Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are you patriotic ?

184 replies

janet0001 · 05/01/2023 23:05

Do you feel patriotic ?

I do feel patriotic and I got laughed at and basically mocked when I said it.

I was quite upset about that - AIBU?

OP posts:
WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 06/01/2023 10:22

Stickmansmum · 06/01/2023 10:06

Absolutely not. Patriotism/nationalism and religion are the source of all evil in the world.

I assume you mean for EVERYONE then? Are you going to say that next time someone says they are fiercely proud of their ethnic roots when they are not British?

whereaw · 06/01/2023 10:20

Everyone should feel proud of their roots, their ancestors and the systems that have allowed them to exist at all.

I am so proud of the women who throughout history endured childbirth, child raising and often abominable conditions of poverty, invasions, war, extreme weather across history that allowed me to be here today.

To not be patriotic, in my opinion, spits in the faces of all the people who walked before us to try to make the world better for them and their children.

It is an innate feeling of so many lives and people before me that have led to the possibility of my existence.

It happens to be that my ancestors are mostly from the British Isles, though I wasn't born here myself, I live here now and love it dearly.

Pride doesn't mean blind acceptance of everything that ever went before. It's simply acknowledgement and gratitude. Pride is community and caring about those around us because we share something important. It's wanting to make the world better and believing that there are some systems that our ancestors put in place that do make the world better.

That is true across ALL peoples and places.

I cannot understand people who mock and sneer at a sense of pride.

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/01/2023 10:14

No, not at all.

Honestly (and I'll probably get flamed), I think its a bit stupid to be proud of having been born in one particularly country and not another. It's not anything you have any control over and its in no way a measure of a person's quality, ambition or intelligence. What's to be proud of?

I also think patriotism fuels the worst kinds of division and xenophobia.

Can't see any upsides to it really.

MarshaBradyo · 06/01/2023 10:11

Patriotic may be too strong a word as if people start saying you have a duty to do x or y I think hmm not really. A recent example was you have a duty to enjoy Jubilee (I did enjoy the street party but not due to duty) or duty to act a certain way for the public and I find that too onerous.

However certain elements such as writing, creativity, science, justice as pp mentioned, arts are dear to me here. I’m reading a great book atm which covers science in 20thC and the history is excellent and with great contributions. Of course also from other countries which are included.

OopsAnotherOne · 06/01/2023 10:10

I wrote that whole long post above and forgot to mention probably my most important point-

No, OP. I don't feel patriotic in the way a lot of people claim to. I don't feel proud or that I have achieved something simply from being born in a certain geographical location. Nor do I feel that England/Britain is any better than any other country, nor am I "better" just for being born here.

I simply feel pride that I walk the same land as my ancestors did. I don't think that is considered patriotism by most.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/01/2023 10:08

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 06/01/2023 10:05

Wow. Hmm

Can you elaborate?

Im part Welsh and part Scottish, and a big part from another European country, as well as part English, so I’m not sure why I’d feel strongly English.

OopsAnotherOne · 06/01/2023 10:06

Interesting question OP.

I'm not really patriotic in the typical sense of the word, I do like England and enjoy living here to the extent , but with the state of the economy and the cost of living crisis etc it is not really something I can feel "proud" to be a part of at the moment. I don't feel patriotic towards a country where many of us are struggling to keep afloat.

However, I feel patriotic in the way that I feel a strong sense of belonging in England. I was born and raised here and most days I walk along the same roads, visit the same towns and spend time on the same land my ancestors lived on for centuries. There are buildings both up North and down South where my great, great, great, great grandparents lived in which still stand and I felt a huge sense of pride when I visited those same buildings. To walk up the same garden path that over 200 years ago, my same relatives did. It's very special to me.

I have family trees from my mother's side and father's side, both families I can trace back to the 1500s. In Tudor England, relatives on my mother's side of the family were working, living and walking the streets of the town I still work in today. To be able to visit the same places they did makes me feel proud to live in this area. Not so much "patriotic", but I suppose I'm trying to do my bit keep the town a nice place to be to keep it for future generations as my ancestors did for me.

By giving both my parents 23andMe DNA tests for Christmas under the sneaky guise of "see where your ancestors are from!" I was able to get a more detailed view of my own ancestry, from both my mother's and father's lines.

