Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are people normalising antidepressants?!

283 replies

mumyes · 05/01/2023 21:04

Just watched yet another reel on Instagram about "the thugs that make me happy"...coffees with friends, downtime, fresh air...and my antidepressants.

It feels like the entire world thinks it's normal to take them.

I am in no way judging those who do, it just feels bloody tragic that life is so shit for so many people that this is now becoming what seems like the norm.

Lessen stress on people, pay them more, treat workers better.

Oh no, let's treat people like shit & shovel pills into them so they don't care.

Surely this is not a good thing.

OP posts:
OoooohMatron · 05/01/2023 23:57

BedfordBloo · 05/01/2023 21:12

The same reason we normalise putting plasters on cuts, running a burn under cold water, taking antibiotics for a bacterial chest infection, and taking paracetamol when you have a headache. Because antidepressants are the appropriate medication for depression in a lot of cases.

Why does it offend you to “normalise” taking medication when necessary?

Exactly this. You wouldn't think twice about taking medication for other illnesses, why is mental health any different.

Wiluli · 05/01/2023 23:53

Because unfortunately the nhs or medical profession prescribes things to help with symptoms and never gets to the root of the issue . It’s cheaper to do it this way . I agree with you , medication should be an alternative to other less damaging treatments . A while ago I went to a baby class that people seemed to all have been given meds for post natal depression , literally only me and another never took any meds ( class of 13 mums ) . They seem to be the doctors first port if call these days

NooNooHead1981 · 05/01/2023 23:41

MeinKraft · 05/01/2023 23:29

Respectfully, there is a world of difference between the drug you were taking and the GP prescribed anti depressants that are the general subject of the thread.

Unfortunately there isn't in some cases, and antidepressants can be equally as harsh and harmful when given to the unfortunate susceptible individuals. They are all pretty neurotoxic to the people who are genetically predisposed to the adverse effects.

MeinKraft · 05/01/2023 23:29

NooNooHead1981 · 05/01/2023 22:13

I'd like to show people what my involuntary movements are like which were caused by the adverse reaction but i don't think it will let me post any videos on here.

Yes, I'm an extreme and most likely rare case of a bad reaction but it isn't totally uncommon and I don't want to sugar-coat just how horrendous these totally avoidable iatrogenic injuries are.

I was back arching on the bed, restless, grimacing, and feeling like my head was detached from my body when I was taking the antipsychotic for just a few days, and I wouldn't want anyone to go through the same hell as I have. The drugs are effectively a chemical lobotomy in some ways and doctors still have not really any true idea what they do to the brain or how they actually work.

Respectfully, there is a world of difference between the drug you were taking and the GP prescribed anti depressants that are the general subject of the thread.

5YearsLeft · 05/01/2023 23:27

Balloonsandroses · 05/01/2023 22:33

@5YearsLeft interestingly there is a drug which acts on dopamine reuptake - bupropion - but it’s only licensed for smoking cessation in the UK. Gets used extensively for depression in the USA, seems to work well for some.

I suspect more women than men are on antidepressants because more women than men are diagnosed with depression. I don’t know the reasons behind that - maybe more willing to seek help, maybe centuries of patriarchy mean women still have a harder time and more vulnerable to adverse events, maybe something biological, maybe a bit of all three.

I absolutely think antidepressant use should be normalised and supported - they are life saving for some and improve quality of life for many more. However, I wish CBT was available swiftly so that it was more of a realistic choice for people (as the evidence suggests it should be) rather than “sorry you feel awful and can’t function, I think you have depression, would you like to try a tablet I can prescribe today or join a waiting list that’s months long for therapy or both?”

Actually, I should have mentioned probably for anyone interested, I think Buproprion is still pretty weak for dopamine reuptake, as it is still a norepinephrine-dopamine reuptake inhibitor, but there are a few other drugs; just not used for depression. In fact, the most common dopamine reuptake inhibitor is considered a psychostimulant (in the same category as amphetamines), and is, or was, the most “popular” medication for children with ADHD, methylphenidate. Interestingly, when methylphenidate was given to 65 depressed patients, 38 of them reported significant improvement, which is pretty impressive in a study and apparently, it’s used in some countries for treatment-resistant depression. I have no idea what it would “feel” like in comparison to an SSRI, but I’d imagine it might provide a feeling of more actual energy.

