Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are you patriotic ?

184 replies

janet0001 · 05/01/2023 23:05

Do you feel patriotic ?

I do feel patriotic and I got laughed at and basically mocked when I said it.

I was quite upset about that - AIBU?

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 06/01/2023 09:16

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 08:45

@Alexandra2001 You people voted to make moving to Europe extremely difficult

I take that as you think I voted for Brexit. Which shows how little you know about me, my background or my work.

What's done is done. You might have the energy to keep going over the vote and talk about getting another referendum, but I have other more compelling things to think about at present. There are more places in the world to move, live and work than the EU. Instead of people being unhappy with their lot in life, why not set goals to change that?

Pretty clear you did though..
Because you want to move on... (the classic brexitier response) i don't know about you but in RL if i make a poor decision... i seek to change it, mitigate its effects... no one in either of the main parties wishes to even improve relations... its all Make Brexit Work.. or even more ridiculous "Take back Control" neither recognise the devastating effects brexit has caused.

Europe is/was a handy place to move, 2 hour flight home, similar culture & values.

As i said.. people who might hate living here.. may have many very valid reasons why they can't move.

To be patriotic or proud of ones country.. there needs to be something to be proud about & the UK has gone down the drain under the Tories.

Sarahcoggles · 06/01/2023 09:14

I'm proud of the UK. Sure we're not perfect, and times are particularly tough at the moment, but we have a state funded health service, state financial benefits, we have laws protecting vulnerable minorities, we punish hate crime, we support diversity, we have a robust legal system, we have a largely uncorrupt police force, we have democracy, and we take human rights seriously. On a lighter note, we know how to queue! And despite the financial challenges face by many, we always raise loads of money for Children In Need, Red Nose Day etc.

I know people will come along and deny everything I've said, probably giving examples of our shit NHS and unfair benefits or whatever, but on the whole I think we've got nearer the "whole package" than many other countries.

Overall I think we are, in general (obviously there are plenty of exceptions), a nation of decent people.

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 09:09

Rockybooboo · 06/01/2023 08:39

If you actually read what they put, it sounds like they liked living here until 2016 which was the year we voted to leave the EU. There could be potentially millions of people who want to leave. We can replace them but how easy would that be?I

Also if the PP is in my position then it will be really really hard to just go and live abroad. I'm in my 50s, I don't have skills that are in demand abroad. Also my loved ones are here. I have friends that go back 40+ years and my is nearly 80 and I want to live in the same country as her.

It is comparable to the NHS nursing situation. I've got two relatives who are NHS nurses and they were so proud to join in the 90s and they're both senior nurse s. They love the NHS but it's on its knees and they are struggling to provide the service they want so they're very unhappy. However they still have the passion for nursing. They could go and work in the private sector but they'd rather improve where the work.

What's your point? If you're implying that when Brexit was voted on in 2016, they suddenly hated living here that sounds extreme as nothing actually changed there and then but maybe their feeling about living here changed for them. But the simple fact is, we're not going to rejoin for quite a long time, if ever, so why stay where you're miserable whether that's because of Brexit, an ex, or the weather. If you're unhappy with the situation you find yourself in, don't keep on suffering, look up where to move to, what's needed to get there, and make a plan.

I accept lots of people have family and it's difficult to leave them. There are always reasons to stay. But if you "fucking hate" it, wouldn't your family want you've go and be happy?

Your relatives have decided to stay in the nhs and try to improve it. I'm very grateful about that because we desperately need them. But that doesn't mean if someone fucking hated going into work every day, that I'd have them stay. You only get one life. If they think they'd enjoy their life somewhere else, I'd encourage them to go.

GlomOfNit · 06/01/2023 09:09

YellowAndGreenToBeSeen · 05/01/2023 23:54

I think the UK has some spectacular countryside and beautiful buildings. We’ve created amazing cultural phenomena and have a wealth of talent across arts, technology, science, academia, politics and the like.

I’m also fond of our sense of (self depreciating) humour and our pub culture.

I don’t feel at all protective of these things, not ‘proud’ of them. They just ‘are’. I don’t feel proud of the flag and couldn’t give a fuck if we do or don’t win at any sports or music competitions - I don’t ‘blindly’ support the UK or England in anything.

I’m embarrassed about our standing in the world and how we’ve become a political laughing stock.

I’m patriotic in that I’m furious and devastated at what Brexit has done to our country and I’d love to be able to reverse it.

This, absolutely. I'm proud of British contributions to the arts and culture, to science and technology. But I look at what's happening in the arts now, museums closing everywhere you look, theatre dumbed down, funding for all areas of academia slashed - and think we're pissing it all away. NOT proud of that. And our global standing is so embarrassing. I think in another few years we'll truly be a by-word for sad, laughable failure that nobody listens to any more.

SleeplessInEngland · 06/01/2023 09:09

The history of the Empire is something most brits haven't reconciled yet. Indeed it was barely taught in my school even though I did history up until A-Level (I hope that's not still the case).

I suspect many don't even know if they're meant to be proud of it or not.