My father's family came across from Scandinavia with the Vikings and settled here, staying ever since. My mother's side is almost 100% British, with a tiny percentage of North African (given the small percentage, it is likely to be a Roman soldier during the Roman occupation of Britain who had relations with one of her ancestors).

The point I'm trying to make is that my ancestors have been settled here for over 1000 years on my father's side and even more on my mother's side. Britain is home for me and everything about all of the ancestors I've traced has happened here in this country. I am proud to know so much about my ancestry and I believe that makes me patriotic in the sense that I feel pride in knowing where I come from, how they lived, what they did, where they went and knowing I can walk those same streets and fields. I feel a connection, more than patriotic. I think patriotism comes in many forms and is different and personal to every individual.

Stickmansmum · 06/01/2023 10:06

Absolutely not. Patriotism/nationalism and religion are the source of all evil in the world.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 06/01/2023 10:05

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/01/2023 09:58

Agree with you. I say London or Britain. Never England. I don’t feel English as opposed to British at all, but I do feel like a Londoner.

Wow. Hmm

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 06/01/2023 10:04

VladmirsPoutine · 06/01/2023 10:00

No. As someone said upthread I support England at the world cup and that's about it and the reason I even do that is because Rashford and Saku played.

Hmm
VladmirsPoutine · 06/01/2023 10:00

No. As someone said upthread I support England at the world cup and that's about it and the reason I even do that is because Rashford and Saku played.

GPTec1 · 06/01/2023 09:58

Done a lot of work for Govt and defence over the years and always felt proud to do so.
I was involved in a new Met Office building which thatcher opened and then did a speech on climate, Trident too.

I detested her but felt proud of our teams contribution in making this happen and actually in her speech too.

Now? older wiser me, far less so, i feel Austerity has ruined the UK.

Its hard to be proud of the UK when the chances are, if i had a stroke etc, i would not be treated in a timely manner, my friends mother spent 2 days in a marquee outside an AE dept, people died around her.. in a car park (her daughter is a ex nurse, stayed with her, feeding turning)

We are nothing without a fucntioning NHS and we will not grow as a country either, few companies will invest in the UK if their workforce cannot access good health and education services.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/01/2023 09:58

Pleasepleasepleaseno · 06/01/2023 09:02

Dotjones · Today 08:51

Yes but in the sense we should be proud of our past glories like the empire, two world war victories, our time as top dog on the world stage. Yes in the sense of all the good we've done for the world (whether they appreciate it or not) and yes in the sense that traditionally our country has undoubtedly been "the best", whether that's the people, the culture or whatever else.

Is this an actual joke? You're proud of past glories like the empire?

I love my city (London) and if I was abroad I would always say that was where I'm from. That's because it is a friendly, inclusive forward looking city in my opinion.
I wouldn't tell people I'm from England though. If I'm honest I'm embarrassed of what we've become since Brexit. And the empire was a fucking disgrace.

Agree with you. I say London or Britain. Never England. I don’t feel English as opposed to British at all, but I do feel like a Londoner.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/01/2023 09:57

KimberleyClark · 06/01/2023 09:48

I’m proud of the UK legal and justice system. Especially when compared to the US.

Legal system has some faults, but yes I agree. Especially in terms of judicial independence.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/01/2023 09:56

This is a really interesting thread to come back to.

I agree that Brexit damaged a lot of feelings of pride I had in this country. But like others there are British achievements that make me feel quite proud still.

I also think my lack of patriotism in some senses might be a form of privilege. In terms of the Uk as a whole (rather than the individual nations ) we haven’t had to fight for our country’s right to exist. Certainly not within living memory or many generations. So it’s easier to say “I’m not patriotic”, which I do say. Just a thought.

KimberleyClark · 06/01/2023 09:48

I’m proud of the UK legal and justice system. Especially when compared to the US.

MarshaBradyo · 06/01/2023 09:45

Re the question - I feel a kind of separated positivity / fondness to the two countries of which I am a citizen

I also enjoy elements of other cultures. I think I could find something good and interesting about any

Phos · 06/01/2023 09:43

I'm not sure. I don't think one can say you're proud to be a nationality or colour because you didn't really choose that.