The study:
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3181580/

Of course there are huge problems with both of the things you say, and I completely agree: that a lot of men who need help for depression aren’t seeking it, and that we have a mountain of literature that shows the most effective treatment is often therapy PLUS medication, yet so often only medication is provided. I’m very, VERY fortunate that I see a therapist who is also a psychiatrist as well, so we have talk therapy for 45 minutes roughly once a fortnight (increased to once a week when I was in a crisis), and then based on it, he makes decisions about my need for medications or medication changes.

Suicide was the leading cause of death for both men and women, age 20-34, from 2001-2018, so I think it’s a hard argument that anti-depressants are “too” normalised.

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · 05/01/2023 23:19

I agree with many points here.
They are a useful tool at times
Save life's and suffering and enable the sufferer to act on healing.

WetBandits · 05/01/2023 23:19

Eyesopenwideawake · 05/01/2023 23:15

Because I believe the chemical imbalance theory was discredited many years ago - it was only ever a theory suggested by the drug companies - but I know that brain scans can identify changes in someone with major clinical depression.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/aug/03/the-chemical-imbalance-theory-of-depression-is-dead-but-that-doesnt-mean-antidepressants-dont-work

Oh I already knew why you asked; I looked at your posting history. I just wondered why you hadn’t just said so straight away instead of quizzing me.

I don’t suffer from depression so I don’t believe that applies to me. I’m sleeping better, having fewer intrusive thoughts and worrying less since I’ve started on mirtazapine so I would say that they are absolutely working for me. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Eyesopenwideawake · 05/01/2023 23:15

Because I believe the chemical imbalance theory was discredited many years ago - it was only ever a theory suggested by the drug companies - but I know that brain scans can identify changes in someone with major clinical depression.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/aug/03/the-chemical-imbalance-theory-of-depression-is-dead-but-that-doesnt-mean-antidepressants-dont-work

WetBandits · 05/01/2023 23:09

Eyesopenwideawake · 05/01/2023 23:03

"I know that mine have helped me change my life because they have corrected a chemical imbalance in my brain that was causing me to feel very anxious and obsessive."

May I ask, what tests did you have to confirm the chemical imbalance in your brain?

Why would you like to know?

Eyesopenwideawake · 05/01/2023 23:03

"I know that mine have helped me change my life because they have corrected a chemical imbalance in my brain that was causing me to feel very anxious and obsessive."

May I ask, what tests did you have to confirm the chemical imbalance in your brain?

WetBandits · 05/01/2023 23:00

Do you feel the same about pain relief or medication for high blood pressure, for example? Or is it just the people with mental ill health that should shut up about the medications we take to improve our health? 🙄

I know that mine have helped me change my life because they have corrected a chemical imbalance in my brain that was causing me to feel very anxious and obsessive.

Natfrances · 05/01/2023 22:57

For me taking a low dose of sertraline takes the edge off, it blocks out the depression and anxiety so I don't feel as much, I'm not happy or sad just being if that makes sense but I can cope more with things and don't worry about stuff as much. On the downside I forget things and can feel quite tired.

Stickly · 05/01/2023 22:48

I think most of what I wanted to say had already been said...i do just want to say thank god for sertraline (in my case) I'd most likely be unable to work or be a healthy parent due to severe PTSD. I just want people to be able to reach out, and I think the less stigmatised it is the better (hence the increase in mention in social media).

Quirkyme · 05/01/2023 22:42

procrastinator8 · 05/01/2023 21:07

No it’s not a good thing but our society is not equipped to prevent the problem but to ‘treat’ it.

Agree

Eyesopenwideawake · 05/01/2023 22:42

@Littlepuddytat

Fantastic post.

Eyesopenwideawake · 05/01/2023 22:40

Someone with depression - whether it be caused by their situation/environment, negative self view due to a less than ideal childhood, or genetics - looks to their GP for a solution.