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 06/01/2023 09:02

Dotjones · Today 08:51

Yes but in the sense we should be proud of our past glories like the empire, two world war victories, our time as top dog on the world stage. Yes in the sense of all the good we've done for the world (whether they appreciate it or not) and yes in the sense that traditionally our country has undoubtedly been "the best", whether that's the people, the culture or whatever else.

Is this an actual joke? You're proud of past glories like the empire?

I love my city (London) and if I was abroad I would always say that was where I'm from. That's because it is a friendly, inclusive forward looking city in my opinion.
I wouldn't tell people I'm from England though. If I'm honest I'm embarrassed of what we've become since Brexit. And the empire was a fucking disgrace.

BigMadAdrian · 06/01/2023 08:57

I'm Welsh, but live in England (and have for a long time). I'm not particularly attached to the UK as a whole - I don't think we're particularly special, certainly nowhere near as special as some people seem to think we are. I do feel a strong sense of belonging to Wales though.

midgetastic · 06/01/2023 08:56

No

I don't feel patriotic

Further I think it's my duty as a human being to suppress such feelings as they lead to countries competing ,rather than working together for the good of the human race and the planet . Patriarchy leads to A sense of entitlement and being the best that hampers working together

I think this country like any other has done good and bad things
I am ashamed of things like the First World War, the slave trade , the assumption that our culture is best because we built the best weapons and soldiers and are happy to fight

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 08:54

JassyRadlett · 06/01/2023 08:44

People who make this argument never explain why they didn't leave prior to 2016, if living as part of the EU was so intolerable.

I love being British. I love living in Britain. I've been fortunate through work to have been to so many places in the world.But I'm always glad to come home. Why would I want to live anywhere else, whether in the EU or out? The EU doesn't change how I feel about my nationality. I didn't move because I love living here but if I "fucking hated" it, I'd make plans to move elsewhere.

Just because people don't moan 24/7 about the Brexit result, doesn't mean they voted for Brexit. It just means they're realists and are getting on with living life.

Dotjones · 06/01/2023 08:51

Yes but in the sense we should be proud of our past glories like the empire, two world war victories, our time as top dog on the world stage. Yes in the sense of all the good we've done for the world (whether they appreciate it or not) and yes in the sense that traditionally our country has undoubtedly been "the best", whether that's the people, the culture or whatever else.

That doesn't stop me looking around now and wondering how we've allowed it to turn to shit like it has. The Will Durant quotation "A great civilization is not conquered from without until it has destroyed itself from within" sums us up nicely, the period since WW2 has seen us allowing the systematic deconstruction of all that made Britain "Great" for so long.

TopSec · 06/01/2023 08:50

janet0001 · 05/01/2023 23:05

Do you feel patriotic ?

I do feel patriotic and I got laughed at and basically mocked when I said it.

I was quite upset about that - AIBU?

Yes I am 100%. Both myself, my husband and my son are veterans (my son actually now deceased lost his life whilst serving with the peace keeping forces in Kosovo) - we took our coin and we served for our Queen (and now King) and country. Yes, very patriotic.

Trainbear · 06/01/2023 08:47

Billy Bragg wrote very interesting on seeing at George flags, albeit sometime ago. As a left winger he immediately thought of the bnp and racists etc But he realised and thought “why should the left allow the “baddies” to appropriate a flag which represents one of the nations making up the uk who fought for workers rights, who not only abolished slavery in its own territories but fought to outlaw the practice globally, who welcomed into its education system many from overseas eho fought against unjust laws devised by the uk elites.
Why should the resilience and resistance to naziism in 1939 not be admired? To realise that the rest of the world has either been conquered (Europe) supports the enemy(Russia) or does not want to get involved.
The brexit vote did not go the way I wanted-but did those who voted the same as I did jump up and down like crazed chimps and overthrow the government. We accept a high number of asylum applications. The last few years have been trying, but it’s down to us to make it better.

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 08:45

@Alexandra2001 You people voted to make moving to Europe extremely difficult

I take that as you think I voted for Brexit. Which shows how little you know about me, my background or my work.

What's done is done. You might have the energy to keep going over the vote and talk about getting another referendum, but I have other more compelling things to think about at present. There are more places in the world to move, live and work than the EU. Instead of people being unhappy with their lot in life, why not set goals to change that?

JassyRadlett · 06/01/2023 08:44

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 08:04

They shouldn't have to sacrifice their happiness living in a country they hate because we have workforce problems! Would you say that to a nurse who can't bear working in the NHS anymore? Some people just don't like living in Britain. Don't make them feel guilty, let them go. And lets recruit from peoplec who do want to live here.

People who make this argument never explain why they didn't leave prior to 2016, if living as part of the EU was so intolerable.

housemaus · 06/01/2023 08:40

No, I don't. I think it's weird to be proud of being a particular nationality as if it's not anything other than an accident of birth.

Rockybooboo · 06/01/2023 08:39

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 08:04

They shouldn't have to sacrifice their happiness living in a country they hate because we have workforce problems! Would you say that to a nurse who can't bear working in the NHS anymore? Some people just don't like living in Britain. Don't make them feel guilty, let them go. And lets recruit from peoplec who do want to live here.