If we take patriotism as a sense of attachment to one's country then yes, I would say I do feel that but I can't explain why exactly. The UK has it's flaws but so do all countries. I don't feel like we should self-flagellate over behaviours of the past. Certainly they can be acknowledged but for someone born in the late 20th century to say they're ashamed to be British because of things that happened centuries ago is a bit of a reach. If they have issues with current day goings on then that's up to them and a decision whether it should be attributed to a whole country of an individual/group of people.

My own sense of patriotism is heightened by being married to someone who has come here from overseas. Other members of his family have followed. They are all British nationals from birth, just happened to live somewhere else. When they start slagging off Britain or comparing it unfavourably to their old country, I do feel annoyed. I feel like if it's so great there, then why did you leave, why not go back?

NormalNans · 06/01/2023 09:43

I don’t feel remotely patriotic. I think that country boundaries are largely man made and that where we were born in relation to that is pretty meaningless. There are things that I like about the UK and things I’d change but I don’t support national teams etc because I just don’t get that sense of national pride.

MarshaBradyo · 06/01/2023 09:40

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 08:45

@Alexandra2001 You people voted to make moving to Europe extremely difficult

I take that as you think I voted for Brexit. Which shows how little you know about me, my background or my work.

What's done is done. You might have the energy to keep going over the vote and talk about getting another referendum, but I have other more compelling things to think about at present. There are more places in the world to move, live and work than the EU. Instead of people being unhappy with their lot in life, why not set goals to change that?

I’m with you on this

MarshaMelrose · 06/01/2023 09:37

Alexandra2001 · 06/01/2023 09:16

Pretty clear you did though..
Because you want to move on... (the classic brexitier response) i don't know about you but in RL if i make a poor decision... i seek to change it, mitigate its effects... no one in either of the main parties wishes to even improve relations... its all Make Brexit Work.. or even more ridiculous "Take back Control" neither recognise the devastating effects brexit has caused.

Europe is/was a handy place to move, 2 hour flight home, similar culture & values.

As i said.. people who might hate living here.. may have many very valid reasons why they can't move.

To be patriotic or proud of ones country.. there needs to be something to be proud about & the UK has gone down the drain under the Tories.

Pretty clear you did though..
Because you want to move on...

You're ridiculous. Why am I going to spend the next 10, 20 years just going over and over Brexit? Moaning that were not in the EU. If you want to politically agitate for change, good for you, go ahead but I'm not seeing or hearing 16m remain voters agitating. Are they fed up about losing? Yes. Are they living their lives out of the EU? Yes.

One of my closest friends was coming to early retirement, had loads of plans, holidays arranged. He was diagnosed with terminal cancer and was dead within the year. My mum has dementia. At the moment I've been living several months with her as she can't be on her own. It's exhausting. I have no life really and I want to go home. I'm trying to get her into a care home. Everyone on her side of her family has it so I'm probably going to get it too.

I don't know how long I've got left or what the future might hold but I'm not spending my life fretting over something done and gone when I could be enjoying what this country has to offer.

Scooopsahoy · 06/01/2023 09:30

I don’t understand how anyone can feel proud of something that they didn’t personally accomplish.

So I can be proud of my individual actions, but how can I be proud of being born in one country rather than in a different one? It just doesn’t make sense to me.

midgetastic · 06/01/2023 09:24

No I am not proud that I was born the the same country as the people who first managed to get slavery undone - although I suspect that many other areas also didn't participate in slavery

I mean why ? It's illogical - it wasn't my actions or anything I supported , it's just chance where I was born

hotdiggetydog · 06/01/2023 09:19

"Patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel"

Trainbear · 06/01/2023 09:18

midgetastic · 06/01/2023 08:56

No

I don't feel patriotic

Further I think it's my duty as a human being to suppress such feelings as they lead to countries competing ,rather than working together for the good of the human race and the planet . Patriarchy leads to A sense of entitlement and being the best that hampers working together

I think this country like any other has done good and bad things
I am ashamed of things like the First World War, the slave trade , the assumption that our culture is best because we built the best weapons and soldiers and are happy to fight

Britain participated in the slave trade along with virtually every other country/tribe etc. British businesses and individuals bought slaves from tribes/warlords/countries/native traders. Britain not only stopped its own trade but it stopped the trade internationally and globally. Are you proud of that?
The descendants of these slaves gained independence from the Uk and many have chosen to come to the Uk. If it was such a terrible place would they have?Would they have stayed? Would they have made such an active and proud contribution to the Uk?

Swipe left for the next trending thread