Within that typical 8 minute consultation, with a doctor who hasn't specialised in mental illness, there is little time or opportunity for the doctor to do anything other than prescribe what the patient desperately wants - a pill to make them feel better. If the antidepressant does that then the patient is going consider it a success. Sometimes simply the placebo effect will be sufficient to get the patient through a shitty situation or maybe there will be a sustained positive effect. If it works, great. All you then have to deal with are the nasty side effects of withdrawal and, if your life hasn't improved while taking them, being right back to square one.

What is clear is that the antidepressant market is a massive part of the pharmaceutical industry - valued at around $16 billion in 2022 and growing fast. Therapy does not generally produce any profit for the drug companies or the people who lobby on their behalf.

This video is enlightening for those who want to know more;

Hadtochangeitforthis · 05/01/2023 22:40

what a sad post to read - firstly because your experience of depression was exactly that, your experience.
Secondly you listed some great factors that helped your wellbeing improve (so what happens if you don’t have that?)
thirdly because as many have said, they do work for many and you aren’t forced to suffer other conditions before getting accessible effective help.
fourthly when talking about circumstantial mental illness and not taking meds for it, it would suggest there is readily available help to assist with the problems…..there isn’t. Primary care mental health waits can be up to 1 year.
fifth point - I work in mental health and circumstantial or not people’s depression and anxiety can get so bad that resolution through therapy such as CBT sometimes can’t be achieved without the initial boost in wellbeing or reduction in symptoms that meds give. When I trained, we were advised to say that guidance suggests that a combination of medication and therapy is good practice. I.E if you need meds take them, access therapy too and then hopefully reduce your meds if possible (still….not always possible) so it saddens me to read posts like yours that could actually be discouraging. If a large number of your friends are taking meds…I’m happy they’re seeking a solution to their problems, it could be meds, it might be something else but there’s an element of shame in your post and I hope someone in a Tough spot doesn’t read this and get put off.

WickedWitchOfTheEast87 · 05/01/2023 22:35

Greenshake · 05/01/2023 21:11

They are given out far too freely with little consideration for other (non-pharmaceutical) ways of dealing with things.

I have Bipolar Disorder and take anti psychotic meds when I don't take them my moods go up and down so for me yes its normal to take them every night with a cup of tea. I suffered for years before diagnosis those meds help me big time non pharmaceutical alternatives doesn't always work for some everyone handles their mental health differently.

Balloonsandroses · 05/01/2023 22:33

@5YearsLeft interestingly there is a drug which acts on dopamine reuptake - bupropion - but it’s only licensed for smoking cessation in the UK. Gets used extensively for depression in the USA, seems to work well for some.

I suspect more women than men are on antidepressants because more women than men are diagnosed with depression. I don’t know the reasons behind that - maybe more willing to seek help, maybe centuries of patriarchy mean women still have a harder time and more vulnerable to adverse events, maybe something biological, maybe a bit of all three.

I absolutely think antidepressant use should be normalised and supported - they are life saving for some and improve quality of life for many more. However, I wish CBT was available swiftly so that it was more of a realistic choice for people (as the evidence suggests it should be) rather than “sorry you feel awful and can’t function, I think you have depression, would you like to try a tablet I can prescribe today or join a waiting list that’s months long for therapy or both?”

Littlepuddytat · 05/01/2023 22:33

5YearsLeft · 05/01/2023 22:15

If this isn’t a goady comment, a very quick read of a Wikipedia entry would tell you how they work. Every antidepressant is in a category named after the chemical it affects, to tell you “what it does.” For example, the most numerous category is, I believe, the SSRIs. As I said, the key is in the name: they are selective SEROTONIN reuptake inhibitors. The article on SSRIs says right at the beginning that these drugs, such as Sertraline, limit the réabsorption, or reuptake, of the chemical serotonin, so the person will have more serotonin (it’s a little more complex than that - it forces the serotonin to stay longer in a certain cell gap). You should then be able to read how serotonin works to understand why these anti-depressants, in particular, aren’t “happy pills.”