If you actually read what they put, it sounds like they liked living here until 2016 which was the year we voted to leave the EU. There could be potentially millions of people who want to leave. We can replace them but how easy would that be?I

Also if the PP is in my position then it will be really really hard to just go and live abroad. I'm in my 50s, I don't have skills that are in demand abroad. Also my loved ones are here. I have friends that go back 40+ years and my is nearly 80 and I want to live in the same country as her.

It is comparable to the NHS nursing situation. I've got two relatives who are NHS nurses and they were so proud to join in the 90s and they're both senior nurse s. They love the NHS but it's on its knees and they are struggling to provide the service they want so they're very unhappy. However they still have the passion for nursing. They could go and work in the private sector but they'd rather improve where the work.

Alexandra2001 · 06/01/2023 08:36

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 08:04

They shouldn't have to sacrifice their happiness living in a country they hate because we have workforce problems! Would you say that to a nurse who can't bear working in the NHS anymore? Some people just don't like living in Britain. Don't make them feel guilty, let them go. And lets recruit from peoplec who do want to live here.

Lots of people don't have the skills... have family commitments or are too old to emigrate.

You people voted to make moving to Europe extremely difficult & have divided the country, probably forever, you ve also wrecked why many were proud of the UK but aren't now.

You ve also added to the stresses on the NHS with so many EU health workers who have left the UK.

...and pls don't insult us by saying you didn't.

Visa and health insurance costs make lower paid workers coming here not practical... we have higher immigration now because we are allowing in 5m HK Chinese, regardless of skill or age, they are not able or interested in doing the work EU workers used to do and the Ukrainians whilst younger, often have young children and will return to Ukraine when they can but when they are able to work, are fantastic employees.

I think you wont be surprised to know i'm not particularly patriotic... what is there to be patriotic about? Liz Truss? NHS? Transport? roads? or Sunak?

Parky04 · 06/01/2023 08:32

The most patriotic I have been is when we held the 2012 Olympics. It was truly magnificent, and for me showed the best of being British.

Its all gone a bit shit since then!

MissTikMeg · 06/01/2023 08:32

I'm not patriotic in the slightest.

I'm not proud to be from the UK at the moment! We are in a mess.

AFS1 · 06/01/2023 08:31

I remember feeling real pride in our country during the London olympics. The opening ceremony, the success of our athletes, the volunteers, the diversity and inclusivity of it all. It summed up everything I felt made Britain great. And then Brexit happened and the Tories did what we all knew they would do. I also came to realise that a significant proportion of our population is racist.

i’m now ashamed to be British. We’re at best a laughing stock. At worst, we’ve become a horribly divided country with nasty thugs parading their St George crosses as a weapon against anyone they don’t like.

The hard right has destroyed everything that was good about this once great country.

TheBirdintheCave · 06/01/2023 08:24

Yes and no. There are a lot of things that are embarrassing about being British but there are also lots of things to be proud of.

I always try and be the best ambassador I can for our country when I go abroad as I hate the (not always untrue) notion that British people are rude and ignorant louts when travelling.

Stunningscreamer · 06/01/2023 08:21

It's changed and it seems to be the people who claim to be the most patriotic who are destroying the things that made us a great country.

And absolutely this.

Stunningscreamer · 06/01/2023 08:18

Fathercrossmas · 05/01/2023 23:11

I would have been when we were in the EU and maybe just maybe could be thought of as a leader in certain fields. Now we have lost all the top talent because of Brexit, our NHS is round the U bend, the royalty have turned into a take-a -break special issue, our government are a bunch of elitist money grabbing Charlestons. So nope. Not patriotic. I like tea though, which is possibly what stops me emigrating.

Absolutely this.

It broke the belief I had that we would basically do the right thing. I'd always felt there were groups of mindless idiots who waved the Union flag and bashed up bars abroad during the football but that the majority of people were sane and reasonable. It's not just the vote itself but the number of weirdos that became obsessed with it posting on a daily basis and telling people to get over it without the slightest attempt to understand the implications and why people were upset.

Similarly with continuing to vote for an obviously politically bankrupt and corrupt Conservative Government when it was clear the country was already starting to fall apart. Not realising that you can't have decent public services and ever lower taxes. Still voting in people who clearly have their own agenda to enrich themselves.

I've just given up with them. I live here because my friends and family do and because I'm too old to start again. But I would not choose here as my preferred home if I could have chosen where I was born.

KimberleyClark · 06/01/2023 08:14

For Wales 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿 yes. For the UK no not really.

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 08:04

Rockybooboo · 06/01/2023 08:00

This is such an immature attitude. Were struggling because were short of working age people so lots of people moving abroad is not a great idea. If there a lot of people who are unhappy, can't we work out a way to make it a better place to live.

They shouldn't have to sacrifice their happiness living in a country they hate because we have workforce problems! Would you say that to a nurse who can't bear working in the NHS anymore? Some people just don't like living in Britain. Don't make them feel guilty, let them go. And lets recruit from peoplec who do want to live here.