me or emailed me or said anything about why it’d been taken down.

I’m sorry that it happened to you OP.

ShimmeringShirts · 06/01/2023 00:19

.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 06/01/2023 00:00

Hi! I just clicked on the link in my email to see your reply to me and you post was deleted. I thought, Hmmm I wonder what posts happened after mine?
If you remember, I replied to your reply that I thought you were brave.
What happened after?

Swipe left for the next trending thread