Serotonin is NOT a happiness chemical, nor does it cause amnesia, or lack of emotions - so you won’t be floating on a cloud, or forget what made you sad, or be incapable of a full range of emotions, though the hope is that it will stop major depressive states. It just simply does not make people “happy.” Not even like fresh air does. That’s the chemical dopamine. So it is believed someone with more serotonin will experience less anxiety, possibly less psychosis, not more happiness. This is why most people on anti-depressants explain it as “keeping them even” or stopping them from reaching a deep depressive or anxious state, versus making them feel even a slight “happy” lift, like they might feel at some point from fresh air or seeing a friend (note: these things don’t erase depression; I’m just saying that for some people, sometimes, they can boost dopamine a bit).

The second most common class of anti-depressants, SNRIs, are serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors, so the exact same thing but with both serotonin and norepinephrine. Again, you can just read the Wikipedia article on what norepinephrine is, or on SNRIs.

We do not have a way to introduce dopamine for neurological use. The only dopamine for medical use is by vein, has a very short period of working (half-life), doesn’t affect the brain so much as the heart, and has some bad side effects (possible kidney damage). If we had TRUE anti-depressants that could somehow raise your neurological dopamine in a manner that didn’t lead to a dangerous rebound, I imagine they would be worth trillions of pounds and save thousands of lives. As it is, SSRIs are the best we have and they DO save a lot of lives - think of it as them removing some of the depression and anxiety, not overwriting it with happiness.

Studies have shown that those with anxiety have less serotonin, which is why it makes sense that: these drugs work, and we should take them. The real question is: WHY are people anxious, or depressed? As many people have commented, they don’t have a bad life or bad job or bad treatment from others, yet still need anti-depressants. Some psychologists are beginning to posit it’s because humans have reached a point where what we expect from modern life is simply pushing ourselves too far - how many women post on here that have no time for any personal hobbies or time to themselves? It’s impossible to keep filling from an empty cup without eventually feeling anxious and depressed. The idea that a job, a family, and no one treating you badly should be enough to make up a life is perhaps the problem. And the idea that “not badly” is good enough treatment may be part of it, too - how many times have women posted on here that are married to men who are just awful, but they seem to think since they aren’t being abused or treated TOO badly, that the treatment is acceptable? And yes, some people could have an absolutely perfect life - be healthy and wealthy and with a loving family and still feel depressed, because we’re talking about chemical imbalances, and that’s what anti-depressants treat.

Great post.

raffegiraffe · 05/01/2023 22:28

No,this is a terrible example. Stress causes a temporary rise in systolic blood pressure. It does not cause hypertension. I'm glad this dad's BP reduced but it wasn't because he had a less stressful job. This is not how it works.
Depression is common, one in four lifetime risk, and using medication to increase neurotransmitters seems to reduce symptoms for a good number of sufferers. This is why they are commonly prescribed. No kick backs or conspiracy, just evidence based medicine.

OCDmama · 05/01/2023 22:24

I don't have depression, I take them for OCD. It's a lifelong chronic condition for me, and Sertraline helps when it flares up. I'm able to manage.

Don't judge.

JamSandle · 05/01/2023 22:22

mumyes · 05/01/2023 22:17

I totally hear you, but the numbers of people this applies to is far far outweighed by the vast numbers of people - mainly women - on ADs.

I dont think men are any less depressed than women. But there are social and cultural reasons men don't seek help.

mumyes · 05/01/2023 22:21

lifeturnsonadime · 05/01/2023 22:18

My teen is going to be taking Sertraline for the rest of his life, because he has a chemical imbalance.

it is known that people on the autism spectrum often produce less seratonin than neurotypical people.

it is not environmental or because he is less resilient, it is treating a hormone imbalance. It is life saving.

Such ignorance on this thread.

Flowers
OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 05/01/2023 22:18

My teen is going to be taking Sertraline for the rest of his life, because he has a chemical imbalance.

it is known that people on the autism spectrum often produce less seratonin than neurotypical people.

it is not environmental or because he is less resilient, it is treating a hormone imbalance. It is life saving.

Such ignorance on this thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread